Oryctes
11 Aug 2008
News / Should Poland send volunteers to Georgia ? [100]
There can be no argument about the fact that Georgia has been a loyal ally of the USA. They sent soldiers to Iraq, applied for membership in NATO and cooperated in oil projects independent of Russia. They did all this because they wanted to safeguard the newly-won independence of their country from Russian military and economic blackmail. Russia sees Georgia as nothing but a satellite that should be totally subordinated to Russian economic and strategic interests. That's why they fomented ethnic conflicts in Georgia and did everything possible to support the separatists in the regions of Abhazia and Osetia. For instance they granted Russian citizenships to the inhabitants, provided them with arms and created their military bases there. When Georgians responded to provocations and attemped to take control of their own land, Russian launched a full-fledged attack on Georgia and are already in control of over half the territory. They are bombing civilian targets and infractructure, apparently trying to destroy as much as they can before withdrawing. But I don't think they're going to withdraw before installing a puppet government that will do their bidding ever after. One more Russian objective is to frighten Ukrainians who have also applied for memberhip in NATO and cooperate with the USA. I still remember Russian threats when Poland applied. Generally, there are many analogies with Poland. It's worth remembering Germans started WW2 claiming they had to defend German inhabitants of Poland from our persecution. The French who were theoretically obliged by a military treaty to support us in fighting off foreign aggression said they "were not going to die for Gdansk/Danzig". After the war we were sold again by our western "allies" - to the Russians this time. I think the same will happen to Georgia.
I understand all Americans who don't want to get involved in another war, and all those who point out how costly it would be to stand up to Russia. But don't tell me leaving Georgians to be crushed into obedience by a barefaced agressor 100 times their strenght is fair play. And don't tell me you believe Russian propaganda about Georgian crimes against population (its own) - if you do, I know what your opinion about Hitler's attack on Poland in 1939 would have been: we had ourselves to blame, right?
There can be no argument about the fact that Georgia has been a loyal ally of the USA. They sent soldiers to Iraq, applied for membership in NATO and cooperated in oil projects independent of Russia. They did all this because they wanted to safeguard the newly-won independence of their country from Russian military and economic blackmail. Russia sees Georgia as nothing but a satellite that should be totally subordinated to Russian economic and strategic interests. That's why they fomented ethnic conflicts in Georgia and did everything possible to support the separatists in the regions of Abhazia and Osetia. For instance they granted Russian citizenships to the inhabitants, provided them with arms and created their military bases there. When Georgians responded to provocations and attemped to take control of their own land, Russian launched a full-fledged attack on Georgia and are already in control of over half the territory. They are bombing civilian targets and infractructure, apparently trying to destroy as much as they can before withdrawing. But I don't think they're going to withdraw before installing a puppet government that will do their bidding ever after. One more Russian objective is to frighten Ukrainians who have also applied for memberhip in NATO and cooperate with the USA. I still remember Russian threats when Poland applied. Generally, there are many analogies with Poland. It's worth remembering Germans started WW2 claiming they had to defend German inhabitants of Poland from our persecution. The French who were theoretically obliged by a military treaty to support us in fighting off foreign aggression said they "were not going to die for Gdansk/Danzig". After the war we were sold again by our western "allies" - to the Russians this time. I think the same will happen to Georgia.
I understand all Americans who don't want to get involved in another war, and all those who point out how costly it would be to stand up to Russia. But don't tell me leaving Georgians to be crushed into obedience by a barefaced agressor 100 times their strenght is fair play. And don't tell me you believe Russian propaganda about Georgian crimes against population (its own) - if you do, I know what your opinion about Hitler's attack on Poland in 1939 would have been: we had ourselves to blame, right?