PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by delphiandomine  

Joined: 25 Nov 2008 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - Q
Last Post: 17 Feb 2021
Threads: Total: 86 / In This Archive: 69
Posts: Total: 17813 / In This Archive: 12419
From: Poznań, Poland
Speaks Polish?: Yeah.
Interests: law, business

Displayed posts: 12488 / page 181 of 417
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
UK, Ireland / Western Europe is not Paradise after all (Polish doctors in the UK more popular) [75]

The bribery system in Poland is appauling though - for the 'have nots'.

What I gather about Poland is that the bribery system works in a strange way - doctors are often given 'presents' that they don't even ask for at times.

I've always thought that Poland needs to introduce a blanket "no presents" for anyone working in the public sector. No flowers, nothing - it's the only way to get rid of the problem.

But certainly, for me, GP care is far, far superior in Poland than in the UK. I remember the last years of living there - I had to tell the worst lies to even to get an same day appointment, whereas here, there's no reason at all to lie.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

Your conclusion.

No. The conclusion that is remarkably easy to come by when you observe voting patterns over the last 22 years.

Your guess.

It's not a guess, it's a fact.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

Which reflects the will of the people. Were the people interested in such a thing, they would vote accordingly.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

Which reflects the general population. Most people I know couldn't care less about what happened in the past - it's a foreign country, they want to move on with their lives and stop living in the dark old days.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

2) Ban on public office, political activity and civil-service posts for all PZPR members who did not dump their memebrship cards during 1980-81.

What about those who actively helped the regime in various ways, but never held PZPR membership?
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
News / Poland's future rulers meet in Katowice [5]

Future rulers my ass! :-) At least I hope not. Somehow the Duckboy never mentions how he will finance his crazy ideas. Populism at its worst!

He'll do exactly what he did before - tell the people that they can do it themselves.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

She answered that she won't sell herself (lack of the proper word- she used the word szmacić) for 1000.

She sounds like a very honourable person :)

It's worth pointing out that Solidarity were hilariously socialist - maybe even more so than the PZPR!

Hm, I never was the revange taking kind of person and I think the way Poland dealt with things was the best option.

The problem was that - all along - it was never about 'revenge', but rather the whole TKM philosophy. If you take the time to look at what Solidarity demanded, the worker faction was far far more interested in 'less work more pay' than any political solutions.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

That's called historical justice.

The problem is deciding on where to draw the line. Do you punish every single PZPR and associated association member? Do you punish only the top ones? How do you punish them? Who does the punishing? Would it be appropriate to punish those who profited from their family's treasonous activities?

What in your view would be the just reward for those who extracted fingernails

The best way to deal with it is to hold a proper Truth and Reconciliation process. Find out the truth, find out what really happened and make sure that it never, ever happens again. You don't need to send people to prison or subject them to a lengthy trial process - but we do need to find out the truth. That would be the Christian way - and it would also make sure that anyone involved in such activities would find it very very hard to do any business in future.

What about those who like fugitive Michnik never pulled a trigger but ordered others to do so?

Likewise. Find out the truth and make it publicly available. Just like with Daddy Kaczynski - the truth should be established and his treasonous activities published. But this truth should apply equally to everyone, not just those who aren't politically connected.

What are the Delphianite just desserts for these 'men of honour'?

I think the truth being published and available easily is more than enough punishment. For a start, I certainly wouldn't give employment to anyone who was supporting the regime's propaganda abroad.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

committed or not, they used their political influence to become what they are today and considering that at least officially

And where do you draw the line? For instance - is it acceptable for foreign journalists who wrote pro-regime propaganda to enjoy the good life today?

Oh, I'm absolutely convinced you do, LOL (first hand information)

Oh dear. You do realise that there are perhaps 100-200 Communists in Poland today, and that most people have never met one?

some fo the ex-'S' activists ride buses or walk and the ex-commie types often fancy the Lexus, Mecedes, Alfa-Romeo, Infiniti, Volvo or Audi makes...

An interesting observation, common to the jealous classes. There are plenty of ex-Solidarity types who now drive such vehicles too.

No, you won't fuind any links on this.

No, I expect not. Paranoia tends to be unverifiable.

if true decommunisation had been carried out, where would those who wanted to leave Poland most likely go

They wouldn't have left, because they probably would have stayed to overturn such wide ranging punishments.

Most countries pragmatically realised that punishing the ordinary members of the Party was futile. I think only in Eastern Germany we saw something approaching this - and that was because Western Germany had many workers able to step in and replace them.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

What on earth are you talking about?

You do realise that the experience of 1980 and 1990 showed that the vast majority of members of the PZPR were opportunists who dropped the Party like a hot potato and that committed Communists were very few and far between?

Then again, I know what a Communist is, unlike you and most other Americans. Here's a clue : Christian Democrats are not Communists or Socialists.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
History / De-communisation in Poland? [38]

I wonder what would have happened if a thorough-going de-communisation had been carried out in Poland after 1989

Many people would have lost their jobs and livelihoods and social unrest certainly would have followed. Revenge would have been taken, which would have made a mockery of Poland's Christian history.

It might start at let's say 10% of their previous year's earnings going up to 50% in the upper echelons (Politburo, KC).

Which would have caused social unrest and mass disobedience. Many people were signed in by virtue of where hey worked - you can't punish the ordinary Party members like that.

all party members who had not left the party when Solidarity emerged (1980-81) would be additionally banned from holding pulbic office

Not every single person opposed to the PZPR supported Solidarity.

I certainly think that if it had been done properly, many people would have fallen on very hard times. I suspect that many people who at least passively collaborated would have found themselves in a lot of trouble.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
News / A new AWS (Poland Solidarity Movement)? [54]

I would say that I would be quite happy if Solidarity dissolved itself. They are a bunch of populists who do nothing good for the country.

I wouldn't complain as well. They've long ceased to represent the workers, and their attitudes have caused a lot of problems for the workers down the line.

Solidarity these days reminds me of the NUM.
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
Law / Unemployment aid in Poland for an EU citizen [14]

Thanks a lot! You're from Poznań, right? Do you think it's possible to get a job there in 2-3 months time if I don't speak Polish, besides some crap slave labour in a call centre?

Generally speaking, you need to pay your dues here. No-one is particularly interested in hiring foreigners who don't speak Polish unless they are a must-hire for some reason.

I've met people like you before, and they really struggled to find work. If you aren't desirable for Poles, then call centre work is as good as it gets. There's nothing wrong with such work in the beginning - it'll help you find something better in the long run.

Why are you moving here?
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
News / American firearms collector squares off with Poland over rare World War II gun [5]

However, since the article also said Gasior (who immigrated from Poland in the 1980s) was proud of his ancestors' participation in the defense of Poland it would have been a more gracious gesture on his part to have donated the rifle to a museum in Poland rather than put it up for sale on the open market.

Perhaps the law on exporting pre-1945 items was in force at the time and he had exported it illegally?
delphiandomine   
30 Jun 2013
Travel / Just visited Poland - here is my random rant [154]

From what you've said, you've certainly developed that "Pole moved abroad sneer" that many of them developed. It's particularly common with those that emigrated to English speaking countries.

1. There appears to be shortage of people in Poland.

There's no shortage of people in Poland. I'm not sure where you were looking, but the shortage of that age group comes in villages and small towns - not in the major cities.

5. Anti-radars on the roads... pathetic disaster.

I think it's a far bigger turn off to have the disaster that is Polish fatality rates on the roads. It's also a far bigger turn off to have Poles driving the way they do. Tourists aren't bothered by strict controls - they expect it when driving abroad. For what it's worth, enforcement is still absolutely pathetic compared to Western Europe. Anyway, if you obey the law, what's the problem?

7. I have to pay for a plastic bag in a store!?

It's quite obvious that you haven't travelled very much in the world if you're surprised by the idea of stores charging for plastic bags. This is actually a Government-mandated idea in order to cut plastic bag consumption - it's very very sensible. In many civilised countries, plastic bag use is heavily discouraged - and in some countries, each bag is taxed. It's a normal civilised idea to discourage the consumption of such bags.

10. The quality of hardware stuff (like furniture) is not good. And the sizes are small, really small.

I'd question you on this, but its pretty obvious that you're basing this on a single experience in a single place.

11. In Poland you have to pay for everything extra. Besides the plastic bags, you have to pay extra for small things like juice, lemon to tea, or even extra toilet paper.

I've been here for quite a while and I've never seen anyone charging for lemon for tea or for extra toilet paper. Could you perhaps explain where you've seen this?

As for paying for juice - where, exactly, is it free?

12. The famous Polish beaurocracy.. still thrives. I was trying to open a bank account in Poland.

Everything. This is Europe, not the United States, and in Europe, ID cards rule supreme. For what it's worth, many American businesses will refuse European ID cards, and there are many stories of Europeans being refused booze because they only had a passport on them and not a driving licence.

13. Poles have been duped by their politicians (well, that affects most of the countries) and now business owners take advantage of the failed policies. For example, it's very common for a Pole to work on a contract basis (and the contract is being renewed every... WEEK).

I think it's pretty obvious now that your post is nothing but a troll post. No-one is renewing contracts on a weekly basis - it's just too expensive to deal with such things like that. Accountants would be pretty unhappy about such a setup, the tax office would be highly suspicious and so on.

14. Parking meters.. are being installed everywhere in the cities.

Which is normal in most European cities due to a lack of parking places. Again, this is Europe, not America - Europe doesn't have the space to build huge parking areas everywhere.

16. Energy cost is way too high in Poland. I wonder why.

Because Poland doesn't make heavy use of Government-subsidised nuclear power plants, perhaps?

As for "living in darkness" and "only having a few seconds to dry your hands" - please. I don't know anyone that does either of those things - again - where did you observe this?

17. Corruption. If you have a company and can offer a much better deal but you don't know anyone in the government.

Could you perhaps explain the source of this "fact"?

because it's not easy to find one that pays well in Poland.

Keep telling yourself that.
delphiandomine   
28 Jun 2013
Law / Unemployment aid in Poland for an EU citizen [14]

You can't claim in Poland first - you need to be receiving unemployment benefits in Hungary and then use the EU right to seek work in another country - they will pay your Hungarian unemployment benefits for 3 months maximum in Poland as a result. The money paid comes from Hungary, not Poland - and you will receive the same amount as you would in Hungary.

If you turn up and try and claim in Poland, you'll be denied due to the lack of paying into the Polish social security system.
delphiandomine   
28 Jun 2013
Life / Fr. John Bashobora National stadium Warszawa (Warsaw) [81]

Some would have you believe the Catholic church is under threat in Poland, numbers don't lie?

It's a general religion thing - people do seem to be drawn to huge events like this. But how much are tickets?

To put it into perspective more people will pay to see Fr. John Bashobora, than will attend the Heineken Opener Music festival in Gydnia featuring world renowned musicians.

You can't really compare - Open'er is expensive and in a far off destination whereas Warszawa is central.

Woodstock gets what, 250,000 every year?
delphiandomine   
27 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

It can be increased and that's what is regularly done on the ways to all Polish ports.

And those ports are proven and can be expanded further for a similar price. Swinjouscie in particular could really benefit from being upgraded to take Baltimax ships now that the S3 is well on the way to completion.

In principal it would be bad for the environment.

It's clear that it would involve the destruction of a Natura 2000 area and therefore is a no-go.
delphiandomine   
27 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

Wouldn't it be possible to use the harbor for limited commercial ventures confined only to the Baltic sea. Along the lines north south, east west?

It can be used already for such - there used to be cruises to Kaliningrad from there for instance. The fact that these cruises no longer run while they still run from Gdansk suggests that the market simply isn't there.
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

I wouldn't, I'd still call it a massive waste of money and an environmental crime.
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

I've heard many far fetched things from you Polonius, but this is by far the most ridiculous yet.

Do you think they could also rebuild a railway bridge and dredge the port?
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

Maybe they could get the army, boy scouts and volunteer townsfolk to do much of the digging for free.

That might have worked with the Panama Canal, but these days?

Where there's a will, there's a way!

You forget about something called "money".
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
Real Estate / Foreign investor, properties in Poland, walk away from mortgages? [209]

My friend has a property "investment" apartment, currently the apartment is valued at £120k (uk sterling) and the mortgage is £200k.

That's not an investment, that's a liability.

How do people get themselves in such a mess?
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
Law / Getting married in Poland (documentation, church) [42]

- You (the non-Catholic person) need to bring some form of proof that you are single from a Catholic church in your place of residence.

This can be negotiated away, provided you're known to the priest in question.

- The Catholic partner must undergo premarital training/workshop/preparation (whatever you want to call it) at some Catholic church. This is usually a one or two day workshop.

It's actually well worth doing if you can find the right priest to conduct it. Mine was - in a nutshell - excellent. He had many interesting stories about previous classes, and had an incredibly enlightened attitude.

- The non-Catholic partner must sign a declaration saying that will allow the Catholic partner to practice their faith freely without interference, and one more saying they agree to have their children baptized at the Catholic church.

As far as I'm aware, this isn't an obligation anymore.

I heard of people paying only 300 and people paying 1000.

No! Do not make any contribution to the priest before the wedding. There is no need to do so - they are strictly prohibited from refusing to give the sacrament for financial reasons, and the amount given should depend very much on their attitude.
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

That is probably an figure inflated by opponents to use as a scare tactic

You do realise that in order to make Elblag even remotely viable as a seaport, they would have to do almost total renovation of the port (including a huge amount of dredging), rebuild a railway bridge, build some locks and build the canal. It would be expensive, expensive work.

Smaller figures have also been mentioned.

By people who have no idea what large projects cost.

Ain't there no such thing in Poland as muncipal bonds?

No. No-one would trust the municipality to actually spend the money on what it's supposed to be spent on.
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

Maybe it's a local harbour, but whatever the case, a team of experts or trouble-shooters should be set up to do a feasibility study.

Who needs experts when it's already been costed at over a billion Zloty and also been shown to be incompatible with the Natura 2000 area there?

Maybe Elbląg could come alive again by combining local water traffic with recreational facilties to give the good people of Elbląg a sustainable livelihood.

At the cost of a billion zloty?

Maybe create a sepcial econ zone there. There may be numerous other possibilites.

There are possibilities, but there's no need to spend a billion zloty on electoral bribes.
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
News / Poland's Nationalists hold congress [132]

Can you perhaps name a mass murderer, or someone who follows a mass murderer that is "in charge" in Poland?
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
Law / Getting married in Poland (documentation, church) [42]

Usually it's not too much of a problem but can vary according to the views of the individual priest.

It seems to depend entirely on your relations with a priest - if you know a friendly one, then it's not a problem. Otherwise, expect a bureaucratic muddle.
delphiandomine   
26 Jun 2013
News / Restoring the Port of Elbląg? [113]

No it wasn't. Tusk said it's ok but not the priority so will be slightly delayed... only after some more time he forgot about it just like about many other things.

Probably because he realised that it's not worth spending a billion zloty on something that will only allow ships up to 5-6m draft anyway.

If you failed to notice, a bit of cargo is being transported there even now and in some years when Russians were not making much mess, it was a few hundred thousand tonnes a year, so there is clearly some potential, no one is saying that Elbląg would leave behind 3 city.

How much of that trade was with Kaliningrad?