The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives 
 
 
User: Guest

Posts by Vlad123  

Joined: 27 Oct 2012 / Male ♂
Last Post: 19 Feb 2013
Threads: 7
Posts: 204

Displayed posts: 211 / page 1 of 8
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Vlad123   
19 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

Couldn't agree more! As a quasi-native German/English speaker who learned Polish in adulthood

How do you find sound of Slavic languages,for example Russian or Polish in comparison to other European languages?
Do they sound melodical to you?
Vlad123   
18 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

I prefer the sound of Polish to Russian or my own family's Bohemian Czech.

So are you ethnical Czech?Did you ever hear Ukrainian language?If yes,how do you find it?
On this forum some people believe that Ukrainian and Czech are somewhat similar in pronounciation.
Do you think so?
Vlad123   
17 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

I usually have to hear them start to speak in order to finally realize that they're Ukrainian and not Polish

So what is difference between Ukrainian and Polish accents?And which of them sounds more unpleasent to you?
Vlad123   
16 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

Are you asking me if it's a coincidence that Poland has been boardering with Germany for long centuries?

Coincidence,of course,but what?Poles borrowed German accent?Even in those areas which belonged to Russian Empire?
Vlad123   
15 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

It was not my qoute originally I just citated someone

By the way, the most popular speaker of Ukrainian with an accent is Yulia Tymoshenko.

Interesting.Could you explain what in her personality or political program could attract people?She was prime-minister in Ukraine couple of times.Was her primership any successful?
Vlad123   
15 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

so why English people keep thinking I'm Austrian or German when I speak with my Polish accent?

Once they asked me if I`m German too.This is out of complete ignorance or sometimes accent of people from the same nation could sound differently.If some person speak harsh and rude he will be more likely mistaken for German.So do you think Polish accent sounds similar to German purely coincidently or those languages are somehow originally related?

Also we Poles mixed with other nationalities (mainly Jews and Germans but also Scotts,Dutch and God only knows who else) over the centuries so much that under different criteria we wouldn't qualify as Slavic.

According to mind of my Ukrainian friend some Poles indeed look somewhat similar to Austrians or Germans,
but still not all of them.Genetical researches show that Poles have no more then few percent more Germanic blood than their Eastern neighbours and defenetly could qualify as Slavic nation.
Vlad123   
15 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

to average US person all East/Central Euros sound Russian

You would be wondered but in many parts of the Western world Poles became
more numerous than Russians or Ukrainians and therefore first of all local people will
ask you if you have Polish accent...
Vlad123   
15 Feb 2013
History / Poles and Russians -- love-hate relationship? [209]

Currently Russian artists are unknown in Poland, and of course even more Polish artists are unknown in Russia...

There is some well known Polish artists who lived and performed in Russia. For example Edita Piekha and Barbara Brylska.
Vlad123   
15 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

extreme palatalization of certain consonants

What is that?

and a host of miscellaneous charactaristics!

And that?
Vlad123   
14 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

Putting the Russian government aside, I like the Russian language.

Why do you like it?
Vlad123   
14 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

When a person has mastered any language and has no problems as a speaker of this language but has an accent, why he/she should conceal his/her accent?

Do you peronally like when somebody speak your native language with heavy accent?Personally I feal unpleased to communicate with such people.
Vlad123   
14 Feb 2013
Genealogy / Do you think all Slavs are white? [178]

The same can be said about Russians (tatar+slavic+mongol mix) and eastern Ukrainians (turkic cossacks).

Where did you take it from?Could you give any link to plausible genetic research?

He was born in Khanty-Mansi, so he's half Asian, Mansi probably.

Yes,seems so.But it is interesting that Mansi language is more related to Hungarian
than to Mongol or Tatar.
Vlad123   
14 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

If you are English speaker and ever heard Russian accent,
what is most remarkeable about it to you?
Also,could you easily make difference between accents
from different Slavic countries such as Poland,Ukraine,Russia etc?
Vlad123   
13 Feb 2013
Language / Ukrainian language similar to Polish? [236]

Not to mention samochOd which is associated with the heavy military machines.

Or some odd and self-made transportaton device...

Yes, for all I know, -enko is the most typical Ukrainian ending of the surnames. Others may include...
Ivanyshyn

I didn`t know that Ivanyshyn is natively Ukrainian family name.
There is Slovenian actress by name Nina Ivanishin.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nina_Ivani%C5%A1in
Vlad123   
13 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

No, Vlad. It "needn't" be, only that "Vlad" is a Romanian given name, since the nick name for "Vladimir" would be "Volodya", NOT "Vlad"

Vlad is originally Slavic name in any form,Romanians borrowed it,I guess.
Currently Vlad is popular short form of some names in Eastern Slavic countries,especially short of Vladislav.
Commonly short form of Vladislav used to be ``Slavic`` or ``Slava`` and short form of Vladimir - Vova.
But now such short forms became less popular now and even serve metter of jokes.For example is somebody
say his first name is ``Slava`` somebody will joke ``Slava KPSS`` (glory to communist party of USSR).
And some other names also could use Vlad as short form.
Vlad123   
12 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

Oh, you're just saying that to make the rest of us feel better:-)

Why?

Is Romanian your first language, by the way?

No,why should it be?
Vlad123   
12 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

Personally,I find English one of the easiest foreign languages to practice,it is much easier than
say French or German both in pronounciation and especially grammar, the problem for me
is not to unerstand and be understood but speak without accent which would be remarkeable
to people.Some people believe - Russian accent is hard accent.But how people could train to
pronounce it correct?Especially I`m interesting in vowels.They seem to be most difficult to
pronounce completelly correct.Russian has fewer number of vowels than English.So we are
trying to simplify English set of vowels.Did you ever hear Russian accent?What exatly features
of it is most remarkeable to you?What`s wrong with vowels?
Vlad123   
12 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

Native English speakers are usually convinced that Czech,Polish,Russian
and Ukrainian accent sound the same for them.This is what I undestood
from forums and personal communication with them.For example my
accent was sometimes mistooken for Polish and some guy told me that
he knows very well how Polish people speak.Though my native language
is Russian, but Russians say I`ve got some Ukrainian accent which they
also mistake for Belarussian.But I do not care which axactly type of accent.
How does it matter? Any non-native speaker has this problem even if he
speaks in Bengali.Is there different methods of accent correction for different
type of accents?I guess methods should be the same.I wonder if there is one
person on forum who trained himself to speak English without an accent?!
Is it possible to do when you are adult?
Vlad123   
12 Feb 2013
Language / Slavic accent correction [110]

Could somebody share experience of trying to speak English
without an accent?How much did you succeed?
What is the best method of accent correction?
Vlad123   
12 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

Classification of Poland as Eastern sounds always derogatory as it brings always cold war era naming to my mind.

Crochet - east- west does not exist any more . Such differentiation finished more than 20 years ago . So only backard people use this term .

There is contradiction somewhere in these statements.Why pay attention to backard people?
Vlad123   
12 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

Nice map crochet88, although England will be Pakistan Jr., France Islamic Republic, and Germany New Turkey.

Germany could also become ``velika Albania`` and all Europe will be Eurabia...
Vlad123   
11 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

By saying something like that you are showing disrespect for all the great cultures and nations from Ukraine to Japan.

Not even talking about Australia!
Vlad123   
11 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

Well-read person will always know that we are central European country.

But fist you have to convince Germans,Swiss and Austrians to become
part of Central Europe instead of Western as they accustomed to be.

central2013.eu/ [EXT]

This link you provided cuts in half some countries.
Vlad123   
11 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

If georaphy of the country is defined by its culture then Western Europe soon to become part of
Middle East.Somebody could think of it as a something worthwhile...
Vlad123   
11 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

The term "Eastern Europe" wasn't that much in use I suppose. It's mostly a product of the Cold war.

Immigration Act of 1924
Congressional opposition was minimal.

Proponents of the Act sought to establish a distinct American identity by favoring native-born Americans over Southern and Eastern Europeans in order to "maintain the racial preponderance of the basic strain on our people and thereby to stabilize the ethnic composition of the population".[6][7] Reed told the Senate that earlier legislation "disregards entirely those of us who are interested in keeping American stock up to the highest standard - that is, the people who were born here".[8] Southern and Eastern Europeans, he believed, arrive sick and starving and therefore less capable of contributing to the American economy, and unable to adapt to American culture.[6]

So restrictive were the new quotas for immigration from Southern and Eastern Europe, that in 1924 there were more Italians, Czechs, Yugoslavs, Greeks, Lithuanians, Hungarians, Poles, Portuguese, Romanians, Spaniards, Chinese, and Japanese that left the United States than those who arrived as immigrants.[16]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_Act_of_1924

From this it is clearly seen that in the beginning of 20-th century Poles and Czecs were regarded as Eastern europeans, secondary people to ``American identity``.
Vlad123   
11 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

I'm afraid it's gonna be friggin' hard to change "Western" European people's perception of that part of Europe. Any country that has ever been behind the Iron Curtain is always gonna be considered part of Eastern Europe.

Could you give a refference which shows that relation of Western powers to that part of Europe was different before an ``Iron Curtain``? For example German Nazies believed that Poles are underhumans and indended to clean Europe from them altogether.
Vlad123   
10 Feb 2013
History / POLAND: EASTERN or CENTRAL European country? [1080]

the Poles have more from ... Mongolia and China inside their "bloodline"

Probably you are from Mongolian steppes...

I see this thread is really troll-on-troll one...

Domogarov in the movie ``Ogniem i mieczem`` is similar to Chechen from
Nother Caucasus.Ukrainian cossacks shaved beard clean,only mustche
they wore.And his black curly hair...
And what did you want to say be posting movie fragment?
You forgot to mention Ukrainian witch lesbian who liked to abuse Polish woman.
Maybe you could post this fragment?
Vlad123   
9 Feb 2013
History / Poles and Russians -- love-hate relationship? [209]

who may think Russian government is playing hard towards Poland (by restricting access to gas

Potentially Poland and Ukraine could find alternative sources to Russian gas completely.
There is huge reserves of coalbed methane and shale gas in both Poland and Ukraine,biogas could be produced in large quantities.Gas power plants could be replaces with some Thorium power plants.

Recently some major oil company started production of shale gas in Ukraine.So this is mostly queston of time.

Poles love freedom while Russian are used to being servants of their rulers rather than citizens.

I`m interesting where this love for a freedom in Poles came from.Some ancient Western European hitorian wrote that there is no country in the world (during his time) where feudals would be so cruel to pesants as in Poland.

Polish serfs received freedom later then Russians did.Probably it partially explains it...