News /
US slaps Poland in the face (Comey Poland) [92]
All these things have occurred.
Did they? How do you know? Not from the above sources surely.
There are plenty more survivors' stories very well documented.
Are you referring to "stories" taken on face value and never properly verified?
About your sources:
1. The destiny foundation. Not a research or a historical project but more of a nationalistic propaganda, in their own words:
Our films and multi-media programming are designed to educate, inspire, inform, and instill asense of pride and purpose in being Jewish. To demonstrate how each and every Jew fits into the big picture of Jewish history.
The Talmud teaches us that anti-Semitism is a shortcut to fame but eventually it is a long road to Hell and destruction.
Yes, jon a great source of a mystical piece of Judaist thinking. What it has to do with history, objectivity and scientific research? Nothing.
Its reliability is very low.
2.
Fear: Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz, an Essay in Historical Interpretation
I disregarded that work for a sole reason that the author of aforementioned review wrote that Jan T. Gross is an outstanding historian. Most of the serious academicians do not regard Gross as a historian or at least do not regard his book about Poland as a historical book.
I'm not going to waste my time on somebody who is either an inept amateur or a biased and dishonest person.
3.
Finally, Sandra S Williams ( she is not a renown historian either but only as student in Student/Judaic Studies Program) The impact of the Holocaust on Survivors and their Children.
Her objectivity, integrity and a knowledge can be attested to by her own words:
These Jews had neither family nor friends waiting for them in their original homelands and communities, only unfriendly neighbors who feared that the Jews would ask to have their property returned to them
Poland, where they no longer found a viable Jewish community, and moreover, the Jews who had survived were still the objects of hate and murder by Polish nationalists.
Her knowledge of the contexts and reality in Poland at the time is astounding. No, more can be expected. In her bibliography she listed a book I have randomly checked -
Polish Jews: The Final chapter by Earl Vinecour. The text is mediocre at best, it harps on some anti-Polish stereotypes.
In all your sources are focusing solely on the fate of the Jews without understanding of the wider contexts and circumstances. All of them seems to be unaware of the fact that about three millions gentile Poles were also murdered by the Germans, a number at least equal to that of the Polish Jews who lost their lives.
