PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
 
Posts by Sasha  

Joined: 19 Apr 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 2 Oct 2015
Threads: Total: 2 / In This Archive: 0
Posts: Total: 1083 / In This Archive: 553
From: Moscow/Kyiv
Speaks Polish?: Russian, English, Swedish, Ukrainian
Interests: Slavic countries, politics, languages, culture, people

Displayed posts: 553 / page 8 of 19
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Sasha   
6 Apr 2009
News / Poland. Sold for nothing. [341]

.I saw a picture of these Russians on the web and I got curious...Are they 'pure bred' Russian Slavs, or are they a mixture of something?

Is this a Polish picture? They look Polish, don't they? I don't mean to offend you. Sure they can be Russians, but they don't look typically Russian.
Sasha   
4 Apr 2009
History / Taras Bulba - the movie [115]

Great Ukrainian writer working for Russian empire Nikolai Hohol (re-)wrote it for money, I am sure he was not proud of such flat cheap anti-Polish story

This should be awarded to the "bullcrap of a year" nomination.
Nationality is in one's mind therefore I would dare to conclude Gogol was Russian afterall and he did see things from the Russian point of you.

In this movie a lot of blood, a lot of Ukrainian cossacks of 15th century dying for Russia (even Russia as a country did not exist that time), a lot of hate words against "liechy"..

Every historian movie in the new history is more or less politically-inclined. It's at least hypocritic to blame only Russians for producing that kind of movie. Read some Polish articles about Russia or Russians at leisure.

Why you Russians doing it about Ukrainians and Poles?

You slo better mind your own business in parallel and see how many things your government has done against friendly ties with Russia. I don't justify Russian propoganda I just don't think there's any room for plain view on things. Unless you realize what your own government is doing any friendly dialogue is hardly possible. Thankfully the views your representing here are not typical for Ukranians. It's just one of many...

I'll watch the movie and tell you better the way I see it.

And in this new Russian movie Poles called ONLY "liaxy"...

FYI "liakhy" is not really rude. It's related to the name "Lekh" and the old word for "cultivator". :)) "Pschek" has much more rude implication but even this word I can't call rude unlike to your "moscal" and particularly "kacap".

Ukrainians call Russians "kacapy".

You call and so brain-dead Ukrainians do but don't generalize and don't disgrace Ukranian nation.

he name "kacapy" comes from beards Russians had on their chins and looked like he-goats or kozly

Yes but you missed one important point. Exactly WHY the wore beards. They wear beards cause of their Orthodox religion seeing this way their connection with Christ. So the seed of discord is in fact religion. :)))
Sasha   
23 Mar 2009
Food / Pierogi taboos ways you SHOULD NOT create/cook/season them. [18]

I heard of that version and I agree that the word "Rossija" at that point a bit artificial. But since what began as the Anciet Rus grew up to Russia, why shouldn't one treat "pirogi" as sorta heritage? In the modern Russian Ruthenians are called "rusini".
Sasha   
23 Mar 2009
Food / Pierogi taboos ways you SHOULD NOT create/cook/season them. [18]

I believe you have mistaken Polish pierogi for Chinese cuisine!

Sorry. :) I just googled it by that name and didn't pay much attention to its form. I just thought there were plenty of its forms. Your picture is much more precise. Vareniki looks similar way. :)

Looks to be wonton

Yeah... :) I sometimes order them in the US not having a chance to order pelmeni. Basically they're all very close: pastry+filling boiled.

ruskie pierogi.

So what do you finally mean by that term? :)
Sasha   
23 Mar 2009
Food / Pierogi taboos ways you SHOULD NOT create/cook/season them. [18]

Sasha. Pierogi po rusku here in Poland are those perogies with cheese and potato.
Are those the most popular in Russia? I don't quite understand the reference..
From what I know, all sorts of perogies are made in each region of Slavija, with no specific region mastering one kind.

Hello, Filios! :)
To avoid misunderstanding...
Here's Russian "pirogi".
They may be stuffed with meat, cheese, powidlo (jam... usually apple) or anything else.

This is what I think you mean by Polish pierogi.

Pierogi

So the word "pi(e)rogi" is kinda false-friend in this case, cause we call pretty same way different things. This dish exist in Russian and Ukranian quisine under the different name - "vareniki" (derives from the verb "varit"=to boil). It's usually stuffed with curd, cheese etc. In case the filling is a meat we call it "pelmeni". I don't know why... probably that's only a question of my personal preference but I can't imagine them stuffed with any kind of sweet (like "powidlo") filling. However I know people that stuff 'em here with some fruit or berries (usually plums, blueberries, cherry).
Sasha   
21 Mar 2009
Life / What's your favourite Polish cartoon? [10]

Lolek i Bolek... Honestly I can't recall now any other Polish cartoon shown in the USSR. :) They tried to pick those Slavic cartoons where heroes didn't speak (obviosly not to be bothered with a translation). Therefore two most popular cartoons were Polish Lolek i Bolek and the Czech one about a mole. Oba nemije (both are mute). :)
Sasha   
20 Mar 2009
Feedback / How did you find this site? [88]

Rafal, there're lots of friendly, well-balanced people of all nationalities (you seem to be one of them) here. :) I just said that I had been initially interested in some Polish-Russian forums where people don't bash each other as it usually happens on such boards.
Sasha   
20 Mar 2009
Feedback / How did you find this site? [88]

I wanted to find something dedicated to Russian-Polish friendship and asked on here.
Sasha   
18 Mar 2009
History / UPA barbarian murders on Polish and Jewish neighbors during WW2 [150]

Two things to compare:

acient Polish dreams

Russian chauvinistic craze of "Velikaya Russiya"

Borrka. I’m loving it!® :)

with Russian chauvinistic craze of "Velikaya Russiya" what is ABC to every Vanya from Tambov to Vladivostok

Something tells me, that if there were no "Velikaja Rossija" craze there would be "Velikaja RP" craze. So in a way you should thank Russians for bearing a burden another time. :)

in talking about my country?

No, buddy. You duplicated it more than once while talking about mine (id est Russia) and didn't even notice when.

I cannot agree with you. Zhirinovskiy's speeches don't matter because he's a talented stand-up comedian and a professional orientalist possibly linked with KGB. So his fake party was created to serve as a lightning rod for Nazi voters (now most of his voters are those who just like his pranks).

Yes. Yet you couldn't agree on what? Perhaps he's not a very typical specimen but he's still a part of the one whole together with Privalov you mentioned and others... I find progovernmental magazines too dull to read. But I still wouldn't stick with a term "patriot" for them same as you don't call a pear an apple even though they might look similar.

I've read dozens of Russian articles on Ukraine and hundreds opinions on the web and never encountered one in which Ukrainian words or facts of Ukrainian history were not messed up. On the other side arrogant or "paternalistic" attitude towards Ukraine is most common thing even with intellectuals who are rather civilized

No wonder. The current power runs the show. If they can afford to fabricate elections, why in the world can't they afford to set journalist on their payroll? However runet is one of the last shelters of the trustworthy info from within.
Sasha   
16 Mar 2009
History / UPA barbarian murders on Polish and Jewish neighbors during WW2 [150]

Indeed nice post. I just want to clarify something.

Of course not every Russian is a patriot (and an idiot like that man having said it to Ukrainians) yet patriots in today's Russia are majority, they rule your country and will be ruling it for a long time.

Privet! These all tightly depends on which mind we would call "right". I still insist on that the Russian in a right mind would be free of a standard garderobe of traits you listed such as ignorance etc. Don't get me wrong I've seen loads of that stuff and may still see it for one when there's a Zhirinovki's interview on TV or wherever. But he's not all Russia and... he is not a patriot. Same with others... An idiot or just someone who doesn't take into consideration other people's feelings can't be a patriot inherently. Therefore I wouldn't with a term "patriot" at that point or if you still want to I would put in front of it the "pseudo-" prefix.

My purpose was merely to show that Nathan's approach essentially duplicated what you heard in Russian Duma with the only exception of the descriptive adjective... "Ukranian" instead of "Russian".

and acknowledge that "Polska od morza do morza" was no better than "Deutschland über Alles" or "velikaya Rossiya"

Nice. I would even say it was all the same.
Sasha   
15 Mar 2009
History / Taras Bulba - the movie [115]

Alexander, you don't believe that we defeated Poles in 1612 by means of magic, is it possible?

All I've said was that the movie could have been better (in terms of both actors and the whole historical image shown there).

Polish actress Magdalena Mielcarz

Beautiful woman. :)
Taras looks like a mongolian dwarf... too much tanning.
Sasha   
15 Mar 2009
History / Taras Bulba - the movie [115]

I hope this will not be another piece of propaganda, like the Russian production, 1612, was.
How many of you are planning to see it in theatres?

I would only love to see it with no money spent. In other words I'll either download it or wait for it showing on TV as I did in case of 1612 (which I found just a very silly film).

I think all historical films that have been recently produced more or less propagandistic. Countries mostly produce them for internal use. :))
Sasha   
15 Mar 2009
History / Taras Bulba - the movie [115]

Is that true?

What exactly? Well...wait I think I could 100% share none of what was quoted. :)

but for Russians as well.

To put it more clear they were sometimes a problem for Russian government as they didn't want bolsheviks to come to power.

BB, if you want to know more about who cossacks were, I suggest you reading Der stille Don. It has four volumes but it's undoubtedly worth reading. The story is about hard times cossacks had under the "red infection"... and it on the whole rather blackens bolshevism in Russia so that I have no idea on how it went thorugh censorship at that times.

Could it be that because they weren't so taken with the upcoming Stalinism/Bolshevism that they got a bad name by the new rulers?

I suspect bad name was given by Konst's mind. They don't really have bad name in Russia. They're much more respected than bolsheviks. I'm telling you that not as a descendant of Don cossack...
Sasha   
14 Mar 2009
History / Taras Bulba - the movie [115]

A Russian author wrote a book/story/play about an Ukrainian hero who fights against Poles.

He was probably Russian only by selfidentification... as for his genetic nationality... I don't know. Some consider him even Polish. The last name sounds Ukranian for me and I think he's of Ukranian origins.

Pawy I promise that it won't be waste of time, if you read some of his stories. The way he writes seemed at first a bit plain (you won't notice it though, unless you read in the original - in Russian), but he's a genious. His position of one of the best prosaist in Russia is well-earned.
Sasha   
6 Mar 2009
Love / Polish girls' obsession with marriage [124]

Southy, if you like and love her why you feel uncomfortable with the marriage? The will to get married is a normal feeling for those who love each other. Unless you love her and use her only for bedtime there's a problem with you not with her.
Sasha   
6 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

IMHO Russia is still run by Communist Putin and his croonies.

That by no means correct to call him a commie. He found himself as probably "sovereign democrat" but that's only the veil.

As for taking responsibility... pls answer some of mine questions:

1) Countries like Ukraine and Baltic States consider themselves immediate heir of all industry built on their territory by the USSR enthusiastically look for the so-called "Party's gold" but under no circumstances they ever share the guilt or either take any responsibility upon themselves. "Russians are the only guilty party" they say.

2) Everyone likes to name nations suffered from "Russians" so that sometimes they are about to name he Papuans among those. But how about Russians themselves? Who do you wanna take a responsibility? The government? Ok... I agree... but I can't recall any country that recently has taken any responsibility of anything thus something tells me that Russia would be the only country, that admitted bygone sins. Maybe Russians? Then it's ridiculous since they suffered most of all. Almost every family has a member who was killed or anything else y commies (including mine)... so you want me to take responsibility for that my Grandpa hadn't killed stalin and (or) lenin in their childhood before they killed him?
Sasha   
5 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

The Iron curtain kept us apart, unfortunately.

True. But there was no spite towards anybody because commies proclaimed "we're all brothers" and to some extent that worked. I can't say I didn't like it.

The quality of food everywhere was better.
They told us GM foods would be better, now they tell us organic is better. when i was a kid there was no organic foods or so much that there was no concern about anything else.

I agree here.

I am dealing with an old guy today here in Lithuania, he does not work, only for bribes.
The corruption in this country is underestimated, bribes are a way of life.

And?.. I mean I don't quite understand what does nowaydays Lithuania have to do with the USSR? In fact even times of the USSR Baltic States didn't look as a part of it.

One of the big differences between communism and other isms seems to be freedom of speech, tens of thousands of Lithuanians were sent to work in Siberia, as young as 15 years old (I heard).

We can't seriously speak about the freedom of speech at present either. We've probably can speak out more things without worrying of being imprisoned or killed but that's it. As for the freedom of speech in the USSR... I've got the book El otoño del patriarca (Patriarch's autumn) by G.G. Markes published in middle 70s in the USSR.

Secondly I was talking only about 70-80ss when there were no "sendings to Siberia" or so. The earlier years are totally different story.

Earn money?, what use was money, if there was nothing in the shops?.

Of course now we've got far bigger alternative of what to buy but that's surely wrong to state that there were nothing in shops. I could say more about goods and industry of those years but I don't want to look like commy booster. I just want everybody to be as fair as possible towards anything that happened in the past.

I do find here in Lithuanian, that there was a devolution, people who could think for themselves or had leadership qualities were killed.
If you blindly followed, you lived, thankfully this not hereditary and there is a few generations gap here between people over 40 and under 40 years of age, it will take time.

Yes this is the problem. Many people here realize that the brains especially on the early stages of "communism building" were simply extincted (physically).

I'm not sure if I have any specific rate before or after which I can or cannot work with people. Sometimes I may simply call it "generation gap" sometimes it has something to do with their "old school". But I may also tell you I had similar problem with people in the US who still lived in the times of "cold war". Eventually I don't think it's any related to particular regime; it inheres in all regimes.

There're lots of features in our mentality I wish we (Russians) didn't have. Perhaps some of those are related to our commy bygones but I don't dare state if that finally did us good or bad. Who knows... maybe if there were no commies we (you, poles, me) would all live in one big Deutschland.
Sasha   
5 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Capitalism is by no means perfect and needs adjusting but Communism is not for humans in my opinion.

It works for mindless ants and bees, they are the true commies.

I'm not a follower of commies' ideas but in my turn I have to say that an average Russian (should I better say Soviet) of late 70s, early 80s was kinder towards his own nation and foreigners, was better educated, didn't have to worry about the quality of what he ate (because the quality of food was much better) and always had an opportunity to work and earn his living. That's probably eat.

The methods of manipulating people just became in a way a bit more complicated but generally they stayed the same. So your sentence about insects is fair enough for the actual reality.

EDIT:

no it's probably because at work and to a certain extent out of work i rub shoulders / hang around with them. They simply know nothing outside there tiny little world. Telling lies and covering up the truth ( even if very obvious) seems to be a national hobby. Other than that they are ok.

Don't really know what to say on this. Maybe you're just unlucky. I would never marked that as our national feature. I would name some different things...
Sasha   
5 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Just exactly where does Nazi style "National SOCIALISM" differ with Stalinist socialism? I've never quite worked it out.

One of regimes implied unity of all people, all races, all cultures another one superiority of one nation. That's a distinction, id est answer on your question. Although let's put aside the way it was implanted in first case.
Sasha   
5 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

They are generally childish, arrogant and ignorant.

Are you Russian I wonder? I'm asking because the whole your message perfectly fits criteria you mentioned. Should I explain any further?
Sasha   
2 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

sure did.

I don't think everything was so black&white as you're trying to see it.

you're smoking crack

I smoke nothing. You didn't get my irony there.
Sasha   
2 Mar 2009
History / UPA barbarian murders on Polish and Jewish neighbors during WW2 [150]

It is a proven fact that Russians wore uniform to pronounce their belonging to UPA just to fool Poles and bring in anger against Ukrainians because this way it is much easier to fight.

Stop desperately raving, making things up, trying to get out of a scrape and broadcast your BS. Be honest, do me a favour. I won't ask for more. It's proven fact that Ukies themselves killed for instance much more Poles in Volhynia than Soviets did in Katyn. It's well known fact that Polish government this one and I'm 101% sure the one that will be after prefers to shut their eyes on this fact for solely political reason.

and he tried to defend the good name of many people like him

Defending oneself and accusing others is some different things I guess. Don't you agree?

My family member was in UPA. Do I have to be judged by that? Another one was in SS Galicia, so I have to be judged by that too.

Why in the world should you be judged? The best you can do now is not to be blind or insincere taking an honest look at bygone events. As for your relatives God's their judge.

What about the 5 million Ukrainians who were starved to death?????

It is bad. But why do you tell it as if only Ukranians starved to death at that time? How about millions of Russians starved to death at the same period?

He is just being Ukrainian, who is tired of being labeled.

Ok. You may consider me a Russian who's tired of being labeled. Have I ever tried to ennoble my nation by disdaining any other?

I think he is being patriotic

You are after equal attitude with no arrogance. So am I. So why enlighten me pls Const for the chauvinistic BS (being said not serious btw) is a Russian swine and Nat for the alike stuff being said in absolutely serious and aggressive manner is patriotic? It seems like for "nats" good Russian is Russian on bended knee before anybody, self-torturing with a permanent guilt-complex... or who knows maybe even dead Russian. How do you conceive of me dealing with that?

Plus many Polish I know can't distinguish between Russian and Ukrainian.

No wonder, I can't sometimes either. Are you always able to distinguish Mr. Vseja-Ukraine?
Sasha   
28 Feb 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Don't you have the term 'flawed ideology' in Russian?

I think we don't. Sean (the Scottish one), any ideology more or less flawed. Often if it fits one social group it squeezes another. It would never satisfy everybody.

The naming of ideology is like a brand for people some of them are talked-up and own good reputation some vice-versa. Politicians just change the naming convention using the older approach with some changes of course to conform to the actual reality.

Quite funny to track the communists... in the beginning of last century they're all to a man Jews and atheist ruining Christian (Orthodox&Catholic) churches. The current version is they're all Russians, faithful, criticizing the government for being undemocratic but still are demagogues.
Sasha   
28 Feb 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Rubbish.

A brilliant argument.

If the theory doesn't fit change the people....Rubbish.

Yes, this is a rubbish. I said some different thing.

Always pitting one group against another

That politician tool is still alive.
Sasha   
28 Feb 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

No. It was flooding us with tones of luxury goods.

True
:)

I don't want to compare the exact things. In fact there's nothing bad in any ideology. What's usually bad is the way it conducts. Just sit and wait for the way it will be conduct this time... then we may have an exchange of views.
Sasha   
28 Feb 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Was it due to leaders' incompetence,or...?

Not that it failed. It just lived in Poland less than for instance in the USSR. History fetches a circle. We might come back to the comminism under the different name (the EU already became to have some socialistic deviation).

Poland provided exactly what it was to provide - a huge amount of food products, steel, coal, ships, etc. for the Soviets.

So you assert that the USSR just pumped out resources from Poland? :)
Sasha   
25 Feb 2009
Food / Honey Vodka drink suggestions [11]

Stuff like Nemiroff (Ukrainian) needs to be drunk with a nose clip

Really I found it nice.:)

Here's a good suggestion on how to drink:
Sasha   
25 Feb 2009
History / UPA barbarian murders on Polish and Jewish neighbors during WW2 [150]

Knowing your language with excellence (of course, I don't, - it takes time and lots of practice) was always considered as a bad sign for chauvinists like you.

What?! :)) Are you raving?
Do you have anything meaningful to add?