The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Home / Life  % width   posts: 41

Why do Silesians hate Poland?


Ziemowit  14 | 3936
12 Aug 2018   #31
That's interesting...some german has survived in Silesia after the expulsions? Awesome.

I was talking about Polish Silesians rather than German Silesians, but of course quite a lot of German Silesians survived the expulsions of 1946-47 and decided to leave for Germany later on after the expulsions based on the Potsdam agreement were long dead.

One reason was that the Polish authorities, particularly in Lower Silesia, at one time put a stop on German people leaving Silesia after they had realized that qualified workforce were leaving for Germany as well and there was a sudden shortage of specialists in coal mines, workshops and factories.

Those people left Lower Silesia in the 1950s or 1960s. But some of them have remained to this day in their Silesian Heimat. The number of original ethnic German people in Wrocław, for example, is estimated at about 2000 these days.

There are some in the Waldenburg (Wałbrzych) area, too. If you knew Polish, you could be able to listen to their interesting accounts on all those years between 1945 and circa 2000 and later on available on youtube. Born a few years before 1939, some of them they could remember how Lower Silesia looked like in German times. One lady is telling that the area around Waldenburg iss much cleaner and nicer in the present Polish times than it was before 1939 since coal mines and other industry stopped operating in that area. She recalls her pre-1939 Sunday excursions with her father in the vicinity of the village or the small town in which they lived. Another one remembers very well the Schloss Fürstenstein (Zamek Książ) from the time of the WW2 where she lived there as a daughter of a guardian. After the war she was making her living working for many years in the ticket office of the Fürstenstein (Książ) castle. Another one lady says she visits her family in Hamburg on a regular basis, but has rejected their offer to leave Poland and immigrate to Germany. She says there is no nicer land in the world than Lower Silesia, so sho would remain there to her death. The ladies also tell how they were reproached for talking German in the streets of their towns or villages in the times of the People's Republic of Poland (PRL) and add it all luckily ended after 1989.

All of them tell their stories in perfect Polish now. I could not hear the slightest difference in accent to the standard Polish, though some of them picked up the language characteristics for the Polish country people who settled in Lower Silesia after the war. I wonder if there exist those accounts with German subtitles for they would have been very interesting for you to hear.
Bratwurst Boy  8 | 11803
12 Aug 2018   #32
Thanks. That were some interesting insights...
Crow  154 | 9297
16 Aug 2018   #33
Place of Silesia is in Poland. All Silesians and all Slavs knows that. Germany just can`t do anything about it.
Crow  154 | 9297
8 Jul 2024   #34
Latest news

On Jun 30, 2024, Silesian is added as language on Google Translate

source | notesfrompoland.com/2024/06/30/silesian-added-as-language-on-google-translate/
Ironside  50 | 12376
8 Jul 2024   #35
why do people in Katowice hate Poland?

They don't! Maybe you met some nutters but that's about it.
pawian  221 | 25255
8 Jul 2024   #36
Silesian is added as language on Google Translate

Amasing!
Crow  154 | 9297
9 Jul 2024   #37
What is amasing?
wslipach  8 | 97
9 Jul 2024   #38
I noticed that while Poland considers itself as victims against Germany and Russia, the Silesians and Lithuanians consider Poland a brutal bully.

And I think you set up this thread to troll, you grouped Silesians with Lithuanians - two totally different ethnic and cultural grpups from two different countries, you
separated Polish from Silesians - where Silesians are Polish and Polish are Silesians , before you make such gross generalisations and mix it all up on the alleged account of some few persons from the city of Katowice, I suggest you do better than that if you want to provoke some convo.
Crow  154 | 9297
9 Jul 2024   #39
Silesians are Polish and Polish are Silesians ,

Agreed. All Yugoslavians are Serbians and Serbians are Yugoslavians. Plus, parts of Romania, Greece and Albania are Serbian, same way is 1/3 Ukraine is Poland and also Lithuania is Poland.

That for current status of things.
mafketis  38 | 10978
9 Jul 2024   #40
parts of Romania, Greece and Albania are Serbian

No they are not.
Crow  154 | 9297
9 Jul 2024   #41
Oh we shall see. Its only a fraction of what was Slaveno-Serbian and now is under foreign control and in certain level assimilated.

We even don`t need to war for it. No, we only need to exist, to radiate economic stability and to be militarily strong. Then, things begins to rotate around us.

Why do you think that Rome and Germanics worked with Turks in order to keep us in chains?

Our very existence, as original ethnic/cultural background for the Balkan and wider Slavic and European populace, is a threat to certain greedy circles.


Home / Life / Why do Silesians hate Poland?
BoldItalic [quote]
 
To post as Guest, enter a temporary username or login and post as a member.