BiHCroat
4 Mar 2013
History / WAS KATYŃ GENOCIDE? Polish officers were killed [237]
Helo people, I am new here. I have been living in Australia for 14 years, but I was born in Bosnia and Herzegovina actually it was still Yugoslavia then, and I am Croat.
Now, my hobby is history. And don't take anything as granted, because in my old country, Hitory was full of lies and fake claims because of nationalists so called historians who always try to accuse other natinalities and glorify their own.
Katyn is one reason I came to this forum. Because I want to ask you something.
In my opinion all that story has many weird things and does not sound very logic to me. And to me does not make any sense. I know that NKVD is blamed for Katyn Massacre and personally Stalin and Beria. Gorbachev anounced three document that are apparently evidence that NKVD commited that crime.
Now, there are very serious claims that those documents are fake. Why would somebody in Russia make fake documents about Katyn, I don't know and I am not an expert for soviet documents.
But I noticed another thing that have nothing in common with elementary logic. Official version is that Katyn masasacre is commited in April and May of 1940. This is accepted as historical fact.
Another fact is that victims were killed by german guns - Walther. Also they had hands tied with ropes of german manufacturer.
So why would NKVD use a german guns? What for? Some said that the are more silent. That is stupid explanation, does not make sence. If they wanted more silence, they would have found some different method and they would not have taken them deep in the forest.
The main explanation for use of german weapons is that Soviets wanted Germans to be accused for that crime. And here we are in the biggest problem.
Because, what Germans are we talking about.? It is year 1940, Germans are far far away from KAtyn, behind the USSR border, and Katyn is deep in Soviet teritory. Germans and Soviets are still not in the war and nobody know if the war between them would start sooner, or later, or never. So Soviets were able to predict future like Nostradamus, to know that Germas would attack, also they knew that Germans would take over Smolensk region with Katyn forest as well, and already in early 1940 they kill Poles in KAtyn with german Walther guns to set German nazis up and to put blame on them.
This is ridiculous! And stupid. And I don't Know how nobody pay attention on this, especially Russians.
I cannot claim anything, but personally I think that today Russian communists' claims are right in this case and that German nazis commited this crime, because they had more motivations to do that. And I cannot understand why russian officials don't put this thing under the investigation again.
And it is very strange thing that all of us take for granted Goebbels's version of this event. Come on, to trust Goebbels, please ...
Helo people, I am new here. I have been living in Australia for 14 years, but I was born in Bosnia and Herzegovina actually it was still Yugoslavia then, and I am Croat.
Now, my hobby is history. And don't take anything as granted, because in my old country, Hitory was full of lies and fake claims because of nationalists so called historians who always try to accuse other natinalities and glorify their own.
Katyn is one reason I came to this forum. Because I want to ask you something.
In my opinion all that story has many weird things and does not sound very logic to me. And to me does not make any sense. I know that NKVD is blamed for Katyn Massacre and personally Stalin and Beria. Gorbachev anounced three document that are apparently evidence that NKVD commited that crime.
Now, there are very serious claims that those documents are fake. Why would somebody in Russia make fake documents about Katyn, I don't know and I am not an expert for soviet documents.
But I noticed another thing that have nothing in common with elementary logic. Official version is that Katyn masasacre is commited in April and May of 1940. This is accepted as historical fact.
Another fact is that victims were killed by german guns - Walther. Also they had hands tied with ropes of german manufacturer.
So why would NKVD use a german guns? What for? Some said that the are more silent. That is stupid explanation, does not make sence. If they wanted more silence, they would have found some different method and they would not have taken them deep in the forest.
The main explanation for use of german weapons is that Soviets wanted Germans to be accused for that crime. And here we are in the biggest problem.
Because, what Germans are we talking about.? It is year 1940, Germans are far far away from KAtyn, behind the USSR border, and Katyn is deep in Soviet teritory. Germans and Soviets are still not in the war and nobody know if the war between them would start sooner, or later, or never. So Soviets were able to predict future like Nostradamus, to know that Germas would attack, also they knew that Germans would take over Smolensk region with Katyn forest as well, and already in early 1940 they kill Poles in KAtyn with german Walther guns to set German nazis up and to put blame on them.
This is ridiculous! And stupid. And I don't Know how nobody pay attention on this, especially Russians.
I cannot claim anything, but personally I think that today Russian communists' claims are right in this case and that German nazis commited this crime, because they had more motivations to do that. And I cannot understand why russian officials don't put this thing under the investigation again.
And it is very strange thing that all of us take for granted Goebbels's version of this event. Come on, to trust Goebbels, please ...