PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
 
Posts by Babinich  

Joined: 26 May 2008 / Male ♂ 		Last Post: 17 Feb 2013
Threads: Total: 1 / In This Archive: 1
Posts: Total: 453 / In This Archive: 246 		From: Chicago
Speaks Polish?: not quite yet...
Interests: Math, history, science, economics, & hockey

Displayed posts: 247 / page 7 of 9
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Babinich   
5 Dec 2008
News / What did Poland get out of the wars and struggles for others? [1108]

YES its true, Celinski is right. BRITIAN, the main force in Western Europe

NO... :') France had THE land army in western Europe.

England??? 1939??? Marching through Germany??? Erm...do you think they would have been successful?

No, but the French would have been successful walking right through the Siegfried Line into the Ruhr.

Why did the USA declare war on Germany?

Germany declared war on the US.

Anzac forces could combine with Canadian and Japanese troops to invade Russia from the east.

So do you see England and Japan as allies?

I am interested in how you resolve the inevitable conflict between England and an expansionist imperial Japanese empire.
Babinich   
5 Dec 2008
News / What did Poland get out of the wars and struggles for others? [1108]

Britain most certainly should have got involved in WWII, it just joined on the wrong side.

An interesting counter factual. Does this mean Britain stands by as a silent partner in Germany's move east? Or, do the British provide forces for Barbarossa?
Babinich   
4 Dec 2008
News / What did Poland get out of the wars and struggles for others? [1108]

The Red Army was little more than a joke and would have presented no problem to the British and/or French armies.

Does that mean the American forces would be taken off the board? No men, no material of any kind?
Babinich   
2 Dec 2008
News / What did Poland get out of the wars and struggles for others? [1108]

Technically you're correct an invitation was extended. Like all complicated matters, when in-depth study is conducted one can see phony that invitation happened to be.

The Government in Exile Poles were not to be recognized for fear of upsetting Uncle Joe.

There is no such thing in history of WW2 as 1943 Warsaw uprising.

Warsaw Ghetto April '43.
Babinich   
2 Dec 2008
News / What did Poland get out of the wars and struggles for others? [1108]

Here are some examples of lies:
"Poles were not invited to the London Victory Parade."

An official invitation was sent to the Government in Warsaw. Unfortunately, the British had not noticed, until it was too late, that the Warsaw government had not been Britain's wartime ally.

Shortly after VE-Day the Government in Exile lost its recognition (representation of Poland) by Britain.

A last minute invitation was extended but that invitation was declined.

IMO rightly declined...

This is another example of how Stalin outmaneuvered both Churchill and Roosevelt. The latter doing all he could to undercut his British counterpart up until the day he died.
Babinich   
23 Nov 2008
History / UPA barbarian murders on Polish and Jewish neighbors during WW2 [150]



I am of both Polish and Ukrainian descent, Christian, born in the USA, and yet, am I responsible for the many bloody wars and conflict that took place between Poland and Ukraine? Absolutely not. I think a partial solution is constructive and honest dialogue between people and nations.

True... As U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis once said: "Sunlight is the best disinfectant".
Babinich   
17 Nov 2008
News / POLISH FOREIGN MINISTER IN TROUBLE OVER JOKE? [29]

what if the joke wouldn't be about the future US president? and not from the mounth of a politician? would it be funnier then?

You're right; this is nothing more than political correctness run amok.
Babinich   
11 Nov 2008
Life / PATRIOTISM -- POLISH OR OTHERWISE? [23]

When is love for your country and pride in your country's history and culture an extreme?

To be Polish is to be proud; celebrate that freedom and all those who sacrificed their lives to attain it.
Babinich   
10 Nov 2008
News / Candidate of "Hope and Change," Breaks Promise, Leaves Poland Defenseless [47]

The economic negatives of the EUare the sometimes unrealistic demands in the environmental area (Kyoto), labor law, , trade (agricultural subsidies), special exemptions of policy (France/Germany given extensions to meet budget deficit requirements below three percent of GDP to avoid financial sanctions) and taxes.

The citizenry must engage in economic activity and the business sector has to be free to attain a higher level of competitiveness.

I fail to see the need of a centralized body to ensure that rights and freedoms are guaranteedd for all.

If the fear is that sovereignty leads to malevolent leadership thus limiting the freedoms of people, does it not follow that a centralized group of oligarchs have greater power and leverage over those same people?
Babinich   
9 Nov 2008
News / Candidate of "Hope and Change," Breaks Promise, Leaves Poland Defenseless [47]

Even when Russia illegally banned imports of Polish meats, the EU did not show solidarity to Poland. If Poland was attacked, the EU would probably debate over it for months in Brussels.

Ok, if the EU cannot protect "one of its own" through diplomatic or militaristic channels I'd ask what the advantage is in joining.
Babinich   
9 Nov 2008
News / Candidate of "Hope and Change," Breaks Promise, Leaves Poland Defenseless [47]

z_darius

I do not want to leave Poland in any type of that threatens her sovereignty. If I were President I'd do all I could to forge a binding alliance with Poland. I must admit I am biased toward. Poland :')

NATO's shelf life has expired; the EU is now in place.

If the EU cannot guarantee the security for its member states then the existence of the EU should be questioned.

This is why I believe that Poland should actively seek alliances with other nations on the continent. Serbia, Hungary, Sweden, etc...
Babinich   
4 Nov 2008
History / Sarmatia Europe - Could it be political reality? [183]

Actually Germans could made a case for Serbians being the "bane" of Europe...with their Princip assassination being the spark that set the powder keg Europe on fire whose aftermath led to the rise of Hitler....

The blame for Hitler sits squarely on the shoulders of Germany.
Babinich   
4 Nov 2008
History / Sarmatia Europe - Could it be political reality? [183]

Its not that all of us Poles are completely crazy and all over the EU. But it seems to be a good thing to be a part of.

What does the EU provide nations that a strong,, respected, and sovereign nation cannot provide for itself?
Babinich   
30 Oct 2008
News / I support creation of Great Poland [134]

Blaming technology is nothing more than a crutch. It's all about taking personal responsibility for one's actions.
Babinich   
29 Oct 2008
News / I support creation of Great Poland [134]

Crow,

I am with you on this one too.

A greater Poland in Europe would be a great thing. Pride in one's country builds strong local communities and overall, a strong nation state. Generally, strong (non belligerent) nation states participate to free market trading. which leads to stronger economies at home.

For example, an initiative by Poland (and Sweden) call for more cooperation (closer ties) with Belarus, Ukraine, Moldova, Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Why limit ideas to Brussels?
Babinich   
24 Oct 2008
News / Poles are coming home [35]

More... samizdata.net/blog/archives/2008/10/poles_are_leavi.html
Babinich   
28 Sep 2008
History / Why we talk about Nazis not Germans [138]

Well...for many Germans he was the saviour! The situation after WWI was downright ****** for many, Hitler promised to make it right again...cut the drama!

Well said...

Remember that the General Staff, specifically Ludwig Beck opposed the expansionist polices of the Third Reich.

His only hope was that events turn against Germany. To his surprise the moves against the Rhineland and Austria were bloodless.

He retired some time in the fall of 1938 having failed to build a case to the people against the aggression shown by Hitler.
Babinich   
28 Sep 2008
History / Why we talk about Nazis not Germans [138]

I am always thinking about it. Why we hear about Naiz killing Jews Polish Russians enslaving French Polish Russians as forced laubour in factories - not Germans.

Lukasz,

With all due respect I cannot indict the entire German nation for the acts of barbarians. There were many brave Germans that actively fought against Hitler and paid the ultimate price.

It is for this very reason that I cannot hold ill will towards the German people as a whole.