Language /
Polish Swear Words [1242]
I can tolerate your German root proposal but only as one more hypothesis - let it be number 3). I have heard about that - but it has no clear phonetic path from Gothic HORS to Slavonic KUREW.
ok agreed - let's assume it comes from some Urindoeuropean root which evolved differently in Germanic languages and Slavic languages - this sounds pretty plausible, Slavic languages probably then retained the more archaic version (remember k- h change in proto-Germanic)
yes you are right that phonetically there could not be change from *ho/ur to kurew - all other borrowings from Gothic dialects attest that Geramnic h/ch were retained in Slavic as ch (see chlew, chleb - I know these examples)
having said all that I am not a professional linguist
LITWA - all the Lithuanians,
i doubt it is collectivum in this case - in my eyes it just seems shortening of Lietuva - I doubt Lithuanians borrowed the name of their country from their Slavic neighbours - it is however true that the word Litwa acted as a collectivum in Slavic languages
never heard of Tatarwa collectivum but I guess you didn't make it up