PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Archives - 2010-2019 / Language  % width 709

Too many English words in the Polish language!


a.k.  
2 Feb 2012 /  #571
talk shock? i mean, it's just a guess but "tok" sure sounds like "talk" and "shok" is not Polish spelling.

tok szok, you're right.

The word "show" simply isn't used in the title but it certainly is a "show" with

I meant I want you to make up a replace term for show (or talk show) not a title of a specific show. There are/were plenty of shows: "Wieczór z wampirem", "MdM", "Rozmowy w toku", "Szkło kontaktowe", etc.

r don't, be lame but leave out English words in the title of anything on Polish TV.

Why? Oh, why? Would you mind if an American show was called "Tete-a-tete with (name of a host)"?
Lyzko  
2 Feb 2012 /  #572
And Silesians still use 'bana' for 'pociąg' in local dialect.
kondzior  11 | 1027  
2 Feb 2012 /  #573
Yeah! And "Gwiżdże pociąg w lesie" they say as "Wyje bana w lesie"
Lyzko  
3 Feb 2012 /  #574
Wonder, Kondzior, whether they even realize it's from German? Obviously, "bana" > "EisenBAHN", yet conversely, I've encountered numerous monolingual German speakers who claim honestly not to know that their slang word for the phrase "Enough already!" (Basta!) comes from Italian! Many seem unaware of the foreign origins of common "Germanized" expressions; to them, it's just regular German. Was only curious whether the same 'blissful ignorance' of non- Polish words exists in Poland:-)

Off-topic slightly, but I've noticed that sometimes when older Polish people try to write in their pre-War school German, they will write the German with Polish spelling, such as

"Isz habe majnem Sohn gezagt, er zoll szwajgen!" = I told my son, he should keep silent! The word order is correct but the spelling of several words is comically Polish lookingLOL
EnderŸ  
3 Feb 2012 /  #575
"Gwiżdże pociąg w lesie" they say as "Wyje bana w lesie"

Not true right one is: „Gwizdo zug w lesie”
Lyzko  
3 Feb 2012 /  #576
"Zug", and not "Cug", Ender???!
:-))
EnderŸŸŸ  
3 Feb 2012 /  #577
"Zug", and not "Cug"

It's the same God knows how Silesians spell it but yes in Silesian Zug is also train.
boletus  30 | 1356  
3 Feb 2012 /  #578
Also:
cug (colloquially); ciąg; przeciąg; przewiew; zaciąg
[I suspect a German origin for this version of cug.]

Example: Dobry cug w kominie => A good draft in a chimney.
Lyzko  
3 Feb 2012 /  #579
General Polish also has "szlafrok" > "Schlafrock" (actually "Schlafanzug"!), "ratusz" > "Rathaus" and sooooo many more....
a.k.  
3 Feb 2012 /  #580
Do any German have any objections against Poles using their words in Polish language as well? ;)
Lyzko  
3 Feb 2012 /  #581
No more than lots of Germans (strenuously!!) object to the Anglicization of their sacred tongue, a.k. I too am becoming fed up with English words where a perfectly good native word would do.
catsoldier  54 | 574  
3 Feb 2012 /  #582
Its normal process that some words from different language get into polish...

I agree with this.

From my own point of view I don't worry about there being too many English words in the Polish language. Polish isn't going to be that much easier to learn with a few English words thrown in, if anything it may make it harder, how do you decline these etc., there is probably another whole set of rules :-(

I avoid using English words when trying to speak Polish because sometimes I am not sure if it is an acceptable word in the Polish language or am I just spoofing, making English words sound Polish.
Lyzko  
3 Feb 2012 /  #583
As a gag, sure. But the slow foreignization of any language is a concern, naturally. Every language wants to feel valued, why then should Polish or even a minority language like Lithuanian, be made to feel marginalized?
rybnik  18 | 1444  
4 Feb 2012 /  #584
I'm watching the Polish news and the host is reporting on the lost child from Sosnowiec, who turns out lost his life at home. The mother confessed. So the reporter says that there was ogromny linch(sp) internetowy. Does this mean an online lynching? character assasination? Has anyone else heard this term?
strzyga  2 | 990  
4 Feb 2012 /  #585
Does this mean an online lynching? character assasination?

Yes. Lincz, linczować. Has been in use in Polish for I don't know how many years... probably since the times people were actually being lynched in the present US :)
rybnik  18 | 1444  
1 Mar 2012 /  #586
fitnes klub; biznes klub; robokopter
FUZZYWICKETS  8 | 1878  
2 Mar 2012 /  #587
probably since the times people were actually being lynched in the present US :)

right, because hanging was an american invention......
gumishu  15 | 6163  
2 Mar 2012 /  #588
no because spontaneous mob hangings were not so common anywhere else in the world
Lyzko  
2 Mar 2012 /  #589
Lynch is also an Irish family name:-)
rybnik  18 | 1444  
20 Apr 2012 /  #590
I heard blackout on the Polish new today.....Ugh
Zorro  
20 Apr 2012 /  #591
no because spontaneous mob hangings were not so common anywhere else in the world

Plus, everyone is carrying a gun in America these days and they may kill you for nothing and the police then lets you walk free as has been the recent famous case in Florida.

Too many English words in the Polish language and too many American guns in American pokets!
mactifosi  1 | 11  
20 Apr 2012 /  #592
You are Kaczynski?
I claim my €5.

The English language has borrowed many words from other languages such as

Irish
French
Spanish
German
Russian
Hebrew
etc etc etc etc

Should we English speakers stop using these words?
Zorro  
20 Apr 2012 /  #593
You are Kaczynski? I claim my €5.

You mean Ted Kaczynski or Jaroslaw Kaczynski?

Sing sing - nazywają go,
bo ma w oczach coś takiego,
samo zło!
Nie hoduje róż,
ma w kieszeni nóż,
a ja nie wiem
po co?
Peter Cracow  
20 Apr 2012 /  #594
I believe that Latin and French words still have an advantage, but of course Polish language have a lot of new purchases, especially in popculture area, like: celebryta, gugol, maczo or so.

It is sad to say but "Slavish culture" didn't invent either internet or telewizor or even maczo. Vodka and robot are minor achievments and we have to use borrowed terms to name a lot of things.

So what? Eating sznycel or weka is important part of my personality. And what about kotlet or kiełbasa? Do you know how is kotlet or kiełbasa in Slavish?
Wulkan  - | 3136  
20 Apr 2012 /  #595
what is "Slavish"?
mafketis  38 | 10871  
21 Apr 2012 /  #596
If we're taking nominations for ugliest, most ungainly incorporations of English into Polish, I hereby offer the following for your consideration:

"czy mógłby ktoś reupnąć" (could someone reupload?)
Peter Cracow  
21 Apr 2012 /  #597
what is "Slavish"?

Slavic/Slavonic language group to be exact.
Wulkan  - | 3136  
21 Apr 2012 /  #598
Please give a source that Slavic/Slavonic = Slavish
isthatu2  4 | 2692  
22 Apr 2012 /  #599
Maybe he is getting mixed up with Elvish?
Not that ive seen that many pointy ears in Poland..... ;)
pawian  219 | 24575  
22 Apr 2012 /  #600
Feck! I agreee! Poles are monkeys when it comes to foreign language influence. I am especially pissed off by stupid usage of curator of a museum by monkey journalists, while we have a beautiful Polish word kustosz.

Depending on the historical period, borrowing has proceeded from various languages. Recent borrowing is primarily of "international" words from the English language, mainly those that have Latin or Greek roots, for example komputer (computer), korupcja (corruption) etc. Slang sometimes borrows and alters common English words, e.g. luknąć (to look). Concatenation of parts of words (e.g. auto-moto), which is not native to Polish but common in English, for example, is also sometimes used. When borrowing international words, Polish often changes their spelling. For example, Latin suffix '-tio' corresponds to -cja. To make the word plural, -cja becomes -cje. Examples of this include inauguracja (inauguration), dewastacja (devastation), konurbacja (conurbation) and konotacje (connotations). Also, the digraph qu becomes kw (kwadrant = quadrant; kworum = quorum).

Other notable influences in the past have been Latin (9th-18th century), Czech (10th and 14th-15th century), Italian (15th-16th century), French (18th-19th century), German (13-15th and 18th-20th century), Hungarian (14th-16th century) and Turkish (17th century).


en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polish_language

Archives - 2010-2019 / Language / Too many English words in the Polish language!Archived