What do Poles owe to Jews?

...and 99% of Germans.

Sadly misguided majority, only a corageous minority stood up for what ís right and just.

BS. They knew what he was doing and they were proud as the other Germans were conquering country after country. If they were misguided, every single person on the globe can claim the same and disclaim responsibility.

Misguided or obedient. Didn't work very well at Nuremberg, did it?

reddit.com/r/polandball/comments/3nkhm3/the_greatest_enemy/

One of the most popular polandball comics ever....

wow thats a brilliant polandball, there should be a best off polandball archive site.

Did you see the pics on his fridge? :)


There actually is....they are right now celebrating 10 years of Polandball Reddit :)

reddit.com/r/polandball/

How about Art Spiegelman's "Maus"?

What do Poles owe to Jews?
NOTHING.

I was first.

That`s too little. You still need to prove it so that we wil believe you.


Of course not.. This thread is 9 years old while you joined in 2020.

Here we are.
What do the Poles owe to Jews?
NOTHING. Ah, yes anyway, but nothing good:
- Communist oppression of more than 50 years due to the Jews in large part;
- Odious propaganda carried out against Poland, the Poles;
- Many Jews (pro-Russian / Soviet) partially responsible for the tragedies in Poland (uprisings, war 1920, 1939-41 collaboration with the Soviet occupier - denunciations, murders ...),


Exactly. And also their life, thanks to the courage of the non-Jewish Poles and, perhaps, a little remorse for those who died saving them. Many Jews don't feel anything. They consider that it was the duty of the Poles alone, not of other nations.

Zofia Szczucka-Kossak spoke of human duty, and that involved a lot of people for a Jew. (Krall said 45 Poles to save her)


What does it mean to you, your distinction "Polish Jews or Jewish Poles"?
Would you do it for the Jews of the USA? No doubt not.

Have to agree, Poles owe Jews nothing. Germany can pay and they should pay everyone for WWII. The whole Jewish complaining like they were the only victims is complete BS. The Germans located the camps here, they didn't exist before the Germans built them in an occupied country. If a Pole was forced to do any work for the Germans what choice did he have? None. Lay down and die and give up his life or his family for a people he has no responsibility for?

With a gun to their heads, the Jews did enough to their own kind. Why are the Jews not going after their own? The whole discussion is not even worth having any more.

Jews lived and developed in Polish culture and practically all of them had excellent, famous non-Jewish Polish painters as Professors (Maslowski, Chelmonski Pankiewicz, etc for Kramsztyk, Kisling, Hayden, bracia Gottlieb, etc .; pianist Rubinstein, protégé of the conductor of the Warsaw Philharmonic, Emil Młynarski, world-renowned composer and pianist, Paderewski, or composer Karol Szymanowski

Henryk Wieniawski (district name of Wieniawa in Lublin) a famous violinist and composer, whom you quote, was from a family of very cultivated Jewish Poles, converted to Catholicism,

@Alien #331
There were also atheist Jews; cf. Kramsztyk, famous painter, considered himself Polish, period.
He did not know so much about Jewish traditions and did not frequent them.
He was shocked, the German quad locked him up in the Warsaw Getho.
The Poles wanted to take him out, but he stayed there to testify. Strangely enough, a lot of his drawings have disappeared. Without doubt, he also showed another side of the Ghetto, that of the carefree rich Jews.


Jews wanted to do it already as soon as Poland became independent, and you even demanded it in Versailles.

Try to create this Jewish "mini state" in the USA or in another country (France, Germany). Would they agree? They would laugh in your face or locked up in a lunatic asylum.


Jewishness, maybe, = opportunity?


It's obvious. We can also add Michnik's brother, still in Sweden (no extradition)


Yes rather "anti-Jews". Jews appropriate Semites, mostly Arabs, Berbers, Palestinians, etc.)


False. Between the wars, around 375,000 Jews lived only in Warsaw, more than the total number of Jews in France and 10 times more than in Holland.


Pain lost for all these Polonophobes


Absolutely. As a reminder, Auschwitz was not even in occupied Poland, but on September 1, 1939, integrated into the German Reich, like Chelmo, Stutthoff, Sosnowiec, Gliwice, etc.

Since, as some claim, Jews were Poles, the question is what Poles owe Poles.
A half-Jew, half-Pole, will he pay himself?

Or to put a finer point on the question, what do GENTILES owe Jews?

Exactly what Jews owe for living in Poland since that royal moron invited them centuries ago and for their criminal activities as the UB and the Soviet agents.

Yes, a lot of them dropped their Jewish heritage, culture, language etc. Still, they had Jewish background and as such they are eligible to be discussed in this thread.


It means nothing special. I often provide such double distinction so that nobody feels hurt which sometimes happens when only one notion is offered and they feel excluded. .


Thank you very much for your contribution. See you in other threads. :):)

Btw, I forgot to add that this thread isn`t about financial compensation for Jewish property lost during WW2. It is about sth more important. :):):)

Bottom line: I owe what the judge says I owe. For the rest, call God or pray.

which Gentiles and which Jews?

Can there be a partial Jew the way Kamala is black?

Of course. E,g,, when only one parent is Jewish. Isn`t it obvious?

How about 1/8. Still Jewish?

Are you talking about your origin now? I thought it was higher than 1/8. :):)

How about 1/16. Still Jewish?

Stop speculating or even obsessing about those fractions so much. Try to accept this heritage and get rid of that self-hate at last. It badly influences your psyche.

What makes one a Jew? How about 1/32? Still a Jew? If Kamala is black and the other a-hole one was an Indian at 1/1024...it's a valid question at the payout time or the line will be very long.

Judaism is matrilineal.

Judaism is a religion. Some Christians convert to Judaism. Mothers have nothing to do with it.

English vocabulary is not very clear here (and neither is Polish).

Russian handily distinguishes between the followers of the religion (root: iud-) and the 'nationality' or ethno-group (roughly Ashkenezi jews who have a lot of distinct genetic markers like any ethnic population) (root: evrej-)

So in Russia most evrej- don't really practice the iud- religion while a few who do practice iud-ism aren't evrej-...

Much clearer....

If the mother is of Jewish heritage, the immediate offspring is automatically Jewish, like Jesus. Clear enough?