PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by ylzmichal  

Joined: 9 Mar 2013 / Male ♂
Last Post: 22 Mar 2014
Threads: Total: 3 / In This Archive: 3
Posts: Total: 13 / In This Archive: 10
From: Guangzhou, China
Speaks Polish?: No
Interests: History, geography, classical music, politics, travelling, religion

Displayed posts: 13
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
ylzmichal   
5 Jan 2014
Life / Polish people and racism. [943]

Well thanks for these comments, it seems that it is simply unfamiliarity rather than unfriendliness.

Chinese people are the sort who generally don't talk initiatively towards others, but will react friendly when you greet them warmly.
ylzmichal   
4 Jan 2014
Life / Polish people and racism. [943]

I mean, regardless of the current Chinese political institutions. Not everyone in China liked it as well.
Simply regarding culture and the people themselves.
I've heard about some rumors? that Polish people are unfriendly towards Chinese people, especially those from the mainland, and consider us, erm sort of, not worth contacting with?
ylzmichal   
10 Jun 2013
History / How do Poles feel about what the French did during the first few stages of WWII? [30]

has never possessed;

Well they could have given more significant influence on the issue... They are capable for providing more support to the Underground State in my mind, sadly they did the opposite. OK let's stop talking about British.

Or would you by some miracle like to share with your feelings as a Pole about what the French did during the first few stages of WWII?

Well in fact that is what really want to know... And then it turned out to be accusations to Britain, those I've already known.

repeating that statement will very simply mean that you would be lying.

Well I am ready to listen about all sorts of statements other than those I received from, please go ahead. And perhaps you can speak in a more, say, courteous way? Holding opposite opinions does not necessarily means to talk in a way which makes everyone uncomfortable, I dont mean you I mean everyone.

s.
ylzmichal   
10 Jun 2013
History / How do Poles feel about what the French did during the first few stages of WWII? [30]

French had no say in fate of Poland after ww2 but British had and they used Poland and they betray all the Polish soldiers that fought for them

OK I see, Poles despise Brits over their action after war rather than before the war, is that right? Hmmm it seemed acceptable for Poles to be more angry to Brits as they betrayed you twice while French betrayed less... Those Yalta thugs did so to China as well, trying to please commies as much as possible...

"the fourth largest army"?
There are a few Chinese out there who might disagree with you about that.

Well all historians do agree that Poland is the fourth largest contributor on the European Theatre, that's how they mean I think, after all a maximum estimation of 1 million Polish armed forces participating in the Ally cause is much smaller than the Chinese figure of 2-5 million troops. But even if all Allies are counted, Poles are with little doubt the 5th biggest contributor to the Ally cause. And this figure is quite enough for the Allied Powers to put more consideration on Poles than they've actually did, and at the same time the French contribution is not enough to gain a seat in UNSC in my opinion, although I think French accession to UNSC cause generally positive effects.

No fault of the British that you didn't hold those.

As the Allies had already handed over Poland to the Soviet spheres of influence, they've in fact banned Poles from elections, everyone knew within the bottom of their hearts that nobody under Soviet influence could ever have these elections. You seemed to be unaware of the sacrifices of Cursed Soldiers.

Harry: After a lie has been repeated as a 'known fact' for 50 years, it takes a while for people to accept the truth.

Everyone knew that Ruskies are disguting stuff, so Brits treat Polish by handling them to Stalin for creating another sort of Congress Poland is totally unacceptable by all means. Congress Poland is a product due to the failure of Napoleon and Poles, while when the Poles eventually did win in a war with massive contributions it was still treated like Nazi protectorates like Romania, nobody enjoys looking this going on except the NKVD and Stalin and a thuggish and foolish Churchill who disregard the contributions and strategic importance of Poland. Erm I'm not trying to offend but are you a Polish... cuz I think that myself even as a Chinese seemed more sympathetic to Poles compared with you...
ylzmichal   
9 Jun 2013
History / How do Poles feel about what the French did during the first few stages of WWII? [30]

I've heard about accusations towards the Britons for their nonfeasance during the Nazi and Soviet partition of Poland, but I seldom hear about Poles blaming French for similar conducts...

Both French and Britons signed treaties ensuring tremendous military assistance to Poland in case that the Poles were attacked, but neither fulfilled their promise as far as I am concerned. French had always been an active ally of Poland, and in 1939 its military commander, Gamelin, promised a "bold relief offensive" within three weeks of German's attack, which turned out to be a tiny offensive to Saar... If the French had acted more swiftly and made substantial attacks, then it will greatly relieve the Polish army I think. It may even be more significant than British aids as French assaults were bound to be started on land borders, which will be dreadful for German military supplies as it would damage core German industrial areas like Saar and Ruhr, and also lead to Germany's war of two fronts

However it seemed that Poles tend to show their fury to British rather than French, why?
ylzmichal   
10 Mar 2013
History / What do Polish think of Gen. Pilsudski? [12]

Thanks for your reply with photos~ Oh and also he is Lithuvanian, did the Polish ever think of reuniting Ukraine, Belarus and Lithuvania like they did so in the medieval commonwealth?
ylzmichal   
9 Mar 2013
History / What do Polish think of Gen. Pilsudski? [12]

When Pilsudski is mentioned in Chinese books, Pilsudski is a reactionary dictator, a military fascist leader, who ruled Poland without granting people freedom...
But Pilsudski also fought for Polish independence?
What do Polish people really think of him, do you hate him for his dictatorship or praise him for his patriotic efforts?
ylzmichal   
9 Mar 2013
Polonia / Polish people have no presence in China and most people are confused! [16]

Well we didn't like them if the bishops didn't make any reactions towards the government's mandate assignments, most of them will show reluctance to it.

Currently, bishops in China are legitimitized in this way: Assigned by the government, sanctified by the local high ranking priests, and then informing the Holy See. The Holy See always gets angry, but unless the bishop showed great disrespect to the church when accepting the governmental assignment, they will be accepted by the Holy See.

Most of us hope that the Holy See can be able to appoint our priests, at least to reach a consensus with the Chinese government so that we can practise doctrines freely, maybe in the way like Vietnamese Catholics.

However, more and more Chinese youths baptized into Catholicism simply for a curiosity towards western culture, they don't pay much attention to doctrines or papal loyalty... Elder Catholics are more concerned about it.
ylzmichal   
9 Mar 2013
Polonia / Polish people have no presence in China and most people are confused! [16]

Well I'm a senior school student in Guangzhou, I must say that Chinese generally hold favorable impression towards the Polish people, but they are unaware about Poland as in most Chinese' view, Poland is only an Eastern European country partitioned for three times, with little significance for China and the world.

There are many reasons we didn't pay attention to Poland, all Chinese knew that Poland was partitioned for three times and fought heroically against the invaders as our gov't used it as part of our patriotist education, so in our view, Polish are brave people with glorious history of fighting but petty history as a state, and no significant dominance and a humiliated sovereignty, making Chinese people consider Poland a small and poor nation although it was not the case.

Poland was the first democratic country that got rid of the Communist regime, this made the gov't aware of to much discuss about Poland, actually about many Slavic countries. They wanted us to memorize Poland as a country against western powers rather than a country against communism, that's why we seldom mention today's Poland which thrived after the Communists were overthrown. If we knew to much about today's Poland, or Poland's development, Chinese people will, urm you know that. If the Chinese people are still considering Poland a country that always follow USA and didn't have much significance, it will do the government good. Pope John Paul II is Polish, he opposed communism, and he is the leader of Catholicism, and Chinese Catholics are a problem for the government as well as we sought for unification with the Holy See while the government imposed bishops upon our Church in China without Vatican authorization.

And there aren't many Polish here, and your diplomatic missions didn't do much things in promoting your culture and commerce. Poland is insignificant for China in today' lives, also, Poland is a country which didn't play a very important role after all compared with those countries mentioned in our news, like USA, France, etc.. I really hope one day your mother country will become stronger and more dominant, so that our news mention you everyday.

I have to say that currently more and more students who are interested in politics and history are paying attention to Poland. I'm studying at one of the best high schools in Guangdong province which is expert in liberal arts and I have some friends around to discuss about Poland sometimes. I know about Poland and so I often mention about her at school like a civillian propagandist for Poland, mentioning it at speeches and classes and conversations and microblogs. Everyone knows Poland after my efforts and they knew that Poland is indeed a respectable state in many ways. Make more friends with Chinese and especially those who are interested in history and politics, and tell them more about Poland, Poland and China have lots in common after all.