The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by mafketis  

Joined: 31 Mar 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 2 days ago
Threads: Total: 43 / Live: 23 / Archived: 20
Posts: Total: 11927 / Live: 7225 / Archived: 4702
From: tez nie
Speaks Polish?: tak
Interests: tez nie

Displayed posts: 7248 / page 91 of 242
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
mafketis   
7 Jan 2023
Language / Having a really hard time with Polish cases [59]

Not Spain??? :):):)

fine cuisine and style are Italy.... passion is Spain...

I actually like German which is a lot of fun if you approach it in the right way (and my voice sounds better in German than in any other language for some reason....)
mafketis   
7 Jan 2023
Language / Having a really hard time with Polish cases [59]

Back to cases; although they are unnecessary and most languages have them

All languages have ways of expressing case relations (unless you believe the rumors about some Asian languages like Vietnamese or Riau Indonesian).

English uses word order and prepositions, Polish uses distinct forms of the noun (and prepositions).

What's weird about German is the amount of.... redundant endings.... adjective endings are a pain partly because they're mostly redundant (unlike adjective endings in Polish)

Similarly lots of verb endings (accompanied by pronouns) ich spreche, du sprichst etc....

I think written German captured a transitional form of the language going from something more ornate like Icelandic to something simpler (like Dutch or Danish) and now it's stuck...
mafketis   
7 Jan 2023
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

you can do all that without

The least attractive feature of those on the left is the way they love telling people what they don't need to do.... live and let live is like poison to them....

It's like vegans telling people there's no need for dairy millk since there are a bunch of ersatz products instead.

Marvin and Tammi said it best:

youtube.com/watch?v=6AkIFa_wvwU
mafketis   
7 Jan 2023
Language / Having a really hard time with Polish cases [59]

It is very simple: mianownik, dopełniacz

They don't use the terms much in Polish schools... kto co, kogo co, kogo czego etc is far more common.

It's a bit like English. I don't remember teachers in English class in the US ever talking about things like articles (beyond telling us to stop saying "a apple"*) or conditionals (beyond telling us "If I was" was wrong). Nothing at all about sequence of tenses or lots of other things those who learn English as a second language have to deal with...

For extra fun, ask Poles why you say 'Mam komputer' but 'Mam laptopa'....
mafketis   
6 Jan 2023
Language / Having a really hard time with Polish cases [59]

asking native speakers which case was required in any given instance.

terrible idea, most Poles can't even match the (Polish) names of cases with the forms... you ask what case is used by using frames (I used to have a bunch of them for that purpose)

you can also ask kto co, kogo co, kogo czego etc.
mafketis   
4 Jan 2023
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

Doesn't it bother you in any way that you're taking life?

Do you consume meat, dairy or eggs? If so you're complicit in the taking of life...

a human being who doesn't want to be around people who don't have to hunt ....and yet they CHOOSE to do so.

No one's asking you to socialize with hunters or spend time with them... just to be tolerant that they exist (and not everything they do is bad).

Again... being killed by a hunter is a quicker and mostly less painful than the alternatives (apart from being killed predators starving to death or dying of untreated illness or injury are other common ends). Mother nature does not believe in gentle ends for most animals....
mafketis   
3 Jan 2023
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

Not "just" for the fun of it? But they still have fun killing nevertheless?

You misunderstand... hunting can be a traumatic process for the hunter and the high from killing is an adaptive trait to deal with the trauma (as are foraging people who pray over hunting, thanking the animal for giving up its life...) the high is an indication of what a strong drive hunting is.

Yes, there are some sick people who simply get off on killing but that's not most responsible hunters. There are types of recreational hunting that I despise but on the other, hunting is a drive embedded deep in the human (esp male) psyche and it's better to keep it in the open and regulated to some degree.

And most animals killed in hunting suffer far less traumatic deaths than most other wild animals.... pretend you're a deear and the options are being eaten alive by a predator, untreated disease or injury (the latter maybe leading to being eaten alive) or starving to death because you're too old..... or taken out with clean shot that you never see coming.... which would you choose?
mafketis   
3 Jan 2023
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

That's what I was talking about and that's what bothers me.

You wouldn't exist without it..... but now that it's not immediately needed you want to dispose of it?

I want there to be balance in nature. I didn't know that nature needs humans for that

Humans are part of nature...
mafketis   
1 Jan 2023
History / Crazy 1990s in Poland - transition from communism to capitalism - stories [111]

the type of souless financial predators it created.

You've got it wrong... the PRL was far more about soulless financial predation than anything that came after it. That rhetoric by those who had trouble adapting to capitalism has done a lot of damage to Poland... as pawian said, Poland was doing something no other country had ever really tried... obsessing about the inevitable mistakes is wrongheaded and completely irrelevant today.
mafketis   
1 Jan 2023
Language / New Years wishes in Polish? [40]

I'm not sure if I've ever heard it being used in real life...

I don't think I've heard it either (except for someone explaining it) I remember seeing it a lot in the early 1990s... (often incorrectly in store windows as "dosiego roku")

"Szczęśliwego Nowego Roku!" makes more sense

But it's long and awkward 9 syllables vs just 5...

It's also weird that theres no simple way to refer unambiguously to Christmas in Polish... Hungarians have Karácsony, Romanians have Crăciun, Czechs have Vánoce and Poles have.... Święta Bożego Narodzenia.... I sometimes wonder if novi is right that Polish people like making things unnecessarily difficult....
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Language / New Years wishes in Polish? [40]

Merged:

New Year's Wishes!



Why does it seem that no one uses the nice and simple expression "Do siego roku!" anymore?

Now the much longer and more awkward "Szczęśliwego Nowego Roku" seems to have taken over and I... don't like it.....

Anyhoo, Happy New Year to all here, Do siego roku!
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

hunting community in this area has a group that donate meat to poor families in rural communities

Shania Twain (whose adopted father was Ojibwa) has talked in interviews about being the recipient of American food distribution as a child (including game meat) and was very grateful for it.
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

They probably slung it and went for a Big Mac.

not good for them if they did.... properly prepared wild game is a lot healthier than junk food (and Amerindians have the highest prevalance of diabetes in the world).

usually girls that are High functioning autistics

on the autism close hunting connection (close hunting - solitary tracking of animals very different from confrontational hunting (getting a group of guys to run ungulates off a cliff or spear a mastodon...)

sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/06/110603122849.htm
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

What are those 'drives'?

described in #52... finding food, protecting the group, creating group cohesion, achieving status

I haven't noticed majority of people (including men) being into hunting

some aspects of those drives are funnelled into other areas.... why do some men love maps? (I've known very few women who get into them). It's theorize that a lot of features of high-functioning autism (kind of extreme male brain) are related to hunting, autistic men obsess about things like walking tip toe, jumping over things and setting traps...

lots of men who hunt the first time talk about a kind of endorphine rush or high at their first kill...

eagerly resigned from this primal instinct by turning to farming pretty early on

hunting wasn't replaced by farming but by animal husbandry... farming is an update of foraging (same idea - take control of the food source from the beginning to harvest).
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

Nice comparison, bringing new life vs taking a life...

both are biologically based drives without which humans would not exist... it's just that one is idealized and the other is demonized....
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Life / Polish film and serial riddles [137]

What is going to happen to this vodka?

It's about to be set on fire. From popiół i diament, a great movie (not enough is said about the using of lighting in it)
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Poland in photo riddles - part 2 [1680]

what this fish object really is.

leaving aside the temptation to say that it's a s3x doll for jr..... I'll say it's a pillow...

what has happened?

novi's brain after he realized russia is losing...
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

it's better that they kill animals "for fun"

Actually, as I understand it, it's not 'fun' that hunters are after...

You can do that ... None of that involves killing.

And that's why your alternatives don't work - hunting fills primal instincts that other alternatives lack...

You could say that women can fill their drive for motherhood by taking care of baby dolls - which don't involve producing carbon consuming people....
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

Most families gave up 'hunting' as soon as a more convenient food supply

For the most part newly acquired patterns of human behavior do not replace human drives, they sit on top of them... a more stable food supply did not eliminate the drives behind hunting and so recreational hunting is a thing and trying to legislate it out of existence just means those drives will be expressed elsewhere... (in probably less healthy ways)

'hunters' usually have small d1cks.

I won't even ask how you came in possession of such knowledge....
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

sociopaths have a 'necessity' to torture animals and children

To be sure, there are forms of commercial hunting that I completely despise (commerce corrupts as surely as power does). A lot of 'trophy' hunting counts for that (or shooting animals that have been deprived of normal defense responses by captivity). But a lot of hunting is a normal expression of homo sapiens survival drives and should be regulated and not eliminated at all.

Hunting is not my thing at all, but I don't think demonizing all hunters is a very productive activity. It feels good for the demonizer but doesn't produce any good results otherwise....

I have a cousin who spent many hours of his youth hunting in the forests of backwoods Florida... He ate some of what he hunted (esp deer though his family raised cattle) but not all of it. Compared to what happened to a lot of his age peers (nb. rural Florida is a cesspit of dysfunction) that was a downright wholesome activity - downright healthy compared to most of the other options.
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

wistful when a 'hunter' is eaten or gored by an animal they thought they'd kill.

An opinion only made possible by complete alienation from the processes of life and death.

Hunting is a _drive_ part of human nature. No one yet has been able to actually change human nature.
mafketis   
31 Dec 2022
Travel / Do Poles like to hunt? Hunting in Poland. [211]

Hunting is primitive, yes.

Hunting is part of what makes human.... human. It's a very deeply ingrained in the human psyche (especially the male psyche). There are several traditional types of hunting....

food (self explanatory)

defense (taking out other predators to reduce competition and to protect other members of the group)

display (showing off to other men and more specifically to women to advertise one's status as a desirable mate)

There might be others as well... in the modern world a lot of hunting is based on species nostalgia (for lack of a better word) it's also a chance for a type of male-bonding (important for maintaining a healthy society)

The nature of hunting as is why progressives hate it and conservatives supposedly support it (though this support is kind of wrongheaded and buffoonish).

Getting back to the original question - a few years ago I had a student who worked part-time as a local hunting.... interpreter, fixer (she didn't hunt but helped visiting hunters (many from Netherlands) deal with local regulations and authorities and paperwork. She said she really disliked it at first but came to respect it.

Weirdly one of the most commonly hunted animals in Poland (this was in the Kielce area IIRC) is the jenot (or raccoon dog - an animal I'd never heard of before).

Another student (female) became a hunter (an official title) those this is also involved a certain amount of service in the forest (being a licensed hunter in Poland also means being a conservationist).
mafketis   
17 Dec 2022
News / Years of Poland in the EU - assessment of pros and cons [1199]

But should they be defined as 'sin' or as damage limitation/maintaining order?

But then legalizing revenge murders (parts of feuds) or honor murders as "limiting damage" or "maintaining order".... china justifies a lot of its atrocities as 'maintaining order'...

I agree that religions should not be the ultimate arbiter of legislation but it does have a role. I'm not a believer but once you look into it, it does appear that humans are hard-wired for something like religion* and taking that into account should probably occur in creating legislation....

*It's a tricky balancing act, too much religion in a society leads to backwardness and stagnation while not enough leads to nihilism and dissipation