The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by jon357  

Joined: 15 Mar 2012 / Male ♂
Last Post: 1 hr ago
Threads: Total: 73 / Live: 22 / Archived: 51
Posts: Total: 24817 / Live: 14772 / Archived: 10045
From: In the Heart of Darkness
Speaks Polish?: Tak

Displayed posts: 14794 / page 430 of 494
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Notice how Polonius completely fails to condemn attacks on the independent media.

Screamingly obvious.

Echoes of when PIS were briefly in office before and they sent something close to a SWAT team to arrest Piotr Ikonowicz, also a vocal critic of theirs.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

So the harassment of non-PiS media has already started.

According to the media, the raid wasn't part of any ongoing investigation and just seems like harassment - almost certainly score settling by some PIS mafia person in or near Łódż, probably to do with his political role.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

His identical twin's health was such a concern at one point that there was serious discussion about the precise constitutional mechanism for removing a president from office if they are incapable of fully discharging their duties.

Jaro, being electorally toxic, doesn't hold public office apart from his parliamentary seat (having put in impotent
placeholders as president and premier) so that isn't an issue.

The significant thing is the unseemly scramble for succession among Ziobro etc.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Much as i detest Jarosław Kaczyński, I wish him a (fairly) speedy return to health after last night's medical emergency and drama and hope that his serious health problems will be managed well.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland to return to Catholic tradition? [177]

As even the data from the RCC shows, practising Catholics in Poland are now a small minority

Quite. And for a certain political and cultural tendency in Poland and elsewhere this news 50% confirms their fears that even their God has forsaken them and 50% sends them into a sulking rage.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland to return to Catholic tradition? [177]

While those who support PiS and their whack-a-doodle policies are punished right here on earth.

It's entirely par for the course for that particular brand of ultra-conservatist churchmanship which the supporters of the PiS cult are most often exposed to: austerity right, hedonism wrong; piety right, fun wrong; old right, new wrong; suffering right and "part of God's plan", betterment wrong and "the Devil's work".
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland to return to Catholic tradition? [177]

Nowadays we have less than 5% of the relative number of jews that we had 100 years ago, but still their traditions are more alive than never.

Here in Poland those traditions are barely a shadow of what they once were. Though fortunately they are returning slowly.

has fallen from the high fifties (percent of the population) to the low thirties

Haemorrhaging.

Already a minority sport and increasingly a rural one.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Essentially yes, since the socialist economic model that you admire so much tends to impoverish people in every sense.

Read the article, Po. It's free of hysterical polemicising and analyses the situation in a concise, if rather too restrained, way.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

tremble in fear, PiS, the end is nigh!

It certainly is.

To quote from the excellent article, which is one of the best assessments of the whole awful situation that has so far been published

(that 50-word limit is a drag, especially if there's something really worth posting that's, say, 70 words)

Law and Justice blends the religious and patriotic rituals of Poland's long history of resistance to foreign oppression with hostility to free-market capitalism and heavy dose of conspiracy regarding machinations of Poland's enemies.... supported by sympathetic smaller parties, ultra-Catholic media, nationalist youth organisations and an assortment of cranks and cynics

A quarter of a century after the end of communism, the alleged hold of communists over the Polish state is still being used as a pretext to deploy communist-era methods to take hold of the Polish state.

jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Law and Justice" is a reference neither to law and order nor social justice, but to the idea that the Polish state itself is lawless and unjust. If the state is illegitimate, the normal rules of political behaviour no longer apply.

When an MP from a party supportive of Law and Justice declared in parliament in November that "The good of the nation is above the law," he received a standing ovation from Law and Justice deputies, includin Jarosław Kaczyński.

One of the very best articles I've seen in the foreign press. From an independent source, very well-written and sums it up perfectly...

All the paranoia, the spite, the historical messianism and points out the anomaly that the person who actually runs the country holds no public office apart from being an MP.

Contempt for the rule of law; the identification of a minority faction with the interests of the nation; the separation of power from office by constructing extra-legal chains of command; demonisation of opponents and purges of state structures; an ideological re-interpretation of history: these are all legacies of communist rule.

theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/16/conspiracy-theorists-who-have-taken-over-poland
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

As has been said here before, don't rely too much on that particular poll.

You just don't want to face the fact that PIS are doing very badly and the situation has only worsened.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland to return to Catholic tradition? [177]

Like it or not, such is the teaching of the One, Holy and Apostolic Catholic Church

It isn't anything of the sort.

Though good that you wrote it, since it illustrates the sort of dreary rhetoric that has over the last decade caused the RCC in Poland to haemorrhage weekly communicants. That and the deeply unpopular teaching on family planning.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

That comes across like some PRL-era propagandist talking.

In fact PIS have declined in support and credibility since they were elected and Jaro/Macierewicz half stepped out of their shadows.

The election result is a good one and it does very much look like they'll be repeated country-wide.
jon357   
16 Feb 2016
News / Poland to return to Catholic tradition? [177]

I'd say that you would know Po, since sexual diversity is your favourite subject by far however in fact your knowledge of doctrine is as usual wrong here. That or you're simply trolling.

Focus on the thread, not the posters.
jon357   
15 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Rural voters are clearly not happy with PiS.

Good news and looks like it will be reflected country-wide.

The end of the beginning was a little while ago when they attacked the constitutional court - this is a further step towards the beginning of the end which will of course be the local election disaster.
jon357   
15 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Plus the televangelist TV station and other loss-making enterprises of which he refused to reveal the sources of funding, even at the cost of not getting on the digital platform.
jon357   
15 Feb 2016
News / Poland to return to Catholic tradition? [177]

Freemasonry (a long and rich tradition in Poland, by the way) has no organisational opinion on that or any other religious denomination and is not an 'enemy' of any group whatsoever.

Any hostility traditionally came from the other direction however it was refreshing to see the Vatican appoint a chaplain to one of the Italian grand lodges several years back...
jon357   
15 Feb 2016
Love / Valentines Day & Polish men [130]

@Mafektis, that's a very good point.

Anyway, restaurants struggle enough at this time of year with waiters laid off and a quiet time for restaurant suppliers too so no bad thing at all to have a celebration that involves going out and spending some money on a nice meal to lighten up an already miserable month.
jon357   
15 Feb 2016
Love / Valentines Day & Polish men [130]

" is not native to Poland

Nor are you for that matter, however the fact that a tradition originated elsewhere is not any reason at all to reject it. Dzień Kobiet is an example of an imported festival that is enthusiastically celebrated in Poland. Like Valentine's Day.

Valentine's Day like your "Burns Night" is not native to Poland and so simply slapping it on the calendar

Who has been "simply slapping" anything "on the calendar"?

for Poles to have to put up with it.

The millions of Poles who celebrated Valentine's Day this year looked like they "put up with it" very very happily indeed.

That's OK. It's hard for some people to own up to the truth

Don't worry - one day you'll find your Valentine. Though evidently not this year...
jon357   
14 Feb 2016
Love / Valentines Day & Polish men [130]

enuine love doesn't need a date on the calendar

And winter "doesn't need" a festival with turkey and robins but we all like Christmas. Summer "doesn't need" a vacation, January "doesn't need" Burns Night, Spring "doesn't need" an Easter - people still choose to enjoy special occasions.

Valentine's Day is indeed trotted out as a way to celebrate heterosexual monogamy

Not only - in fact not at all by a long chalk. It's for anyone who is in love and who is loved. edited

So who really benefits

Spoken as only an unhappily single young person could.
jon357   
14 Feb 2016
Love / Valentines Day & Polish men [130]

The only real beneficiaries are florists and restaurants.

Spoken as only someone who is single possibly could.

to collectively express it.

Who "collectively expresses" anything?

Just a nice day to take one's beloved somewhere nice and very very popular in Poland.
jon357   
14 Feb 2016
Love / Valentines Day & Polish men [130]

allowing in tawdry, tacky, tasteless, plastic kitsch

Do you imagine that everybody (or even most people) of the many millions round the world who celebrate Saint Valentine's Day "wallow" in anything?

turned them into hapless. docile consumers of garbage.

The masses always need an opiate. It used to be religion but that's been going out of fashion a for some time now. Still no need to "wallow" in anything, especially not your "plastic kitsch" - there are much nicer ways to celebrate Saint Valentine's Day. And he in Poland, people like Saint Valentine"s Day.

Google the old tradition of "Cockle Bread" - that would be nice to introduce to Poland and fun for the bakers to help the fair damsels mould the roll....
jon357   
14 Feb 2016
Love / Valentines Day & Polish men [130]

yet another tacky, tawdry pop-culture gimmick designed to down-dumb the gullible

In what way is a festival, one older by the way than Poland itself, a "pop culture gimmick". Certainly a very long lasting "gimmick"

rather than broadening their intellectual horizons and enriching their life with genuine cultural values.

So people shouldn't have fun?
jon357   
14 Feb 2016
Love / Valentines Day & Polish men [130]

All days like that are invented and 'alien' even your Easter is imported

Quite. Easter has been celebrated long before Christianity was ever thought up and all traditions have to start somewhere. People like St. Valentine's Day (Halloween too) and no reason at all to avoid them simply because they're growing in popularity rather than waning.
jon357   
5 Feb 2016
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Looks like you don't know too much about stock exchanges. Aside from the fact that very few people outside Poland trade WIG shares, anybody can buy shares on any exchange, including people in Poland who choose to invest in NYSE or LSE traded shares.

fail

A level of inanity entirely normal for PiS supporters.
jon357   
5 Feb 2016
Language / Polish was chosen the HARDEST LANGUAGE in the world to learn... :D [1558]

French keyboard

Very easy on an iPad - all you do is one flick for the keyboard language in question (if you want autocorrect and just press and hold a second for the diacritics.

I am waiting

And you'll be waiting a long long time, boy.
jon357   
5 Feb 2016
Language / Polish was chosen the HARDEST LANGUAGE in the world to learn... :D [1558]

It is as though they cannot stand to hear anyone speaking their language with a 'foreign' accent.

I think it's a mix of unfamiliarity in hearing the language spoken in a different way and a kind of xenophobic nationalism, treating it like a minority ethnic language rather than one spoken by people in 4 or 5 countries. Less common now in the big cities.