The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives 
 
 
User: Guest

Posts by Sasha  

Joined: 19 Apr 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 8 Dec 2017
Threads: 2
Posts: Total: 1,083 / Live: 530 / Archived: 553
From: Moscow/Kyiv
Speaks Polish?: Russian, English, Swedish, Ukrainian
Interests: Slavic countries, politics, languages, culture, people

Displayed posts: 532 / page 15 of 18
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Sasha   
25 Feb 2009
Genealogy / Mongolian the Golden Horde - do Poles have Mongolian ancestry? [256]

I myself have nothing against Russians

Neither have I against Poles.

western Ukrainians look more like Polish people, and their language seems close to Polish as well

True. But their group is insignificant on the scale of all Ukranian nation and they stand apart of the rest of the nation. I equally respect Ukranians, Belorussians and Poles. There's no interest for me to say that exactly Belorussians are closer to Poles; this is just what I feel basing on my life experience and knowledge I've got. There's always room for mistake.

EDIT: I'm glad Slavs deal good with each other being abroad. :)
Sasha   
25 Feb 2009
Genealogy / Mongolian the Golden Horde - do Poles have Mongolian ancestry? [256]

Pennboy, different professors make different studies. Surfing the internet you may easily find two diametrically opposite points on the genetics which would contradict each other (I for one have recently found the article "Scratch Russian... get Pole" with a study for it). On the whole I don't tend to thoroughly believe in any of them since the often tied up with political intrigues. So I'm trying to base on the common sense: Ukranians are mostly dark-haired for many factors including early Tataric&Don-Sursk influence whereas Belorussians are mostly blond. The info you're asking about I learnt from the article written by Ukranian author who claimed that in fact there were only two Slavic nation: Belorussians and Poles. All others can be hardly reckoned as Slavic. I don't think it's any biased and I somewhat share it. Btw Belorussian (the initial one, not the current Russianized version of it) is closer to Polish than any other language. And even the current version is so close that Belorussian lady and her Polish husband doesn't strongly need to study each others language since they understand one another quite well.
Sasha   
23 Feb 2009
History / Famous Russian Poles [243]

Kostia, privet!

Yanko- exposes his ukrainian origin.

His last name could have been transferred for several times. Afterall I wouldn't assert he's not any related to Poles. At least I found a couple links proving that (also see post#1 of this thread). What did you find?
Sasha   
23 Feb 2009
Genealogy / Mongolian the Golden Horde - do Poles have Mongolian ancestry? [256]

Based on the newest genetic studies it is the Ukrainians who are the closest to us my blood,

Belorussians are the closest to you. "The newest genetic study" you mentioned was likely to be about politics rather than real state of affairs.
Sasha   
15 Feb 2009
News / Is NORD STREAM dangerous for Poland's natural enviroment? [372]

Russians want Poland.

Russians are either friendly or don't give a sh!t about you... and the second option is what I'd worry about, if I were you Princy.

you dumb ass

Uff... such a poor rhetoric... bad-bad Princy...
Sasha   
14 Feb 2009
News / Is NORD STREAM dangerous for Poland's natural enviroment? [372]

Russian resources are no longer cheap and the price is growing

Great times of the cheap gas (you meant gas, didn't you) are left behind. Now it's growing for citizens of Russia as well.

Russia instigated the conflict but Ukraine is to blame too

I agree in a way.

the point is that Russia could have played it differently, it could start alternate routes through Belarus for example but it didnt

She did. Seriously, or elsewise you would suffer a stronger deficiency. The problem is that the route through Belorussia technically can't ensure needs of all customers.

Because it's right into bullseye example

Don't give me your bull. :)

It hurts, doesn't it?

Well... only if you want it. :)

No, don't answer - let me guess: it's Ukraine stealing it, of course...

I'm not trying to talk you into. I wouldn't really mind, if you didn't buy our gas and oil. In this case Russia will have to get back to her industry which is essentially my dream.
Sasha   
14 Feb 2009
News / Is NORD STREAM dangerous for Poland's natural enviroment? [372]

moronic actions that make Europe dependent on Russia are not responsible and should be opposed with all tools available or the consequences will be severe to the entire Europe Germany included.

Europe will anyway be dependent on somebody's natural resources, id est on some particular country. If not Russia then anybody else but I'm afraid that won't make them (resources) for you:

- cheaper
- guaranteed

Russia is not a stable and trustworthy partner

You mean so-called gas conflict? I see the guilt of Russia there pretty slight comparing to Ukrainian one. However I don't deny Russia played some negative role in all that.
Sasha   
14 Feb 2009
News / Is NORD STREAM dangerous for Poland's natural enviroment? [372]

Why do you like so much to compare some bygone superpowers with the actual state of affairs? Russia is not the USSR, Germany is not fascist anymore. Both are run not by Hitlers (Stalins). Why should you expect any surprise? You still at the times of Katyn... maybe that's the issue.
Sasha   
13 Feb 2009
News / Is NORD STREAM dangerous for Poland's natural enviroment? [372]

Russia won't ever do anything bad to Germany, since she will be afraid of being cut from delivery of exceptional and exquisite German goods.

Richy you merely don't undertand the ABC of a diplomacy. If two countries get along well why should they do anything bad towards each other?! In your case considering that all Polish foreign policy is based on opposing to Russia, do you think you have any reason to expect some nice attitude from our Gov-t back? I guess no...

this is why we oppose it and use the ecology card,

And drive to Belorussia to fill your tanks up? Yes Russia is dominating... but isn't the prices they offer cheap? I would personally prefer to see our country not selling any resources abroad... so that you would "enjoy" the opportunity to check prices of other suppliers.
Sasha   
12 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Poland is more reliable country than Russia.

Well... if you say so. Your word is the best proof.

Good quality and quite cheap, I recommend. :)

Nice to hear that. :) I didn't know we'd produced compasses after the USSR collapse.

For the same reason why Russian foreign policy was so concentrated on the Baltic states. Politicians must turn attention of the masses away from themselves.

Agree with the last sentence as for the first one I wouldn't have said they we concentrated but they did puff up antirussian moods in Baltic States to distract Russians from their actual problems.
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Prince, my questions:

1) do you personally suffer gas shortage?
2) why are you sure that Poland suffers gas shortage? considering your government's mainstream I wouldn't be any amazed if they simply made it up.

3) If this true, why are you so sure that it's Russia that should take responsibility for that shortage?

My general question is "are you sure that your view on the whole is not affected by some of your personal preferences which don't have anything to do with the objective reality"? I think that you should clear your mind of prejudices first.
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

After Poland other countries will be in danger.

Oh yeah... sure... Poland first of all as the hub of the Universe. It's like to carry out surgery on eyes through the rectum. Don't you think so?

Poland doesn't have gas.... we have paid for this gas

Could I read about it? In other words... links?

Why Russia cut off only Poland ?

Why is Polish international policy based on opposing to Russia?

But...but...but...they so LOVE this mantra!

I wish it wasn't true.. :((
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Russian policy towards Poland is hostile.

Nor Polish is better.... Agggrreeeee?! :)

Boring is that you never attemt to see things in a positive way. I do realize that there're currently lots of problems and mutual jabs between two our countries but the position like "you're hostile and we're shiny friendly thence f*ck off" is not constructive at all and doesn't any facilitate to resolve the issue. The strength of the whole is in the power of single; and the more of those who care not shutting his eyes on the problems, the better we get along. I do believe in our really friendly future... unlike to you, I guess.
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

So I've edited my post before your

Oh... I see... you unbeatable champion of editing... :)

We shouldn't buy your gas because it is like heroine

I didn't try it intravenously yet. Can't say for sure. :)

Russia - wants to reduce Polish suverenity.

*yawn*It's so boring Prince. Are you serious? Haven't you got tired yet?
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

We shouldn't buy their products.

Just out of curiosity... do you have any over there except for oil and gas?

P.S. Think you understand that your message on the whole is hardly commentable.
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Hey BB do you know that French army is 10 time stronger than German army!! French army would take over Germany with in 15 days!!

There're two ways to hear something similar: Bush(es) and kindergartens.
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
Genealogy / THE MEANING AND RESEARCH OF MY POLISH LAST NAME, SURNAME? [4501]

Kapustka

That's a lovely way to say "cabbage" in Russian (the regular way is "kapusta"). I think it has the same meaning in Polish but there's always a room for "false-friends". I'm afraid I can't say anything else on your name.

Perhaps she is ethnically from Ukraine, but became Polish with the border changes? I don't know, but I figure anywhere around the Carpathian Mountains also means Southeast Poland, which may increase the probability of a Russian last name?

Even though there're lots of "Kapusta" and "Kapustka" in Russia I would look for the origins in Ukraine or Belarus or Krasnodarskij Kraj of Russia. Historically those are places where people have liked traditionally to pick as a last name some nouns, especially related to animals like "Volk" (wolf), Zajac (hare) etc. Considering the place you mentioned (Carpathian mountains) there's also an opportunity that your forefather might be Ruthenians (Rusini).
Sasha   
11 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

All I'm saying and you probably don't understand is that Iran is trying to start a war it's heading towards it!! I didn't say they did start one!

And what's I'm saying is that it is highly unlikely. Nobody has recently invaded the US, vice versa the US invaded other countries. And the Achmadinezhad's rhetoric towards the US to the large extent caused by apriori hostile attitude of the US and their permanent will to stick its nose wherever it's possible.

and if you haven been paying attention that I'll just remind you that Iran just fired a satellite in to space.

I see you didn't pay attention to mine post. Launch of satellite is a bluff.

The US makes it as if there're loads of enemies all around and they all dream about attempt upon American "democracy" and that serves for the only purpose of puffing up military budget and get out unpunished after Iraq-like oil-operations.
Sasha   
10 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

So they will try to start wars with US!!

Lotnik do you realize what you're saying? Name me at least one country that have recently started war(s) with the US. Iraq? lol
Sasha   
10 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Isn't it the case that it is Ukrainian and to be returned to them 8 years from now?

Basically yes, it is Ukranian. They just don't want to prolong the lease.
And it's interesting... if there're some ethnical cleansing, 1000s of people rotted in camps then Russia is a heir of the guilt but if there're some military bases, factories then of course baltic states or Ukraine or any other country of the former USSR is the rightful heir.

Surely that's the best guarantee that can be provided, inspections? What else would you propose?

The best guarantee is not to keep radioactive materials (going back to my example), i.e. not to install missile shield.

your military is NOT what will give you security!

I'd even say opposite. That's what would jeopardize them.

My suspicion is that Iran already has the missiles, and is now just trying to get something "special" for a payload. After all, as you and I both know, the technology for launching a warhead and for launching a satellite...are the same, and Iran has just done exactly that, contrary to many who thought they weren't so far along.

I've recently listened to one Russian military expert on the Middle East affairs on radio. He cast doubt on that they had launched satellite. As an engineer whose scope of activity includes aerospace vehicles I second his opinion. Iran is bluffing. They in fact did once the launch of the satellite but there was Russia helping them. Their warhead delivery system can cover for now less than 2000km but as I already said Russia didn't feel comfortable with that and tried to reach a compromise with Iran both in her oil interests and interests of her and her neighbours safety.
Sasha   
9 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Poland should't waste a single euro to build up the army. It's just waste of money and i don't believe it will be any new war. Since almost every continent has nuclear weapons who could wipe out the planet of earth in less then 1 hour.

I believe in Economic warfare, maybe Poland should spend money on it's economy instead?

Very nice, constructive and healthy point. All those "shields" are only pretexts for intrigues. Nowadays in fact attacking facilities "a head taller" than those safeguarding.
Sasha   
9 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

First point, the Ukrainian lease til 2017. It was a 20-year lease, signed fair and square. Why does the Russian govt insist on not letting it go?

Oh... you mean the Port Sevastopol. It's about the only significant Russian naval base in the south, the largest in Black Sea. Nobody wants to lessen its military strength.

Second point, Russian inspectors were invited to inspect the installation and operation of the shield. Isn't that a good enough guarantee in itself?

Sean, imagine that there's a crazy professor experimenting with radioactive materials on your neighbourhood. You can come to his place and stare at his experiments as long as you want but this doesn't guarantee your safety.
Sasha   
9 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

although from watching Russia's actions it would seem Russia's interest is the oil...(also?)

Of course, especially considering that putin has no idea on what else he could sell. Well... I forgot about gas...

John, we already discussed the issue about missile shield in Poland and I'm afraid I can't state anything new on that, but as for Iran - Russia's worried more and more about the Iran working on the intercontinental ballistic missile. Believe me Russia doesn't need another pain in neck however I don't see any other way to handle the issue except for diplomatic. Let's face the fact: if Iran would build the missile, Poland shield couldn't help. Well... there's one more way - to invade Iran right-away but this hardly possible. I don't think the world society will allow to the US another Iraq.

The Russian inspectors were offered full access to the facilities. What's the problem here, Sasha?

Excuse me Sean I've lost track of our discussion. Are you talking about Ukraine now?
Sasha   
9 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Russia is, or was, or could be...an ally of the U.S. as well.

I disagree. Two Empires can't be allies. We(you and me I mean) may be friends, I have many American friends but two our governments - never. And perhaps we will both be able to see it better, when the arctic shelf's developed. The basic american interest here is the oil and they always forget while in Europe the old saying "when at Rome, do as the Romans do".

well, we're angry at the Americans, so we might invade Poland"

No... I would apply different logic. The American missile system located in Poland might shake the piece in the region.
Sasha   
9 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

yes , you are a bastard too.

Spasibo, Dr. Zoidberg!

The Kaczinskies and the Bushies are gone...(or lost power at least).

True, but I don't think it would any change the mainstream of their newsblocks.
Sasha   
9 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Yet in many of your posts you have convicted Russia

Me either. So what? Bastard too?

America stirred it up in Georgia

Yes, because it's the only way for the pipe bypassing Russia from that region.

Russia is adamant that they will retain control over it.

Well at least that's what the current power wants. Now our media activelly convincing people that Ukraine goes bankrupt.
Sasha   
9 Feb 2009
News / Poland Should Beef Up Military [286]

Yeah, I think it became apparent that the aggressors were Georgia and different parties were trying to make Russia look bad. Now they have drawn attention to the truth and will build a base in Abkhazia. Well done Russia :)

I find it naive to put it mildly when people say about the future agression of Russia against Poland as if it is something inevitable. Weird. That would be stupid. However I should admit that american influence in Europe adds fuel to the fire.