The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by jon357  

Joined: 15 Mar 2012 / Male ♂
Last Post: 5 Nov 2025
Threads: Total: 76 / Live: 25 / Archived: 51
Posts: Total: 25286 / Live: 15241 / Archived: 10045
From: Somewhere around Barstow
Speaks Polish?: Not with my mouth full

Displayed posts: 15266 / page 101 of 509
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
jon357   
8 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

This one looks like a guy in the ring.

So does Jane Crouch, also a championship boxer. As far as I know, nobody's ever questioned her gender.

I actually watch women's boxing sometimes; a friend is a big boxing fan and subscribes to a TV channel that only shows it. Most female boexrs look a bit like blokes.

It's a shame she's been dragged into the terf/trans issue since she's personally neither.

And of course it's nothing about sport; it's simply transphobia.
jon357   
8 Sep 2024
Food / Bigos Recipe [183]

The American "opinion" is irrelevant

If you look, you'll see that the opinion in question is about the English language rather than Polish food.

I'd agree, stew isn't a particularly accurate description in English and in fact it doesn't need translating any more than pierogi or pizza. Bigos is bigos and to translate it as "hunters' stew" gives a misleading impression of the dish.
jon357   
8 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Who you gonna believe

A test.

If the IOC who are experts in sporting matters (and who don't have a vested interest in stoking controversy) are satisfied that she's a natural born female, and someone like Joanne Rowling (who very much does have a vested interest,) says otherwise, who is more believable?

was actually investigated by the International Boxing Association

She wasn't "investigated" at all and the r*SSian backed IBA have since admitted this. The matter is covered in post 608.

If you're getting all hot and bothered about an issue, it's good to check the actual facts before posting. So far you've said she's both been tested and not tested, and now you're saying that she's been investigated by a spurious organisation who have admitted that she hasn't been investigated by them.

Let's face it, you hate trans people so much that you're hating on someone who isn't trans but who you think looks trans.
jon357   
8 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

I doubt she'd bother. She's too busy training for the sport in which she's finally excelling after years of practice.

As I say, best wait for the test results.
jon357   
8 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

there really really aren't

There are. It's more common than you think.

Nobody with XY menstruates or gets pregnant.

Really??


  • IMG_0815.jpeg
jon357   
8 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

You mean the female boxer, since there's no evidence that she's anything other than female.

There are certainly women with XY however they menstruate providing they have oestrogen supplements and can conceive and give birth naturally. Most don't have any significant difference in muscle mass or bone structure.

There is no evidence however that Imane is that type of woman.

It would be an issue if she were XXX or XXXX however superfemales (like most XYY and XYYY supermales) if they do competitive sport at all would be in the Paralympics due to associated cognitive disorders.

Let's wait until the next stage and see what the results of her tests are.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Joanne Rowling?

No, she's still female as far as anyone knows. Then again, she's certainly not had the years of regular medical monitoring that high-level sportswomen like Imane have so who knows? Has she been tested?
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Let's see.

There will doubtless be tests. You never know, the results may differ radically from all the other medical and fitness monitoring that she has as a top level sportswoman.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

But I don't think you know them either.

Why?

Why are you so anxious to see women's sports destroyed anyway

Don't be silly. She's a woman.

Anyway, let's wait for the trial and the inevitable independent tests.


  • IMG_08142.jpeg
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

butch' women you know will look

Know them, do you?

She's certainly a woman, registered as female at birth and who as a professional sportswoman at a high level has had more physical and medical tests in her life so far than anyone reading this.

As I say, let's wait for the next stage in her lawsuit. Joannne Rowling has already backed down and deleted the deliberately offensive statements she made online.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Yes. I don't think we'll reach common ground, so let's agree to disagree.

She's certainly a woman though and there will doubtless be a lot of coverage of the legal case.

This just shows that the gender binary is something of an illusion and that perhaps the male/female split isn't as rigid as some would like to think.

That is no kind of woman. Anyone can see that.

I see a woman not a man. A butch one, however I personally know even butcher women, some of whom have given birth.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

As a male with an intersex condition

She isn't. Unless you know something the International Olympic Committee don't.

not a complete man" does not equal " woman"

She isn't any sort of man though, is she, and never has been.

And of course, you claim she "refused tests" so how would anyone know?

It's best to wait for the next stages of the legal process she's launched. They will certainly require full state-supervised testing an£ will settle the matter.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

No, Imane is a she. She has a vagina and is a woman.

And yes, Joanne R has backed down and removed her comments from the internet.

And if she, as you suggest, has "refused tests" how do you know she's not female?
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

He is a male with an intersex condition

How do you know she's that?

And if she "won't do tests", how would anyone know?

That is why he won't sue JKR.

She has an open case against Elon Musk and Joanne Rowling (who has backed down on her controversial comments).
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

a bloke. Anyone can see tha

The doctors who assigned her female at birth didn't "see" any such thing and nor did the IOC doctors who tested her.

admitted that he has a " chromosome problem ".

You mean she, and is this an official est or hearsay.

Anyway, tests will be done for the legal case. Speculation beforehand is unhelpful.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Big and strong women have always existed

That's what she evidently is.

Anyway, given that there's now both criminal and civil cases against Elon Musk, Joanne Rowling and others, doubtless there'll be full independent medical tests as part of the evidence which will confirm or deny any speculation.

About her jawline, it doesn't look especially male to me. I'm "finely tuned" ,to differences as well and I wouldn't shag her since she's very obviously not a bloke.

Where were they before then in women competitions?

Always there, however the internet wasn't ablaze with it all.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

She is bigger, heavier, broader

So a woman can't be "big, heavy and broad" then?

Can they only look like 17 year old ballerinas or anorexic catwalk models?

has a longer reach (especially deadly in contact sports)...more muscles

I used to live across the road from a farm. The farmer's daughter when she was a teen once lifted a calf from a well it had fallen in. She had really broad shoulders and huge muscles like Desperate Dan. She's now got 3 kids and several grandkids, Does her strength and bulk make her a man in your opinion?
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Imane is not a woman

What makes you think that?

Why are you so keen on men battering women being made into an official sport? Mm?

That's a daft comment.

Anyway, given that she's lost matches plenty of times, by your 'logic', those fights she lost must be women "battering" men.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Women sports was introduced mainly to give women better ........physical differences between men and women.

And since she's female what's the problem?

If "she"

You mean she, rather than "she". Imane is a woman and always has been.

Khelif has XY chromosomes

And 'the likes of' you know this how exactly? Do you know something that the IOC don't?
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

That just goes to show that the gender binary isn't straightforward and that people like Joanne Rowling are wrong.

The IOC have done the normal medical tests and there's no suggestion that she has male chromosomes or an elevated testosterone level. She's just a somewhat (she only weighs 66kg) sporty looking and flat-chested woman but in fact isn't that masculine at all compared to some you can pass in the street every day.

She can't do right for doing wrong, They didn't want her to box in Algeria because she's female and lowlife like Rowling say she shouldn't box in the Olympics because she doesn't look female enough. Not all women are girly looking.


  • IMG_0812.png
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Why did I hear about it only now???

As Alien says, it's fake news.

r*SSia is behind the whole gender controversy about the female boxers Imane Khelif and Lin Yu-Ting. The false suggestion that they weren't female originated with a now discredited r*SSian sponsored organisation bankrolled by Gazprom which is now expelled from the Olympic family.

It originated a year or so ago because they'd both beaten heavily-seeded r*SSian boxers that various r*SSian gangsters and oligarchs had gambled millions on and the dodgy organisation in question voided their results so the orcs got their cash payouts. They first suggested that they'd failed sex tests done by WADA (who don't do sex tests) and have since admitted that no tests had been run.

And of course r*SSia like to sow discontent and controversy in the free world and are bitter that they can't compete in major sporting events so try to rubbish them.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Life / Warsaw - what's there to love? Semi-livable city? [42]

Such monuments are impossible in the US due to American bigotry and political correctness

Didn't the PiSflappers put a fig leaf on that statue in Gdańsk? The one near Dwór Artusa.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
History / Should Poland organize March of the Living in Volhynia and Eastern Lesser Poland? [65]

A good propagandist, has to be able to produce such content which will convince the widest cross section of society

I doubt most orc trolls are that organised; most are just office monkeys with a budget thrown at their bosses, a list of websites/newspaper subscriptions and a daily position to push.

The ones who write the long turgid essays on Quora are among the funniest. In the newspaper I read, it must be pretty miserable for them since they always get spotted plus it's the newspaper of choice for serving and former army officers who really do know their stuff. That and their generally well educated readership some of whom (like me) write and mark language exams for a living and have studied textual analysis to an extent where it's usually possible to know if someone's male or female, sometimes old or young and sometimes (but only rarely) even tall/short/fat/thin.

And there's also a presence of paid and officially "counter trolls" who run rings round them.

When you make comments to them like "don't let your supervisor see those howling mistakes or you'll be unemployed and back selling your body to old Chechens in hotel bars by Monday", you can sometimes almost see Svetlana's or Natasha's tears dripping onto the keyboard. And they have to go through 6 or 7 hours of this at a time before they go home. The A2/B1 level female orcettes never last long.

And of course a lot of it isn't intended to propagate a view; it's often for the home market ("look what Belgians are saying, they all know we'll win and are scared").
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
History / Should Poland organize March of the Living in Volhynia and Eastern Lesser Poland? [65]

a professional Kremlin troll somewhere else.

His English is far better than most of them.

I take a delight in going through the comments in a particular newspaper's comments field made by people with names like John Smith and pointing out the obvious transference errors from a Slavonic language and giving a CEFR level to their writing. Most are B2 however I've seen as low as A2.

One guy (I'd guess a low C1 but certainly over 65) started arguing about a grammar transference error and hilariously quoted from an old grammar book that was only ever used in the Soviet Union!

On some of the higher traffic sites, all the orcs appear together at about 5 past the hour, take their coffee/vodka breaks at the same time and clock off shift at the same time. It's great fun baiting them and even better when they end up quietly admitting that they're orc paid trolls.

The ones who are outsourced staff in India are pretty easy to spot too.
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Random Sports News [855]

Why would it be?

They're quite religious there. Why would they ask God to save someone who died two years ago?
jon357   
7 Sep 2024
Off-Topic / Nobel Prize and Oscars = Propaganda? [61]

there are more factors than men

What are those factors though?

Modern society

Rape and harassment of women are far from being solely modern.