The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by Sire Brenshar  

Joined: 23 Jan 2010 / Male ♂ 		Last Post: 4 Sep 2010
Threads: 1
Posts: Total: 61 / Live: 25 / Archived: 36
Speaks Polish?: Decently (very slow reder and can't write)

Displayed posts: 26
sort: Oldest first   Latest first   |
Sire Brenshar   
4 Apr 2010
News / THE ARMY OF POLAND - THE REALITY [493]

probably really meant 1775 or you need to crack a book on PL history.

You probably meant 1795 or you need to crack a book on Polish history>
Sire Brenshar   
6 Apr 2010
History / The great mistakes of Poland's history? [216]

Personally I think not finishing off the Prussians and the Russians when we had a chance were the worst mistakes we have ever done: in other words, we've been too merciful.

But is this a good or a bad thing?
Sire Brenshar   
6 Apr 2010
History / The great mistakes of Poland's history? [216]

Quick question Sokrates, are you actually Polish? I thought otherwise in some other threads.

Also you have good knowledge about the September campaign, I certainly am surprised at it, i.e I haven't met any people who got things as right as you have.
Sire Brenshar   
10 Apr 2010
News / Polish President Lech Kaczynski and gov officials die in a plane crash in Russia [686]

My prayers to our President, Lech Kaczynski, his wife, and all the other people of this crash.

I can hardly believe some of the comments posted on this topic, I mean, the victims bodies are probably still warm and some of you have the nerve to make it all a joke?

Anyways, I find it hard to believe that someone did this dreadfull incident, but at the same time, it does seem rather coincident...
I don't really think Russia is responsible, and the only real reason I could imagine them having a hand in this is if they wanted to show a warning, about "past relations" and who's in charge...

But I'm much rather inclined to believe it could be somebody else who wanted to put a stop between the our (PL and Russ) warming relations, and to put a wedge between it.

Just a few words from Polski Radio.

"Many of Poland's political and military elite appear to have lost their lives in the accident, including Poland’s the last president in exile Ryszard Kaczorowski, former defence minister Jerzy Szmajdzinski, head of the Presidential Chancellery Wladyslaw Stasiak, presidential spokesman Pawel Wypych, Secretary of State Mariusz Handzlik, head of the Law and Justice party in parliament Przemyslaw Gosiewski, MP Zbigniew Wassermann and Bishop Tadeusz Płoski."

"Komorowski takes over as head of state"

Truly horrible, these people helped form Poland's spirit...
Sire Brenshar   
10 Apr 2010
News / Polish President Lech Kaczynski and gov officials die in a plane crash in Russia [686]

Read his post more carefully.

Whoever dies during the Enlightened Week goes straight to Heaven, regardless of what sins they had.

Obviously everyone gets to sit beside him, their titles from Earth mean nothing to him if they are received like any other unnamed person.

Whats the point of even having posting that...
Sire Brenshar   
13 May 2010
History / Poles and (Polish) Jews... Victims of war... and beyond [380]

Btw to everyone, the Soviets Unions casualties of 20 million weren't all even killed by Nazis, indeed only between 5-9 were killed by Germans.

-The rest were murdered by the Soviets themselves.
Sire Brenshar   
8 Jun 2010
History / Why Poles love Russia [105]

These are but a few of the reasons that readily come to mind. There are many, many more examples of the crimes and misdeeds of a genetically flawed semi-Slavic/semi-Mongol nation which knows only intrigues and brute force against its own people and their neighbours.

You've forgotten robbing Poland (and Lithuania) of thousands of literature, state records, and all sorts of documents in 1795, and not having given the vast majority that we still don't have back. (We're still waiting)
Sire Brenshar   
8 Jun 2010
History / Why Poles love Russia [105]

We are waiting for the Berlinka still too...

We should give that back too: better to have no art than art by Germans (not saying German art is bad, but that we are basically stealing someone else's culture)
Sire Brenshar   
8 Jun 2010
History / Why Poles love Russia [105]

Improve my knowledge :)

Art moved by Germans into occupied Poland during ww2, and which stayed there (the Polish gov. tried to keep it secret and that it was repayment for all the art Germans destroyed)
Sire Brenshar   
14 Jun 2010
History / The Two Saddest Nations on Earth... Poles and Jews [243]

Many of you will think: "Not another Polish-Jewish thread again"

But I felt this to be necessary...

I want to ask all members on this forum who are really care about such things and don't just try to degrade their fellow Poles/Jews, to make an attempt to show that they really would want Jewish Polish relations to be mended; not on a official foreign relations level, but on a personal level, that we can each say individually "I forgive you", and mean it.

I would like to see if we could all show the friendship between our two nations, whether historical or modern, by posting pictures, work of arts, texts, our own words, or anything else that you feel would help our current stance, or that shows appreciation towards our two nations.

I encourage none-Poles and none-Jews also to help us by showing what you believe our nations were and should become.

If this thread becomes what I hope it will be, I will send it to as many sites and people as I can who still have conflicts in matters between Jews and Poles as proof that we can still be friends despite all hardships, and that we will be for the rest of time.

The Reception of the Jews in Poland

Please, if you mean it, if you think the rift between Poles and Jews should be mended, post below

Allow me to begin

One of my favorite movies with a Jewish character:

If you have nothing positive to post, please do not post at all
Sire Brenshar   
14 Jun 2010
History / The Two Saddest Nations on Earth... Poles and Jews [243]

14 replies... and none bear even the slightest resemblance to what I asked

O well, at least I tried. (what was I thinking last night)

We can just drop he whole thing.
Sire Brenshar   
14 Jun 2010
History / The Two Saddest Nations on Earth... Poles and Jews [243]

Sire, it needs MUCH more than a forum to change popular sentiments. Change comes from both within and outwith. Besides, many Polish PF members didn't live through WWII. They were very different times. Poland has had enough of a transformation to go through after the collapse of communism.

Well, I knew that, just I wanted to see for myself if the common person even tries to change something themselves; I always thought that many Poles wouldn't be as hate-filled as some do seem to be...

Who am I to mess with imperfections anyways...
Sire Brenshar   
14 Jun 2010
History / The Two Saddest Nations on Earth... Poles and Jews [243]

Sire, do you live in Poland? The Jewish question is really not that big amongst common people, believe me. The Poles are more focussed on carving out their own way. I'd very much class indifference the lesser of two 'evils' when cast alongside outright hostility, wouldn't you?

No, I don't live in Poland (yet), but I see your point (all to clearly)

Remember, don't make the issues of yesteryear a burden for those of today. They have their own pressing issues to contend with.

I think that's a good finale for this thread.

Hmm, and sorry about your deceased relative, God bless her.
Sire Brenshar   
15 Jun 2010
History / The Two Saddest Nations on Earth... Poles and Jews [243]

To many posts to answer... But all I can say is (never mind my original idea, since half of it was to NOT post none-progressive stuff) that I actually like the way this thread is going.

I can't really put it into words, but it feels like people are talking deeper than on all those other Polish-Jewish threads.

Thanks very much to everyone who is participating (yes M-G, you did too) I learning quite a bit, reading old texts and half buried (not literally of course) books on Jewish-Polish relations is all very fine, but it will never quite beat the real people expressing their opinions.

By the way, just so people don't get the idea that I'm a Jewophile (whatever that is) this is my first discussion that I am involved in that involves Jews and Poles, generally I am rather critical of Zionists (not to an unreasonable amount though) but my Polish Patriotism actually compels me to... do something (anything) about mending this issue.

-The Two Saddest Nations on Earth... Poles and Jews;
To all those making a fuss about the title, meaning that you don't understand that it's not being used literally, then my only advice is not either learn English or abandon using it completely.
Sire Brenshar   
18 Jul 2010
Genealogy / Polish-Ukranian roots and genes [72]

and start stealing culture and society from asian and muslim cultures. This is why Slavic people are very backward and have copied cultures from the countries around them.

Muslim? You are aware of when Islam began, no?
This is probably the dumbest stuff I have ever read on PF concerning history
Sire Brenshar   
2 Aug 2010
History / Polish history is 100% glorious [297]

I think Polish history is a broken chain of glorious events more;

In many occasions Germans/Ukrainians/Jews/Russians/and other people of all sorts suffered at the hand of Poles.

Seriously Harry, your knowledge of Polish History is terrible, and you should refrain from posting such gross inaccuracies on this forum.

I hate Polonophiles like you, who think that Poland is the chosen nation or something, and I hate even more those who actively preach such things, and thankfully you aren't posting this stuff on other forums.

Do us all a favor, Harry, and learn some real Polish history. You'll find that it is rather glorious, especially compared to nations like England, but you'll also find that it has some blemishes.

Please do not post again until you learn a few things.
Sire Brenshar   
2 Aug 2010
History / Polish history is 100% glorious [297]

No they didn't! Your accusations are nothing but lies told by the entire world apart from Poland in order to besmirch the glorious reputation of Poland! It is all a perfidious Jewish/Communist/British/German/Russian/homosexual/satanist plot!

...

What's your problem? Go back to Sturmfront Harry...

Or take the advice I gave you before.

Mods, can you ban this crazy guy?
Sire Brenshar   
2 Aug 2010
History / Polish history is 100% glorious [297]

he is not playing a game, he provides observations about how some historical events are handled on PF by the Polish posters.
If anything some of the posters are playing a game of a "hit and run".

Yes he is, he is probably the most obvious reason why "some posters" are so "patriotic".
He's looking for reactions and he's certainly getting them too.

Saying that shows that you are either Jewish or a homosexual, or both.

Now was that sarcasm or did he genuinely just assault you there...?

Let us not forget that £ambinowice was swept under the carpet for so long. Oh, the attack on the Czechs was wild and wrong.

Sokrates is the best with his WWII analysis. It just goes to show how different books and direction can lead you 'poles' apart.

Which Czech attack are you referring to?

My greatest sympathy for victims of Poles is mostly the blotched way of dealing with Ruthenians in the VII century and how it eventually helped cause the Deluge, and with the Lithuanians, Czechs, and especially the Ukrainians during the XXth.

Other than that Polish History is rather Glorious.
Sire Brenshar   
2 Aug 2010
History / Polish history is 100% glorious [297]

of course it is Harry's fault that some people are not able to discuss the historic events in Poland in a constructive way. Bad Harry!!!!

Not Harry's fault, but he certainly is a major roadblock in it all. (Perhaps I blamed Harry a bit to strongly in my previous post)

You're a gay Ukrainian Jew? That's as low as sub-humans can get. No wonder you are so jealous of the ubermenschen Poles!

Now you are taking it too far, since no one (except for Sokrates maybe, but that's just his way of getting a point across) has said anything with the equivalent of that.

Hmmm; Harry and Sokrates, I would like to see the two together in their very own personal thread...
Sire Brenshar   
3 Aug 2010
Life / POLISH MYTHS - let's debunk or prove them! [140]

*Polish history is free of blemishes and there are no dark periods in Poland's history as an independent country at all*

Myth.

You and Harry conducting a war?

There is basically only Sokrates who thinks otherwise about what you just posted...
Sire Brenshar   
3 Aug 2010
Life / POLISH MYTHS - let's debunk or prove them! [140]

I've heard the exact opposite...
and having been raised in Canada (sorry) I must say it seems infinitely times better than in North America.

And at any rate, "bad" education in Europe is generally "the best" compared to many other countries.