PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
 
Posts by Polson  

Joined: 9 May 2007 / Male ♂
Last Post: 11 Sep 2016
Threads: Total: 5 / In This Archive: 3
Posts: Total: 1767 / In This Archive: 983
From: Europe
Speaks Polish?: Trying hard (sometimes) to learn...
Interests: Music, sport, history, geography, science, languages...and probably Poland too.

Displayed posts: 986 / page 13 of 33
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Besides, Father Rydzyk is disliked by many Catholics

That's a chance, but he helped Lech anyway. He influenced many people to vote for Lech. And priests in the Church gave political point of views too (the same, Lech), which is, to me, unbelievable...

Radio Maryja and Nasz Dziennik (two - very good, actually - media connected with Father Rydzyk) supported PiS, but PiS lost.... Would you say the Polish Church isn't powerful any more? Or would you argue that PO won because Father Rydzyk supported them, not PiS?

I think Polish people wanted to get rid of the "terrible twins". And people might be disappointed to know that Rydzyk supported him too. :)

Great Heavens, it's nearly 2 am, and I've got to get up at 6 am and write. Bye, Polsonek

3 AM here, dobranoc Puzz, have a nice short night :)
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Polsonek

:)

you're a nice intelligent dude

Hmm...don't know if you mean it, but thanks anyway ;)

Always ask yourself: 'And what if this isn't true?' in regard to other peoples' statements and your own thoughts.

I'm not that influenced. I have my own critical point of view about what people says, and i decide by myself what i can trust and what i can't.

Then you'll be a really bright guy

Lot of work left :)
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Really? What do you mean by 'friend'? E.g. what do they do together?

Rydzyk supported the Kaczyńskis.

So if President of a given country befriends a priest this means that the church the priest belongs to is necessarily powerful in the country?

If the priest helps him to become president of his country, then yeah, i guess he has some power...

Is it evidence of the power of Lithuania in Poland? :)

Nuclear plants, isn't it ?... Germany, the USA, Russia are more important for a "first visit" than Vatican.

Is this also hard evidence of the Church's power? Why?

Hehe, that means that almost everybody can be influenced by the Church, particularly regular church goers.

It's these 3 reasons altogether that proves that the Church is still powerful in Poland :)
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Poland's practising Catholics is more like 70%

...hmm...you mean church goers ?... :)

even Israels President Moshe Katsav has visited the Vatican

I'm not saying it's bad, just that it's one of the first visit, so like a "priority"...

Does not necesseraly mean that the president is a true catholic whatsoever

Actually, he is.
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
Love / Things not to do with a Polish girl? [97]

I know it's important to talk, but most of the time I find myself just keeping it to myself. I like to have my own space, so I spend afew hours a day in my room away from anyone and just enjoy being alone, no influence from anyone else. It's kind of strange for someone to enjoy being alone, I don't hate people, but I like have that hour or two a day to myself

You're my twin, hei brother, nice to "meet" you ;) I'm a loner, i spend most of my time alone, and i never tell my feelings to anybody...Actually i don't talk much.
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

But you're saying that the Polish Church is powerful, aren't you? If so, then you must know some facts on which you base your opinion. What are those facts? Can you give them?
:)

Yeah, Mr the President is a big friend of Father Rydzyk...
Poland is 90% Christian.
One of Tusk's first visit is Vatican...

:)
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Puzz, i don't think Miranda is going to answer immediately cause she's off... ;)

miranda, I'm not surprised you're defending Polson

She wasn't defending me, but just telling the truth. Don't say that the Church is not powerful in Poland. Don't say that the politicians are not almost all Christians and very influenced by the Church. Facts are facts.
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Just leave things the way they have worked before you make more problems

That's the point : in the article, they are discussing about making religion a compulsory A-Level subjet, so they are thinking of changing the system, then they are going to make problems ;)
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

And Poland is still a Christian - Catholic country

Hmm...Poland is a secular country, there is no state religion...everyone is free to believe in the god he/she wants ;)

If the majority wants the knowledge of Christianity to be a compulsory subject, what's wrong with that?

Was it said that the majority wants it ?...

How should knowledge of Christianity hurt atheists or non-Christians?

We should teach differences of beliefs, respect of the difference, everybody's point of view, tolerance, and not only one point of view, one religion.
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Yeah, in the past wars have been fought over religion. Poland called for help against its pagan neighbors in the past = Teutonic crusaders invade lithuania and eventually Poland sides with Lithuania to fight off the controversial crusaders

LoL what religion/belief is supposed to be the "good one" ?...

Quoting: Polson
i don't care about what people think

Shame one you.....

Hehe, i mean, people's minds are not my business :)
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

When has it not been a religious state?

Officially, the Church and the gov are separated in Poland, it's a secular country.

When has religion not effected the choices most Polish people make?

I'm talking about politic and education, i don't care about what people think, everyone is free to believe in what he/she wants.
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Live and let live, mate

Yeah, so why make religious education a compulsory A-Level subject ? True, let live.

Quoting: Polson
Are we all obligated to be Christian

- Are we all obligated not to be Christians?

I can answer both questions (stupid questions, aren't they ?) : NO.

Why should your view be better than that of Christians?

I'm not saying that my view is the best, or whatever, but just asking why should everyone (SO that includes atheists, or people with other religions, beliefs...) receive a Christian education ? Isn't Poland a secular country ?

And do the Christians criticise you as you're criticising them?

I'm not criticizing Christians, just some ideas of some of them. That's all.

:)

the course should include a comparison of different faiths/religions

I agree :)

As for France - she separated church from the government long time ago, which is good because beliefs should stay out of politics.

Exactly. In France, the Church separated from the gov in 1905, but in Poland, the Church and the gov are separated too...At least officially...
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

what do you think?

I keep saying that religion is a personal matter and have nothing to do in politic issues and in education. Are we all obligated to be Christian ?...Freedom also means that we must have the choice to think on our own.

Judging from your posts, the French media seem to be quite Christanity-unfriendly, and Polonophobic too.

Hmm...it's a Polish website :) No French at all. Polish press. There's no attack again Christianity and noone is polonophobic, it's just that school must be for everyone, and not only for Christian people, i don't think you're going to disagree on that, unless you're schoolophobic, atheistophobic, or any other difference :)
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
News / Poland turning into a religious state? Polish politic and Church. [96]

Jerzy Szmajdziński (Left and Democrats - LiD), deputy speaker of the Lower House said on Polish Radio 1 Friday morning that in his opinion, Poland was turning into a religious state.

LiD MP commented on Thursday's meeting between education minister Katarzyna Hall (PO) and metropolitan archbishop of Warsaw Kazimierz Nycz who agreed that religious education could become a compulsory A-level subject.

They also decided that a thousand Polish pupils would take a mock RE A-level exam next spring.

What do you think ?...
Polson   
8 Dec 2007
Language / Why do people want to study Polish? [90]

LoL, yeah German must be a bit easier for English people, even if a lot of the English vocabulary come from French...

;)
Polson   
7 Dec 2007
History / WW2: Britain Declares War on Germany to Save Poland [290]

poland was overrun by the germans within a couple of days

Nothing surprising, right ?...

if they would not have been marching together with their allies people in poland would speak german today...

Not only in Poland...
Polson   
7 Dec 2007
News / Poland adopting the Euro, but when? [65]

as poland is going through a lot of changes both parties (ecu and poland) should watch and analyse before commiting to a certain exchange rate...

Yep, agree.
Polson   
7 Dec 2007
News / Darwins theory of Evolution in Polish schools [59]

darwins trheory is good

Of couse it is.

soul - how has that evolved.. humans and animals are different...

Our brain is much more bigger in proportion to our height, compared to animals. That makes a big difference. We evolved a lot more than them. We began to think, to wonder...

I find the evolution of the human race so interesting :) Proud to be a human, LoL.

(Evolutionist or Creationist...)

:)
Polson   
7 Dec 2007
News / Poland adopting the Euro, but when? [65]

Do you think its a good idea or do you guys prefer the Złoty more.

We're not in a hurry, are we ?...but i agree too with adopting the single currency. Tusk is working on it ;)

when will they get it?

Not immediately. Not before 2011.