The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by mafketis  

Joined: 31 Mar 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 1 day ago
Threads: Total: 43 / Live: 23 / Archived: 20
Posts: Total: 11927 / Live: 7225 / Archived: 4702
From: tez nie
Speaks Polish?: tak
Interests: tez nie

Displayed posts: 7248 / page 150 of 242
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
mafketis   
21 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

graffiti such as " to lgbt" (this lgbt)

More like "this is lgbt" (referring to the candidate - or maybe 'he's a fag')

a fully Christian country where nobody is discriminated.

"discriminated against" is the correct form

In general, I think that gay rights are a wonderful civilizational advance (recognizing that non-conformists have a place in and can contribute to society as well).

That said, there are aspects of some fringe lgbt issues that I'm not comfortable with but it's impossible to discuss here because most people can only argue with empty slogans and not with ideas.

I'm not okay with drag queen story hours (which several sexual offenders have taken part in...) Drag is entertainment for adults not children.

I'm not okay with the current transgender movement (which is incredibly regressive and/or insane).

I'm not okay with legalizing polyamory situations

I'm not okay with normalizing the sexualization of children (not just a lgbt issue - some of the worst offenders are heterosexual men sexualizing pre-pubescent girls or even worse the girls' mothers)

LGBT issues were only a kind of sideshow in the recent election, which should have been a home run for PiS but even with the entire state mechanism openly campaigning for Duda (in a really unprecedented way) it was a squeaker. Not a good long term prognosis for the health of PiS (which has no chance in h3ll of surviving JK.
mafketis   
20 Jul 2020
Food / Origin of the pierogi [127]

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_Hedge

zero hedge isn't that bad, judgement is needed on the part of readers but it's accuracy rate easily matches or exceeds that of laughably bad newspapers like the New York Times (propaganda shadow of its former self) or the Graundian...

Reading only sites approved of by twitter and facebook is a recipe for brain rot and duck speech....

Please stick to the topic
mafketis   
19 Jul 2020
Food / Origin of the pierogi [127]

when does the noble pierogi stop being pierogi?

When did ramen stop being ramen?

a.allegroimg.com/s1024/0c8c36/d625b4d047388200605fce0304f2
mafketis   
19 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

As our resident malignant narcissist points out.... his brand of..... Christianity apparently does not disapprove of domestic violence as long as the victim is prevented from leaving the marriage. In fact he appears to find sex with victims of violence to be "the best"....

The cultural issues that PiS is supposedly worried about are not in the convention so withdrawing from it is symbolic support of normalizing violence in the name of tradition.
mafketis   
19 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

I guess the contentious thing is

PiS trying to rile you up and make you angry so that you don't notice how they're wrecking everything....

Even if domestic violence rates are low in Poland, authoritarian governments like to do what they can to normalize violence at all levels of society so that people accept violent government oppression as just the way things work, Putin and Erdogan (who also resist anything trying to limit domestic violence) are good examples.
mafketis   
18 Jul 2020
Work / Medical jobs in Poland? [12]


All of those require years of study and fluent Polish...
mafketis   
18 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Another play from the authoritarian playbook..... normalize domestic violence (de facto defend it on grounds of 'tradition' or 'family values' or 'culture' or 'religion')

PiS wants to withdraw from the Istanbul convention because domestic violence is apparently a key part of Polish culture....

kobieta.onet.pl/polska-wypowie-konwencje-stambulska-minister-rodziny-przygotowujemy-sie-do-tego/7jcnrm2
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

repolonisation of the media was raised since the start of PiS rule and nothing materialized

Yes, let's hope they're lying and konfederacja going off on Georgette is their own suicide mission and not part of another catastrophic PiS plan....
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
Language / Polish opinions on foreign languages? [54]

They had been brainwashed by communism

The way he put it, they went from the kaiser to the fuehrer to communism....

Also the ones he was dealing with were not creme de la creme.... they were long-term unemployed in a training course to try to improve their chances of getting a job.... he said about a third were okay and he could see them succeeding another third.. maybe and the last third was just hopeless, not stupid as such but uninterested in taking any kind of control of their life and uninterested in anything more than two meters away...

And to be fair I've known some East Germans who were perfectly fine people... but I can imagine the dregs there are pretty bad....
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

. This is one of the most favorite excuses of all the loonies or all the autocrats or all the dictators

As I outlined in #3931, this is a standard political play....

Viva Georgette! Viva independent media! Viva scrutiny and investigation of governmental operations!
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

minor dispute over a clumsy diplomat

The dispute is over Poland crapping over US political values... Georgette is just making US policy clear (and that won't change if she is removed - which I don't see happening unless Trump loses).
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

Military and economic connection between the US and Poland is more important than some minor issues

There will be no military and economic connection between the US and Poland if Poland is hostile to American capital and a free and independent press.
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

press doesn't really matter in Poland

Do you think PiS wants to stop with print media? Their main mission is to remove that pesky tvn24 full of reporters that don't answer to them.... That's why Georgette is getting involved, a Polish government that's hostile to American business is not a good or reliable ally....
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
Language / Polish opinions on foreign languages? [54]

Nope (I visited Dresden)

I've heard that Germans from the former DDR are a lot less friendly and outgoing than those from West Germany... I had a non-Polish friend who had a gig teaching in Frankfurt/Oder and while he really liked a lot about Germany he couldn't stand most East Germans... (he used the term "Scheiß fickende" a lot when talking about them....
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

the issues are related - you need to shut down the independent press before you can safely start locking people up for expressing the wrong views in public...
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

any meaningful signs from the real reality

It's a standard set of moves in the political playbook

1-Claim that "foreign" (or Jewish or socialist or church) influence in media is too strong and is hurting the nation

2-Force sales to "patriotic" publishers (ie party cronies)

3-Scrutiny of government actions and criticism of government disappears from media

4-Let the plundering begin/continue unimpeded by prying eyes....

If step number 1 doesn't set off alarm bells then you have no idea how politics works in the real world and nothing you say can possibly be of any value.
mafketis   
17 Jul 2020
History / Poland must get back Lwow, Wilno and Brest back [345]

an overwhelming sense that only PiS actually bother with them

Which is kind of true.... a consistent problem with PO was that they couldn't even pretend to care about the working or rural classes... while PiS is good at PRL style 'send a minor dignitary to make 'em think we care' style gestures.

That's one reason I had high hopes for double K but he took the high road (which seldom pays off in politics).
mafketis   
16 Jul 2020
History / Poland must get back Lwow, Wilno and Brest back [345]

He denounced his Polish citizenship

denounced or renounced? And usually citizenship (especially when it was renounced for no longer reigning political conditions) can be regained if a person wants it...
mafketis   
16 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

5 more years of Duda seem too much.

It depends on whether PiS can avoid early elections. There are a lot of signs that it's splintering (it's largely made up of factions that hate each other).

If JK becomes to weak to enforce discipline then all bets are off....
mafketis   
15 Jul 2020
History / Poland must get back Lwow, Wilno and Brest back [345]

what you mean here can you explain, are you talking about past Polish history

Conservatives are always trying to reshape their country according to a fantasy schema that never really existed*, Progressives are always trying to pave the way for a future that can never exist.

I'm a realist, a country has to deal with the past it actually has (as the past and not something to endlessly obsess over and try to correct) and has to deal with the present as it actually is (and not some fantasy about what it might have been had the past been different) in order to prepare for a future that's possible.

*The first PiS government was trying to recreate a fantasy version of the interwar republic (as they imagined it might have been). The current PiS government is more about recreating the PRL with nationalist and religious slogans instead of communism. Both are dead ends.

Progressives are equally misguided but have no power in the current set up...
mafketis   
15 Jul 2020
History / Poland must get back Lwow, Wilno and Brest back [345]

, i'm sure if personal circumstances were different ironside would have wanted to stay with his extended family in Polan

what's stopping him now?

you are not Polish is that correct ?,

No, I'm not. I'm American (ancestry mostly German with some Irish, Greek, maybe American Indian, maybe some other stuff). But, I've chosen to live in Poland for a very significant chunk of my life and I don't regret it. And I'm not trying to turn the country into some past fantasy...
mafketis   
15 Jul 2020
News / Poland's post-election political scene [4080]

not realising countries like ours can`t stay alone coz sooner or later they are swallowed by more aggressive neighbours.

No country can really stand alone in the modern world, it's only a question of who your allies are. And I'm afraid Konfederacja idiots think Russia would be a good ally (based on their similar authoritarian leanings).

In terms of Mosbacher, her spirited defense of a free press is in direct conflict with the PiS desire to criminalize criticism (or scrutiny). Again, straight from the PRL playbook.
mafketis   
15 Jul 2020
History / Poland must get back Lwow, Wilno and Brest back [345]

he was able to run a casual phone conversation in English

I'm not entirely sure.... I think he was listening to words and trying to cobble together what it could be about rather than actually understanding.

(a common strategy in the non-advanced, I've done it myself)

I'm sure Ironside is disappointed though... no Lviv for him!
mafketis   
15 Jul 2020
News / Presidential elections 2020 - your opinions about campaign, candidates [2222]

Far right ideals are not going to move Poland forward. They will crash and burn as they always have

And right on time... Konfederacja wants the government to declare Georgette Mosbacher persona non grata and for her to be replaced... Is this something they think will work or that most Poles will support?

Or maybe.... they're being used by PiS as informal bad cops?

onet.pl/informacje/onetwiadomosci/konfederacja-domaga-sie-uznania-ambasador-mosbacher-za-persona-non-grata/lgtr6kh,79cfc278