The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives 
 
 
User: Guest

Posts by Piast Poland  

Joined: 28 Aug 2010 / Male ♂
Last Post: 5 Mar 2012
Threads: 3
Posts: 165
From: Canada/Poland
Speaks Polish?: tak

Displayed posts: 168 / page 5 of 6
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Piast Poland   
15 Apr 2011
News / Poland ready to receive Libyan refugees [159]

It is not Poland responsibility to host these people. The countries who are there like the US, UK, France should. They, if anyone signed up for taking them in, certainly not Poland.
Piast Poland   
23 Mar 2011
News / Poland - Third World Country?? [300]

Since there is no USSR anymore there seems to be no second world. Even so I would not Classify Poland as second world. It more of a first world country just a step behind others like France or Canada.

Whoever thinks that Poland is third world is just stupid or a stupid troll.
Piast Poland   
18 Mar 2011
History / Life in Partitioned Poland (Specifically in the Prussian Partition) [118]

dismantled Polish state was high due to racial discrimination and unemployment on traditionally Polish lands

Thats a quote from Bratwurst Boy quoting a source in another thread. While Prussia may not have been as bad as the Russian partition, it was still not a wonderful place. Dont say there was no discrimination or persecution.

On a side note I seem to be finding that the Austrian partition was the best for Poles.
Piast Poland   
13 Mar 2011
History / What nation do Poles feel closer to? [74]

So you could say until July 1, 2011. Hungary and Poland will be very close.

But then Poland gets the presidency right after :)
Piast Poland   
6 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

For 3rd world country like Poland

LOL

Cannot believe I actually have to explain this to some people. The point of the above is question the quoted commentator on why he holds this view and in extension why Poland needs a so called boost from the US. I guess some people are just that dense. My comment is in line with the thread, and I was not insulting anyone.
Piast Poland   
6 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

At this time Europe, as a whole, is incapable and unwilling to fight the real threat in today's world

That is why we need to have closer ties. Not just one way, Poland to Europe, but back and forth if you know what I mean. The US can remain a partner, but why promote publicly such ties with the number one target for these terrorists.

wouldn't say there is as "strong" isolationist movement in the US

Right.
USA has never been isolationist, not even before world war 1. People may think so, but even back then they have been constantly invading nations in south and latin america.[quote=Dande]I wouldn't say there is as "strong" isolationist movement in the US
Piast Poland   
5 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Sky you have some very good points in your long post there. I just think that Europe should replace the US in those roles, for reasons I have already stated. That and what Marek was saying that Poland would just be obligated to serve the United States upon request in any future conflict. We dont need the US just Europe.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Sure thats a good point. But the international standing that Poland will be left in after this close relationship will not be good. On the whole its probably not the best idea, or the best way to go about it.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

"they're unarmed right now they'll be armed again in a year or so once rotation is over and they are permanently placed there. But those will be the PAC-3 Patriots much much modern and effective"

How is that good? Insignificant.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

I am waiting for them to tell me why the air base in Poland is a good idea, let alone the whole partnership.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

So Sky and Guesswho, how would this base be positive for Poland at all?
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Poland's own generals said it's military is capable right now to protect itself

Thats why it needs to be built up!

Not just ties with Germany but whole of Europe.

Lithuania

Is this a joke?

Anyhow what exactly did Germany and South Korea get out of it?
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Why suck up to anyone at all, especially the US. You cannot say Poland will get anything out of it. Maybe eventually in the distant future. You are saying that the alternative is to suck up to Russia? why? Closer ties with the rest of Europe and building up Polands own military will suffice.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

More or less. But it would be preferable to keep it at a distance, ie short of actually hosting bases. Build European bases where European armies are hosted.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

I wouldn't worry about it too much, empty talk

Thats most probably correct.

The only reason why U.S. is promising air base in Poland is to preposition their army and obligate other nation to fight the upcoming war.

This is a big part of why the US base is not a good idea

And I thought we agreed on thightening bonds within Europe but that too means a strong atlantic alliance...

Without sucking up to the US on every chance.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

China is moving away from that style of government. Slowly but surely. What makes you think that they would build an empire here and impose that rule over the world? A little far fetched. And I thought we agreed that the move with the US is not a good idea.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

That does not explain why china is a problem, and Poland should come closer with the US.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Well, start learning mandarin then...

Since you know Mandarin would you like to explain.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

But why would China be a threat at all, especially to Poland. China as a power is more favorable to the world then the US. China even when strong has never involved itself in the type of physical and political empire building in all its history. I dont see how this country could be a threat. Tiny US bases in Poland would not help even if there was a threat. Maybe Germany has to worry, but about what? Economic competition? The US yes, a threat to its empire.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

tell me, how?

It took them long enough to even do this small thing which according to your article is going to be in 2018. Who know what other "problems" they will run into before then. Even that is besides the point. Poland does not need this. Missile defense from what? Who is going to bomb Poland? Im sure US has these systems to protect itself, as well as other European countries.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

We have not had a single attack or even threat. I see your point though, and I said before we should be concentrating on ties, but with those closer to us. Poland does not need this base, and we have seen how the US treats our agreements. Even closer ties with Germany would be preferable.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Tell me how they care. When they shamefully backed out of their missile defense agreement. Gave us FAKE equipment? A lot of care.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Yeah...and these are of course not Polands enemies but chums, right?

We should be pursuing closer ties with the rest of Europe, not the US which is so far away and does not care.

That is called appeasement, and never worked. They will come for you only a bit later...

It is not appeasement if one does not want to even go down that path.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Delph has a good point, when it gets right down to it, the US just doesnt care when it is even in the slightest inconvenience for them, what a healthy relationship. Poland may be on some black list as you say, but much less so than almost any other NATO country. This can only make it much worse.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

Who has said anything about worrying about the Russians!? What about terrorists/islamists/jihadists or whatever you want to call them. The US has many enemies, is on the decline, far away from Poland psychically, culturally and in just about every other way. Why make such a close relationship with them, not others? Interesting to see Americans supporting this, but as I said, what about the people. Sikorski is not the people. You ought to know that politicians never wholly represent the people, do not be naive.

Skysoulmate: what are you accusing me of? Nice of you to reconfirm that you fight wars and kill people for the oil corporations though. If you think that I only say this on the internet you are wrong. Truth is truth.
Piast Poland   
4 Mar 2011
News / US air base to be in Poland [193]

As I said think of the bigger picture. International relations and foreign policy. Some jobs being created is not all important. Interesting story :

timesofindia.indiatimes.com/world/europe/Frankfurt-airport-attack-a-jihadi-act-says-Germany/articleshow/7624611.cms