The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by delphiandomine  

Joined: 25 Nov 2008 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - Q
Last Post: 17 Feb 2021
Threads: Total: 86 / Live: 15 / Archived: 71
Posts: Total: 17813 / Live: 4639 / Archived: 13174
From: Poznań, Poland
Speaks Polish?: Yeah.
Interests: law, business

Displayed posts: 4654 / page 118 of 156
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
delphiandomine   
8 Feb 2012
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

in the worse case to blame Poles for what happened to them during WWII

I do partially blame the Polish politicians for it - the people are blameless (except for electing such morons) - but part of the tragedy of WW2 lies with Poland's absolutely senseless aggression towards Lithuania/Czechoslovakia, Poland's marginalising of her minorities and the other things that went on.

The people can't be faulted (especially given that Pilsudski was more or less a dictator) - but the politicians certainly should get some of the blame.
delphiandomine   
31 Jan 2012
Language / Polish was chosen the HARDEST LANGUAGE in the world to learn... :D [1558]

send me to France, Germany, Spain, Portugal, Italy for 2 years, I'll walk out C1 easily. try doing the same in Poland.

Likewise for a Pole - send them to Russia and they'll be at C1 level easily (I know a Russian who did just that in Poland within 8 months), but send them to Germany/the UK and they'll be far worse off.

I'm also pretty sure none of us would be anywhere near C1 level if we went to somewhere like Finland - or interestingly enough, Swiss German is apparently an utter btch to learn, not least because language schools won't enrol you onto Swiss German courses without being fluent in German first.
delphiandomine   
31 Jan 2012
History / Polish inventors - what have they ever given to the world? [101]

Just reading this thread now - why are Polish-Americans so desperate to cling onto people who aren't even Polish when there are so many interesting genuinely Polish inventors out there? Could it be ignorance as to what Poles have actually done for the world?

This guy - en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jacek_Karpi%C5%84ski - clearly beats Wozniak into the ground.

In 1971 he designed of one of the first minicomputers, the K-202. Because of the policy on computer development in the People's Republic of Poland, belonging to the Comecon that time, K-202 was never mass produced. Karpiński later became a pig farmer, and in 1981, after receiving a passport, emigrated to Switzerland.

The K-202 would have been revolutionary if produced on a mass scale - just shows what a messed up country the PRL really was.

And yet, Polish-Americans cling to Wozniak despite him being a Ukraine-loving German.
delphiandomine   
31 Jan 2012
Language / Polish was chosen the HARDEST LANGUAGE in the world to learn... :D [1558]

It's not "insanely hard". It's difficult for English speakers who can't grasp the case system, but if it was "insanely hard" - why do Slavic language speakers find it ridiculously easy?

I know a few native German speakers who found Polish to be quite easy. And don't forget that Polish is remarkably easy to find if you want to practice it, too.
delphiandomine   
30 Jan 2012
Travel / What is the weather like in Poland where you are now? [211]

I guess I don't mind scraping off the windows and then getting into a warm car

But what if you can't get into the car?

My fuel cap froze last winter...that was a rather ridiculous situation :( -20c in Poznan, low on fuel and a frozen fuel cap. Bah was the only word I could utter.
delphiandomine   
30 Jan 2012
History / Polish inventors - what have they ever given to the world? [101]

He was even awarded by the Polish American Congress with "Hetitage Award".

I wouldn't trust that shower of fools - they seem to recognise almost anything as Polish if it can even be halfway claimed as such. All for political point-scoring, of course.

And you'd no doubt call him an anti-Polish racist because he admits that he tells jokes about Poles

So - we have a guy who could easily be a bit Jewish telling jokes about Poles. Why isn't MediaWatch screaming for his head, like he would if a French-Jewish person was telling jokes about Poles?
delphiandomine   
30 Jan 2012
Life / Are Poles mentally more Eastern European or Western European? [170]

And historically Poland has geographically always been much further east than it is now.

Indeed - it always surprises me to learn how close the German border was to Poznan between the wars - which explains the massive cultural and linguistical influence from Germany.

And then when you consider that what is now "East" in Poland was the middle of the country, it's not hard to see how the mentality is firmly rooted in the East.

Hardly. Either you've never lived in Paris or you've never lived in Poland. Or both.

Krakow, Paris of Poland? ....well.
delphiandomine   
30 Jan 2012
History / Mother tongue in Poland - acccording to 1931 census. [174]

Really?No,it would be just like in 1938.

Ah yes. One year later, Poland was humiliated. And you think it's wise to repeat history?

Oh really?We would control the whole Lithuania before the NATO would even call a meeting and then we would negotiate new border with Wilno in Poland.NATO and EU can go to hell but they would get over it.

Alternatively, NATO would order an immediate ceasefire - and when it wasn't obeyed by the renegade Poles - they would spring into action. You could also easily see a situation where Russia gets involved to protect her people in Lithuania - meaning Poland would be under attack from all sides. End result : Poland humiliated and internationally isolated.

You think it's that much of the problem to put it back there?It's not.

It's no problem to put it back, but you'll find the other borders suddenly close up too. Poland would be paralysed within days if the borders were closed.

We can also harras all the Lithuanian trucks transiting thru Poland.We have a whole arsenal of measures which could be used.

Good luck with that - I imagine Poland would be begging for mercy within minutes of being told that EU funds will not be paid until such nonsense stops. Incidentally, harassing trucks would hardly force Lithuania into submission - there are such things as ferries, you know.

In short, Poland would have nothing to gain, only to lose.

Poland isn't going to risk everything for the sake of a few right-wing troublemakers in Lithuania.
delphiandomine   
30 Jan 2012
History / Mother tongue in Poland - acccording to 1931 census. [174]

The beating that Poland will take from Lithuania's NATO allies after such an attack would be interesting, as would Poland's swift expulsion from the EU and NATO.

Closing the border would achieve what, exactly?

I just don't understand why are we so soft on them when we can press them in so many ways for instance by closing the border and/or Możejki and they done without a single shot fired.

Closing the border isn't exactly possible when all the barbed wire was removed anyway.

You must be a coward then.

Or they could humiliate Poland - or have you forgotten how they stuck two fingers up at the Soviet Union?

I can just imagine the headlines now as big Poland attempts to bully tiny Lithuania.

I guess I'd rather have Tusk as a prime minister than yourself - go figure

Do people genuinely believe in Poland that Poland could force Lithuania into anything these days?
delphiandomine   
29 Jan 2012
Law / Registering Foreign Car In Poland [24]

actually, I am not so sure about 'inability', because this law was taken to the european court and IRRC the verdict was that this is against free trade rule or something.

There hasn't been a judgement made yet. All signs are that Poland will be told to allow it - but given that Poland has joined the French club of simply ignoring judgements that she doesn't like, it would seem unlikely that RHD's will be allowed anytime soon.
delphiandomine   
29 Jan 2012
Law / Registering Foreign Car In Poland [24]

Unfortunately - you can't register a RHD in Poland. While it is technically possible, the powers that be won't issue a valid MOT for the car if it's RHD. Sorry - but with a RHD car, your only option is to drive back to the UK for an MOT once a year, or register it in another EU state (not that it's easy to do).
delphiandomine   
29 Jan 2012
Life / Are Poles mentally more Eastern European or Western European? [170]

If Poland would have insisted on participating in the Marshall Plan what would Stalin have done?

Poland simply didn't have the choice of refusing at that time - it was very much under Soviet occupation that only ended in the mid 50's.
delphiandomine   
28 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

At least now we know what your definition of socialism is :)))

Socialism is very much about favourable short term policies and damming the long term. Gierek was an expert at that, if you care to recall.

Then please show me any serious economist or business NGO, which says that current government's economic policy is good. Thank you in advance.

Err...you'll find many, many people praising the current government.

But you won't read it, because you know, it's PO propoganda.
delphiandomine   
28 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

there is entire soviet union that proves I am right (by its very own collapse)

Err..that's strange logic.

Christ, people here are SO IGNORANT!! Its beyond words

Yes, because you know best, don't you? I mean, screw the research - the Dear Leader guides you!

the reason for collapse was Russian - Afghan War that was lost - in 1979 - a year before events we are talking about.

The war wasn't lost at all in 1979 - in fact, during the 79-80 period, they were winning. And well.

Thanks to delivery of modern weapon to Afghan soldiers/warriors by CIA, Russian army took MASSIVE losses in both people and military hardware

The losses weren't massive in 79-80. In fact, the Soviets were destroying them - much of the CIA equipping came much later on, too.

and was direct reason why Russians were so afraid of helping jaruzelski

If they were afraid in 80, how can you explain Soyuz 80 moves? What you're claiming has absolutely no historical basis whatsoever.

they were weakened and thinking that the same may happen in Poland

They weren't weakened. The Soviet Union could still easily have dealt with the problem - but - as always, they were worried about economic sanctions. It was made clear to them that intervening in Poland would have consequences - and furthermore, the archives in Moscow are closed.

especially that CIA was already looking at Poland and started quietly helping Solidarnosc financially

The money that the CIA contributed was peanuts. It might have helped with the purchase of printing presses and so on, but on the whole - nothing major.

Its not like they didn't have more tanks and airplanes - they obviously had, but war dried them financially

They still had more than enough cash to deal with Poland if the political will was there.

they simply had no interest in helping jaruzelski and turning polish society against themselves by direct military actions - it never worked in the past. it was way more reasonable to sacrifice him and establish 'brand new' puppet government.

Err, they had plenty of interest. But in 1980, Kania managed to convince Moscow that he could deal with it - and when he couldn't deal with it, Jaruzelski got the nod. They wanted a Polish solution to a Polish problem - not least because it would appear to be legitimate. They knew that Czechoslovakia and Hungary were public relations disasters - and the Soviet Union emerged more or less blameless for the solution.

ONLY REASON for martial law was to save asses of jaruzelski and his fellow commies

That's the sentimental reason. The truth, as always, is more complicated.

If you actually looked at it from an analytical point of view, you'd soon realise that there were two choices - do nothing, and have the Soviets eventually intervene (in line with previous Warsaw Pact actions), or do something. Don't forget that doing nothing was causing the state to collapse - and was risking civil war.

and he did it only because he still believed in this communist bullshit

I'd love to know where the historical evidence is for this assertion. Is it what you read in Gazeta Polska?

There are recordings and documents showing that. Read it before writing anything more.

Really? Please, do link us to these recordings and documents.

There is certainly enough evidence to suggest that Honecker and Husak were ready to give a beating to Poland. But for what you claim - where is it?
delphiandomine   
28 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

brilliant answer. thank you for proving my point.

No, thank you - after all, you're choosing to disregard official figures in favour of the usual PiS "BLAH BLAH I CANT HEAR YOU FINGERS IN MY EARS BLAH BLAH BLAH" nonsense. Thanks :)

You are so pathetic and arrogant that I see no point in further discussion

Usual PiS tactic - "I WON'T DISCUSS BLAH BLAH YOU'RE WRONG BLAH BLAH FINGERS IN EARS".

No wonder the educated voters laugh and sneer at PiS types.
delphiandomine   
28 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

another flash of 'higher intelligence'.. can you point where I precisely did that?

Let's be honest - the statistics say it all. PO voters are richer and smarter than PiS voters. End.

this is product of your friend's infinite wisdom

Wow. One isolated incident is all you can produce?

And at least he had the courage to do something, unlike PiS 'bohater internetowy'.
delphiandomine   
28 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

Nah, you support PiS through and through and only deny it when it's inappropriate to admit to it - for instance, in educated company. I noticed that after the last electoral humiliation, 30% of Poles voted for PiS and only about 20% actually admitted it. There's always an amusing discrepancy between total votes and total supporters - this forum saw at least two, maybe three clowns suddenly claiming to have voted for Nowa Prawica despite showing no pro-Korwin Mikke sentiment before.

And, uh...what makes you think I can't hold a debate in the language of Poland? I had an interesting chat the other day with someone about local politics, actually.

->your absolute hatred for US Polonia

edit

->your obsession against PiS, anyone who disagrees with you is a default PiS supporter!

That's because they normally are. Or worse.

It is terrible amusing watching people spout the same old tired PiS slogans while denying to be PiS supporters, though.
delphiandomine   
28 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

seems you are considering yourself to be this 'educated elite', so I will only point one massive flaw in your thinking - do you remember PiS getting 80% votes?

Among the uneducated US Polonia - yes.

this is also another 'meme' created for people like you - considering themselves as 'better' part of society.

That's exactly, word for word, how PiS supporters behave. This entire thread contains proof of it - even when given evidence, they immediately dismiss it as propoganda because the Dear Leader told them so. They often claim to "know the truth" and will not entertain any rational debate - most young PO supporters will actually have a very open mind and are very open to better alternatives.

'totalitarian rhetoric'

And you honestly think that the Dear Leader wouldn't sign it (and ratify it) straight away, bearing in mind his brothers comments about internet users?

We all know that the only reason he opposes it is for the sake of opposing (and the fact that most of his supporters couldn't afford to buy the films/music/etc anyway.

The current government is anything but totalitarian - in fact, it shows how short your memories are if you've already forgotten what a totalitarian government was.
delphiandomine   
27 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

the East Germans were such utter and complete toadies who had fallen for communism hook, line and sinker

They really were a tinpot state - I can't remember the quote now, but in one book I have, it makes reference to how the Germans absolutely embraced Communism - and were even better at it than the Soviets.

in fact whilst the rest of Central Europe sort of played along with the military exercises, the East Germans used
to show the Russians up and were the finest troops in the Warsaw Pact

Yup, and there were several (unreported at the time) diplomatic crisises between the PRL and DDR too.

I must dig up one of them for you - it's to do with territorial waters, and is very very interesting.
delphiandomine   
27 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

The funniest thing is - there was really NO NEED AT ALL for martial laws.

Really? The fact that society was breaking down, that there existed the very real and scary possibility of civil war (as any serious historian will tell you) and that the State was failing to function wasn't a good reason? Jaruzelski had no way of knowing that Moscow may have let Poland go - especially after the build up for forces for the "Soyuz 80" moves that were a thinly veiled threat towards Poland.

Absolutely - and these are the people from whom PiS drew their support, who were the most vulnerable to their totalitarian rhetoric. The educated elite didn't touch them with a bargepole.

Indeed, and it proves my point - newspeak is very appealing for them. And again - it shows how conditioned they are by the Communists.

I was studying Medicine in Wroclaw during this time. I can tell you this much. The predominant opinion of the Polish students that I hung out with and their parents was that the General had no other choice. They all agreed that the alternative scenerios were not attractive ones.

This is now commonly accepted as the reason - there was very little room to move on his part. He was clearly installed by the Soviets to sort the mess out in Poland - and from his point of view, it's very easy to see (after what happened to Kania) that he either sorted the problem out or they got someone else that could sort it out.

Chechoslovakian army was no match for Polish one - so thiose plans are plain ridiculous. Actually, an idea of Chech army performing any military actions is funny by itself ;D

It wasn't just the Czechoslovak army that you had to worry about, but also the East Germans who were rather keen on beating Poland up. With the Soviet numerical advantage, I can't imagine that Poland would have lasted long, especially as the "will to fight" had gone at that point. Gomulka's threat of fighting was taken seriously - but Jaruzelski could never have used the same threat.

this is going from memory and I am far too lazy to check but I remember that the year before, the Russians conducted a massive military exercise in Poland which
was a very unsubtle demonstration of what Poland might expect unless they were very careful

"Soyuz 80" - it made it painfully clear to Jaruzelski what he could expect. I'm not sure how else he was supposed to think - we know now that the Soviets wanted a Polish solution to a Polish problem, but how could Jaruzelski know that after the actions during 1980?

I can uderstand delaph who is foreigner and knows sh!t about Poland (clearly)

Yeah yeah, I know **** because I quote from Poles about Poland. Truth is, you and your ilk are classically conditioned - you just can't accept the painful truth.
delphiandomine   
26 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

Basically, PiS are hard left economically - they are very much socialists. It's denied, of course (socialism is a dirty word here - but it's almost certain that they would hurt small/medium businesses in order to help the huge state-owned businesses. They're also very pro worker-rights - so depending on his business, he might very well be in a bad place if PiS won. Generally speaking, they stand for all sorts of benefits for workers and little rights for employers - which is why most business owners are against them.
delphiandomine   
26 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

Which it is actually hoax! Which you have taken at face value ! Whereas it is yet another BULL in a long series of propaganda articles.

Actually, you just prove the point. PiS supporters instantly denounce anything that doesn't agree with them as lies - which is exactly what the Communists did. Again - Western propoganda was often denounced on Soviet Bloc TV - the infamous "black channel" in East Germany was probably the best example, though it went on elsewhere too.

Would you like to present any evidence to support your claim that he was hunting down his political opponents?

Err...you might start with his boasting about how they spied on his coalition partners.

As for "spying" by Kaczynski on his coalition partners - would you like to point out the way he was doing that spying ? Was he hiding under their table or in their wardrobe? Maybe he was using a glass pressed against a wall to listen to their conversations ?

He already boasted about how he used the ABW.

Everybody knows that rag and what it stands for. If anyone is dividing people and is totalitarian at heart that them - self-admiring poisonous circle of haters and professional liars !A Good company for you.

Newspeak through and through.
delphiandomine   
25 Jan 2012
News / Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to Poland PiS supporters (what a surprise) [89]

Who did you vote for in last year's general election?

Not PiS, that much is for sure ;)

Oops that's right your a opinionated Brit who can't even debate with any politician in the language of our country :)

That's right - you're showing everyone why PiS must be kept firmly in opposition.

The topic is -

Communist era 'newspeak' appeals the most to PiS supporters