joepilsudski
30 Sep 2008
Life / 'The Pianist' - the movie. What's your opinion? Polanski [59]
Yes, what?...It was only a movie, and a movie maker, in this case Polanski, often takes certain liberties with the written work the movie is based on...and remember: Polanski has some first hand experience with death, as his wife Sharon Tate, preganant at the time, was brutually murdered by Charles Manson's witches.
I don't see this at all...Have you ever experienced sudden violence, or sudden catastrophe?...What happens to the person exposed to this is simple: they go into shock: I say this from first hand experience...Even trained military personel go through this....As far as losing his 'Polish minions', you degrade those Poles who helped him out of basic goodness...Also, Szpilmann lost his whole family suddenly...In the blink of an eye: One day life is relatively normal, even with the wickedness all around...then the wickedness strikes YOU, and everyone closest to you is gone, DEAD, never to be seen again...Think about that.
What am I driving at with all this?
Yes, what?...It was only a movie, and a movie maker, in this case Polanski, often takes certain liberties with the written work the movie is based on...and remember: Polanski has some first hand experience with death, as his wife Sharon Tate, preganant at the time, was brutually murdered by Charles Manson's witches.
The Warsaw Uprising is shown as just another annoying nuisance to our poor hero, who loses contact with his useful Polish minions and thus is left to his own devices, the poor thing
I don't see this at all...Have you ever experienced sudden violence, or sudden catastrophe?...What happens to the person exposed to this is simple: they go into shock: I say this from first hand experience...Even trained military personel go through this....As far as losing his 'Polish minions', you degrade those Poles who helped him out of basic goodness...Also, Szpilmann lost his whole family suddenly...In the blink of an eye: One day life is relatively normal, even with the wickedness all around...then the wickedness strikes YOU, and everyone closest to you is gone, DEAD, never to be seen again...Think about that.