The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by mafketis  

Joined: 31 Mar 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 18 hrs ago
Threads: Total: 43 / Live: 23 / Archived: 20
Posts: Total: 11923 / Live: 7221 / Archived: 4702
From: tez nie
Speaks Polish?: tak
Interests: tez nie

Displayed posts: 7244 / page 189 of 242
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
mafketis   
3 Oct 2018
Life / Differences between Irish, British, Polish, American and other nations culture, tradition, music - loose talk [241]

Steeleye Span set my teeth on edge

I lurve Maddy Prior (and her collaborations with June Tabor as the Silly Sisters).

Are you familar with Clannad's early stuff? T

The first album I had by them was Clannad 2 (around 1980 and then bought anything by them through Fuaim) after that I drifted more into alternative American punk stuff (X, Black Flag, Minute Men, Husker Du)

The only song by them in English I really, really liked was two sisters

youtube.com/watch?v=GhnPOUyEomc

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clannad_2

A favorite in Irish was the more contemporary An Tull

youtube.com/watch?v=MlOrEIKNOXQ
mafketis   
3 Oct 2018
Life / Differences between Irish, British, Polish, American and other nations culture, tradition, music - loose talk [241]

Okay I'm American but I never totally "got" CCR. A very good band with some very good singles, but nothing for the ages. Being marginally from the US south their southern shtick always felt a little put on (and so I wasn't surprised when I found it was in fact a put on). If you want real Southern Rock from the US it's the Allman Bros and Lynyrd Skynyrd all the way.... (Wet Willie have their moments too)

On the other hand, I loved TRex more than I can say from the first moment I heard them (they only had one hit in the US) and they never, ever sound stale to me, they sound as vivid and fresh to me now as when I first him.

I also have a particular love of British folk rock groups like Fairport Convention, Steeleye Span and Pentangle (and Clannad especially when they sang in Irish)
mafketis   
1 Oct 2018
Genealogy / Polish Gypsy Roots & Roma ancestors in their families [205]

Gypsies however don't traditionally inbreed that much,

Shows what you know.... I was talking with a scholar who's studied gypsy culture in Southeastern Europe and he says a big problem is that doctors often don't know how to begin treating them because of the high levels of what might be called 'distant inbreeding' (they have something like castes, not surprising, and marriage happens overwhelmingly within those).

I've personally seen lots of gypsies in Hungary who clearly have genetic.... issues (not so much in Poland I have to say, but gypsy culture reaches its heights of dysfunction in SE Europe and is comparably more functional (though often still pretty awful) in the UK and Spain (where some leave the gypsy lifestyle and integrate into the mainstream).

our NHS is for everyone

Not buying it, the following is appalling and ignoring it in the name of.... some weirdo progressive idea is morally repellent

independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/london-borough-child-deaths-redbridge-parents-related-cousins-pakistani-families-council-report-a7741146.html
mafketis   
1 Oct 2018
Genealogy / Polish Gypsy Roots & Roma ancestors in their families [205]

however often devastating and increasingly a thing of the past, fortunately.

How much of the NHS budget goes to treating birth defects from Pakistani inbreeding (aka 'cousin marriage')? Is there any evidence of cousin marriage decreasing in parts of the Arab world or Pakistan?

Culture and history matter in making social policy (and culture probably has a genetic element that science is just starting to get a handle on). Pretending that none of that matters in the face of enlightened social policy is a mass tragedy in the making...
mafketis   
1 Oct 2018
Genealogy / Polish Gypsy Roots & Roma ancestors in their families [205]

More likely a response to the reaction of others.

It's also selection pressure, small endogamous groups with non-standard lifestyles like the Amish or Gypsies or Orthodox Jews tend to filter out those whose genetic profile makes them ill adapted for the lifestyle. Over generations this makes the core group more like itself and less like outsiders.

Inbreeding does something similar, your relatives are more related to you than are the relatives of non-inbreeders and so family ingroup ties are much stronger.

People are not blank slate widgets but rather the products of time and circumstance and longterm genetic trends that are far stronger than do-gooder social policy....
mafketis   
1 Oct 2018
Genealogy / Polish Gypsy Roots & Roma ancestors in their families [205]

They're actually quite good, and certainly don't 'fudge data'.

Like adding in African DNA? DNA isn't the magic silver bullet some people think it is, it can give a good idea on the major components but people want a perfect 100% count and as of yet that's impossible.

I wouldn't mind finding out (and wouldn't mind having Gypsy roots at all) though I don't think it really matters

Well.... the emerging truth is that genetics and culture are probably more intertwined than progressive people would like, with genes associated with behaviors like clannishness or altruism are not at all evenly distributed among different human groups. In other words, gypsies act like gypsies (clannish, distrustful of outsiders etc) because of their dna.

everyone outside South East Africa is the result of a long, complicated and mixed human journey.

Actually the Out-of-Africa hypothesis has been taking its lumps as of late....
mafketis   
20 Sep 2018
History / Not proud of my Polish heritage [110]

A true Gaeltacht man would say his family were from Tír Chonaill ;)

A true Gaeltacht man would say his family were from Tír Chonaill ;)

Google translate fails again?

As for the rest of your post (takes off hat, bows low)
mafketis   
18 Sep 2018
History / Not proud of my Polish heritage [110]

the whole object is to push propaganda that leads Poland away from the current path

I'm not happy about all of the current path either, and paranoid insistence on determining who is and isn't "really" Polish seems very in line with the PiS modus operandi. And their destructive and paranoid attempts to rewrite the history of the early and late 1980s are doing tremendous damage - young people in their 20s know nothing of the communist period.
mafketis   
18 Sep 2018
History / Not proud of my Polish heritage [110]

I would like to see Poland shed itself of it's Jewish political leaders and ethnic Poles fill their position

Okay, you're a kremlin troll (leading sooner or later up to the need to ally with the pariah leper state of Russia)

"Ethnic Pole" and "Jewish" are not discrete categories (the way "Ethnic Russian" and "Jewish" are). There's always been some overlap.
mafketis   
17 Sep 2018
History / Not proud of my Polish heritage [110]

Even today, I don't see anything promising for the future of Poland.

Have you ever actually set foot in the country? The changes over the last 20 years are so are fairly amazing, not all positive but more positive than negative by a long shot. And staring down the USSR for 45 years and having the USSR blink first is an amazing historical accomplishment - a massive societal change without a single drop of blood (as much as that disappoints some here)

I am comparing us to other world powers

Dumb idea, compare it to other countries in the region and it's doing very well, not perfect but pretty well.

I prefer is that Poland develop into something I can be genuinely be proud of.

What would make you proud?
mafketis   
17 Sep 2018
News / German state declare diplomatic war on Poland. [56]

Southern Europe needed solidarity

Tell it to Greece, stuck in depression for..... 10 years now and no hope of ever getting out of it?

on whose insistence she decided to not close the borders

which story is this, there've been a few trying to explain her irrational act
mafketis   
17 Sep 2018
News / German state declare diplomatic war on Poland. [56]

Germany' foreign policy towards Poland under Merkel was always very conciliator

It was, and then the historically good relations that PO had achieved with Germany turned into electoral poison in September of 2015 "PO is friends with that crazy lady and liable to do whatever she tells them? Nein danke!"

as reliable partner in European affairs

How many European leaders did Merkel consult with before opening up the borders? That's how many countries should help afterward...
mafketis   
16 Sep 2018
News / German state declare diplomatic war on Poland. [56]

So you're saying that in 2015 Germany didn't take a dangerous turn toward the unstable but simply revealed what it already was - a dangerously unstable neighbor that makes massive decisions on their own and then expects other countries to comply....... noted.
mafketis   
14 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

e it wasn't imagined in the 1950's that countries would be so openly and massively corrupt.

Well that didn't start with Orban... the Gyrucsany government was far worse than even PiS (it was about as bad as PiS-ites claim PO was).

You jest, but actually, would it be such a bad idea for standardised postal rates, so stamps could be used interchangeably all over the EU?

A nice idea that should be doable in a half dozen pages of legislation.... which means the EU would take two years and come up with a 6000 page monstrosity that was more trouble to implement than it's worth and that micromanages the size of letter carriers lapels...
mafketis   
14 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

We still have our postage stamps

How long before there's an EU Postal Directive that "harmonizes" postal rates (and stamps and the size of mailboxes and envelope sizes etc)?

now it's just the harp.

which makes it look like a Ryanair product tie in... (and now I want coins with deer and fish on them too!).
mafketis   
14 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

y main complaint about the EU at present is how ineffective and weak they have been in handling the problems that started with Hungary in the first place

Which problems would those be?

Both the 2004 expansion (too much too fast without enough institutional stability) and the introduction of the Euro (to solve problems that no longer existed) are examples of major hubris on the part of the EU.

The gross incompetence in their mishandling of the entirely predictable Euro crisis and the ongoing migration crisis are examples of institutional atrophy as most of the major players are simply trying to hang on to their power and privilege rather than find workable and lasting solutions to either problem.

Also the EU has done nothing to actually create any kind of emotional connection with EU citizens, for various reasons they cut themselves off from most real European traditions and cultures. Take the Euro, national currencies have pictures of real people or real places - the euro has a bunch of fake bridges that carry zero emotional resonance.

What's left is a bunch of slogans that no one believes and a surrender to financial interests of the largest countries ueber alles... who wants to sign on to that?

The European Union BE (Before Euro) had probably done more to eliminate poverty than any national or international institution in history.... how the might have fallen.
mafketis   
13 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

said the said articles would save decent and independent journalism

Here's a good intro to the topic (starts at 9.00)

youtube.com/watch?v=hFROh2RCtog

Germany and Spain already have similar legislation... and it hasn't helped at all.
mafketis   
13 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

seem to have a B in your bonnet about the EU Maf. I'd still rather live in an EU member state

In theory I support the EU but in the last some odd years it's been going off the rails and pretending it's not doing a lot of damage to itself won't change that. My criticism is because I support it (within well-defined limits).

Just waiting and seeing what will happen is what got us into the current situation and also won't help...
mafketis   
13 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

n general research is carried out on various proposals and is presented to members of the European parliament

I don't know of anyone who knows anything about how the internet works who supported articles 11 or 13...

And the EU parliament is very corrupt at the personal level, have you seen this

youtube.com/watch?v=VTpkdtzncT0

There was another one some years previous where they run in the building to sign for the day on their way to the airport (I think it was on German tv). One hapless crook was humiliated standing with her face to the wall while waiting for the elevator and muttering about the impertinence of journalists monitoring her gravy train....
mafketis   
13 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

As to these Articles, only time will tell the results.

So why don't you give the Polish government the same benefit of a doubt?

To be clear I dislike PiS and its agenda, but everything you've said about the EP could be used as an argument to let the PiS program play out...

Why the double standard?
mafketis   
13 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

In other news the European Parliament just passed article 13 (aka the war against memes)

A bunch of technocrats with no understanding of human nature or the internet passing legislation that they neither understand or will be affected by themselves....

Brexit is starting to look smarter by the day...
mafketis   
12 Sep 2018
News / Poland in the European Union. Polexit? [559]

Eu is simply a sugar daddy to millions of poles.

And someone who gets money from a sugar daddy is a vvhore, is that what you think of Poland?
mafketis   
6 Sep 2018
Language / Short Polish<->English translations [1050]

The critical thing is to _not_ spring this on Kasia in front of her parents.

He doesn't know them, she does. If she wants to marry him she'll know the best way to tell them (which might include having him "officially" ask them in Polish).