The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by gumishu  

Joined: 6 Apr 2009 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - A
Last Post: 1 day ago
Threads: Total: 15 / Live: 11 / Archived: 4
Posts: Total: 6187 / Live: 2571 / Archived: 3616
From: Poland, Opole vicinity
Speaks Polish?: yes

Displayed posts: 2582 / page 28 of 87
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

eyewitness's testimony should have been censored

I don't know of any testimony that would contradict those from the 1949 trial - please show me if you have any
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

This whole tax is political (anti-non state media) and zwyczajne zdzierstwo too.

the media can happily add the tax to their prices - sure the higher cost of advertising would influence consumer prices a bit that's all - instead they have thrown a tantrum - if this is not political what is - you swallowed it as an attack on the media (as probably millions of others) - I see their move as an attack - and the tax as just another tax
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

Do you think the eyewitness's testimony should have been censored because it reflects badly on someone?

please quote it - how do i know there are any testimonies to support your claim
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

Nowa-oplata-na-rachunkach-za-prad-Znamy-stawki-8011301.html

wysokienapiecie.pl/34168-ceny-pradu-rosna-przez-oplate-mocowa-ale-nie-koniec-podwyzek/ - read this - opłata mocowa is not a whim of PiS it is there to give Polish energetic system more safety - also the electricity prices in Poland are still lower than the EU average (last I checked Germans pay almost 50 per cent more than us)

once again - seriously read this article (I doubt you ready any of the articles I posted but well..) - tvp.info/43539295/kierunkowano-nas-na-sciganie-legalnych-podmiotow-a-tymczasem-rozwijaly-sie-mafie

if you don't infer from the article that the PO, PSL and others from the so called total opposition are crooks then I don't know what could change your mind
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

And remember, an eyewitness more recently gave an interview that contradicted that.

the court has spoken - I don't even get when you get all those new and recent testimonies - if there where any the court would pass a different verdict
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

We do. The costs will simply be passed on.

of course I understand - I also understand the mechanism by which PiS aims to lessen the burden of the social spending - and I understand why Trzaskowski said: 'Nic co zostało dane, nie zostanie zabrane' (Nothing that was given will be taken away (as for the social spending under PiS) - I just don't find the prospect of PO, PSL or SLD getting power back appealing - imagine big social spending and a renewed VAT fraud, fuel smuggling and a monopoly on media

so yeah - this whole current action is purely political and the argument that PiS wants to shut down hostile media is manipulative - but I guess Paulina would not understand
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

the fees by another 20-25zł a month to cover the increased electricity costs.

thank the EU CO2 quotas for that - and the PO government who agreed on the new system of counting the quotas or some such (basically Poland first agreed to be eligible to pay excessive CO2 starting from 1990 or 1989 and Tusk agreed to change that to the detriment of Poland (and to give him a boost to his career in Europe)
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

so why instead of burdening private media with another tax

they can happily add this new tax to the prices of their add time/space which will doublethe positively effect on the budget - the whole action is simply political (and anti-PiS)
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

She is (or was, not sure about now) pro-PiS - I even noticed that, not only my parents, gumishu.

you noticed that she is not a PiS basher if you ask me - your bias prevents you from seeing that she is trying to find truth as is Polsat news branch under her leadership - what is more there a journalists there who were very anti-PiS in the past and somehow Gawryluk haven't fired them so far
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

PO knew about gaps in taxes and fuel smuggling - they did next to nothing to avert it

tvp.info/44282599/szefernaker-8-mld-zl-rocznie-tracilismy-na-lewym-obrocie-paliwa

tvp.info/43539295/kierunkowano-nas-na-sciganie-legalnych-podmiotow-a-tymczasem-rozwijaly-sie-mafie
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

eyewitness's testimony should have been censored because it reflects badly on someone?

three holocaust survivors testified that Edward Malinowski helped them during a trial 1949 - the court aquitted Malinowski of charges of collaboration with the Nazis
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

They won't allow the simple narrative of "VAT sealing means we can pay generous benefits" - they will look at the numbers ....

- the gap in all taxes combined was estimated by PiS in 2015 to be in the measure of 60-70 billion - what this article you 'linked' stated was manipulation - VAT fraud has been eliminated (also the contrabanda of fuels from the west by fuel mafias)- VAT evasion is much harder to fight as is income tax evasion

And even if Polsat is just trying to be objective - then why are they taking part in the media protest if the new tax...?

I heard something about Solorz held by the throat because he invested in energy sector and PiS blatantly blackmailed him - Solorz is not a PiS ally which is now to be seen - if Polsat became openly pro-Pis it would loose a lot of viewers so he chose Dorota Gawryluk as the head of news who tries really hard to be objective (which I admire her for)

During the PiS rule in the years 2016-18 (just two years) Poland's debt rose by 110 billion PLN

that's also a manipulation - the global state debt rose by about 82 billion - Poland's debt also includes the debts of municipal authorities of which PiS had little pow

in 2018 the state debt rose by a mere 10 billion and in 2019 13 billion - I'm not sure but as far as I can remember the number were lowest in the history of democratic Poland

The budget's deficit for 2020 is supposed to be 90 billion PLN:

all of the European economies shrunk in 2020 - Poland was among the least hit actually

The budget's deficit for 2020 is supposed to be 90 billion PLN:

Poland's deficit counted in tens of billions during PO/PSL without any significant social spending because of VAT fraud, VAT gap, fuel smuggling and income tax gap - they did little to avert it - my belief is they were not really willing to because of being chums whith the beneficiaries of those gaps
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

The improved VAT collection had very little to do with that

22 billion (*but I safely even a bit more) bet more went into the official economy - you don't think it created jobs? - you don't think it created a snowball effect

Have you completely ignored the massive amount of investment in Poland over the last few years?

you are right now contradicting the narration of the total opposition and other critics of the goverment who said that foreing investment in Poland slowed down significantly when PiS came to power (because it is seen as unstable) - so who of you is right?
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

I'm telling you that it's simply not true.

you are arguing with a point I haven't made - I haven't said all of the VAT growth was directly thanks to curbing the VAT fraud

A rise in VAT revenues would be quite normal during economic boom periods.

the economic boom we had was mostly because of the influx of the money that used to leak to VAT fraud into the official economy especially to those who had very little before (who could suddenly afford more than just bread and margarine)

kryzys-zweryfikowal-efekty-uszczelniania-vat-%E2%80%92-luka-wzrosla-do-36-mld-zlotych

the current VAT gap has nothing to do with VAT fraud but with VAT evasion which is caused by the rise of black economy where money flows without being reported - some people are affraid now of buying things and services legally - like all those fraudulent doctors and lawyers who cannot prove their income and have to go -an fear electronic VAT fakturas

I haven't said nothing in the shape that PiS has removed all of the VAT gap - however that part of VAT gap (VAT evasion, black economy) is not easy to curb
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

@gumishu
demagog.org.pl/wypowiedzi/jak-wygladaly-wplywy-z-podatku-vat-w-ostatnich-latach/ - this table shows the VAT income in recent years (and roughly 52 billion rise between the years 2015 and 2018) - the big chunk of the growth was thanks to stopping of VAT fraud

and means that only the opposition is hurt by such cuts.

the oppostition shouted scandal and they paid for it

may I also remind you that they simply implemented the plans brought by PO/PSL in order to achieve that?

if it was true why did Rostowski say - pieniędzy nie ma i nie będzie (there is no money for 500+ and there won't be any) - maybe he is an expert like that
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

It's about academic freedom to publish testimonies of survivors regardless of what they say.

the libel was on the part of Engelking and Grabowski - and was justly rectified - academic freedom doesn't mean you can write anything about anybody

Very critical af the government's shoddy behaviour.

what's wrong with supporting a libeled person
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

2 bn for TVP,

stopping the leaching of the budget by crooks who used state-subsidied pharmaceuticals with the e-recepta and the laws surrounding it will probably give 4 billion PLN yearly - of course PO government couldn't do it (or maybe they didn't want to)

Sorry Gumishu, but you really have to rely on different media than that run by PIS.

I never said all of the PiS programmes have been funded by the growth of VAT income (just 500+) - and I thoroughly realize that 13th and 14th pension for those retired are an expensive bribe - I also see why the government is not entirely unhappy with the price hikes of goods and services (but I don't believe your exaggerations delph)
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

the pay rise for politicians?

members of parliament actuallly lost 20 or 25 per cent of their money - after the 'nagrody' presumed scandal - I was thoroughly supporting the nagrody - a goverment that curbed down humungous VAT fraud really earned them - it's just Polish people who are idiots

It's simply not true that the VAT revenues cover 500+. The Ministry of Finance's own numbers proved that.

so you haven't read the article - I am not surprised at all
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

I knew from the beginning that 500+ was a mistake that Poland can't afford and that it will bite us in the ass

you here repeat the lies of Rostowski - and you also prove you read nothing outside your own information bubble - all of the original 500+ programme has been covered by the rise in VAT (not counting the fuel akcyza tax) incomes in Poland -all of it - it caused certain deficit in the budget in the first year (2016) but not later - also Poland experienced unprecedented growth in the year before coronavirus - read here: wpolityce.pl/gospodarka/430887-w-ciagu-ostatnich-3-lat-wplywy-z-vat-wzrosly-az-o-52-mld-zl

which is pro-PiS nowadays

it isn't pro-PiS - it is trying to be objective - which shows just how prejudiced (and probably misinformed) you are
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

I knew from the beginning that 500+ was a mistake that Poland can't afford and that it will bite us in the ass

you here repeat the lies of Rostowski - and you also prove you read nothing outside your own information bubble - all of the original 500+ programme has been covered by the rise in VAT (not counting the fuel akcyza tax) incomes in Poland -all of it - it caused certain deficit in the budget in the first year (2016) but not later - also Poland experienced unprecedented growth in the year before coronavirus - read here: wpolityce.pl/gospodarka/430887-w-ciagu-ostatnich-3-lat-wplywy-z-vat-wzrosly-az-o-52-mld-zl

the rise in the VAT incomes for the Polish budget was mainly because of curbing of VAT fraud which PO seemingly could not accomplish
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

"A libel suit,

simple libel suit - if you want to write history stick to facts - like for example testimonies of the survivors of the Holocaust who said the man accused of helping Nazis helped them survive - and the Polish court agreed that this was a case of a libel
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

You're trying to change the subject.

what I wrote was very relevant to the subject - I wrote about an article on Jedwabne pogrom by IPN - and you dismissed it as not neutral - and I asked what do you base your opinion on IPN - and you said - oh even Wajda said IPN is baaad - to which I replied about Wajda's past - capisci?
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

doesn't want to admit to us that the tax will punish independent media,

how much does airing of a 30 second spot cost and how much do they charge advertisers for it - care to enlighten me - what is their margin
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
History / Malinowo: Polish-Nazi Supression? [447]

Stop trying to change the subject; your PiS-like distraction techniques don't work here.

you haven't even noticed that my posts are relevant to the subject of your prejudice against IPN whose article on Jedwabne I was reffering to - so what do you base your prejudice against the IPN: the words of Wajda ?
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

The persecution of independent media by the authoritarian PiS regime

what persecution - please be factual about it

wgospodarce.pl/informacje/57517-skok-wolomin-to-dzielo-agentow-wsi
gumishu   
10 Feb 2021
News / Previous Poland's government corrupting the media. [125]

dotyczy.pl/skoki-afera-wszechczasow-pochlonely-juz-ponad-5mld-zl-eksperci-twierdza-ze-to-nawet-nie-polowa-strat/445c
człowieku ty nie umiesz samodzielnie myśleć : man you cannot think for yourself - the article claims that PiS didn't allow SKOKi to be supervised by KNF (State Financial Supervisor) - the point is that the problems with SKOKi started during PO rule (according to the article itself) - also if PiS was involved with the affair why didn't PO start a investigative committee in Sejm while claiming so you are just a very bad case of morbidly prejudiced

read this - your article is not factual about SKOK Wolomin - wgospodarce.pl/informacje/57517-skok-wolomin-to-dzielo-agentow-wsi