PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
 
Posts by ConstantineK  

Joined: 10 May 2007 / Male ♂
Last Post: 1 Jun 2024
Threads: Total: 26 / In This Archive: 19
Posts: Total: 1298 / In This Archive: 856
From: Moscow(Russia)
Speaks Polish?: no
Interests: History of Late Ancient World, Tragedie Lyrique (J.B.Lully)

Displayed posts: 875 / page 8 of 30
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
ConstantineK   
12 Jan 2009
History / Mass Grave in Malbork [34]

For sure? The only fact is obvious, that poland began WWII provoking Germany by the act of aggression against some local german radio station near the border and killing all its personal. Only this fact is sufficiently obvious. Certainly you will ask me how do I know that it is a truth? I read it in articles.
ConstantineK   
12 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

And surely, natural polish pans rejected to associate them as equals. That was a blindness of polish elite. Do you think that it was not because of their religion. But even more stupid was behaviour of you bishops and cardinals, who acted as if they lived in 14 century. Actually, your nobility began the process of abolishing polish state, but it were your clerics who succesefuly finished this process.
ConstantineK   
12 Jan 2009
History / Mass Grave in Malbork [34]

how do you know that it was RA. Did they lay their calling cards?
ConstantineK   
12 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

Oh, Borrka! OldBelievers here are not an issue, they had been burnt in the churches by themselves. I can feel reverence for their principes and their firm non-conformism, but suppousing in the same time that question how to cross, by two fingers or by three profanates true faith.

Moreover, we have never executed the policy of proselitism. Actually I don't have intention to disput about advantages and disadvantages of both branches, but even you Borrka should agree that Catholicism have produced more blood deeds than Orthodoxy. Anyway, all polish partitions had strong taste of religious quarrels. Otherwise how can you explaine Cossacs' upraisings? Bogdan Khmelnitskiy certainly had serious reasons for his mutiny. The character of your Sigismund Vasa gives a clue for reasons of Polish calamities in next century.
ConstantineK   
11 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

It's amazing Borya you got me right. We are really make a pair :) It should be my next point. Say, the dissident issue was main one in all this mess with partitions. Honestly, I would never believe that this issue hadn't had any real base, certainly orthodox believers were oppressed by catholics.
ConstantineK   
11 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

Catherine didn`t need any anti-Russian rebellion in Poland to change her attitude to Poland. She was always intent on expanding Russian territory, just waited for a proper moment to do it, and as the Polish state was unable to prevent it, she happily cut it up together with other kings. The partitions would have taken place without any rebellions too.

Nay! I insist that Catherine did not have such monstrous idea as how to divide Poland, at the begining. It was exactly Bar confederates who frightened here by the mirage of new Pugachevschina. Exactly from this point, the fate of Poland was decided!
ConstantineK   
11 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

Certainly it is not a question of dates and strict sequence of events. The Bar confederation might create hostility against Poland from the direction of Catherine.

And what is more, they were against legal king and against reforms. The maximum what they might achiev was a further degradation of Poland as state.
ConstantineK   
11 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

Targowica.
Targowice sounds rather stupid to any person with at least elementary knowledge of history.

You know Borrka that my knowledge of polish history might be attributed as elementary.

It was the Battle of Grunwald.

How is that? Please clarrify!
ConstantineK   
11 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

accused of attempted regicide, the attempted abduction of the king

As I remember correctly they really perpetrated abduction....

Shortly speaking, Targowica was organized by pro-Russian Poles who decided

So, you think that members of Targowice confideration were not polish patriots? May be they were just tricked?

I just want to express my point of view. No doubts, that members of Targowice confideration were Russian agents, but it were Bar Confiderates who triggered the final partition of Poland.
ConstantineK   
10 Jan 2009
History / Targowice and Bar Confederations [34]

Here I beg my Polish hosts to express attitudes to these outstanding facts of Polish history. Please, describe your feelings you experience, hearing these names.

What they bequeathed to the posterity? Here in Russia we think that the legacy of both parties were, to put it mildly, very disputable, is it right?

I know about my poor reputation at forum, but please set aside your aversions to my person.
ConstantineK   
5 Jan 2009
History / Fall of Communism in Poland [33]

Borrka, do you think that communism is dead? Well, may be you are right, but we still have another aces in pack! One of them is 'autocracy, orthodoxy, popularity'. Do you think that you could endure it?
ConstantineK   
2 Jan 2009
News / No Way, No Apology! Poland has every right to support Georgia! [115]

You think Borrka? Which parts do you mean? Don't say me about China, please try to invent somethig new! Or may be you mean that Poland is able to bite something from Russia? We are in different leagues Borrka. You can bark only by the orders from Washington, but remember georgian expirience! Nobody will defend you in case of real fight.
ConstantineK   
2 Jan 2009
News / No Way, No Apology! Poland has every right to support Georgia! [115]

Exactly! Poles are idiots thinking that we want to include them in our state. These stupid thoughts are pushing them to interfer in russians affairs. As a result, it will bring them to open conflict with Russia. The result is obvious.
ConstantineK   
2 Jan 2009
News / No Way, No Apology! Poland has every right to support Georgia! [115]

Who says that we cannot? Who will defend these "states"? You Seanus? I doubt!

No, certainly we don't have this stupid idea of creating new EU. We just want to take back our territories. If you like those Ests or Latvians and etc, you can take them off all. We need the baltic coasts. That is all.
ConstantineK   
2 Jan 2009
News / No Way, No Apology! Poland has every right to support Georgia! [115]

Russians are those who speaks Russian, thus pretty piece of Ukraine is Russian.

Of course georgians and ukrainians do have a right to choose their way, but sure we (russians) do have the right to punish them if they will make wrong choice! The same is with Poland.
ConstantineK   
30 Dec 2008
News / The new Polish government is going to do... reprivatisation [25]

Former East German territories of which West Germans were deprived during the aftermah of the Berlin Blockade

It is quite clear that Eastern Germany territories belong to Russia by the right of victor!