PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by Mr Grunwald  

Joined: 16 Dec 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 18 Nov 2024
Threads: Total: 33 / In This Archive: 10
Posts: Total: 2133 / In This Archive: 804
From: Poland
Speaks Polish?: Yes (Tak)
Interests: history - politics - food - heraldry - pro publico bono

Displayed posts: 814 / page 13 of 28
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Mr Grunwald   
28 Sep 2010
UK, Ireland / Ed Miliband, new Labour leader, talking about Polish immigrants yesterday [62]

"There is a stereotype among some Jews that Poles are and always have been anti-Semitic, which is nonsense."

I liked that, but his family's past is quite... Well im skeptical to that guy. Would have to meet him personally and have a chat, other ways I would never vote for him

IF he would try to get elected in my country ;)
Mr Grunwald   
24 Sep 2010
Love / Do Polish girls like playing with men's feelings on internet? [52]

Hmm, mom says I am very manipulative...

Not good :/

manga fan lol

Ooo

after the novelty wore off i could see why those men were single so long...

turndown...

(this is a genuine profile featured on match.com)

Match.com ...
Wait a second.. This isn't the History section... What am I doing here?

I feel so lonely...
Mr Grunwald   
24 Sep 2010
Genealogy / Struski/Malek - Can Anyone help me find out my ethnicity? [8]

i think i might have ukrainian or nordic blood, but the only thing i know for sure is that im polish,

Nordic aren't useally that aggressive really...
But I bet your part of "Homo Huliganis" species
Mr Grunwald   
24 Sep 2010
History / What was better in Poland under communism? [67]

German-Polish mixed

You better watch your tongue!

50% polled Romanians declare they prefered communism than current times.

Shocking.

Indeed shocking

Well nott, you see, in civilized countries it is called obowiÄ…zek obywatelski. In Poland it is called donosicielstwo. ;)))

Good one, good one...

1 Thing was better, professional ******** :) in one party. Keep it simple ;)
Mr Grunwald   
16 Sep 2010
Life / The "Rudification" Of Society - Is This Happening In Poland As Well? [146]

My opinion is that, there are more peasants or individuals with a farmer background (or worker)
and they don't have any traditions for manners or anything! the society is going down... Because there are nobody there to lift it up!

You prioritize lower classes then that's what you GET!
Mr Grunwald   
15 Sep 2010
History / Poland provoked Germany to start WW2 by mobilising first [94]

what the f#ck is this crap. thats not true germany wanted to wipe Poland off the map. what bullcrap.

"wanted to" is a good word, if you knew better the Germans tried to do less mistakes then the enemy, then a lot of victories in 1939 in Poland when they invaded. There was always a threat from the western front, so they couldn't afford much casualties or mistakes. Of course they didn't knew that the French were... GO DEFENSE! ;=)

Look...as long Poles score goals for the german Mannschaft we won't invade again...promise!

You should become Germany's sport minister and "praise" the Polish fussballers ;P
I can believe all of Poland would like you, and a good chunk of Germany too if those Poles gave ye some goals :)

"Poland provoked Germany to start WW2 by mobilising first"
Germany provoked Poland, earlier in Gdansk. And later on near Gleiwitz (today's Gliwice)
Mr Grunwald   
12 Sep 2010
History / World War 1 - Poles on most fronts in Europe. Any good sites about it in English? [27]

I couldn't find a thing about polish Jews in WWI though...there were drafted to, weren't they?

Yeah I think so, but Jews, Muslims had their own versions of oath for instance(In 30's Polish army). Wasn't it like that in Kaiser Armee too?

Since when does "beating countries" mean "cool" for Poles???

No no no no! I said: Beating Prussia, Austria + Russia! Occupants! :p

They should adore the Germans then! :):):)

Well they fought Russians in WW1 so some were happy ;)
Mr Grunwald   
9 Sep 2010
History / World War 1 - Poles on most fronts in Europe. Any good sites about it in English? [27]

besides Poland where he is seen as rather "cool".

Well he was cool! Beats Prussia, Austria and Russia! (Until he invaded Russia)

Millions of Europeans die with grave consequences for the near future (another war) but Poland profits...

War = People die
Enemies die = Free Poland
How can that be negative ;)?

BB do you know how Germans treated other minorities which were in the army? Like Jews for instance!

(Saw an movie about some Christmas day and there was an German Officer who was a Jew that's why I am asking)
Mr Grunwald   
8 Sep 2010
Genealogy / Polish nationality? Which of the following (if any) determine being Polish. [231]

Polishness always starts with the heart. Every true Pole wears it there.
No matter where you live,your heart tells you who you are.

Good good I go for that!

People entitled to call themselves Polish are those who have Polish blood,it means Polish ancestors.Nobody can deny somebody's parentage.
Polish descent makes Polish nation, provided that the people have the will to be Polish.

I think more, the ones who shed blood for Poland has the right to call himself/herself Polish.
And has a Polish soul, no matter if you talk Polish or not, it's your actions that count!!!
If ones feel Polish one is Polish (Although knowing Polish is highly advisable)
Mr Grunwald   
8 Sep 2010
History / World War 1 - Poles on most fronts in Europe. Any good sites about it in English? [27]

The civil war just started...I wonder what with the conscripted Poles happened as Russia bowed out of WWI...probably marching home?

Well one thing for sure was that in 1917 the Germans had signed a peace treaty, meaning all Russia's Western territories belonged to Germany. But in 1918 Germany surrendered and had her own "revolution problems" at home. So nobody knew who all these territories belonged too, the commies thought of it belonged to them as they were a new version of Russia. While Poles thought where Poles lived was theirs, and Poles lived scattered all over the area, and adding Belarussian, Ukrainians, Balts. It was one huge chaos ball :)

russia was a freaking mess at that time as they had internal conflicts too.

Indeed.

Are Poles interested in WWI as much as in WWII???

Probably not, but some are and I bet Polish Legions have a special place. Fighting for Germany wasn't much attracted as then they maybe would fight French people (not a popular thing to do) but with the Austrian-Hungarian Empire which knew Poles animosities towards Russia they sended all of em against Russia, so fighting with Austria-Hungary was much more preferred then Germany's banners. Although some/many did in normal German regiments I think.

I am not sure if there was many Poles fighting on the Balkans...

Hard to say....but I don't remember that the territory of the future Poland was "ransacked and pillaged" during WWI

Well, maybe not ransacked and pillaged as many Germans lived in those areas too, and I guess the Central powers didn't want to lose some form of "I like those Germans better then Russians!"

If they went on pillaging and rampaging then perhaps no Poles would fight for central powers :)
But the front lines were moving.
Mr Grunwald   
7 Sep 2010
History / World War 1 - Poles on most fronts in Europe. Any good sites about it in English? [27]

Poland was occupied by Germany, Austria-Hungary and Russia from 1795-1918. A recent Polish study estimated 3.4 million Poles served in the Armed Forces of the occupying powers during World War One. Total deaths from 1914-18, military and civilian, within the 1919-1939 borders, were estimated at 1,130,000.[4] The following estimates of Polish deaths, within contemporary (post 1945) borders, during World War I were made by a Russian journalist in a 2004 handbook of human losses in the 20th century. Total dead 640,000: including military losses from Polish delegations of the following armies below. POW deaths in captivity of 20,000. Civilian losses due to the war included 120,000 due to military operations and 250,000 caused by famine and disease.[3] The ethnic Polish Blue Army served with the French Army. The ethnic Polish Legions fought as part of the Austro-Hungarian Army on the Eastern Front.

Austria-Hungary (Polish Legions): 67,000
German Empire: 87,000
Russian Empire: 96,000

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_War_I_casualties
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polnische_Wehrmacht
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polish_Legions_in_World_War_I
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Army_%28Poland%29

On mobilization, the Russian army totalled 115 infantry and 38 cavalry divisions

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Imperial_Russian_Army

I didn't find much information about the Poles/Polish army in Russia.

Anybody know any good cites about it in English?
Mr Grunwald   
3 Sep 2010
Love / Polish citizen in the UK: I made a mistake and now she won't forgive me, help! [57]

my girlfriend took naked pictures of herself with my fone

...

but i didn't know
not until my course mate saw them n my fone and he made a pic slideshow
and now it's all over school.

CAN'T STOP LAUGHING!

She's thinking i did it myself, pls help me
this is the girl i intend to marry after my final exams 2months from now

O o
You should fix it up!
Even after my few minutes rolling on the floor I feel sorry for you
Mr Grunwald   
3 Sep 2010
History / Why did the reformation not have a huge effect on Poland? [28]

I think he means being a Scottish jesuit.

Oooohh thanks!

what had dramatical consequences for traditional tolerance in Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth.

The tolerance in a broader aspect loosed it's meaning when the partitions started!
When in 1918 Poland was reborn, a lot of policies were mimicked from her neighbors.

"Why did the reformation not have huge effect on Poland?" Because there wasn't a King that had problems with the Church and it's power (there was a lot of religions in Poland-Lithuania) but a problem with the Szlachta! (Or Magnateria)
Mr Grunwald   
1 Sep 2010
History / Why did the reformation not have a huge effect on Poland? [28]

convert to catholicism or GTFO somewhere else

I beg to differ, half my family was protestant with German heritage and they stayed in Poland a goooooooooood time. A lot of Szlachta was protestant but it was the... What was the name of... ah yes Jesuits.. Later on Jesuits converted a lot of Poles through the university of Cracow.
Mr Grunwald   
1 Sep 2010
History / Today is the 1st of September (WWII start in Poland) [138]

for them the great european war ended 1989 !

it's quite easily to understand, during ww2. there was 3 fractions.

"Allies" (the West)
Axis (Nazi Germany with their vassals)
Commitern (Soviet Union)

So when did just 1 stand victorious?
In 1989...
Mr Grunwald   
30 Aug 2010
History / Is Jozef Pilsudski the king of modern Poles? [138]

that statement make no sense.. a dictator is a dictator.. nothing democratic about it.

totalitarian state, dictatorships.. there are variation...
There was a president.. government... more democratic then I would thought it to be!
Even it's own Jewish "senate" if I don't recall
Mr Grunwald   
27 Aug 2010
History / Is Jozef Pilsudski the king of modern Poles? [138]

was a de facto dictator..

Poland was under a dictatorship from 1926 but I must say, it was one of the most democratical dictatorships ive heard of :)
Mr Grunwald   
25 Aug 2010
Love / ARE POLISH WOMEN CATTY...? [75]

all women can be catty...

There are different Cat's... but one thing I know for sure! They like meat better then fish
and **** on a sofa in revenge for something!
Women don't do that in general, (mostly individual cases)