UK, Ireland /
How might Britain`s withdrawal from EU affect Poles there and here? [474]
You might be thinking of the BNP, pawian.
"They steal our jobs" is a common phrase thrown around Britain ever since we started the Industrial Revolution , when the Luddites smashed up weaving looms for depriving honest folk of honest jobs. And although it's been proven wrong countless times, ten generations have completely ignored the Lump of Labour fallacy so the idea isn't going to leave the voters' minds any time soon.
What does annoy me is the approach to funding. When the Eurozone needed 50bn to bail out the PIIGS countries, what was the proposal? Tax the banks. Of course, it was all the banks' fault from the beginning, so it's only right that they should pay.
What wasn't highlighted was
which banks had lent the money. As can be seen on this chart:
2010/05/europe-debt-web.jpg
You can see who owes money to whom. Add up the totals, and you'll see that although Britain lent nearly $420bn, Germany exposed itself to $704bn and France an enormous $911bn - more than double that of Britain. In all, Germany and France are owed 75% of the total.
So when the proposal came to tax the banks, why was it done in a way that would mean 80% of the tax? It would be generated by the City of London in a so called "tobin" tax, which charges a fee per financial transaction. In that way, Britain would generate an incredible 40bn euros in tax a year... which would pass to France and Germany's coffers to pay off the PIIGS debts. This was the famous British Veto of October last year.
Is that the solution? Tax the Brits to fix the French economy? What about the other EU funding? What about CAP, the EU programme that subsidises farmers? What about the fact that CAP amounts to 20% of the EU budget, and 20% of CAP goes to France's 500,000 farmers. That's right - 4% of the entire EU budget goes to 0.1% of its population. 17% of CAP is shared among the 12 "new" EU states, even though Poland alone has four times as many farmers as France does. And yet every time the budget comes up for debate "Vee vill not diskuss CAP" say the French. "Non non non, no discussion".
That's why Britain wants out. In comparison to the leech that is France, the few hundred thousand Poles in the UK, who actually work for a living, are no bother at all.