Roman Polanski accused of unlawful sex with a minor

"On 11 March 1977, Polanski was arrested for the sexual assault of a 13-year-old, Samantha Geimer, that occurred the day before at the Hollywood home of actor Jack Nicholson.[46][56] The girl testified before a grand jury that Polanski gave her both champagne and Quaalude, a sedative drug, and despite being asked to stop, he performed oral sex, intercourse and anal sex upon her.[57][58][59][60] The grand jury returned an indictment charging him with rape by use of drugs, perversion, sodomy, lewd and lascivious act upon a child under 14, and furnishing a controlled substance to a minor"

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Polanski#Sexual_assault_case

And some Polish were defending him, where is this US citizen's defence and why aren't you crying bloody murder for Polanski?

How can we overlook Poland's favourite paedophile, Roman Polanski? A Polish-American criminal so considerate that he makes sure to only cum in a child's arse just in case she could get pregnant.

I'm sure he tried to justify it in many ways. It seems to be a skill amongst quite a few folk here to do that. Oh, the child needed love or children are maturing faster these days etc etc. I don't think some people here need defence lawyers as they've got it all worked out in advance.

Isn't he Jewish as you pointed out some time ago ?:)


whats wrong with that ? eh?

Yes he is. But people who aren't bigots understand that it is perfectly possible to be both Jewish and Polish. Pity you can't grasp that fact.

Seems to me that majority of Poles aren't bigots then :)


Well done Harry.

Polański is actually a Jewish film director and a Polish pedophile. That should be ovious for all enlightened, European non-antisemites.

Not really. He's just a fugitive from justice, whatever his cultural identity. Then again, not all countries shelter him, do they?

Yes, he is--and I don't think he was observant of the Talmud, which is sadly chock full of pedophilia, either. That might be a bad point to bring up, by the way; nonetheless, someone needed to say that not all Jews observe the Talmud, are pedophiles, or are Talmud-observant pedophiles. Someone also needed to bring up that you can't always blame Talmud observance for pedophilia, either--though there's an obvious correlation.

The point (which needed to be brought up--because someone was going to bring it up and Ironside was accused of being a bigot--the point) being; Roman Polanski is Jewish, isn't Talmud observant but did commit pedophilia, and doesn't speak for all Jews--even Talmud observers, many of who don't actually know what's really in the Talmud.

A few Jews are paedophiles, the vast majority are not.
A few Poles are paedophiles, the vast majority are not.
A few [insert nation here] are paedophiles, the vast majority are not.

Are we all agreed with the above?

Yes; but since Ironside was accused of being a bigot, I had to bring up why he might be mentioning what he did.

Yes; but since Ironside was accused of being a bigot, I had to bring up why he might be mentioning what he did. You ought to study the Talmud a little bit--it has some sick stuff. By the way, Anti-Semitic propagandists often try to paint all Jews as P'rushim who study Talmudim Bawli w'Jeruszalajimi (Talmudim Bavli v'Yerushalayimi; which, as I said, has some pretty-sick stuff). Look at Martin Luther--he accused all Jews of following sick stuff like this--Jewamot (Yevamot) 55b (As I said, it's sick; but Ironside implicity brought up a point.).

Also, remember that Poland was a center for P'rushi Judaism.

Grzegorz_


The point that Ironside was trying to make, though, is that Polański may have used the Talmud as his rational. By the way, this is why Karaite and many Messianic Jews avoid the Talmud--that is, we (and I speak as a Messianic Jew who) wants nothing to do with the Talmud.

@Harry
You were claiming that Poles are defending Polanski because he is Polish and I asked you - isn't he is Jewish ?
You never answered ! Would that make an anti-Polish bigot out of you ? Sure it would !

Polanski is a Polish Jew and I respect him a lot.He's neither pedophile nor rapist as this little American cvnt had fake ID and was sleeping around long before she met Roman.

Yep ! He is OK !


That is cultural thingy !I have met some 12 years old who would put to shame 22 years old.
You know but those WASP types, there are so puritanic in their public approach to law, , nobody ask about skeletons in their wardrobe i.e bigots1

He knew how old she was and a person's prior sexual experience has no bearing on whether or not they can be raped.

No. It. Is. Not.
Having sex with children is always wrong. Full stop. End of story.

He knew what she told him.Do you know what a statutory rape is?


It is as surprise,surprise, legal sex age is different in most of the countries.


+1

Statutory rape is rape. And as a friend of the child's family, he knew how old she was.


And 13 is well below the age of consent in both the country he committed the crime in and the country he came from.

Really "Mr.Know everything"?It was her mother who put her into Polanski's "bed" (bathtub).

And that somehow justifies him drugging and anally raping the child?

Hard to think of that guy without remembering he's on the lam for bumming a 13 year old.

He served his time, the judge decided to change the sentence afterwards, which is suspicious.

But she looked like 17.....

And he looked like 38 ;-)

moved from another thread


Hahahaha, are you serious? :D

This stuff is just comedy gold - they actually want to make a Polish citizen face a legal system that is a complete joke?

So you side with rapists who should enjoy impuntiy and be above the law? Interesting!

The Guardian newspaper so quotes the Chairman, unless it is a misquote - and I know who I trust more:)


But Delph comments on warped America. Rightly so. Polanski took plea bargaining and was going to be done out of it apparently. Not difficult to grasp, is it?

Unless you're naturally bitter and twisted ( Well, Poles wanted bitter and twisted, and "Every country gets...etc.....")

As for American "justice"....... Bill Cosby anyone? (Allegedly.)

In March 1977, film director Roman Polanski was arrested and charged in Los Angeles with five offenses against Samantha Gailey, a 13-year-old girl - rape by use of drugs, perversion, sodomy, lewd and lascivious act upon a child under 14, and furnishing a controlled substance to a minor.


At his arraignment Polanski pleaded not guilty to all charges, but later accepted a plea bargain whose terms included dismissal of the five initial charges in exchange for a guilty plea to the lesser charge of engaging in unlawful sexual intercourse.

Upon learning that he was likely to face imprisonment and deportation, Polanski fled to France in February 1978, hours before he was to be formally sentenced. Since then Polanski has mostly lived in France and has avoided visiting countries likely to extradite him to the United States.


Keep laughing when he goes to prison and they put him in a cell with his new lover Bubba.
Bubba don't show mercy on grown men who sodomize children.
Hats off to the new PiS for doing what is right.
Just another reason I would have voted for them.

Yes, because the good legal system is the one from you country, Britan, which allows Anjem Choudary to say that he is gonna put a burka or kill your own queen.

Differently than the Brits, the Poles have some balls and are not afraid of criminals.

@Delph: I seriously doubt it is a Polish government's concern ;). R. Polański, born in Paris, obtained French nationality in 1976 and has for ages lived in Paris (also French wife, Emmanuelle Seigner) and in Switzerland ;)

Of course it is NOT the governments' business to suggest what the (independent) courts should do.

Unless you love a totalitarian society that is. That's what Kaczynski grew up in, and the poor sod is brainwashed into thinking that the state has to interfere at every turn - whilst most us couldn't give a stuff what the state thinks. It is an establishment, and as such is not on our side; it is to be pitied, or, as probably will turn out in this case, to be despised.

We think for ourselves thank you.