The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by mafketis  

Joined: 31 Mar 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 23 hrs ago
Threads: Total: 43 / Live: 23 / Archived: 20
Posts: Total: 11920 / Live: 7218 / Archived: 4702
From: tez nie
Speaks Polish?: tak
Interests: tez nie

Displayed posts: 7241 / page 217 of 242
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
mafketis   
27 Jan 2017
News / President Duda rules out homo marriage in Poland as banned by the constitution [172]

Sodomy though contradicts ALL known religious teaching

I think you mean 'bestiality' aka 'zoophilia'.... animals cannot consent.

Which is pretty meaningless as long as their parents think that it is the best thing since sliced bread.

Find some parents that think that and get back to us.
mafketis   
27 Jan 2017
News / President Duda rules out homo marriage in Poland as banned by the constitution [172]

in the Polish constitution it states marriage is between a man and a woman

And the Polish constitution is effectively in abeyance since the party leader decided that it should be put aside when it conflicts with his immediate political goals.

Start following the constitution and rule of law and then we'll talk.
mafketis   
27 Jan 2017
News / President Duda rules out homo marriage in Poland as banned by the constitution [172]

Perhaps we need a new word to separate these people away from normal primates?

You're referring to PiS voters I assume? If Duda is against homo sapiens marrying I guess that says something about supporters of the current government. Notice i did not use the word "sub-human". I'm too polite for that.
mafketis   
9 Jan 2017
Language / Harmless old-fashioned Polish swear words/phrases [159]

It can be sometimes used like we use SOB in English

I've never heard it used about a person, usually it's generalized frustration/rage, more like GD it! Sh1t! Mother!Fvck! (maybe not as strong as the last)
mafketis   
8 Jan 2017
Law / Weapons laws in Poland. Carrying a concealed handgun? [918]

ot Daniel would've been safer and alive WITH a gun

he was a thug, Daniel with a gun would have meant a lot more Poles than himself dead

(that said, killing him over trivia was completely wrong and I hope the perpetrators have a miserable rest of their misbegotten lives in prison)
mafketis   
28 Dec 2016
Law / Weapons laws in Poland. Carrying a concealed handgun? [918]

Guns don't kill people, people kill people.

Things make sense when you realize the entire US "gun control" movement is about trying to keep guns from urban minorities (especially blacks and hispanics) without actually saying that.

Similarly, most urban liberal education policy is about resegregating schools by exporting minorities (especially blacks and hispanics) out of cities where liberals live.

US liberals have a bunch of policies that are extemely anti-black and anti-hispanic but since they can't say that and keep their liberal status they come up with these weird and elaborate workarounds.....
mafketis   
27 Dec 2016
Genealogy / Possibility and proof of being Tatar [15]

She also appears to look Tatar (to me).

I cannot say I agree, but Tatars have been intermarrying with Poles for many generations so who can say. If I saw her picture and was asked I would say she looked Polish or Russian....
mafketis   
20 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

By comparison, Christmas Day is an anti-climactic also-ran.

Wigilia is an occasion and Christmas Day is no big deal in Poland. New Year's Eve is another big holiday (strengthened in the PRL due to Russian influence?) but epiphany is like Christmas Day, not much happens for most people.

Christmas in America is a festive season (who does advent in the US?) and Christmas Day marks the end of it (no Boxing Day whch I had no idea what it was before I moved to Poland saw references to it on Sky TV).

New Years Eve isn't as big a deal in the US (outside a few big cities) and Epiphany is mostly known where there are orthodox (Greek where I'm from) or from Spanish speaking countries (Christmas isn'ta big holiday in Spain, Epiphany, dia de los reyes magos, has always been bigger). Latin America seems to be a mixed bag in holiday terms....
mafketis   
20 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

Nothing wrong with that, is there?

Of course not. I think it's a perfectly legitimate way to give believers a feeling of connection to the religion, especially crucial when it was young and there's no reason to change now.

but that in no wise makes the celebration of the Nativity any less solemn, uplifitng and inspiring, does it?

I'm not a believer (though, like Camille Paglia, I respect religion). It's never been my favorite holiday but I have no desire whatsoever to inflict my lack of faith on people who do find comfort in it.
mafketis   
19 Dec 2016
News / Germany After the EU and the Russian Scenario - future of the European Union and Poland [310]

As far as the first statement, true as it undoubtedly is, the fact is it is when times are tough that a degree of empathy is most sorely needed, from ALL sectors of the society!!

So suck it up citizens! These Albanians and Iraqis need our help!

The government is attracted by the lure of cheap labor

But you have to get them to work for them to be cheap labor. How many of the Merkeljugend have found jobs?

The government though must call a halt to this policy and then, this might begin to stabilize matters

But western governments have made it completely plain that they will not halt the policy no matter what the voters want (which is faaaaaarrr more dangerous than anything FPO has advocated in the last couple of years).
mafketis   
19 Dec 2016
News / Germany After the EU and the Russian Scenario - future of the European Union and Poland [310]

Put YOURSELF in the position of being a stranger in a foreign country being unfairly targeted for the alleged misdeeds of your fellow countrymen.

Put yourself in the position of being in your own country and your government is cutting back needed services to citizens in order to take care of a bunch of economic migrants masquerading as refugees. Would you want to vote for a party that says it wants to put citizen interests first or for a party that doesn't even seem to much like the fact that country exists?

you're clearly playing the Devil's advocate, Maf, but it's enough already!

you're clearlyd unable to actually find terrible party positions or terrible things said by FPO people, enough with the fear mongering already!
mafketis   
18 Dec 2016
News / Germany After the EU and the Russian Scenario - future of the European Union and Poland [310]

The examples speak for themselves! READ THE PAPER, CHECK OUT THEIR PROPAGANDA.

I'm not just talking about you, almost every single story talks about how extremist and nasty FPO are..... without actually mentioning any particulr policies they prefer.

The few policies I've heard of sound okay,

rolling back EU intergration... (would a straight up 'do you want more or less EU integration?' referendum actually pass in any country?)

limiting participation in Mama Merkel's Madness... (worst poltical decision since WWII why help her pretend it's been anything but a disaster?)

leaving the EU if Turkey joins.... (especially under Erdogan)

Either name some policies they're proposing that are bad or stop expecting me to pay attention when people say they're so terrible.
mafketis   
18 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

You said Santa Claus, not some folk grandfather figure

Santa is just another incarnation of the motiff, the idea of him getting in houses through chimneys dates from 1809 and the reindeer pulled sled from 1820 or so.

BTW can you prove that in pre-Christian times there was a grandfather gift-giver reminsicent of Father Christmas or Dziadek Mróz?

I have no intention of doing a dissertation and it's a bit of a deduction but all these figures (and the old man at the end of the year) didn't come from nothing.

And of course the church as a long history of coopting pagan practices and putting a christian veneer over them. Nothing wrong with that at all it's a way to make people feel the faith is connected to them.
mafketis   
18 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

I didn't know that. I spent one Xmas in Poland a few years ago with friends, but no-one had presents on Wigilia.

Was this with friends or their families?

Also traditionally Xmas presents for adults traditionally tend to be small and symbolic in Poland (for financial and cultural reasons). That's changing some but it's nowhere like the US where people spend waaaaaaay too much money on presents.
mafketis   
18 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

Poles traditionally get presents from Sw. Mikołaj on December 6th

that's just for kids, traditionally

but the Poles I know in the UK, also give out small presents on Wigilia or Xmas da

Usually presents are opened during wigilia in Poland, Christmas day in Poland is usually.... just lazing around, eating, going to church (if you're so inclined) and/or visiting family that isn't too far away.

Basically, he's only happy when he's being miserable ;)

I don't mind him being miserable, but why insist that everybody else join in?
mafketis   
18 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

The brown fur hat adorned with holly leaves and the pipe of Nast's imagination was not replicated by Coca-Cola

So?

All across Europe you find the folk motiff of the onset of winter (or the winter solstice) being associated with an old man, possibly bearing gifts.

That's the idea uniting figures like Ded Moroz (Dziadek Mróz) and Father Christmas (who existed for centuries before being formalized in the Victorian era).

Calling that figure Saint Nicholas is just one more manifestation of that, another example of Catholicism co-opting pre-Christian pagan beliefs.

Deciding that one of these is the only true incarnation is very weird and I don't understand the logic.

Dude, life is too short to be so upset about Santa Claus.....

If I had my druthers Santa wouldn't be very well known outside the US but I'm not going to start ranting and raving about it.
mafketis   
17 Dec 2016
News / Germany After the EU and the Russian Scenario - future of the European Union and Poland [310]

Austria's vote in the correct path to democracy

How is voting for a party whose policies they agree with _not_ the correct path of democracy?

slow the march of les petites faschistes:-))

If you have to choose.

1. you can wave away the parties you don't like and unpopular EU policies towards greater integration and more non-European migration continue unabated

2. Some parties that are a bit further to the right than you like come to power in order to start changing unpopular EU policies.

(nb 1 is a likely path to civil uprisings in a few EU countries....)
mafketis   
10 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

Historically they differed in that the American Santa Claus of Irving and Nast creation was a rotund, jovial, bacchic figure rather than a saintly one.

Christmas in America also has a rich secular tradition probably mostly inherited from the England. The current version of Father Christmas only dates from Victorian times I believe but similar figures go back centuries.

Where does the Russina Ded Moroz (Polish Dziadek Mróz) come from?

The earliest American colonists (like modern Jehovah's Witnesses) didn't celebrate Christmas because of the lack of Biblical justification. As immigration grew beyond the highly religious Pilgrims and Puritans some, largely secular, English Christmas traditions were celebrated so that might be another factor contributing to the more secular Santa Claus.
mafketis   
10 Dec 2016
Life / Opłatek, not presents, epitomises the true Polish Christmas spirit [85]

Santa Claus, Poles refer to as Święty Mikołaj, correct?

I would say they're very different characters. Santa Claus can probably be traced to some stories by Washington Irving who largely wrote about the Dutch colonies around New York. That Saint Nick was originally almost a satire of the Dutch Sinterklaas (short and fat instead of tall and thin). The substitution of a sled drawn by a (single) reindeer was the contribution of an anonymous children's book aroud 1820 or so. Also along the way Sinterklaas's slaves were turned into elves (pc goes waaaaaay back).
mafketis   
9 Dec 2016
Polonia / POLES vs BULGARIANS [160]

How Poland is divided? Ideologically? Politically?

Poland is divided in several ways that intersect each other. These include geography (west vs east - the vistula/wisła river is a rough dividing line), politics (winners vs losers in the post-communist system) and generations (old vs young). It's a bit more complicated (it always is) but those are the big divisions. There are also regional distinctions that come from the partitions (basically the parts that were more German(ic) are better off than the parts that were under Russian rule because Russian rule at all times and in all places is terrible).

West vs East (aka Poland A vs Poland B): This is a bit like the North/South divide in Itay or the South/North divide in England. The west is richer, more productive economically and has more of a functioning civil society. The east is poorer and more mired in eastern (Russian) ways of doing things.

Winners and Losers after communism: Many who failed to prosper after the end of communism are bitter and want revenge against those who have done better. The more radical want to rebuild communist-era-style institutions (without communism per se).

Old vs Young: While Polish people are not nearly as socially liberal as their western peers, they generally have litle tolerance for living in the past and they are bored with the endless wars rooted in the communist period. Their main concern is finding a job that will pay them enough to live on and not increasing social safety nets for economically unproductive older people. The oler generation, sensibly from their point of view, votes for more of a safety net for the old and against most types of change, even those that are needed.

I don't personaly know a single Bulgarian person who is welcoming towards the illegal migrants from Africa and Central Asia.

This is true in Poland as well. I work around people who are some of the most tolerant towards other cultures you can imagine and not a single one supported Merkel's madness or the plan to accept her surplus. The only acceptance of the idea of settling the Merkel youth in Poland I've come across is from Brits on this forum who like the idea of weakening social cohesion because they dislike most features of traditional Polish culture.