The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by jon357  

Joined: 15 Mar 2012 / Male ♂
Last Post: 5 Nov 2025
Threads: Total: 76 / Live: 25 / Archived: 51
Posts: Total: 25286 / Live: 15241 / Archived: 10045
From: Somewhere around Barstow
Speaks Polish?: Not with my mouth full

Displayed posts: 15266 / page 417 of 509
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

oh either you play dumb

This is what you've been doing all day. It seems to come naturally to you.

maybe we use different definitions of what direct democracy is

Evidently you use a different definition of democracy to that of the rest of the free world. If you want a return to a PRL-bis, feel free to advocate for that. Most people very clearly don't.

an interesting electoral strategy given that it's about a third of the Polish workforce who work for some branch of the state.

Remember, they despise employee rights, like anything else that doesn't work in their direct favour, and are actively and openly trying to create a one-party state. Hence the nightly Polish pro-democracy rallies.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Not my job to reconcile this very good (and not manipulated) poll. Remember that many of the thousands coming out every evening to protest the PiS junta's attack on democracy were people who initially voted for them.

But hey, if you prefer a far-right authoritarian theocratic state, no amount of common sense, logic or decency is likely to change that.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

I'm actually in favour of completely direct democracy

So you should be happy with the existing system that the PiS junta desperately want to replace.

I don't see them as an authoritarian force

You're probably the only person who believes that, if you actually do believe that. Everything they say, everything they do is deeply authoritarian.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

the unrestricted hiring and firing of them according to the new law is limited to the intermediary period of 6 months after the introduction of the law

You still fail utterly and spectacularly to get the point of a stable democracy. Why would they even want a period like that, unless they were going to fire any not under their patronage.

then it is going to be regulated

By whom?

a ruling party appoints judge

You're still missing the point. There's a reason that democracies don't do this.

Evidently you dislike the idea of parliamentary democracy and prefer authoritarian one party rule, something Poland once had.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

I understand you don't like these people

Millions don't. Thousands of ordinary people come out on the streets against them nightly.

Ziobro

A sinister and cynical careerist. Do you remember the scandal about the laptop?

that if PiS were to appoint judges

Remember it isn't just appointing. It's hiring and firing by the ruling party directly, thereby placing them under soviet style Party patronage. There's a good reason that democracies have mechanisms whereby this does not happen.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Protest too much?

Far too much. What he's trying to do is transparent. It looks like it could be over for the current regime, and he's trying to present himself as a moderate and more credible (i.e. electable) figure.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

no party in Poland has at the moment a monopole on governing

One is very much trying too manipulate the system to obtain one party rule - the whole point of this discussion is about their blatant attempt at a coup d' etat. Perhaps you've missed that somehow, just as you've somehow missed the thousands attending Polish pro--democracy rallies.

electer (regular judges) and the Supreme Court judge

Neither are directly appointed nor can be arbitrarily dismissed by the Party of the day. Something else you've missed.

this led to many scandals and unfair rulings

I'm sure that even you don't think that judges who depend on the patronage of the screamer Kaczynski, the deranged Macierewicz or the sinister Ziobro are likely to be less rather than more scandalous and unfair

Which is why thousands are turning out on the streets each evening, and why 87% of Poles are concerned that democracy is being eroded.

You have no valid argument here, none at all.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

completely without any democratic control

Evidently you prefer Party control, just like the old days...

Fortunately most people prefer an independent judiciary, hence 87% of people in Poland expressing their concern about the erosion of democracy this week
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Pawłowicz would better fit in the rumpus-raisers' faction where there are many more of her kind -- brash, pushy, screechy, tasteless and lacking in class

That's exactly where she is. A member of parliament and part of the PiS junta
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

he will introduce the law that will put those MP's who voted for the PiS Supreme Court bill for 5 years in prison

And there was me thinking that PiS supporters enjoyed the idea of parliament controlling legal process...

It would be interesting to see their own 'principles' turned back on them...
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Pawłowicz is not holding favours of Kaczyński

Utterly and absolutely irrelevant. When a member of parliament in that party(one of the best known and most widely loathed ones) says that they're going after journalists, people should (and do) take that very seriously indeed.

Whenever lame 'arguments' you use to try to dodge out of that.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Pawłowicz is not the one setting tone

What a pathetic, weasly, silly little answer. So you're trying to deny she's one of their best known politicians.

When someone with her role in the party, a very prominent member of parliament, stands up and talks about going after journalists, people should be very worried.

And they are. The latest survey shows that 87% of people in Poland believe democracy is seriously threatened at the moment.
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

I don't see a slightest hint of PiS controlling the private media

Looks like you prefer to ignore the vile Pawlowicz's idea to go after journalists next...
jon357   
21 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

By the way what is this Duda playing at?

Listening to people and doing his job.

That and trying to stop the current crisis from escalating further.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

bias or poor understanding of the Polish reality

I suspect those thousands of Poles taking part in the vigils etc tonight have a clearer and more up-to-date understanding of Polish reality than someone who emigrated to a different continent almost 30 years ago.

sad

The PiS junta and their supporters are weeping tonight too. The tipping point has been passed and it will never get better or easier for them.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

I'm sure the political discourse is suitably elevated by these iterations of your eloquence, however yes, it's a Chain of Light. A very big thing, and apparently the PiS junta hierarchy are absolutely dismayed at the moment and arguing with each other behind the scenes.

This could be getting very interesting soon, or indeed very 'nieciekawy for PiS...
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

I just saw a film clip of the Chain of Light in Katowice. It stretches right through the city. Impressive and poignant.

over 80 criminal hearing against Ziobro?

kaminski to 5 years in prison for maladministration "offence"

Decisions of the prosecutor and courts. The real, independent ones. Not show-trials in a one party state.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

How on earth do you think that putting the court system under the direct control of a political party is a good idea?

Indeed. No party stays in power for long, and they may well find that their opponents will one day use it against the, In every way a bad idea,

under control of people.

Read up on the concept of parliamentary democracy and an independent judiciary.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

I doubt that somehow. All the reports say they're seriously worried by the scale of opposition to their proposal, as well as the international response.

The protests this evening in Warsaw were huge, this week each one has been larger than the last. It could well be turning into a Warsaw Spring.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

This is today's Polish pro-democracy protest in the centre of Warsaw. A crowd as far as the eye can see.

using security agencies

What do you think the PiS junta are doing right this minute...


  • 20155587_87039162313.jpg
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

hows that for free press?

A hell of a lot freer than now. Have you actully watched the news on TVPiS? About as impartial as North Korea.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

The Polish pro-democracy vigils are happening right now around Poland, plenty of people out on the street, all very civilised and decent.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

PO and N Representatives should be in jail awaiting a trial for treason n

There would needed to be grounds for that. Having a different point of view to yours is not grounds.

as I said Polish is more emotional than English,

Only if the speaker is, like Kaczynski, deranged.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

a nice punch-up, tonight, maybe spiced up with a little bloodshed

The opposite of the dignified vigils organised by the Polish pro-democracy movement. Though doubtless some of the organization and groups praised by Kaczynski and Macierewicz would like a good scrap.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

No doubt that will drive First Secretary Kaczynski even further round the bend.

Is that even possible? He's far enough round it now.

nobody but First Secretary Kaczynski will ever again be allowed to win elections in the PiSlamic State

This is of course what he dreams of. Of course, when another party gets in, the 'reforms' will be used against his clique.

The Chain of Light tonight will be particularly impressive.
jon357   
20 Jul 2017
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

In other words PiS was lying about the economy being 'w ruinie'...

Of course. They are predicated on hysteria and negativity.

And once again, people are out on the streets to oppose their anti-democratic acts.