The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by gumishu  

Joined: 6 Apr 2009 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - A
Last Post: 17 mins ago
Threads: Total: 15 / Live: 11 / Archived: 4
Posts: Total: 6186 / Live: 2570 / Archived: 3616
From: Poland, Opole vicinity
Speaks Polish?: yes

Displayed posts: 2581 / page 47 of 87
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

Answer my question, why not raise the tax threshold? Not a vote winner, as that would mean working for a living to feed those kids?

I agree with you that 500+ programme is a bit cynical and aimed at winning votes easily as tax threshold raising would only affect those who actually work but it did have an impact on the economy - there is over 5 per cent rise in retail sales in 2017 compared to 2016 (in some months the year to year rise was even above 10 per cent) - at the same time the alcohol consupmtion in Poland hasn't risen dramatically (if I remember correctly the rise was about 2 per cent) so it looks like the money from 500+ is more or less well spent - also the unemployment is at historical low (counting from the communist times where it was formally null) - which means there is not really that many people who only rely on the programme as their sole source of income)
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
Life / Why Do You Love Poland? [907]

Help him. Easier said than done but still ...

some people are beyond help untill they have enough themselves - my brother doesn't have enough yet - he hasn't hit the hard bottom so far - but as soon as my mom passes he definitely will
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
Life / Why Do You Love Poland? [907]

my brother drinks on Wigilia - but he's an aloholic and drinks almost everyday - he even once went to Pasterka partially drunk - he doesn't bother to go to Pasterka anymore though
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

7 kids if I remember rightly. It's so easy to be magnanimous with other people's money.

so you know precisely one family with seven kids and only because they were made famous by Duda, quite telling

again, the 500+ programme has been wholly funded this year by decreasing the VAT gap that was there for the whole time of the PO+PSL rule - do you prefer this money spent on poor families or on VAT scammers, just asking
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

Unlike PL where Ziobro could prosecute Tusk and have him tried by PiS appointed judges

judges will be randomly alotted to all cases - and no - there will be no massive purge of regular judges for the simple reason that there are not enough people to replace them - and again it will be the KRS appointing judges not PiS and the representatives of the Sejm in the KRS will be elected with the 3/5 majority in the chamber - so you are just spreading false propaganda

To hand out my money to people who have 7 kids and are too lazy to work for a living?

how many families with 7 kids do you know if I may ask?

Ziobro is an elected official - if people find that his actions are against their best interests they will choose a different party next time don't you worry
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

and again - it is a fact that the Supreme Court judges are there for life but their appoinment is purely political/partisan by the governing president and there are fights and machinations around the nominations like after the passing of the late judge Scalia - where the Senate refused hearing of Obama candidate for the post until Obama's term run out
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

the US judges get life time terms

only in the supreme court my friend

in many states (the majority afaik) judges are elected for a term (and probably can even be dismissed during the term if enough people wish for it)
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

In Germany each Lander has input into judicial appointments

not just input but according to wikipedia the justice minister of any given Land MAKES the decision to appoint or not appoint someone as judge and also on their further promotion - and the justice minister is chosen by the ruling party/coalition as you would expect which can has as low as 50 per cent of votes in Landstag

In Germany the chief prosecutor is not the justice minister.

what difference does it make - are you going to say that chief prosecutor in Germany is not a political position - as far as I know it is a political position in the states (Attorney General)

as far as I know it is a political position in the states (Attorney General)

heh - I wasn't aware of this and just found out that the head of the Department of Justice in the USA is the Attorney General - so it's the same situation as in Poland
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

direct political appointment of judges? you are clearly making this up, the Sejm representatives in the KRS will have to chosen by the 3/5 majority of Sejm - mass firing of judges - sure after they reach a retirement age

the appointing of judges will according to the proposed law be much more democratic than it is in Germany - just read the wikipedia entry on German judiciary (with understanding of course)
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
News / EU triggers Article 7, could strip Poland of voting rights [91]

direct partisan control so that they will issue judgement according to what the government wants

where do you draw this conclusion from - please quote facts

Polish people want a just and working judiciary system - which they were stripped ever since the collapse of communism
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
Life / Why Do You Love Poland? [907]

well it clearly follows the observation that the world is not black and white - there are aspects of the Polish culture/psyche that are counterconstructive if not downright detrimental and it is easier for foreigners/outsiders to spot them
gumishu   
20 Dec 2017
Life / Why Do You Love Poland? [907]

Although not a Catholic myself, I strongly beg to differ. So would Jesus, I have little doubt.

yes Jesus definitely said 'love thy neighbour as thyself' and i think it also applies to neighbours who happen to be Jews or muslims
gumishu   
16 Dec 2017
Genealogy / Why are some Polish people dark complected, and others very light [511]

Many Germans have strong Slavic influence in their gene pool - ever heard of Vends Lyzko - some areas in Germany west of Oder still had Slavic speaking minorities after the second world war (Upper and Lower Sorbian - Lower Sorbian is by now only understood by a couple thousands of elderly citizens in the area of Cottbus but Upper Sorbian is in a better shape)
gumishu   
16 Dec 2017
Genealogy / What does my Polish name mean? [401]

Slezak is Czech/Moravian for Ślązak/Silesian/Schlesier

and Śląsk/Silesia/Schlesien is Slezsko in Czech
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
Travel / Are Polish people as unfriendly as Slovaks? [84]

You do realise not all people here are Polish, don't you?

I'm Polish and I'm quite blunt too, to be honest - and argumentative at that heheh
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
UK, Ireland / Racist ex-priest Międlar tries to fly from Poland to U.K. again. [293]

I would be heavily concerned over the removal of the 1st amendment from the West,

Britain never had anything in the form of the 1st amendment from what I can gather, and now they for the big part got rid of freedom of speech they ever had - you can be prosecuted for calling muslims names (according to some hate speech laws), people get fired from jobs for accidently putting pork on muslim kids' plates in school cantinas and you have to provide space and time for muslim prayers in a workplace if you employ any muslims (otherwise you are racist and in trouble)
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
News / Goodbye Sunday Shopping in Poland - Hello Electoral Reform [246]

let's be honest they don't have the best diplomatic skills but in the bigger scale they try to be loyal to their country and people.

yes, it's true they are not best of diplomats probably - but I am very glad you managed to notice they care for the country and the people - I understand you don't share their moral stances based on religion but I mostly do even though I am not christian - and even though I am a iron electorate of PiS I don't hold Kaczyński to be perfect, flawless, and infallible or even a great strategist as many PiS voters do -

I don't agree with some of their legislative proposals either (like ban on Sunday trade, ban on ritual slaughter or ban on fur animals farms to name a few) - what I believe though we don't have anything realisticly better at the moment -

I ultimately am for more of a direct form of democracy like in Switzerland including electing judges - the judiciary system in Poland designed in 1989 and 1997 is judges appointing new judges and judges controlling judges (through the KRS) - this, the special caste like attitude of the judiciary and their specific political leanings but also their involvement in cliques especially early on after communism ( i can give you some examples but I will spare you for now it is a long post anyway) have caused a lot of anomalies including corruption on all levels, inefficiency, incompetency, inconsistency (which should not be a case in codex law you would think) that haven't been addressed throughout the years (like hardly any corrupted or biased judge facing any serious consequences) - this (the judiciary being an authority unto themselves) has to end - and some control of the judges by officials elected by the public (i.e. representatives of the public) is a step in the right direction - but as I say I am ultimately for electing judges directly by the public for terms in office possibly on all levels of the judiciary (like it is in many states of the US) and the power for people to depose a judge they don't think s/he suits them anymore
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
News / Goodbye Sunday Shopping in Poland - Hello Electoral Reform [246]

@gumishu

So sorry but PO or KOD....they are just nasty, selfish traitors for me ( and I guess more people in Poland).

you are actually one of very few lemmings who woke up - many still wish Poland ill only so that they could see PiS out of power - hatred for PiS has been programmed into them by years of media brainwashing
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
News / Goodbye Sunday Shopping in Poland - Hello Electoral Reform [246]

but apparently they are well educated and progressive and PIS is uneducated and backward

choose this day who you support those who claim to be educated and progressive or those who don't care for titles but who care for the people

btw you seriously believe people like Kijowski, Petru, Schetyna, Gronkiewicz-Waltz would fight for the country in need?
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
News / Goodbye Sunday Shopping in Poland - Hello Electoral Reform [246]

No impartiality whatsoever now.

I suspected so - masks falling off

So sorry but PO or KOD....they are just nasty, selfish traitors for me ( and I guess more people in Poland).

a quote from Kaczyński you probably heard misinterpreted: - W Polsce jest taka fatalna tradycja zdrady narodowej. (...) To jest jakby w genach niektórych ludzi, tego najgorszego sortu Polaków - In Poland there is this nasty tradition of national treason (...) It is as if it was in some people's genes, the genes of this worst kind of Poles
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
News / Goodbye Sunday Shopping in Poland - Hello Electoral Reform [246]

Two of those are anti-PiS and will stay anti-PiS, whether PiS are in government or not.

yeah, when PO were in power it created a world unique situation were all major TV stations kept on criticising the opposition and were PR-tubes of the government for the most part (sometimes Polsat journalists were more inquisitive but only some of them while some were rabidly anti-PiS - Polsat was trying to pose for the most objective news source those days)
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
Travel / Are Polish people as unfriendly as Slovaks? [84]

I told him about it was that the people generally all seemed very rude and blunt.

well even good people become bitter in this forum faced with enormous lies and denial found in certain individuals here
gumishu   
1 Dec 2017
News / Goodbye Sunday Shopping in Poland - Hello Electoral Reform [246]

still the anti-PiS opposition that has most of the audience in the media.

it's not that anti-PiS opposition has more audience - it is quite debatable actually - it is that most media outlets are anti-PiS - while Trump is not very similar to PiS the media bias against PiS is similar to that of anti-Trump bias in American media

as for political preferences of Poles according to latest polls: about 32 per cent of the adult population (those who vote and who don't) support the current government - some 20 per cent (don't remember the exact number from the poll) support a party from the opposition - buuuut ... 44 per cent don't support either the government or the opposition