News /
Polish President Lech Kaczynski and gov officials die in a plane crash in Russia [686]
It will be interesting to read the report. The Yak crew on the ground was in contact with 101 during the arrival and the approach. ATC suggested a diversion and informed the crew of the Il's attempts to land. The controller (and the Yak crew) at the field informed the crew of the conditions.
Also, Pilot error doesn't necessarily mean its the pilot's fault if its induced pilot error.
Sure it does. The pilot error in this case was knowingly descending past minimums (with the AP engaged), as well as ignoring TAWS. The pilot is responsible for the safety of the plane and passengers at all times, this is no exception. For instance, if TCAS starts screaming at you that another aircraft is closing in, you don't need permission to change altitude or heading, you just do it. Same goes for an approach in minimums. The controller will not tell the pilot to break off an approach, it is expected that they will call minimums and go missed.
Also does that CFIT syndrome you talk about have to do with sudden whether/fog changing conditions?
Mostly it's lack of situational awareness due to pilot error. Changing weather conditions shouldn't be an issue on an approach like that. You reach minimums, and you go missed. The fog was already known (as relayed from the Yak crew, and the controller). According to the transcripts, they never made visual contact with the runway, but went below minimums anyway. Trying to dip below and "take a peek" is a fairly common way to die on an approach. It's also a good way to get down through that last illegal 20m and land the aircraft.
If you don't believe the transcripts are authentic, then there's nothing to analyze and it just turns into mass conspiracy with endless vague theories that can't be analyzed due to lack of evidence.