News /
Polish final report on Smoleńsk aircrash [870]
Again you do not understand a lot of things here and then try blaming me for oversimplifications. So let me put it loud and clear for you: doctor Binienda is not the right doctor - to use your own irony. He is not an expert in aviation in any way. He is an expert in solid mechanics:
This time I was oversimplifying I don't think that he is an aviation expert per se. However he is an expert in his field. Everyday he is dealing with materials and mechanisms used in building aircraft. That way he is dealing with aviation.
To put it plainly he calculated that wing of Tu-154 couldn't be cut off by a birch of that size. All the calculations and simulation are there for any scientist to see.
You don't agree with him - fine prove that his calculation are wrong -fair enough.
Any scientist can do it - that scientific and only way.
Appearing on TV and babbling something about the issue is not the way at all. I don't need to know anything about Arytmowicz to know that it is politics not science what he is playing at. He is taking part in propaganda, I don't know whether he is doing that for money or other reasons but he is not doing it as a scientist.
And of course Macierewicz is full of this, all the time.
Sure he is, he is politician after all.
It doesn't affect those calculations though.
Notwithstanding that his is not a professional pilot,
boletus hold your horses, to investigate a crash there is plenty of experts needed, among them pilots, experts like Binienda and all, however here is only some theoretical calculation and only theoretical calculation can contradict that.
Anyway I don't understand what being a pilot has to do with it. After all pilots do not mow down threes on daily bases.
The right doctor in aerodynamics and aviation
Lets cut the chase you are motivated by political bias. He is not right doctor, his part in propaganda performance disqualified him.
The right way to do it - i.e. explain Smolensk crash - is to assembly real commission and real experts, ask the USA for assistance and reclaim plane and black boxes.
This is the only way.
As for Binieda his theory is just theory but as long as somebody will not prove him wrong I think that is probable theory.
I am only worried that most of it is wasted on Iron. Pearls before swines...
Speaking about swine ...............don't go monkey on me now! Because I will go Iron monkey on you if you will behave like that.