PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by Bratwurst Boy  

Joined: 2 Apr 2007 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - Q
Last Post: 24 Nov 2024
Threads: Total: 8 / In This Archive: 2
Posts: Total: 11831 / In This Archive: 4472
From: Berlin, Germany
Speaks Polish?: No
Interests: his helmet

Displayed posts: 4474 / page 1 of 150
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Bratwurst Boy   
30 Dec 2019
Genealogy / Ochmann: Curious about my Family History.... [29]

How do you know this? The OP did not indicate the place of his birth.

Not the OP but the mentioned example....

....and there have been famous people with the name such as Polish singer Wiesław Ochman.

I strongly doubt if Marek was a first name given to children in the Polish-speaking Silesian families

Why? What's wrong with it?
Bratwurst Boy   
27 Dec 2019
Genealogy / Ochmann: Curious about my Family History.... [29]

He was born in Bytom in 1937....and in medieval times it was not only polish:

"....It is one of the oldest cities in the Upper Silesia, and the former seat of the Piast dukes of the Duchy of Bytom. Until 1532, it was in the hands of the Silesian Piasts, then it belonged to the Hohenzollern dynasty. After 1623 it was a state country in the hands of the Donnersmarck family. From 1742-1945 the town was within the borders of Prussia and Germany,and played an important role as an economic and administrative centre of the local industrial region...."

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bytom

So his nationality after 1945 was polish for sure, the name and the region point to german heritage though...why is that so hard to accept...it's Silesia after all! A mixed region if there ever was one...
Bratwurst Boy   
2 Dec 2019
News / Will Poland tighten border control with Germany? [60]

Tighten the outer borders....go with a comb through the EU states to weed out all those who don't belong here, who shouldn't be here, the illegals and the foreign criminals.

I like the idea of a "Festung Europa"...with hotspots outside to regulate and steer wanted and needed immigration, clearing up the asylum status of refugees BEFORE they are coming here.

That means putting alot of money and personal into a common EU military, a common EU police force and a common EU immigration agency and also looking for non-european countries willing and able to work with our hotspots, lending us territory and personal, rewarding them with EU contracts/support funds and cutting our money for those who don't...that's where I would start.

The economic aspect is more important.

That's what I believed for a long time too...that argument worked also especially well in Germany as we just had a very long economically good time....but that isn't the case for other EU countries and won't be true for Germany either as the wind blows rougher now...

Now the questions will get louder if open borders are still such a good thing when the economical situation keeps getting worse. When at the same time the criminal abuse of the lack of border control is rising...

Imagine all the trucks from Poland having to pass a border post before they enter.

Agreed! That's why I don't see a wall between Germany and Poland any time soon....and the immigrants aren't exactly moving the polish way! No wall needed...
Bratwurst Boy   
2 Dec 2019
News / Will Poland tighten border control with Germany? [60]

There is still the idea of the European Union....a sum of all of us...but bigger....better.....stronger! A real, equal, respected player on the world stage! Not just a lot of insignificant tiny and middle sized beggars and bootlickers of the mighty and powerful!

Tell me when you are ready to build walls between the US states too keep lowlifes from other states out....more secure for sure, but also effectively killing the "United" in the US, destroying it's "greatness"!

I'm not there yet....but I acknowledge the problem.
Bratwurst Boy   
1 Dec 2019
News / Will Poland tighten border control with Germany? [60]

Maybe that "no borders" thing is really not working....

Germany has lost total control about who is coming and going (and staying)! I start to doubt that concept too. Just to be faster at your next holiday destination can't be it....to many drawbacks for that.

But when I think about it I don't have the polish-german border in mind first actually!
Bratwurst Boy   
21 Oct 2019
History / WWII - who really was the first to help Poland? [900]

I wonder where you draw the line....

Hungarians and Romanians were also fighting alongside the Germans...they died together in huge battles like Stalingrad.

Which "people" do you mean exactly? And how did "they" help Poland?
Bratwurst Boy   
21 Oct 2019
History / WWII - who really was the first to help Poland? [900]

Hmm, the first helpers that come to my mind are Romanians.

What is astounding, since Romania was a german ally....

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romania_in_World_War_II
Bratwurst Boy   
26 Sep 2019
History / Does Poland deserve credit for the 1989 Revolution? [87]

Why not?

I really wish Berlin would put that unbearable "moral finger" away....we have no right at all to criticize another country. Especially not those in the East who all fighted and won their freedom for themselves, not more or less "gifted" by allies!

West-Germany has never fighted with blood for their democratic freedoms...and the fall of the wall would had been unthinkable without the Russians losing interest, without the Hungarians and yes, the Poles.

Who are we to criticize ANYBODY about their take on democracy!
Bratwurst Boy   
26 Sep 2019
History / Does Poland deserve credit for the 1989 Revolution? [87]

Berlin harking on at the Hungarians for their democratic choices was utterly wrong in 1989 and is still utterly wrong today...

It seems both times it's Germany which is wrong! I get a bad feeling about this...
Bratwurst Boy   
26 Sep 2019
History / Does Poland deserve credit for the 1989 Revolution? [87]

For me the most visual image of that time was the Hungarians just trampling down that wire fence to let fleeing GDR people in...the first ones who just didn't want to play the "game" by the old dirty rules anymore...from then on a dam broke!

I personally will be forever grateful to the Hungarians for that!

I wish today's german gov would remember that better and stop harassing the Hungarians so much...

PS: I always wondered why no Hungarians post on this forum! We have people from everywhere but not Hungary?
Bratwurst Boy   
19 Sep 2019
News / Commemoration of 80th anniversary of the outbreak of the WWII in Warsaw. Poland a full-fledged NATO member. [30]

WW II startet on 01. 09. 1939.

The german people in the Sudetenland were forced into the newly founded Chechoslovakia against their will by the victors of WW1, sowing the seeds of WWII. They were treated by the Czechs as second class citizens (no right to vote for example)

Unsurprisingly they saw Hitler as their liberator and welcomed the annexion! They fighted for their right of self determination. Not a good cause to open the war against Hitler for the allies, so they looked the other way.

Now the invasion of Poland was another thing altogether...
Bratwurst Boy   
17 Sep 2019
Polonia / What are qualites of Germans? [60]

....the root of the problem remains Merkel's stubborn unwillingness to depart from her exaggeratedly liberal agenda....

*nods*

I truly think she has Germany no longer on her radar anyhow...she plans already her career after she left the chancellory...she is so totally no longer "here"!
Bratwurst Boy   
17 Sep 2019
Polonia / What are qualites of Germans? [60]

Na ja Tacitus....and there was Grönemeyer recently...if that wasn't a nod to Göbbels in the Sportpalast then what was! :)
Bratwurst Boy   
15 Sep 2019
Polonia / What are qualites of Germans? [60]

Only in German sorry...a survey from September 2019

zeit.de/gesellschaft/zeitgeschehen/2019-09/aengste-der-deutschen-gelassenheit-zukunft-sorgen-studie

That survey headline states the Germans are looking as carefree into their future as they did 25 years before...mostly western Germans though...it seem eastern Germans are the bigger scaredy cats.

I'm not sure how the survey comes to that conclusion as a few sentences later the numbers show that 56% fears that the german state might be abit overwhelmed by the refugees. 55% fear inner-german tensions because of that, sharing the place with a fear of Trump (also 55%)

Maybe the author and I have different opinions what "carefree" looks like..

PS: That's good news, Trump led the fear race last year with whopping 69%....let him win a second term and I predict a fear scale of only meagre 30ish something anymore...

At the same time the fear of terror attacks has sunken mightily too...and the climate fear is not really that high what is abit astounding as the coming weather doom is constantly in the news.

Are there similiar surveys from Poland? Russia? The US? Britain?

Could be interesting to compare...
Bratwurst Boy   
31 Jul 2019
Genealogy / Polish blood only makes up 1% of your "Polishness" [77]

Nah,that doesn't ring true with me.

I have to agree with Lyzko here...since I have known Poles it was hard to NOT slight them, and which other diaspora has a website about slights against them??? ;)

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Polish_sentiment
Bratwurst Boy   
20 Jul 2019
Travel / Which Poland's city is LGBT friendly? [43]

I guess that might have more to do with traditions than with God's will (or what his proxies on Earth interpret as such)...
Bratwurst Boy   
19 Jul 2019
Travel / Which Poland's city is LGBT friendly? [43]

One of these processes is the development of the middle class. Why is it so important?

I would agree so far....but I wouldn't bring political correctness into this.

IMHO the matter is much easier....a well off, educated middle class demands rights, individual rights. They don't want to live anylonger as others dictate to them, they have the money, they line the states cases, they bring the jobs, they go around and see other places which give them ideas, they want to live as they see fit, also sexually.

They become so powerful and influential that neither god, nor church nor king nor party head nor old traditions whatsoever can stop them to get what they want, they get greedy. And why shouldn't they!

The bigger the middle class the bigger the liberal rights in one country...that belongs together!

Thing is you don't get economical progress without an equally growing affluent, liberal middle class...to fight LGBT's is useless in that regard.

PS: It will be interesting to see the same principle working in China. There too a rising middle class is demanding it's rights, the fight with the all-ruling communist party is already on.

PPS: It works the other way around too...a shrinking middle class opens the door again for illiberal opinions...nicely to see in East Germany after the de-industrialization after the "Wende" and the impoverished parts (Rust belt) of the US.
Bratwurst Boy   
4 Jul 2019
History / Why is Poland such an American boot licker? [60]

with "40 brands of sausages but not enough money even to buy cheapest one" of beginning of 1990's.

The change was handled atrociously in the ex-Sovietunion, every one agrees on that. That was a catastrophe! The worst of both systems...no longer socialism with welfare for all but totally free-for-all unregulated predator capitalism without laws where the most ruthless grabbed the most.

I'm glad the ex-GDR avoided that because of the "Anschluß" to rich West Germany whose money cushioned the collapse...
Bratwurst Boy   
4 Jul 2019
History / Why is Poland such an American boot licker? [60]

Regulation works (the German model has even it's own name "Ordo Liberalism")!

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ordoliberalism

Countries with regulated capitalist economies have a higher standard of living across the citizenship. Whereas unregulated capitalist economies have more very rich and also more very poor people, the standard of living is very unequal.

Planned economies don't work and the standard of living is generally very low.
Bratwurst Boy   
4 Jul 2019
History / Why is Poland such an American boot licker? [60]

But skills and knowledge that got during service can be used later, once there is a good cause...

Sure....but I favour a life of choices. People should have the choice to serve in peace times. To gain more soldiers the armed forces just need to become more attractive.

Sweden and Norway is quite socialist.

Not really...

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model

Socialism means always between other markers also a planned economy....but capitalism is reigning supreme in all european countries! Some more regulated, some less, but always free market capitalism.
Bratwurst Boy   
4 Jul 2019
History / Why is Poland such an American boot licker? [60]

tack'n.

I do what? :)

If you choose to sit home and refuse to serve while your country is being attacked

You are mixing things....

There is always the possibility of conscription in war times...but not in peace times. The US and most EU countries have chosen to make the military service in peace times voluntary. What is your problem?

just give it time and your Socialism will turn into Communism.

I have lived through real socialism, I can compare...you can't! Germany right now is not socialist and won't turn communist. No country in Europe is socialist! Just calling it that way doesn't make it true!
Bratwurst Boy   
4 Jul 2019
History / Why is Poland such an American boot licker? [60]

To do their part as a team/society to afford the liberties for everyone.
Have you ever heard of patriotism ?

Well...conscription would mean forced patriotism, the soldiers don't have a choice. In that regard voluntary service would count much more. Only then it's a real statement.

Oh that's right, you still believe Socialism works.

As an eyewitness of the total failing of socialism I must object. Oh, and btw. all socialist countries had conscription armies, it didn't save them in the end! People kept running away, even soldiers!

(And I can swear to you that the enforced socialist state patriotism was exceptionally low in the ex GDR NVA, so no...conscription doesn't mean patriotism at all!)
Bratwurst Boy   
4 Jul 2019
History / Why is Poland such an American boot licker? [60]

I don't see any possibility for an EU army to become a reliable force.

It's the only logical way to go...because right now it's not working at all!

I do believe such an army would have been smashed by the military forces serving Vladimir Vladimirovitch Putin's

May I ask why makes you believing in a russian military threat?

Combined european forces are not possible in your mind but an attacking Russia is?

And shouldn't you especially cheer for and support the buildup of a working EU defense when you believe in a real russian military threat?
Bratwurst Boy   
4 Jul 2019
History / Why is Poland such an American boot licker? [60]

Why should they be expected to serve?

EU nations continue to phase out military conscription

dw.com/en/eu-nations-continue-to-phase-out-military-conscription/a-5749541

Much of Europe has done away with compulsory military service, or made heavy cut-backs....

An EU army won't need a subscription for peace times...the US has no need either.

Poland would have to increase the size of their military substantially ....

Quite the contrary!

Combined forces means less costs and effort for everyone! Right now the EU consists of 27 fully fledged armies, now that is nuts!