News /
Will PiS be happy if AfD wins elections in Germany? [1442]
Schopenhauer, Kant, Hegel, Nietzsche, Heidegger, and Marx
Let's see...
Schopenhauer - critique of pure reason: limits knowledge to phenomena, excluding metaphysical knowledge of God and the soul, undermining natural theology. The ethics of moral autonomy places the human will and reason as the ultimate moral authority rather than divine law and grace. The exaltation of human reason apart from divine revelation and grace leads to moral subjectivism and undermines the authority of the Church and Scripture.
Verdict:
HegelHegel's idea of God as the unfolding of Spirit in history undermines the unchanging, personal God of Catholic doctrine. Suggests that truth evolves over time (totally retarded when we think about extratemporal eternity). Reduces theology to speculative philosophy, blurs Creator-creation distinction, and replaces divine revelation with dialectical reason.
Verdict:
SchopenhauerLife is fundamentally suffering, and the highest goal is the denial of the will-a view contrary to the Catholic affirmation of creation and the redemptive value of suffering. His metaphysical "will" dominates human action, conflicting with Catholic teaching on moral responsibility. Denies the goodness of creation and the meaningfulness of human life and freedom, opposing the Catholic view of hope, providence, and salvation.
Verdict:
NietzscheNietzsche's rejection of God aims to overthrow the Christian moral order. Promotes a radically self-assertive ethic contrary to humility, charity, and obedience. His glorification of strength, contempt for compassion, and attack on Christian virtues align with the "pride of Lucifer" and undermine natural law and divine revelation.
Verdict:
HeideggerHeidegger's philosophy often excludes or relativizes the personal, revealed God. Emphasizes human existence in a way that often lacks reference to sin, grace, or salvation.His existentialism abstracts Being from God, making his thought spiritually sterile or ambiguous from a Catholic standpoint.
VerdictHmm... the stake might be a bit too harsh. Let's say: official reproach, stern warning, a little bit of torture and some time in the dungeon to reflect on his mistakes.
MarxReligion is the "opium of the people", class struggle as the engine of progress negates Christian teaching on solidarity, charity, and the intrinsic dignity of each person, Marxist ideology opposes the Church's teaching on the soul, God, private property, and the family, promoting atheism and often leading to persecution of religion.
Verdict
Do you have any other heretics for me?
