PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by jon357  

Joined: 15 Mar 2012 / Male ♂
Last Post: 19 Jul 2025
Threads: Total: 73 / In This Archive: 51
Posts: Total: 24814 / In This Archive: 10045
From: In the Heart of Darkness
Speaks Polish?: Tak

Displayed posts: 10096 / page 316 of 337
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
jon357   
18 Aug 2012
News / Poles, Polonians and aliens on Pussy Riot? [182]

The fact that, regardless of their political message, they cuased a rumpus and desecrated a place of worship is conveniently omitted

And that is irrelevant. Doing their stuff in a church wouldn't be neccessary in the UK, the US, Poland, France etc. In Russia a different paradigm applies. If Russia was a bit less autocratic with opposition activists and journalists murdered on the direct orders of the president they wouldn't have needed to make that gesture at all.

convicted to 2 years in a penal colony

Not that Russia has a legal system worthy of anything other than contempt.

Just goes to show how close the Church-destroying Stalinists were to today's religion-bashing ACLU-style loonies.

I'd rather see every church in the world (except the architecturally or archeologically interesting ones) put to the torch than ***** Riot imprisoned.
jon357   
17 Aug 2012
Law / SKOK Stefczyka? [5]

Are they ,more reliable than Ambergold and Fintroyal?

A thousand times more reliable and a longer history.

Is SKOK Stefczyka a parabank, cooperative bank, savings & loan or what?

Not quite any of those. A few similarities to a Friendly Society but again, not the same. Not a sparkasse or a 'plankton bank' either, but similarities to all of those.
jon357   
15 Aug 2012
Language / Polish regional accents? [141]

someone from Warsaw

One problem with this is that there is a discontinuity between pre and post-war Warsaw. So many of the people were killed - at least two-thirds and many others left. Most of the people there now were either brought in from smaller towns and villages in the 1950s, 60s and 70s or are descended from people who were. And of course people move to the capital from all over the country because of their work. The result is a kind of Estuary Polish.

An old Warsaw resident told me that the pre-war Warsaw accent was quite sibilant - lots of sh and ch. I've met elderly people who've spent their entire lives there, even through the Uprising and the massacres that followed but I can't say I've noticed that. People's accents can change with time and exposure to others.

There used to be a programme on Polish television that showed fragments of pre-war films with a commentary. Most of the actors were of course cultured so perhaps their accents weren't typical.The accent was very different from today's - closer to that of educated bourgeois elderly people I know who came from Vilnius, Grodno etc.
jon357   
15 Aug 2012
Language / Polish regional accents? [141]

This thread put me in mind of an old lady who lived in the village I grew up in. She was at least middle class - perhaps even 'county' and was the widow of the area's largest farmer. She lived in quite a grand house built by her husband's family in the Eighteenth Century, came from money herself, was very articulate and cultured however someone from the home counties might just hear a Yorkshire accent and make a very incorrect assumtion about her.

I suspect there are/were quite a few people like that in Poland. People whose vowel sounds are similar to those around them, but speak in a different register.
jon357   
15 Aug 2012
UK, Ireland / Polish Family stabbed to death in St Helier. [40]

Rzeszowski's saying that voices in his head told him to do it. The prosecution say he is habitually violent.

The court reached a verdict:

A man who killed six people in Jersey, including his wife and children, has been found not guilty of murder.
Damian Rzeszowski, 31, stabbed his wife Izabela Rzeszowska, 30, his daughter, Kinga, five, and son, Kacper, two, in St Helier on 14 August last year.
He also killed his wife's father, her friend and her friend's daughter.

bbc
jon357   
15 Aug 2012
Language / Polish regional accents? [141]

I'd call it educated home counties

That's a good description. I suppose mine is educated Yorkshire. It has a bit more in common with RP than with any dialect and is several social degrees higher than, say, Estuary English and a bit of an old fashioned sound.

I do know a bit about what I'm saying

I suspect not as much as you would like to think.
jon357   
14 Aug 2012
Language / Polish regional accents? [141]

In this fragment of the old movie "Włóczęgi" (Tramps), you can hear traditional eastern accent from Lwów (now Lviv, Ukraine).

A friend from Lwow sounded just like that. He wasn't old - he'd be 46 now.

There are still accents - it's easy to tell he difference between a Poznan person and a Warsaw person.
jon357   
14 Aug 2012
News / 70% of Poles like Komorowski. Do you? [120]

If this is a case - what's wrong with that? Many speakers prepare their speeches beforehand, reading them several times - in their own native language - to the mirror or to family members. Good for him if he employed a tutor just for that. At least he was not the embarrassment, Lech Kaczyński was

I'd go as far as to say that pretty well all politicians do, especially when they reach high office.

By the way, the first lady, Dr Komorowska speaks English. With me only spoke Polish, however at the gathering where we met there were a number of dignitaries from the Arab world present and I heard her speaking English with reasonable ease.
jon357   
14 Aug 2012
History / 75th anniversary of Stalin's 1937-38 anti-Poland genocide [32]

The Bolsheveiks won the Russian Civil war. Then he had the Gulag stystem.

They say he changed his Russian name to appease the Russian population.

No, No, No.

His name wasn't unpronouncable - it was Dzugashvili. Translates to English as 'Shepherd. Stalin means 'man of steel' not 'steal' (why the capitals?) and he didn't change it to appease anyone, he adopted it as a pseudonym (one of several he used - his favourite was 'Soselo' the name under which he was a celebrated Georgian poet) while he was on the run from the Tsarist secret police.

Learn some history - preferably not from websites.
jon357   
14 Aug 2012
Travel / Custom Restrictions for Income Devices in Poland [4]

All that sort of stuff is available here at the Apple Store in various malls.

You don't say though how many you plan to bring - whether it's just a few presents or wholesale quantities.
jon357   
12 Aug 2012
News / 70% of Poles like Komorowski. Do you? [120]

So the PiS demographic.

Anyway - the President is for everyone who lives there, and since 1989 there hasn't been a better one.
jon357   
12 Aug 2012
News / 70% of Poles like Komorowski. Do you? [120]

(you know those young and "educated").

You seem to be implying that you're neither.

jon I like you, so please stop lying. He was controversial in some circles and thats all.

I'd even go a bit further and say he was a laughing stock at home as well as abroad.

Poland's team seriously impressed their EU colleagues in accession negotiations. They punched well above their diplomatic weight at the time and earned a great deal of respect on all sides. Poland is not a yes-man.

Exactly - and he acquitted himself very well during the recent EU Presidency.

Komorowski has his weaknesses as well as strengths, howeve at long last Poland has something that it hasn't had before in the 3rd republic - a President with dignity.
jon357   
12 Aug 2012
News / 70% of Poles like Komorowski. Do you? [120]

Komorowski represents Poland in a dignified way

Compared to his predecessor who was an international laughing-stock, very much so.
jon357   
12 Aug 2012
News / 70% of Poles like Komorowski. Do you? [120]

He's clearly a peasant. Just look at him.

Most Poles are. And yes, one could say "just look at them"

Part of his appeal stems from the fact that he comes across as a man of the people.
jon357   
12 Aug 2012
Travel / A week in Lodz - genuine taxi, trams, night safe? [7]

1. How can i spot a genuine taxi, and not the rip off ones which I need to get into the centre

The name of a company on top. Lodz airport isn't far from the centre anyway.

2. Is it safe to use the trams at night?

Yes

3. Is it safe to walk alone at night?

Yes, though the usual precautions are sensible.

4. Would their be any recommendations to visit towns outside of Lodz(for sightseeing), but within close proximity to Lodz itself

No. There isn't much worth seeing in the surrounding area, but a trip to Warsaw might be a good idea.

5. Where am I able to buy a sim card upon arrival at the airport

At any newsagent or kiosk. They are labelled either 'Ruch', 'Kolporter' or (the best ones) 'Relay'. There is one at the airport, and the airport one is most likely to have an English speaker in.
jon357   
12 Aug 2012
UK, Ireland / Poles 'failing to integrate in the UK'? [58]

The failure of young migrants to integrate with the community has been blamed for the closure of a Polish club in Northamptonshire.

Working mens' clubs are closing by the dozen, Polish or not. And the generation coming to the UK are products of the post-communist 'free for all' - suspicious of community involvement unless there's something tangible in it for them. Normal in Poland.
jon357   
12 Aug 2012
History / 75th anniversary of Stalin's 1937-38 anti-Poland genocide [32]

"being a Jew is nothing more than a religion"

Perhaps you'll link to a quote where I said that.

But somehow I doubt it.

Amazing how a troll can turn a thread about the Stalin years into something about race - without actually making any points either.
jon357   
11 Aug 2012
History / 75th anniversary of Stalin's 1937-38 anti-Poland genocide [32]

What's the surprise. People who worked for Stalin had liottle or no choice in the matter and it's frankly unlikely that someone would be attracted to nationalism in a country that had discriminated against then terribly.

BTW, admiting what?

Trolling again?
jon357   
11 Aug 2012
History / 75th anniversary of Stalin's 1937-38 anti-Poland genocide [32]

but why is it that of all the minorities Jews were the most overrepresented?

He deliberately drafted them since they were less likely to be Russian nationalists.

When Stalin (an ex seminarian) wanted something, the only choice was his.
jon357   
11 Aug 2012
Life / An Indian wants to convert to Christianity in Poland [60]

I trust that you're reasonably trying to escape India from persecution against Christians. I can only--if I even can--imagine what Christians in India experience

There are between 24 and 27 million Christians in India including the head of the ruling political party, the Minister of Defence and many other public figures.

am a Reverend Minister I work of an Evangelical Church as a counsellor. I was previously based in Southern Europe however for the past three and half years I have been based in Poland. I counsel British expat and help them anyway I can, both practically and of course spiritually. I am part of the 'New Christian Ministry' born from the very active protestant movement in Belfast.

Where are you from originally?
If you don't speak Polish, there's a few churches in Poland that perform masses in English. Not sure of the details, but it might be worth looking into.

Every Sunday there's a Mass on ul. Radna in Warsaw.
jon357   
11 Aug 2012
Life / What's the deal with Polish Piracy? [27]

Six factors, any one of which is sufficient. A mismatch between price and income. A history of having to get round scarcity. A history of having to circumvent the law. A philosophy that it's OK to do something if you can get away with it. The belief that if someone doesn't protect their property from being taken it is available to take. A tradition that if something doesn't obviously belong to one person, it belongs to nobody.