So you are saying that repeat pedophiles will be led to the perform pedophilia, no matter if they are castrated or not,
I'm saying that paedophiles will repeat offend until they are caught.
When they are caught they should be locked up for life.
If they are in prison, for life, they don't need castration.
If they are released after serving time and on the same day of release castrated...this means they are punished twice.
I'm trying to think the above through with regard to the law. Nothing else.
But if I had to deal with a paedophile... the law wouldn't protect him.
Also, the criminally insane are locked up in a secure unit. In many cases for life.
I will concede that even some of these people are put on various drugs for various reasons... and there may be an arguement that paedophiles are no different.
A schizophrenic may be put on drugs to, among other things, pacify him.
Maybe the same arguement could be used for paedophiles.
Without knowing what prison term and treatment is available... it is difficult to assess