The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives 
 
 
User: Guest

Posts by Jed  

Joined: 10 Apr 2010 / Male ♂ 		Last Post: 6 May 2010
Threads: -
Posts: 165 		From: Moscow, Russia
Speaks Polish?: No
Interests: science

Displayed posts: 165 / page 2 of 6
sort: Latest first   Oldest first
Jed   
28 Apr 2010
News / RUSSIA TO MAKE PUBLIC THE KATYN FILES... [274]

There was a civil war in 1918-20 - White movement lost, most educated people were killed. Any resistance was supressed with mass murders.
Stalin "cult" was removed after 1953 and most radical NKVD officers were killed or were put to prison -but by other communists. Mass murders and repressions were stopped after that. Stalin was already a history when I was young.
Jed   
28 Apr 2010
News / RUSSIA TO MAKE PUBLIC THE KATYN FILES... [274]

At least he didn't concentrate on killing his own people..

History is not reversable.

I would be happy if Western democracies could won war against Hitler without Russians. May be it would help us to remove Stalin and communism earlier and save more lives.

Child rapists are true heroes?

Looks like I missed the moment when you opened a case against rapists? There was an army tribunal for rapists in Soviet army.
Jed   
28 Apr 2010
News / RUSSIA TO MAKE PUBLIC THE KATYN FILES... [274]

nobody can help you...

OK - we don't ask for your help.

It is our history and we can't change it. The problem was who was more evil - and in that period of time even Stalin was better than Hitler.
Jed   
28 Apr 2010
News / RUSSIA TO MAKE PUBLIC THE KATYN FILES... [274]

That isn't a matter of opinion...aren't you yourself not interested in finding out and punishing war criminals?

And who are war criminals? Was there any trial?

They won war. Losers can call them "criminals" - I can understand it but it doesn't matter.
Jed   
28 Apr 2010
News / RUSSIA TO MAKE PUBLIC THE KATYN FILES... [274]

No, it's quite different - they fight for our country and won. If necessary we will repeat.

Russians in Afghanistan were the same like Americans in Vietnam, Yugoslavia, Iraq, Afghanistan. All these are just local wars - part of a big political game with local people lives. Yes, all these are crimes.
Jed   
28 Apr 2010
News / RUSSIA TO MAKE PUBLIC THE KATYN FILES... [274]

I'm sure it'll be well received by why is it "brave"?

It is not brave at all - and nothing new . Copies of all these documents were sent by Pres. Yeltsin to Polish officials in early 90-th.

But for unclear reason these docs were "closed" again in Russian archives. The catastrophy with Polish President put publisc attention to this problem - and now Russian public opinion is on Polish side...

I wonder how many of the old veterans marching in the victory parade every 9th May are war criminals, maybe even were there in Katyn or raping their way till Berlin...

There are not criminals - they are true heroes and winners. Criminals - forever - are those who lost WWII.
Jed   
24 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

It wouldn't be admissible as evidence in court as it's almost impossible to make anything out.

May be I also became paranoid but when somebody trying to put public attention on the obviously meaningless "evidenses" - the aim could be not to find the truth but put us as far as possible from it.
Jed   
24 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

He doesn't say dawaj gnata, does he?

No it doesn't. We have a long discussion with Olga on other thread - and at the end even she confirmed that listened something like "Davay gnat' ih otsuda" = "Let's take them away from here". I didn't hear even that on this place of video. "Gnat' " is a verb "take away" = wygnat' (looks like Polish also has it) = prognat' .

Russians didn't find anything special on this video. I think most misinterpretations are based on misspelling Russian.

It is a scene of crash and officials showing way for fire tracks and pushing away occasional public from dangerous place with firing plane.
Jed   
23 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

if it is found your government has tried to cover-up an assassination

(1) It would be very hard to cover - it requires handreds of participants involved. It would be hard even 30-40 years ago and looks totally impossible now.

(2) I would need really good proofs for international jurisdiction

From general point of view - who "lost" and "benefit" and how - I didn't find my government in the first lines of "beneficiars" list but rather in the list of potential "losers".

One of the reasons why I'm here - I would like to see how Poles inside Poland estimate these "benefits" - I found myself totally incompetent in intermal affairs of Poland after reading many stupid comments about Russian affairs and intentions here - I would look the same.
Jed   
23 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

And how would anyone even dare when this is documented:

In your case you already have a conclusion- Putin and Russians are guilty - and take any real or false evidence only against them.

I told many times - we are not in position to discuss technical details based on incomplete evidences and we don't have any experience for that.

On your photos - may be they testing lights or somebody ordered them to check and replace lamps - we don't know. It doesn't explain why the plane was directed to the hill several hundred metres before landing strip.
Jed   
23 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

In case you don't have a clue what a cockpit looks like

Olga, I can't read Polish, but it is not a cockpit on the first photo - it looks like an opposite part, a tail with engine.

Look here: charter97.org/en/news/2010/4/10/28038/

Because as we know, pilot's errors NEVER happen.

I don't like to blame the pilot - he can't answer. We wiil have the right to blame him only after all other possibilities studied.

And the whole flight and visit organisation are almost out of discussion - there are possible alive people sharing responsibility?
Jed   
22 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

Poland still has not received THEIR OWN
POLISH PRESIDENTIAL PLANE'S BLACK BOXES

Did you read only headlines?
"Two Tu-154 flight recorders, which contain flight parameters and voice recordings are being examined at the laboratory in Moscow by Russian investigators and Col. Zbigniew Rzepa from the Polish Supreme Military Prosecutor's Office"

Did they completed mutual investigation already?
Jed   
22 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

Couldn't find any reliable source for this stupid idea. May be this is your 'reliable" source of information?

kavkazcenter.com/eng/content/2010/04/22/11899.shtml

The only information contained in this source is that they hate Putin and Russia so much that it makes them blind and simetimes even dead.
Jed   
21 Apr 2010
News / Crash of Tu-154 at Smolensk-North--could it have been a bomb in the Polish plane? [233]

Where's their camera showing the plane and weather

The first witness interview I saw on Russian TV (Rossiaya 24) was with Polish journalist with camera in hands - he run from a meeting point in the airport to the crash site immediately after the catastrophe. I don't know his name but he wasn't alone - there were other Polish witnesses.

Ask them about weather conditions - it should be in Polish sources. For myself it is not a question - a lot of witnesses in Smolensk confirmed that there was a heavy fog at this time. Nothing to discuss.
Jed   
20 Apr 2010
News / Is it possible that Polish president was assasinated? If so then, by whom? [921]

How? By getting rid of the staunchest supporters of it, i.e. less opposition to overturning it.

Just read your article lower:
"Last month Obama scrapped a plan agreed by his Republican predecessor George W. Bush to install a controversial anti-missile system in the two neighbours." - it's about those SM-3 for 2015.

Thus, the problem is currently not existing. No reason for mads in Russia to kill somebody.
Jed   
20 Apr 2010
News / Is it possible that Polish president was assasinated? If so then, by whom? [921]

Jed, is this headline any clearer for you?

That's a danger: "...aside from the Patriots Washington aims to deploy new SM-3 missiles in Poland and the Czech Republic in 2015."

How Kaczynski "assasination" would influence it? It may only increase Poles favor to host US shield. Russia has the opposite aim. Look somewhere else.
Jed   
20 Apr 2010
News / Is it possible that Polish president was assasinated? If so then, by whom? [921]

How is this for recent?

Did you read them youself?
NYT:
"Moscow has been a staunch opponent of the shield, asserting that the antiballistic missiles were directed against Russia, a claim that the United States has strongly denied." - This remark is about GMD while previous text is about "Patriots".

Informations in kyivpost is neutral (don't you forget it is from Ukraine?)

This is the missile thread: Do Poles in Poland really feel betrayed because there won't be any US Shield?
Jed   
20 Apr 2010
News / Is it possible that Polish president was assasinated? If so then, by whom? [921]

I'm just making the point that the Russian government was pissed about this--there's no denying that.

All your proofs sent us to 2008 - it's all about GMD missiles. Newer information is rather neutral.

I don't think we should be happy with "Patriots" - more arms create more danger. I just said that danger level is lower with it than with GMD. May be I missed something but there are no serious targets in Polish territory to protect with Patriots against our tactical missiles. GMD position would be a target but it is not there.