I am a polish communist.

Quite. Nobody in that party is, despite the toxic rhetoric from reactionaries.


It isn't. Promoting totalitarianism is I think illegal, however Communism in itself isn't totalitarian; people confuse it with the failed iteration of it in the Soviet Union and other states which weren't even ready for Social Democracy, never mind anything else.


This is true. These were third world countries so chaotic it was possible to create chaos.by dictatorial, usually military, regimes.

These are the two key things.

In Indonesia, an autocrat backed by the military actually massacred half a million Communist sympathizers. This was done in the space of a few weeks.

In South Vietnam, a dictatorial regime composed of military men killed hundreds of thousands more in extrajudicial killings.

The reason Communist states around the world were so brutal, could very well be because the main exporter of Communism was Russia. In Russia, it took on a severe bent because it was shaped in a context of civil war and famine, and where most of the men in charge had spent a long time either in prison or in the military.

That's pretty well it.

A writer (I forget who) wrote two interesting things about Communism. One was that if it had been achieved first in Japan rather than the Soviet Union or China, it would have worked very differently and the other thing was that if it had been achieved in 1950s Britain, especially the northern industrial regions and Scotland's central belt, nobody would really have noticed much difference.

The countries that got it were an uneasy mix of rural poverty, intellectual ideological absolutism and a huge military infrastructure.

I slightly knew someone (he was called Professor Ludwik Haas) who spent 17 years in the Gulag for being a Trotskyist and 17 months in a PRL jail after the Soviet Union let him go. He was certainly a Communist however they hated him because he was a real one. And sometimes I think the far left in the U.K., the Trots and Tankies, hate people like me who are middle of the road Labourites from the trade union movement even more than they hate capitalists.

xD

Oh, how I would like to see Britain turning communist! Not very Christian of me but I would. Actually, the entire Western Europe should turn communist for 45 years at least. I bet they would see some difference then.

meh is that somebody brand new or an old poster returned with a new moniker? I wonder.
Anyway, whoever it is it is intended for trolling.
---

304? PM me your number.

Religion didn't kill anybody -People did.
At least Christianity put an end to sacrificing humans in some pagan rituals.

Socialist for sure.

What Poles and others from more absolutist societies don't grasp about the U.K. is that we invented Socialism, via Owenism and the Cooperative movement. Nothing was ever imposed from outside, there were no revolutions, no Esbeks and Ubeks and any corruption there was never a fraction of what it was in Poland or is even today.

And if we had been Communist, don't think for a second that there would have been the sort of repression that existed in Central and Eastern Europe.


It's ee cummins.

No you are not, you already tried that one on us as AntiRussianPutinHater last week
Do you have a penis ? Yes, yes you do so you are a man, a very fem man, but still a male.
Is your name Michael, yes it is.

I don't, I smell Delph written all over his posts
If I were a Mod I would immediately delete this troll thread as it has nothing to do with Poland or Polish people.
He claims to be Polish but clearly he isn't with that Scottish accent.(Bloody hell)
(guilt from his old moniker)
You're busted again ole boy.
Man up and admit that you can't fool us with your trolling as a Polish Communist.
How disgusting of you.

No, I do not and never have had a penis.

No, my name is not micheal.


I'm raised in a part of the UK where we all use bloody hell, xD.

And Johnny Reb ain't no polish name.


It certainly has more than a thread about the USA's elections.

This is my first time on this site. Mods can check IP records.


???


man up and admit - ty to chlopak co nie ma nic lepszego do robienia niz policiowac fora internetowe.

tak to dla ciebie wazne to a: zrob se forum swoje, albo b: stan sie moderatorem.

I'd rather be stuck in a gulag then 'confess'.

Betcha I could pal up with some guards and be out in no time /s.

'Than' is the word you were looking for.

Be careful what you wish for. Revolution likes to eat her own children. :)

Another sick Brit coming to an American forum to talk shlt...


...because they know too much...

Thank you, that is indeed what I meant.

Hey, commie, why are you here on this forum?

Don't you have one like this in the UK or are you afraid of your Internet police?

I didn't ask you if your name was micheal, I ask you if your name was michael.
Your buddy Mr. Twister (jon) taught you well.

You are the only one I know to have ever used that term in the last ten years that I have been here.
In fact we bust another one of your sock puppets when you used it before, remember now. 😳

Who claimed that it was or are you just throwing a cheap diminishment out there in your defense.😋

No, no it does not.
That thread is on the back page blocked out to all nonmembers by the P.F. Admin. (jon) even though it does concern Poland.
That is why your thread should be moved off the front page because it has nothing to do with Poland or Polish people

You have been using a VPN to hide your I.P. for years for all your sock puppets.
You seem to navigate around this site pretty well for being your first time here. 🙄

Its my hobby

What makes you think that I am not a Mod.

Tacy sami - a staw miedzy nami!
I am neither one nor the other.


That is not my problem.
You can cross check my Ip - it is quite obviously a Tmobile Ip and not a vpn.


No, we actually don't have one in the UK.

Why aren't you on Vkontakte and not some little american forum?

You don't have forums like this one or Internet police?

A quick forum search shows that it has been used by Milo, Jon, Atch, Dolno, Wroclaw Boy, Dolno and many others, primarily from the UK. You really do talk out of your arse.


The fact that moderator isn't written next to your name.

Internet police is busy arresting boomers with fascist tendencies that voice them a tad too loudly on facebook.

It is a yes or no question, not "neither one" nor "the other".
Mr. Twister trained you well.

I did and that is not what it is showing but I just did a quick search that is not always correct.

Oh shut up, Karen and read again only slower this time before you ejaculate all over yourself in excitement.
Put emphasis on the words, the only one I know
I said that
Now get lost and quit your stalking/trolling.

LOL - we both know that when the Mods post they don't always have Moderator written by their names if it is a personal post, stupid.
Now Git !

You didn't and you can't, since you aren't a mod.

And since you're pretending to be, what's the location associated with the IP I'm posting from now and have mostly posted from all year?


And you never have.

Switch it on, and make one post or admit you're a liar.

And I just pointed out that numerous forum members have used that exact same phrase so are you going to accuse them of being 'commie' too? Your powers of deduction are crap


Stop talking more sh!te! Yes, they do if they're making a personal post. If you see red writing on someone's post that could be a mod or admin. The only stupid person here is you.

You're not a mod and have no idea of anyone's IP address.

Neither one nor the other means that no, I am not either Micheal nor Michael.

Do not criticize my completely correct grammar just because you can't understand it.

Criticising the grammar of second language speakers is never nice.

Though (and I'll hope your not offended), the word criticise is spelt criticise.

English, please..

I am neither X nor Y.

I am not X or Y.

Both spellings are correct.

We are on an American forum, and with the hate I'm receiving for being a brit, I'm trying to use American English.

The running dogs of late stage capitalism.


Me too.

There's English English and there's local variants.

I would...... all over you......communists are as disgusting as fascists and perverts.

Your first incorrect assumption is that you'd get close enough to me.

HaHaHa!..... you are very stupid....... of course I would get close enough to you and you would make me feel sick......fait accompli!