PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by MediaWatch  

Joined: 30 Aug 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 31 May 2016
Threads: Total: 10 / In This Archive: 9
Posts: Total: 942 / In This Archive: 662
From: USA, Richmond
Speaks Polish?: a little bit
Interests: History

Displayed posts: 671 / page 4 of 23
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / Poland being the powerhouse of Europe [40]

Don't worry MW, the EU will flood Poland with uneducated and unskilled 3rd world labourers. They'll save the day.

If that happens, Poland is a doomed country.
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / Poland being the powerhouse of Europe [40]

Poland is a European country. India isn't so I think its more accurate to measure a European country against other European countries.

In general, the European countries that have been powerhouses all have bigger populations then Poland. Russia and all the EU richest nations Britain, France, Italy, Germany have larger populations then Poland and it has only helped their GDP. Even though Russia proportionally is doing worse then mainland European countries, at least it used its huge population to seize resource rich land over its history to sustain itself now.

For what its worth, here in North America, most Mexicans are dirt poor and uneducated, but they use their huge population to come over the border to make things better for their ethnic group as a whole.

Russia and Germany would never have been powerhouses if they had the population size of Hungary, Slovakia, Chech Republic, let alone Luxembourg.
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / How Polish diaspora see future of Poland? as ethnic Polish state or just Polish in origin? [120]

No you're the liar

I said this:

Better yet, Germany and Russia stole ALL of Poland between 1795-1917....they did it again in 1939 for two years.... and today Poland has diplomatic relations with both countries.

AND THIS IS YOUR RESPONSE???????

Well done, you manage to compare the situation when no Polish territory is being occupied and no Poles are being discriminated against to a situation where Poland was occupying what it had agreed to be the territory of another nation and discriminating against the unfortunate people who lived on their own territory; that is stunningly good work.

I'm clearly making the major point of referencing Poland's past of being occupied and discriminated against and then secondarily comparing it to how today Poland has diplomatic relations with those past occupiers and you come up with your above incoherent response??

But to be fair here, why don't you explain to me how you came up with your answer:

Well done, you manage to compare the situation when no Polish territory is being occupied and no Poles are being discriminated against to a situation where Poland was occupying what it had agreed to be the territory of another nation and discriminating against the unfortunate people who lived on their own territory; that is stunningly good work.

I have to hear this. Because your response answer makes absolutely no sense based on what I said.
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / How Polish diaspora see future of Poland? as ethnic Polish state or just Polish in origin? [120]

There is no selected edit on my part.

Its quite simple. I talked about Poland being occupied in two different times in history and you responded by saying basically: "Poland was not occupied and Poles were not disriminated against".

If you want to talk about things in the present, then WHY would you respond to a statement I'm making about the PAST?? Are you retarded?

There is NO selected editing here. I talked about something and you clearly responded to it and were hence caught in a lie. Now you're trying to talk your way out of it accusing me of "selective editing". Give me a break.

As is quite clearly shown by my quote which you edited, I use present tenses.

No its clearly a pity that you have to accuse other people of that which you do all the time. Lie.

So if I'm CLEARLY talking about two periods in time in the PAST about how Poland was being occupied and being discriminated against, WHY IN THE WORLD would you give me a direct answer that has NOTHING to do with the subject matter I'm talking about?

Are you hallucinating about what you see in messages? Is your mind working OK?
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / Poland being the powerhouse of Europe [40]

When the power shift changes from west to east could poland be the powerhouse of europe so close to germany but far enough away from the PIGS and still profitable even in a recession.

Poland is going to have a hard time becoming a powerhouse if its birthrate is not increased.
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / How Polish diaspora see future of Poland? as ethnic Polish state or just Polish in origin? [120]

No Harry you are the liar.

Are you trying to deny that you said Poland was not being occupied and Poles were not being discriminated against when I said Poland was being occupied from 1795-1917 and in WWII?

Well then look at my message #88 (top part) and your response to it in message #89. Here let me refresh your memory.

This is what I said in message 88:

Better yet, Germany and Russia stole ALL of Poland between 1795-1917....they did it again in 1939 for two years.... and today Poland has diplomatic relations with both countries.

This is how you responded.

Well done, you manage to compare the situation when no Polish territory is being occupied and no Poles are being discriminated

You have a lot of nerve accusing me of lying when you are lying through your teeth.

It didn't. Being occupied has a strict definition - to do with diplomatic recognition. Poland was partitioned. That's why we in Poland call it 'Rozbiory' not 'Okupacja'.

Yes I'm sure if you spoke to the leaders of Poland and the average Polish person they would say Poland was not occupied during the partitions or being discriminated against. LMAO!!!!

Man are you nuts.
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / How Polish diaspora see future of Poland? as ethnic Polish state or just Polish in origin? [120]

Well done, you manage to compare the situation when no Polish territory is being occupied and no Poles are being discriminated

Well done. You just proved for the umpteemth time what an anti-Polish Bigot you are.

You just basically claimed that Poland being whiped off the map by Germany and Russia from 1795-1917 and again from 1939-1945, did not constitute Polish territory being occupied and no Poles being discriminated against.

That's because in your anti-Polish mind, a "good Poland" is a Poland that does not exist and the hell with the ethnic Poles in occupied territory being oppressed by two other nations.

But what else can anyone expect from Silly Harry and his ingrained anti-Polish biases?

Remind us of all the things which you have done for Poland. Other, of course, than making Poland a much nicer place by never ever coming here.

Yeah dream on. The last person I have to prove anything to is somebody like yourself.

Do you talk about it while eating Busia Sofia's golumpkies and pierogies?

You and your fellow Poland-Basher Delphiadomine keep talking about this "Busia" thing. I have never heard this word (that you and Delph dreamed up) so you mind telling me what it means???

I get the impression that the Polish-Americans see enemies where Poland doesn't. Another great sign of how they're totally out of touch with (as they say) - "Polish reality".

This is code for:

I Delphiadomine want to bash Poles with impunity and I get offended when people of Polish ancestry challenge my Polish-bashing.

Remember, he defends Poland on the internet. Poland doesn't want/need defending, but he doesn't let that little matter stop him.

MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
News / How Polish diaspora see future of Poland? as ethnic Polish state or just Polish in origin? [120]

If another country had invaded and occupied what it had agreed to be part of Poland and then spent a couple of decades discriminating against the Poles who were unfortunate to live on the wrong side of the illegal border, would you expect Poland to have diplomatic relations with that country?

Better yet, Germany and Russia stole ALL of Poland between 1795-1917....they did it again in 1939 for two years.... and today Poland has diplomatic relations with both countries.

The knowledge of Polish history displayed by the average member of the Polish diaspora in this thread demonstrates that they lack the most basic of knowledge about Poland to make any reasoned assessment of when Poland is going. Those who know not where Poland has been cannot hope to know where Poland will go.

Says the Polish-Basher Harry.

The one thing the Polish diaspora is very conscious of is how Poland's enemies like yourself have been trying to define Poland according to your own anti-Polish viewpoint, to people outside of Poland.
MediaWatch   
4 Jan 2012
History / Polesie Voivodeship before WWI? [11]

i am polish and most poles are anti

You seem to be something different each day. One day you are Belarussian then you are Polish then you are Russian then you are Jewish......

One day you say you live in Belarus then another day you say you are from Germany....

You just sound like a Russian troublemaker.
MediaWatch   
22 Dec 2011
News / Amnesty to Illegal immigrants in Poland [102]

Beware brotherly Poles.

Thanks for the advice.

NEVER MAKE THEM CITIZENS PLEASE!!!!..

I agree with you. Poland should do what Dubai does and NOT make foreigners in the country as citizens.

We in the US have made the mistake of giving millions of illegal aliens amnesty and it has only hurt the US. These former illegal Mexican immigrants now use their American citizenship to vote for more amnesty to illegal Mexican immigrants in America. These Mexicans in America have more loyalty to their ethnic background then to America.

This has been true with many of the ethnic groups that came into Poland. They have more loyalty to their ethnic background then to Poland and only ended up UNDERMINING Poland.
MediaWatch   
6 Dec 2011
History / Richard "The Iceman" Kuklinski [16]

Maybe.

I know a guy who knew him and he said he had no idea he was the "Iceman". He said Kuklinski played the "family man" thing really well if you knew him from a far.
MediaWatch   
6 Dec 2011
History / Richard "The Iceman" Kuklinski [16]

Yeah I know I was just kidding.

But I did read a summary of a book from an Italian guy who wrote on him and the mob, how Kuklinski either beat the hell out of or killed people who told him "Polish jokes", when he was younger.

I laughed when I read that.
MediaWatch   
6 Dec 2011
History / Richard "The Iceman" Kuklinski [16]

An upcoming movie about The true story of Richard Kuklinski, the notorious contract killer.

I don't think it was a good idea for somebody to start a conversation with Kuklinski by calling him... "Polack"

LOL
MediaWatch   
1 Nov 2011
News / GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)! OUTRAGE! [1016]

I hope I don't come across as trying to undermine Poland, it's not my intention. I'm sorry for reviving the thread.

Galloglaich,

For you to say what you said, I take you at your word that you're not trying to undermine Poland. I'm sure you're a nice guy. Just because you may have some views that are different than mine or some other Polish people here, that doesn't mean that you have bad will towards Poland or anyone else. The problem here is that there are anti-Polish trolls here who will use some of your information.......... against Poland and Polish people. That is what I think is escalating things here.
MediaWatch   
1 Nov 2011
News / GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)! OUTRAGE! [1016]

MW, I got this info from a pro-Serbian, patriotic Polish woman. She told me the Serbs were demonised, and they were. She's fluent in both languages.

Well there's good an bad apples every where Seany. That Polish lady you said yourself was Pro-Serbian. I'm Polish American and I'm pro-Serbia. I'm also Pro-Crow ;) ;)

Copernicus was not 100% Polish, is it sinking in yet? ;) ;)

What does that mean??

Does not compute.

:D

Happy Halloween Seany!!
MediaWatch   
1 Nov 2011
News / GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)! OUTRAGE! [1016]

There is a monument to Polish Kopernik in Serbia

Serbians knows

I'm glad.

I have started to like the Serbs after reading information from Serbs like you and others on this forum.

Thank you Serbians ; it is nice that you don`t want to distort our history unlike some lunatic home spun German historian

I agree.

And Poland repays Serbia back by believing all the BS spread in the media about the Serbs being demons. Nice :( :(

Don't you think you are generalizing about Poland?

The last Polish president was Pro-Serbia.
MediaWatch   
31 Oct 2011
News / GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)! OUTRAGE! [1016]

"Sarmatism" (also, "Sarmatianism") is a term designating the dominant lifestyle, culture and ideology of the szlachta (nobility) of the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth from the 16th to the 19th centuries.

This is true. Not only that but I read that Martin Luther mocked Copernicus by calling him a "foolish Pole" for discovering that the Earth went around the Sun. So even Copernicus' enemies knew he was Polish.

I would also add, for context, there was always strong tension between trading towns, especially the Hanse towns, and the Church went back to the early Middle Ages.

You say there are "many German Catholics remaining in Prussia after Luther". Of course there were still German Catholics in Prussia. Not every single one of them became Lutherans.

But if you mean "many" as in there were more German Catholics then German protestants in Prussia you are wrong.

Do you know what parts of Germany became predominately Lutheran and which parts were Catholic? Take a guess. Central, North and North East Germany became predominately Lutheran. So HELLO......what does that tell you?

Also one of your recent links talked about the SLAVIC background of Copernicus' mother's family.......even though she had a German name. Now I never knew Germans were Slavic?? LOL

Not only that your link said that the cities of Silesia were over half Polish even though economically the Germans were dominate.

Do you want me to show you those things in your own links on Copernicus?

You say Copernicus was of mixed ancestry.

I tell you what, why don't we split the difference here and both agree that Copernicus was mixed but that he was predominately of Polish ancestry?
MediaWatch   
31 Oct 2011
News / GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)! OUTRAGE! [1016]

Off topic, MediaWatch. Stick to the thread, and cease flaming.

Why don't you take your own advice and do the same? Half of your messages are flames at other people especially at Polish people you disagree with.

I don't expect you to understand such complicated concepts of "Poland was made up of several different tribes that came together, all of different ethnicities". Even today, there's still a hell of a mix of ethnicities in Poland - Ukrainians, Lemkos, Gorale, Kashubians, Silesians, etc.

Why are you going so crazy about the definition of one's Polish ancestry?

Its obvious you don't care about the proper definition of who is or is not Polish. You are using a false argument just to DIMINISH the Polish ancestry of anybody who has done good things.

If Copernicus was a criminal, you would be the first to say he is 100% Polish and then you wouldn't split hairs as to his ethnic identity.

German nationalists and Neo-Nazis are pushing the notion that he is German. How would they know for sure especially when the nation of Germany didn't even exist when Copernicus lived? Yet I'm sure your on the side of the Nazis on this topic.

Why don't you go back to your Russia forums where you can have more fun openly bashing Polish people there more than here?
MediaWatch   
31 Oct 2011
News / GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)! OUTRAGE! [1016]

While it may be the case that most of the Germans were xenophobic and Protestant in the 20th Century, it's unfair to pretend that was the case in the early-modern period. Poles and Germans continued to intermarry during the entire time of the Rzeczpospolita. These people weren't angels but they weren't Nazi's either.

Your information is in reference to Germany in the past 140 years.

Sure there are German Catholics. About 40% of Germany is Catholic today.

But you do realize that where (and when) Copernicus lived, ie near or in German areas, those areas largely were the first to convert to German Protestantism?
MediaWatch   
31 Oct 2011
News / GERMANS WANT TO GERMANIZE KOPERNIK (COPERNICUS)! OUTRAGE! [1016]

Nicholas / Niklaus did in fact speak both Polish and German.

Copernicus's ancestry is 100% Polish.

Copernicus' mother was not German just because her name was German sounding. If that was so, she and her whole family would have JOINED the religion of their fellow German Martin Luther like 99.9% of all the other Germans in their area when Martin Luther came on the scene.

Instead she and her family were glad to be CATHOLICS and glad to SUPPORT Poland! Germans back then were very proud of their ethnic background just like the Germans today who are trying to say Copernicus was part German. If Germans were not so adamant about their German identity back then, why did they do everything to maintain the German language and push German culture into nearby areas?? Neither ethno-centric Germans back then or today would be so adamantly supportive of Polish interests over their own proud German interests. A "German" mother of Copernicus would no more promote Polish causes over German causes then Germans today who are trying to say Copernicus' mother is German.

Poles historically spoke more German and have more German last names then any other nation outside of Germany. Part of it was due to Poland being adjacent to Germany. So Poles speaking German or having German names means NOTHING. They are still ethnically Polish. I have family members that had German names and spoke fluent German because at the time "when in Rome they did as the Romans" or in this case they lived in German lands and assimilated into German culture. Just like Copernicus' mother's family did.
MediaWatch   
22 Oct 2011
History / Why have Poles contributed so little to Academics? (Particularly Science) [180]

I really find your accusation amusing

AlexTheGreat: Except most Poles didn't consider Jews as fellow Polish neighbors for the majority of Polish history..

Perhaps you don’t realize it but it is you who has this need to distinguish who is who and you’re doing just that in this thread. What’s the matter?

That's a good point.

I never understood that double standard.

If Poles merely make an observation about how a citizen of Poland is a Polish Jew (because many Polish Jews are proud of being Jewish and identify themselves as Polish Jews), that is a no no according to Jewish nationalists. But when Jewish nationalists distinguish a Polish citizen as a Polish Jew because he did something they thought was positive, then its OK.

I don't get it.
MediaWatch   
19 Oct 2011
History / Do Poles really blame Britain for Poland becoming Communist after the war? [104]

Isthatu2,

I think that is a kind British gesture to the Polish people.

:)

Do you have any links on this or similar things?

I'm glad you posted these type of things before.

TODAY there should be no reason why Brits and Poles should not get along.

In my opinion, I am glad Britain has allowed Poles to live in Britain and to grow up in British culture.
MediaWatch   
19 Oct 2011
History / Do Poles really blame Britain for Poland becoming Communist after the war? [104]

Although I have mixed feelings about this topic, as a Polish American, I don't know if I could blame Britain for Poland becoming communist.

Its a complicated topic and the British were in a tough position.

But hey, if its any consolation to Poles, at least Britain let in quite a few Poles right after WWII and in recent years. In my opinion, I think that was a kind British gesture and Poles should not take it for granted.

There might be some bad apples in Britain (like any country) but I generally have no bad feelings towards Brits.

:)
MediaWatch   
17 Oct 2011
News / Polish Diaspora - many of these 20 million actually speak Polish? [79]

Delphiadomine is a very angry Russian-Scot.

He got into hating Polish people, especially the Polish diaspora, after the Polish people (many in the Polish diaspora), questioned Russia's honesty in its reporting of the Smolensk crash.
MediaWatch   
17 Oct 2011
News / Polish Diaspora - many of these 20 million actually speak Polish? [79]

As usual you sound like a crazy Russkie racist nazi.

If you look at Russkie racism it makes Polish racism look like nothing. Russkie racists went so far as killing tens of millions of people who they felt, "did not fit in" with Russkieland.

They are "polluting" if you listen to your average Polack nationalist.
It's spelt Czech, by the way. Not sure why Americans have such problems with that word.

This sounds like more of your racist Russkie nonsense and my misspelling of Czech was a typo you fool.

Have you taken your meds today?
MediaWatch   
16 Oct 2011
News / Polish Diaspora - many of these 20 million actually speak Polish? [79]

But then you'd have to start counting whether or not they are actually Polish, or whether they were "polluted" with Czech/German/Ukrainian/Lemko/etc blood along the way.

No you wouldn't have to do that. Only somebody who has a racist mindset like yourself would feel the need to do that.

Its interesting that somebody like yourself, who is NOT of Polish ancestry, regards nationalities like Czech, German, Ukraine, Lemko, etc as "polluting" material.
MediaWatch   
15 Oct 2011
History / Why have Poles contributed so little to Academics? (Particularly Science) [180]

However, in modern times it seems Poles are lagging behind in fields such as astronomy, biology, chemistry, and physics.

There is a tendancy among some people to think that just about any great invention was from somebody who was Jewish.

According to some people, famous inventors like the Wright brothers, Thomas Edison, Henry Ford were Jewish. Sorry they were not.

I doubt Polish Jews got all these Nobel prizes. But if they did, it was because they lived in Poland which gave them all their opportunities to be the best that they could be, which they did not get in most other countries. This is why most Jews CHOSE to live in Poland for ONE THOUSAND YEARS.

As for people of Polish ancestry, the co-founder of the great company Apple Computer, which has revolutionized the world with its technology, is of Polish ancestry.

Enough said.