PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
 
Posts by SeanBM  

Joined: 10 Mar 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 6 Jun 2017
Threads: Total: 34 / In This Archive: 17
Posts: Total: 5781 / In This Archive: 2214
From: Beauty is in the eye of the beer holder.

Displayed posts: 2231 / page 30 of 75
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
SeanBM   
8 Mar 2009
Travel / Recommendations for Zakopane [48]

Here is a skiing video I made. Skiing, Carpathians, Tatra, Białka Tatrzańska, near Zakopane, This is the second video I have ever edited. I would like very much to know your opinions and hear constructive criticism. The major problem is the camera shake.

Białka Tatrzańska is near Zakopane.
SeanBM   
7 Mar 2009
Life / Irish man wanna move to Poland [60]

Hello malolo,

Whereabouts in Ireland are you living?.
I'm from Dublin and i live near Krakow.
We traded places :)
SeanBM   
7 Mar 2009
News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]

One team calls the other Jews and it is considered an insult.

I remember someone posting a youtube link about "Cracovia" football fan club (hooligans) associating themselves as Jews.
And now the rival team "Wisła" are saying bad things about Jews.
It is unclear to me if they mean only the other team or not.
That St. David's star crossed out is becoming common enough.
SeanBM   
7 Mar 2009
News / Poland embraces new effort to fight anti-Semitism [138]

Unfortunately, yes - this country needs such education.

I just drove through Krakow and saw some badly written graffiti about Wisła (football teams) and kill the Jews.
SeanBM   
7 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

I was talking to a Lithuanian last night about the USSR, he said that Lithuanians see the Soviets and Russians as completely different.
And that the Commies destroyed Russian culture.
Maybe that is how Lithuanians can live with so many Russians from that era?.
Do any Russians agree or disagree with this ides?.

I am sorry, I am sorry this whole bloody war took place and so many lost their lives. I am sorry I never met my grandmother, aunts, uncle and others I never even saw picture of, not to mention a country. Today I am sorry that Russia cannot say, were sorry, Stalin was wrong.

I would think you would prefer a correct history than just an apology.
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

That is wrong in any society.

Yes. The transition period is not going very well here, very slowly with little support or understanding.
It is changing but slowly, too slowly for these old women.

When we look at the Cold war and what it was, it is still there just changed the faces.

Well... I think some people have been brought up fighting, so what are they supposed to do now?.

I would like to see better relations between east and west.
I am amazed the past two years how many Russians there are travelling, it never used to be like that.
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]

I can blame Stalin our so called ally. One thing must be faced, Stalin never intended to have a free Poland. Right from the on set of war, Stalin made his plans known.

What was that thing...
The Warsaw uprising, the Poles revolted against the Nazis and the Red army held back, letting the two beat each other and then came in to claim it for themselves.

That should have been an indicator as to the BIG plan.

Jeez that is a really bad way of putting it but you know what I mean?.
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

I remember hearing a radio show about an old woman talking about how she still never uses people's names when on a tram or generally in public, for fear of getting into trouble or putting someone else in it.

I actually have many accounts of this myself, a guy here in Vilnius was building something beside where I used to stay, he was on top of a wall with a hammer and chisel, banging away., I asked what he was building, he said 'I don't know'.

For quite a few people here the cold war is not over.

I do feel sorry for the elderly women who beg on the streets here, they were promised a job and a flat and now have nothing.

They were brought up completely dependant on the state and now they can not do anything for themselves.
They fell in the cracks between two very different worlds.
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics [57]

The ordinary Red Army soldiers were heroes if it wasn't for their enormous blood sacrifice the Germans would never have been defeated in the East. We owe the Red Army a huge debt of gratitude and respect for that sacrifice;

Actually in Ireland we were thought this.

Anytime I am in England there is always something about how the British won the war.
American movies about this time is about how they won the war.
I was supprised in Ireland that we were thought about an 'alternative' history, the cold winter and the HUGE Russian (soviet) sacrafice..

But your statement is different from what happened after, when they occupied and oppressed the people terribly.
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

people were silenced.

Why?.

One of the biggest differences I have noticed between this Polish Forums and Poland (the country ;)
Is that on PF people talk about world war two.
While in Poland people of a certain age or older talk about the commies, after all it was the last opressive invasion.
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

I see, thanks.

It looks like there will be two histories.

Lithuania got into 'trouble' banning Soviet stuff.
They are trying to show that the U.S.S.R was terrible here.
Perhaps Poland should do the same?.

I don't think an apology is realistic from Russia but at least a realistic history is needed.

Why is it that the Commies got away with all of this while the Nazis didn't?.
This is a long question of course.

---------------------------------------------------------------------- -----------------

I have a question for the Russians on here, it is not about communism but land.
Do Russians have a special obsessiveness about land?. Just you have by far the biggest country.
Land is important to everyone but RussiaĄ come on, it is two and a half times bigger than China, it is enormous.
Just a side order question :)
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

So, Russians cann't expect that other nations will accept Russia as a heir apparent of USSR achivements without taking USSR faults.

I understand.
Would you (any of you) see a difference between The Political ČelliteČ and the normal Russian?.
I have to say I do.
Admittedly it is not a clean or clear distinction but one I think is to be noted.

check out the newest post from communist "Russia to outlaw criticism of WWII tactics".

Where is that?. Can you post a link please.
SeanBM   
6 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

But there was no spite towards anybody because commies proclaimed "we're all brothers" and to some extent that worked. I can't say I didn't like it.

So long as you were a commie, of course their were commie hunts in America, much like the witch hunts.

And?.. I mean I don't quite understand what does nowaydays Lithuania have to do with the USSR? In fact even times of the USSR Baltic States didn't look as a part of it.

Lithuania has everything got to do with USSR, it was part of it.
Lithuania needs to modernise but there are very definite hail marks of commie up bringing here.

We've probably can speak out more things without worrying of being imprisoned or killed but that's it.

A good start, is what I'd call that.

I could say more about goods and industry of those years but I don't want to look like commy booster.

This is a discussion,
the USSR is finished.
I would like to hear more about what you were told.

I'm not sure if I have any specific rate before or after which I can or cannot work with people. Sometimes I may simply call it "generation gap" sometimes it has something to do with their "old school". But I may also tell you I had similar problem with people in the US who still lived in the times of "cold war".

From the USA you may get prejudices but people work.
My point was that people have learned not to work in communism, it is very destructive.

maybe if there were no commies we (you, poles, me) would all live in one big Deutschland.

Nobody knows but it is better to have one enemy, rather than be attacked (not liberated ha ha ha) from both sides.

These countries have still not recovered. However even till this day the UK Government still advertise this as a great piece of British history and triumph.

the Russian folk I know refuse to talk or even accept things that have happened in thier recent history. It is as if somthing like " If we don't like the truth then forget the truth and it will go away". For some reason is seems uncomfortable to look at reality.

I lost your point, it sounds to me that you are writing one is as guilty as the other?.

Indians are left with the things that they want and appreciate about their former invaders or oppressors, yet still remain undeniably and unchangeably Indian.

You can't blame people for looking to the future and taking the best from what happened.
But as you said

invaders or oppressors

.

In order to have a good road the foundation must be secure and built on trust. No one will ever trust Russia until the past is dealt with, including their own. Build on substandard ground ther first frost will show the sink holes I say.

I think the mixing of peoples will help this greatly.
In every conflict the politicians tell us how evil the others are, now we get to see the truth for ourselves.

Not to mention how long do you think the victims should wait for an apology.

It seems everyone is waiting for an apology from someone.

shame is an understatement, look at what Germany has been put through. News flash, NKVD was just as bad as Nazis,

I actually agree with this.
The Soviets have come off far too lightly.
And if it continues, they might be seen as "liberators", which of course is not true.
Out of the frying pan into the fire.

It has not escaped my attention where the people talking about not giving apologies are from.
I also think celinski's point is not so much about an apology but about how the history books will be written? celinski?.

Liberals are the scolds who feel guilt about the past and try to make everyone share their guilt and shame.

You should pay one cent every time you use the word Liberal :)

Russia is still run by Communist Putin and his croonies.

KGB is the official name, cough cough cough.

Baltic States consider themselves immediate heir of all industry built on their territory by the USSR enthusiastically look for the so-called "Party's gold" but under no circumstances they ever share the guilt or either take any responsibility upon themselves. "Russians are the only guilty party" they say.

I don't think so, I would like to make a separation between communist state policy and the Russian people.

you cann't just take what was good and forget what was bad, and start saying around the world how tragic it was that USSR collapsed (Putin). It is simply incoherent message.

Could you clarify, I did not understand this.
SeanBM   
5 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

an average Russian (should I better say Soviet) of late 70s, early 80s was kinder towards his own nation and foreigners,

What foreigners?.
The Iron curtain kept us apart, unfortunately.
I am very happy, we (normal people) get to communicate finally and not let the politicians, with their own agendas, tell us what other people are like.

was better educated, didn't have to worry about the quality of what he ate (because the quality of food was much better) and always had an opportunity to work and earn his living.

The quality of food everywhere was better.
They told us GM foods would be better, now they tell us organic is better. when i was a kid there was no organic foods or so much that there was no concern about anything else.

Work and earn money

?,
I am dealing with an old guy today here in Lithuania, he does not work, only for bribes.
The corruption in this country is underestimated, bribes are a way of life.
Earn money?, what use was money, if there was nothing in the shops?.

The methods of manipulating people just became in a way a bit more complicated but generally they stayed the same.

One of the big differences between communism and other isms seems to be freedom of speech, tens of thousands of Lithuanians were sent to work in Siberia, as young as 15 years old (I heard).

They have banned the sale of any and all Soviet memorabilia here, saying it was as bad as the Nazis.
(it should be noted that Lithuania has an agenda when accusing the soviets). The Jews here were mainly killed by Lithuanians (during the Nazi occupation) they really did do it themselves.

Then the Soviets came and the jews fought with them, sometimes killing Lithuanians, so there is a bit of a political battle here.
Something like, you killed us (forget about what we did).

I do find here in Lithuanian, that there was a devolution, people who could think for themselves or had leadership qualities were killed.
If you blindly followed, you lived, thankfully this not hereditary and there is a few generations gap here between people over 40 and under 40 years of age, it will take time.

I can't work with many people over here over 40 as a result of the communist infliction.

I do not have much time now, I will try to make my point clearer later.
Do you know what i mean?, is it the same for you (you being anyone).
SeanBM   
5 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Wow!, that could apply to any nation.
Perception is nineteenths the law.

I looked up, you are referring to the Russians.

I know some russian people very well, there is a side of them which i dislike very much and also a side which i like. Such is the complexity of thier makeup that it is very hard to put into words.

Yeah... again, could apply to a lot of people.

Needs work,
Try harder
(D+)
ha ha ha,
I am just kidding with that last bit.
SeanBM   
5 Mar 2009
Love / Polish village girls vs big cities girls [37]

Polish village girls vs big cities girls

Is this a spaghetti wrestling match?.

She told me that girls in big cities are pervs and kurwas. It is unbelievable what this girl does.

Thanks for the tip ;)

So maybe village girls have more vitamins,or..?

By vitamins you do you mean stamina or virtuous?.
SeanBM   
5 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

One of regimes implied unity of all people, all races, all cultures

I have to say, i remember being thought about Communism in school in Ireland as a teen.
I thought it was a wonderful idea, truly beautiful.

Until I got a chance to see how it has been implemented and the many pitfalls.

Capitalism is by no means perfect and needs adjusting but Communism is not for humans in my opinion.

It works for mindless ants and bees, they are the true commies.
SeanBM   
4 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Don't forget that after WWII, Poland's infrastructure was devastated. The USSR rebuilt a lot of that.

I have a problem with this statement.
two things,
The commies did promise a lot but did not build much in the way of infastructure, it is apparent today.
Secondly, if the USSR rebuilt the train lines, how come they are the western size and not the Russian size?.
Even today you have to change train from Poland to Lithuania.

It's not a question of communism failing in Poland; it's a question of the Polish people being ready for communism. The backwardness of the peasants, the Western-looking intellectuals, the demoralized urban classes, the destroyed infrastructure spelled the defeat of that system before it could even take root. The social conditions were not right for communism in Poland.

When Marx spoke of communism he meant it for the developed, industrial nations like France and England. It was never his aim to advocate it for peasant societies like Russia or Cuba.

?, I thought even Marx was aware that true communism could not work, that people would not be able for it and it would take supermen to do it?.

Not the English and the French.
SeanBM   
2 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Don't forget that after WWII, Poland's infrastructure was devastated. The USSR rebuilt a lot of that.

I am in Lithuania now, drove here from Krakow and the infastructure is terrible.

And why all middle aged and old people like communism and think it was better at that time?
In fact I never met anyone to describe me a shitty life under communism.

Naw, Polish people were being used and they did not like it, I have spoken to many people about it.
There is more of a feeling in the older generation of Lithuanians of missing the false nannying of the state.
Sure there was work but nothing in the shops.
Sure there was free houseing, for those that could afford it.
Sure Mother Russia would look after you, the price was your freedom.

If you lived in one of the occupied by communist Russians, Eastern European country you would see how it really was and how the system worked.

Or more to the point Čdidn't workČ.

Communism failed in the eastern block, because the Soviet Union gave weapon-production top priority to an ununjustifiable degree. If they stopped in the 60ties at a state where they had enough IMCBs to destroy the socalled free world, they could achieve their goal to free the proletariat class from the burden of exploitation.

You coukld continue that sentence 'they could achieve their goal to free the proletariat class from the burden of exploitation and instead be exploited by someone else.

That is a supposition, you do not know that.

I help build this edifice while in third and fourth and fifth year of university study for my volunteer work brigade

I have a job for you.

I have met many people here in Lithuania whose parents were sent to Sibera for offrences, many people did not make it, horrorr stories.
Siberia always makes me think of Austrailia, in this respect, if you disbeyed the Russian commies you were sent to Sibera, If an Irish man disobayed the English Empire he was sent to Australia.

Commyunism kills individualism, in Cambodia they even killed anyone with glasses, saying they were intillectuals.
I have worked in Lithuania for many years now and I still can't get my head around some of the stupid systems in place here, left by commies.

I will write more on this laters.
SeanBM   
1 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

I think it's side effect of communism. In communist system they already have a job and they don't need to do something to keep it or they don't have any chance to go up. So best thing is just hanging around.

I live in Poland and work here and Lithuania.
There is a big difference between Poland and Lithuania.
Lithuania was part of the U.S.S.R (Soviet Union), they looked at Poland as the Free West.
Even today i can see a huge difference between Poland and Lithuania.
It will take Lithuania many years to get out of this mentality you described.
Poland is light years a head.

============================================================

Edited: Quoted text was removed to random chat.
SeanBM   
1 Mar 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

No excuse...You are a 'Gold Card' member...Then you have some money...If you want the fruits of my study for free, forget it...

If you really believed your statements you would not be selling your "special information".

I have laid out two years of posts here, with detailed information on topics such as 'communism', with many sources included...Look them up...Or simply use Google...The origins, history and tyranny of communism is docummented to a voluminous degree...Or you could read books.

But where are the Atheistic Jewish Utopians who created and spearheaded this tyranny of communism?.
I am not going to waste my time looking up your posts.
By what you have just posted it is clear that you are just stirring shot and in need of a dollar, two years you have been posting and you couldn't get 50$ together?, Jeez man that's sad.

If you can't back up your statements then why bother making allegations.
Funny thing is I have read some of your other posts a while back and quite enjoyed them, ah well.
SeanBM   
28 Feb 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Communism was created and spearheaded by 'Atheistic Jewish Utopians'

What are you talking about?.
Have you any thing to back up these statements?.

Please read historical sources...The information is readily available...If you want individual tutorial sessions from me, we can arrange that, but there will be a charge.

Worst excuse EVER.
SeanBM   
28 Feb 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Communism was created and spearheaded by 'Atheistic Jewish Utopians'

What are you talking about?.
Have you any thing to back up these statements?.
SeanBM   
28 Feb 2009
News / More and more jobs moving to Poland from other parts of Europe... [50]

IKEA is the next one. They want to invest lots of money in Poland. A serious money.

Yes, serious money.

500,000USD in a retirement account by the time you reach 65 is usually not enough to live a comfortable existence in the U.S. during your final years in the big cities.

How much do you think a Polish person gets?.
And define comfortable.

We do not pay off our mortgages often, but tend to refinance to longer term loans, upgrade our homes and do other things which soak up income.

Why?.

costs of living are low enough that they can survive on Social Security benefits.

Do you actually know how much they get and what the cost of living is here?.

I appreciate that things are grim in the U.S. but from what you have written, it sounds like you do not know what things are like for the majority of people in Poland.
SeanBM   
28 Feb 2009
History / Why communism failed in Poland? [275]

Could communists have produced better results in Poland?

No, Communism in Poland was a buffer zone, a stooge a puppet between those commie Ruskies and the West.
This could never have benefited Poland and Polish people found that out quickly.

Why, the lazy, of course.

In communism everyone had to work.There were no lazy.

I wouldn't have said lazy, just conditioned not to do their job, it is still evident today.
I will put it another way, it was 100% employment but there was no reason to work, you were not going to get more money or lose your job.

One of the major pitfalls of communism was there are no incentives, just Siberia if you talked against them.

They created problems so people could work.
"Communism heroically fought obstacles that other countries just don't have".