The BEST Guide to POLAND
Unanswered  |  Archives [3] 
  
Account: Guest

Posts by Lexie0987  

Joined: 4 May 2011 / Female ♀
Last Post: 8 Jul 2011
Threads: Total: 1 / Live: 0 / Archived: 1
Posts: 4
From: America, New York
Speaks Polish?: I'm learning it.

Displayed posts: 4
sort: Oldest first   Latest first   |
Lexie0987   
5 May 2011
Language / Polish was chosen the HARDEST LANGUAGE in the world to learn... :D [1558]

If you're a foreigner and you managed to achieve even a basic fluency in Polish
then you must be some kind of a linguistic genius (unless you come from a Slavic
country).

Not really. If you listen to native Polish speakers and how they pronounce words, you will start to get a sense of how to say the words. If fact, many Polish words are not difficult for a native English speaker to pronounce, namely:

Problem [problem]
Kot [cat]
Lampa [lamp]
Katedra [cathedral]
Okno [window]
Radio [radio]
Telefon [telephone]
Komputer [computer]
Mama [Mom]
Tato [Dad]
Brat [Father]
Numer [number]
Dokument [Document]
Mapa [Number]
Plan [Plan]
Dom [house]
bilet [Ticket]

Also, the consonants are very similar to English consonants. So, the pronunciation shouldn't be too difficult for the English speaker. The vowels and that strange trilled "r" could be difficult, although I'm told that some Poles pronounce it like the French "r."

I'm currently studying the language now, and I do not see what is so challenging about the language besides the word order. You have to understand that Polish is a reflexive language, meaning that the word order is more flexible than in English. I find that I can but the verb in front of the noun, something I can't do in English because of its stringent word order. For example, Mówi Maria, or Maria Mówi.

And another thing. Polish and English are both in the Indo-European system of languages, so there are many traits that they both share.

Wish I could go into this more, but I have some Polish to learn. Gotta go, or as the Poles say, Muszę już iść
Lexie0987   
5 May 2011
Language / Polish was chosen the HARDEST LANGUAGE in the world to learn... :D [1558]

It strikes a nerve with me when people talk crap like this because I went through years of torture learning Polish grammar and know the difficulties involved. I'd love to hear you speak Polish Lexie, we'll see just how challenging this language really is.

I have some concept, but it is a work in process for me as I just started learning the language.

It strikes a nerve with me when people talk crap like this because I went through years of torture learning Polish grammar and know the difficulties involved. I'd love to hear you speak Polish Lexie, we'll see just how challenging this language really is.

You misunderstand me, Fuzzywickets. I didn't write my post to state that Polish isn't difficult or that people who find it difficult are idiots or mentally slow, quite the reverse. Polish IS a difficult language, and I see that even though I've just started the language three weeks ago. The cases, the conjugations, etc, etc are very daunting and as I am currently struggling to master the language. (See my post on imperative/ conditional) My post was meant to suggest that you don't have to be a genius to learn how to speak or understand Polish. In fact, the person I was responding to suggested that it was impossible to learn it, which I find a ridiculous statement.

I can feel your pain, Fuzzywickets. I really do. The word order is baffling to me, but that doesn't have to stop me from learning the language. It's all about motivation, as someone else on here mentioned.

For one, I counted 3 mistakes in your list.

I've noted them. I wrote them in a hurry.
Lexie0987   
8 Jul 2011
Language / Why is the Polish language so difficult? [309]

Much of the complexity and subtlety of Polish comes from its grammatical structure

Your post reminds me of an American literature class I took in graduate school. We had to read William Faulkner's "The Bear" and "The Jail," two "short" stories that will make your mind spin. If you ever get a chance to read "The Bear," you will notice that there is one sentence that takes up five pages and is the longest sentence in American literature. (He will later top his own record in "The Jail," written three years after "Go Down Moses.") I think Faulkner is an exception because the subtlety of his work comes from his narrow usage of vocabulary and the complexity of his sentences. So, it can be done in English.

I just think Polish grammar is very, very tricky to the non-Polish speaking world. I would love to learn Polish, but I just don't understand the word order. There has to be some books out there on Polish sentence word order, there has to be.