Off-Topic /
Best posters [886]
What do you mean by criticizing?
We all have our foibles and licentiousness we need to overcome. Having them and professing to be a Christian doesn't make one fake. Calling licentiousness what it is isn't being fake.
Being a scoundrel and claiming to be a Christian isn't even necessarily fake-just makes one a bad Christian that causes great scandal.
Life is a spiritual battle with victories and defeats. To my mind, the key is engaging this battle with humility, which is a struggle in and of itself.
So, just because someone isn't living a life in complete alignment with Christ's will doesn't make him a fake Christian. I think "fake Christian" is a misguided term. The real question to be asked, IMO, isn't whether someone is a fake Christian, but rather is that person striving towards sanctity or not-and within that is realizing one's own sinfulness and need of mercy and that each of us are no better or worse than the sinner across from any of us; however, that doesn't mitigate or equivocate the sin itself and the need to acknowledge the sin and work to amend sinfulness.
Which, reminds me, I need to get to confession.