johnb121
24 Nov 2013
UK, Ireland / Mentally ill people in British society [55]
I find your whole approach offensive. Are you REALLY suggesting that an illness is something you feel should be hidden away and, in effect, imprisoned? The British tried that - those moserable old Victorian asylums that until 30 or so years ago still operated on the outskirts of the bigger cities and "hospitals" which were very variable in approach. An old gentleman I knew suffered from depression and regularly ordered into hospital for electro-convulsive therapy, but otherwise lived in his home with his lovely wife - are you suggesting HE should have been locked up? Imprisoning the mentally ill who can function in society is a sign of a primitive and cruel society, one which punishes the "different".
I accept that some people are criminally insane - and for them there are secure units in hospitals, etc. But anyone who CAN function in society without being in some way a danger to themselves or other people deserves every help we can given them to enable them to do just that.
but they should have their areas to live in
I find your whole approach offensive. Are you REALLY suggesting that an illness is something you feel should be hidden away and, in effect, imprisoned? The British tried that - those moserable old Victorian asylums that until 30 or so years ago still operated on the outskirts of the bigger cities and "hospitals" which were very variable in approach. An old gentleman I knew suffered from depression and regularly ordered into hospital for electro-convulsive therapy, but otherwise lived in his home with his lovely wife - are you suggesting HE should have been locked up? Imprisoning the mentally ill who can function in society is a sign of a primitive and cruel society, one which punishes the "different".
I accept that some people are criminally insane - and for them there are secure units in hospitals, etc. But anyone who CAN function in society without being in some way a danger to themselves or other people deserves every help we can given them to enable them to do just that.