The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by Vlad1234  

Joined: 25 Mar 2013 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - O
Last Post: 21 Apr 2022
Threads: Total: 16 / Live: 7 / Archived: 9
Posts: Total: 883 / Live: 582 / Archived: 301

Speaks Polish?: No

Displayed posts: 589 / page 18 of 20
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Vlad1234   
28 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

I do not disagree that modern Russia retains strong Asian ethic and cultural influence. As well as Ukraine and Belarus. But since Kievan Rus was European state originally wouldn't you want to bring them back to European civilization completely?
Vlad1234   
28 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

Thanks. It was interesting to read. Never heard of this before. But it happened more than 80 years ago... How long people can live obsessed with the past?

Here we need to note, however, that Russian empire and USSR were influenced by Asians to a large extent. Neither Lenin or Stalin, for example, were European ethnically. It doesn't mean that Asians are somehow inferior, of course, it is just such happened historically, that they are culturally different quite a bit.
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

But Poland's export to Canada is 3 times bigger than Canadian export to Poland. It's largely made of ships, aviation engines & components

This is impressive! Could you name some particular companies which export ships, aviation engines & components, furniture and software in Canada? I think if Poland would export only food in Canada they've already did a remarkable success! You can find it in many stores and supermarkets. Probably you have strong trade relations particularly with Canada?

After that Poland made the biggest progress (perhaps except Estonia) out of all commies countries.

I very glad for you (wipes tear). It is good for Ukraine to have such a developed neighbor. I hope Poland and Ukraine will become friends someday.

The poorest ? Moldova, Ukraine, Belarus, Armenia, Serbia, Kosovo etc. What they all have in common is Russian intervention and a refusal to reform.

I think one of the reasons why Eastern Slavic countries have failed in some important aspects can be lack of desire of people in these countries to stand for each other. What includes a lack of an ethnic and basic solidarity. In Poland people are more united probably and tend to help each other more.
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

Only once as a child I sold apricots on the market. Business was good. A good free money sufficient for icecream. (smile)
But it was during the last year of USSR. I didn't visit Ukraine for a while, so maybe you will tell my what is a problem? A wrong legislation?
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

No it is not one of the richest now - but it is in the middle and has overtaken wvery other east european nation except Slovenia.

And certainly Czech if you included them. Still it depends on how you calculate GDP. How much Polish manufacturing grew in the last 30 years? Here in Canada I purchase alimentary goods "made in Poland" sometimes, such as herbs, chocolate, soar cabbage or similar but never saw any Polish product other than food.

The poorest ? Moldova, Ukraine, Belarus, Armenia, Serbia, Kosovo etc. What they all have in common is Russian intervention and a refusal to reform.

What kind of reform do you think they need?
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

Mongolia is in no position to threaten anyone. Russia however is.

Does it make a reason to make up the facts to make Russians guilty in all the crimes during the past history? I prefer objectivity over propaganda. I dislike demonization of any nation. Regarding Russian threat. Russian population continues to age and shrink quickly, significance of the hydrocarbons will fall with time. The only territory Russia added during 18 years of Putin rule was Crimea which size is 27,000 km2 (compared to 17 million km2 of Russia total size). If Russia will continue with the same speed it wouldn't be able to double its territory even in 10.000 years.
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

I am not sure where you are going with this...

He wrote that Poland was one of the poorest in Europe in 1989. Is it one of the richest now?

You would be wondered but according to a modern sources the system that existed in Hungary in 1960-1980-th was one of mildest in Eastern and Central Europe of those times. According to some sources they didn't even have a truly guarded border with Austria and anyone who really wanted to trespass it, could do it. This is not a propaganda (don't get scared), but just a historical curiosity.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goulash_Communism

Because the current leader of Russia openly voiced his regret about the SU's demise

With the same success he can regret about demise of Russian Empire in its 1866 borders.

What is typical to a leaders of a countries which were a large empires once. For example mongols praise Gengiz-Khan and built him a huge monument in Ulan-Battor.

Does it mean we need get scary of Russian monarchists and afraid of Mongol invasion?
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

I meant if some actions of Soviet government are used to represented them as a "Russian crimes" why not bring some facts just for objectivity? In any case USSR is long gone. Why to get scary with "Soviet propaganda"?
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

Yes in 1939 they bombarded and destroyed many Eastern Polish cities with artillery. Whole villages were burned and the inhabitants slaughtered and raped during the Soviet advance at the end of the war

According to wikipedia:

On the Polish side, 3,000-7,000 soldiers died fighting the Red Army, with 230,000-450,000 taken prisoner.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_invasion_of_Poland#Aftermath
No number of a dead civilians is even mentioned in wikipedia. Can you provide any link?

Yes the USSR deported hundreds of thousands of Poles, basically just for being Polish

There were many Polish citizens of other nationalities. Not sure there was any strict ethnic selection. Soviet government claimed they selected them for been members of a Polish officers families, intelligentsia, administrators etc. Those people who they believed were capable to engage in anti-Soviet activity or switch to the enemy side in the War. Many of these people died in Russia been unprepaired for harsh conditions, but many successfully returned back to Poland or decided to stay in Russia by the good will. I wonder what would be their fate if they would get into German occupation a year later.

Soviet rule left Poland one of the poorest countries in Europe by 1989.

Only Soviet fault? Haven't Eastern Germans, Czechs or Hungarians been subjected to a similar system? Did the live exactly like Poles did?

Your 'knowledge' sounds like Soviet propaganda.. hmm in fact it is a soviet propaganda in a form of an opinion.

The thread was about the Russians, not the Soviets. And subsequently some crimes attributed to an "ethnic" Russians. No propaganda here. Only the facts taken from reliable sources that matter.
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / Do Polish people in general dislike Russia or Germany more? [369]

from what i know, both Russia and Germany did kind of terrible things to Poland like Japan did to Korea.

Can be completely equalized? Not sure. To my knowledge Russians didn't level entire Polish cities (like Warsaw) to the ground, didn't send millions of ethnic Poles to die in camps just for been Polish and didn't carry the plans to eliminate Polish state and Polish ethnicity altogether. Even contra they've injected hundreds of billions of USD in Polish economy during 1945-1989 and even sent the first Polish cosmonaut to the space.
Vlad1234   
27 Sep 2018
History / What is Poles opinion on Intermarium (Międzymorze)? [188]

So, if Three Seas Area isn`t for Serbia and Ukraine to join then they are territoriality separated, what isn`t acceptable.

The distance will not separate a friendly hearts. I write it to you from Canada (smile).
Vlad1234   
25 Sep 2018
History / What is Poles opinion on Intermarium (Międzymorze)? [188]

The leaders of Russia, Belarus and Ukraine all expressed desire to enter EU (at least some of them in the past). They aren't going to be accept any time soon and I think that a Slavic Union (which may also include non-Slavic members) could be a good ski jumping rope for them as a preparation before joining EU somewhere in the future.

As a Ukrainian I think that a Polish-Ukrainian Confederacy alone would create a formidable union with 80 million population and 1 million square kilometers territory. Add skillful Polish administration and investment capital to skilled Ukrainian workforce and resources. Russia could be a good possession for a Union as well thanks to its huge resources and technical skills in certain areas. In 2014 Putin expressed desire to create a free trade zone from Portugal to The Pacific. I think that historically Ukraine, Belarus and parts of Russia belong to Europe (or at least originally were), culturally and civilization-wise and all European countries need to rethink their farther integration.
Vlad1234   
2 Jun 2015
History / Differences between Poland and Russia [43]

8- Russia was closed of to the west, Poland welcomed the west
10- Different cultural preferences, russians tend to be very eastern in mindset, polE's are more european.
11- General polish hostility to communism (while not 100%) and general russian exeptance of communism

Peter the I, Catherine the Great, Enlightment, hundreds of thousands of German, French, Italian and Western European settlers, engineers, architects, generals, nobles welcomed in Russia, granted with privilegies, correspondence of Russian Tsars with Voltaire, abolishment of death penalty by Catherine II in 18-th (!) century, abolishment of serfdom in 1861 (in Poland only in 1863), French as the first knowledge of Russian court and perfect knowledge of French, German, English etc. by Russian emperors and nobles, Citizenship war, White movement, dissident movement, M. Gorbachev, perestroika, Yeltsin etc...
Vlad1234   
30 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

English_Polish - English_Russian
Cloud_Chmura - Cloudy(person)_Chmuryj
Curse_Klatwa - Oath_Kliatwa
Citizens_Obywatele - Inhabitants_Obywatieli

Groin - Pachwina - Pach
Reptiles - Gady - Gady (archaic)
Sick - Chory - Chworyj (archaic)

If - Jeżeli - Jeżeli
Windy - Wietrzny - Wietriennyj

Could somebody reveal to me origins of Polish word "wykidajlo" - a bouncer? The same as Russian wyszybala. In Russian wykidat' means "through away something" for example garbage. Is there a similar word in Polish or this is a borrowing?
Vlad1234   
27 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

Not in modern Russian. An old Russian word for cat is "kotka" or "kot'ka". A modern diminutive is kosziećka for a female cat and kotik for male. Kotionok is a kitten.
Vlad1234   
27 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

It seems that I quoted an item from a list that didn't contain Polish versions of any words, but English, Czech and Russian ones. My fault.

But that's Czech and your comment was about Polish. Don't you know the difference between Czech and Polish?..

A male (and only male) cat in Polish is kocur. Are there similar ones in Russian?

No.
Vlad1234   
27 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

You can say "mnogo" in Polish, but it isn't a commonly used word. Dużo, wiele - ok, but mnogo?

Wiele is a German borrowing. Diużyj in old Russian means very strong and big (usually about a person.).
Vlad1234   
27 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

kpc21 writes:

Vlad1234 - Many - Mnogo - Mnogo

Do not retreat to "falsifications". (joke). That's a shame, really.
My list contained:

Multitude - Mnóstwo, mnogość - Mnożestwo, mnogo

Multitude, not "many".

Similar situation is in case of cat. In Polish the basic word, used when the gender isn't important, is kot and it's a male word, while in Russian it's koszka and it's a female word. In Polish if you want to specify that your cat is female, you call it kotka or kocica. In Russian, when you want to specify that it's male - I don't know.

In Russian it is kot as well as in Polish. And personally I do not give preference to kot or koszka if I refer to a cat in general.

Russian uses "western" words for months, like English, while Polish has own ones (except for March and May).

Old Russian names for months were based on Slavic roots and some of them similar to Polish:
February - lutień. April - cwietień. September - Wielieseń.
Vlad1234   
26 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

Polish łaska = grace, mercy, pity. Czech laska = love. Russian laska = weasel, kindness. However Polish laska = staff, rod, kane.
Actually a Russian word "laska" difficult translate in English. It could be translated for example as "showing a signs of tender attitude".
Vlad1234   
26 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

On the other hand, certain basic words such as Polish "tydzień" cf. "tyden" in Czech, "Dzień dobry" and "Dobry den" point to a closer day-to-day proximity, not to mention the buzzing sounds of Polish and Czech, compared to the much more exaggerated palatalization of Russian and Ukrainian.

Russian ''Dobryj dień'' or ''Dień Dobryj". However Czech pronunciation doesn't sound similar to Polish when you listen to both languages.
Vlad1234   
25 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

It is a wery well known fact in linguistics. Polish and Czech belong to the same west slavic group of languages. What was the reason to include them
into the same group ? Do you think it was geography ?

As I've already wrote in one of my posts:
I'm not a professional linguist to do such a statements but in my dilettante opinion division of Slavic lang-s into Western and Eastern is quite vague and conditional. Lexically the Czech is hardly closer to Polish than Russian. Maybe even contra. Use of Latin alphabet, fixed stress pattern (though different between Polish and Czech) and some other small similarities do usually serve as a reason for division. Polish alphabet is not exactly Latin. It uses characters not present in English, for example. Cyrilic alphabet on other hand share some similar characters with Latin. For example: A, B, C, E, H, X, T, O, K, M, P. Ukrainian alphabet does have even "i".

Some distinctive features of the West Slavic languages, as from when they split from the East Slavic and South Slavic branches around the 3rd to 6th centuries AD, are as follows:[3]
development of proto-Slavic tj, dj into palatalized ts, (d)z, as in modern Polish/Czech noc ("night"; compare Russian ночь);
retention of the groups kv, gv as in Polish gwiazda ("star"; compare Russian звезда; but note also Russian цвет vs. Ukrainian квіт, "flower");
retention of tl, dl, as in Polish/Czech radlo/rádlo ("ard"; compare Russian рало);
palatized h (ich-Laut) developed into š, as in Polish musze (locative case of mucha, "fly")

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/West_Slavic_languages

Cropped quote - over 100 words
Vlad1234   
25 May 2015
Language / Slavic languages words similarities with Polish [238]

Descendants of Rurik were Rurikovichi - the noble princes. Rurik is Scandinavian name. According to legend he was welcomed by Slavs to rule Novgorod area.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rurik_dynasty