History / History of Poland before, during and after World War II [16]


Calm down i dont think he realised its derogatory.


Try Norman Davies.

News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]


Peter that is of course incorrect, what is correct however is that Jews turned en masse towards the Soviets and that NKVD units involved in singling out and disposing off Polish target groups were uniformly consisting of local recently Polish - Jews.

The vast majority of Polish-Jewish society was passively supporting Russians, a minority decided to volunteer for the dirty work, this alone shows the validity of my issue with Jewish loyality.

If there were more than a handful of Jews in Poland i'd myself work actively towards some sort of a verification action, having Jews who do not feel Polish as citizens of Poland has proven to be dangerous and damaging in the past thats why if there were more of them they'd deserve special attention in the present.

As it is there's so few of them that they're non factor and they can believe whatever they want, they're not a socially relevant minority anymore.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


No one is disagreeing, however we are saying that Soviets murdered Home Army soldiers that they found, both those that crossed the river and those already present on the other side.

Harry is the one who invented Vistula tunnels:)

News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]


Actually they do! :D

News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]


Have you ever read "Forum Żydów Polskich"? These people message each other in private to establish a common strategy in discussions about polish anti-semitism.

There's also comments like "i'm a relgious Jewess i'd never marry a catholic", lovely little place where polish jews get together.


I'm talking about learning from history, its always good to learn on your own mistakes, history shows that treating Jews as Poles was a mistake, the minute they got a chance there was a mass turncoat movement in which they allied themselves with Stalins Russia.


Not really, it all boils down to what you believe in, if a Jew feels he is Polish and is ready to declare "Poland is my country and none other above it" Israel included, than in my eyes he's as Polish as you can get.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


4:55 To the east Soviets were doing the same ( on shooting Poles ) please pay attention or was the english too difficult?:)

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


233 sorties? Thats nothing both in terms of supplies and flights, 4000 containers? In terms of both RAF capability to supply and the demands thats token support, just about enough to say "we did help" but nowhere near the amount required or even noticeable.

So yeah Allies did not help except for a token symbolic support.

Also nice for you to come forth with a number, i knew it but i wanted you yourself to dispel those magical "hundreds":)

News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]


Ask them

Thats why Jews should undergo simple national verification after which they would be listed as Polish-Jews or simply Polish citizens, i dont really care what you were born but what you believe in, we also have to take our history into account, Jewish betreyal of their Polish co-citizens gives food for thought about differences between Jewish citizenship and Jewish nationality.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


You mean Home Army?:)


Could you please post a link to those hundreds of USAAF flights? I know that some random flights by Polish volunteers from RAF were done as well as a token few flights by RAF but these were if anything purely symbolic in proportion.

News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]


Jewishness is a matter of religion however their faith see's Israel as their holy land and perceives every Jew as its citizen even if only in spiritual way also nationality and citizenship are different matters, citizenship is a question of international law, nationality is the question of spiritual and cultural self indentification, based on that Jews that feel connection to Israel cannot be considered Poles.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


Excuse me but what are you talking about right now? I believe we've made it clear that the only tunnels were the sewers under Warsaw, the polish Home Army had no business in crossing the river either since the fight was on their side.


Temper Harry, you may not like me, i certainly dont like you but we can still pretend to be civil for the benefit of others:)

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


And where did Celinski write that there were tunnels under Vistula? He just said tunnels aka sewers and Poles were indeed evacuating via the sewers, i'm not responsible for what you invent in your own mind though:)

News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]


Leading on from you not knowing what the hell you're writing about, religion does not define nationality.


Neither does race, Jews are a peculiar phenomenon in that they're a nation beyond the borders of their own country, therefore one needs to declare himself whether he's a Jew with Polish citizenship or a Pole with Jewish roots.

You cant be both Pole and German for example, yes you can have two citizenship but there's still one nation you'll have to choose.

News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]

You're either a Jew with Polish citizenship or a Pole with Jewish ancestry, you cannot be a Jew and a Pole at the same time, luckily knowing our right wingers these books wont last more than a year or two:)

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


Yes against the orders of the high command.


No they were not, they made it through and joined the AK units, the second wave was stopped and failed to establish the bridgehead because Russians would not provide fire support and forbade polish artillery to do so.


He meant sewers, and crossing Vistula would be pathetically easy for the Red Army, they had such number of artillery they could shield their engineers without any effort.


As i read your posts i realise that you're either covertly anti-polish or simply severely uneducated, the so called "liason officers" were dropped either to direct the movements of communist partisants or to make contact with AK units so they could later be easily identified for pacification, Russia provided no organised support for AK and no support in any form at Warsaw, they were just another invading enemy army.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


Killing not exterminating, Russians were murdering people who'd they view as obstacle, Germans would just kill everyone so there is a difference but that still doesnt mean we owe Russia anything but a middle finger as far as WW 2 is concerned.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]

They've liberated it from Germans and lets face it German plans for Poles were rather gruesome, we'd be exterminated so Russia did save us from genocide and degradation but their alternative was no rose and candy either so russian veterans can kiss my ass as far as respect and gratitude.

Yes it was Stalins doing but they served him and mark you they personally couldnt care a broken penny for Polish independence and simple human freedoms.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


Yes they were.


They've liberated Poland yes but the way they did it and what USSR did afterwards denies them any claim to gratitude or respect, at least from the countries that became the later "Warsaw Pact".

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]


Boooyah! Our soldiers were heroes!! Do not underastimate the power of the soviet troopers running through a minefield to heroically clear it!

Most of them actually swallow that crap so they'll just pat the guy who came up with it on the back.

History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]

Russia strenghtens its reputation as a civilized state:)

News / Most important invention made in Poland [53]

Women.

News / How many prisons are there in Poland? [9]


Not really, i'd say its OK.

History / UPA barbarian murders on Polish and Jewish neighbors during WW2 [150]

Of course not but developing a plausibly cynical and hypocritical line of thought that puts blame on everyone but Poles takes time.

History / UPA barbarian murders on Polish and Jewish neighbors during WW2 [150]


You should, its your fault by association.

Love / Whose Life is it? Polish girlfriend under family "house arrest" [224]


Oh come on its not like we're going to mug him...oh wait.


Bollocks, our agressive bums are the same as agressive bums everywhere, the fact is though that the if he goes to Poland the girl will get honest with him and i imagine her getting honest would involve "its really best if you forgot me" or something like that.

Love / Whose Life is it? Polish girlfriend under family "house arrest" [224]


You know it really hurts me to praise Justyna for anything after her absolutely moronic comments about polish men but she gave you some good advice.


Take that to your heart, the best option is that the girl is using her family and her partner as a means to dump you, the worse option is that she's a spoiled little cunt who has her relationship back home but enjoys your concern or attention, one way or the other the situation is her doing and her family and ex have very little to do with it, i wouldnt be suprised if atm they're all laughing at you.

Love / In love with polish cleaning woman, but don't speak an OUNCE of polish :( [57]

Infidelity is inherently human and there's nothing not to like about it, its about you not having a good shot with the woman.

Love / Is sex with Polish guys different to sex with English guys? [173]


We're able to please sixty women at the same time waggling one eyebrow meaningfully.


Only the really effeminate ones, the manly ones have clusters of huge penises, like 20 or 30, and they're sentient and sing the polish national anthem while at it.

Love / In love with polish cleaning woman, but don't speak an OUNCE of polish :( [57]

Post contained vulgar words, so it was removed.

Love / did i push him away [36]


I was only excersizing very bad humor thank you, but i am going to lend you a piece of my briliant mind regardless.


The fellow didnt use you per se, basing my responce on your description of the entire situation he is simply an immature twat who's nowhere near a moment in life where he can settle down also he probably didnt treat you as a potential partner rather than a casual shag, whereas you being lonely saw in him a man you'd like to be with his fucked up character ( to which you were and still are blisffully oblivious ) notwithstanding.

You didnt lose him, you never had him however the guy is a largely negative person and many years will pass before ( if ever ) be becomes capable of true deep connection, as hard as it is being a single mother fuck him, he'd be a destructive burden on you so be grateful you parted when you did raise your kid and wait for someone better.