LDeJongh
25 May 2018
Classifieds / Quran translation - I am from UK and looking for a muslim Polish man in UK [75]
I noticed the typical "out of context" claim about quotes from the Quran. The necessary context is found in the Hadith, the Sira and the Tafsir. Sahih Bukhari and Muslim are considered the most authentic Hadith collections. A further major resource is the Sharia, as detailed in the Umdat al Salik (The Reliance of the Traveler).
These are the sources that provide context. However, the Quran does have this to say: Q33.36 "It is not for any believer, man or woman, when God and His Messenger have decreed a matter, to have the choice in the affair. Whosoever disobeys God and His Messenger has gone astray into manifest error."
forums.carm.org/vb5/forum/world-religions/general-world-religion-topics/islam/4756236-is-it-possible-for-islam-to-reform-part-two/page5
I hesitate to accept the opinion of an unknown Muslim over the word of Allah and the most renowned Islamic scholars. I regard them as having more authority.
The Hadith and the Sira are the Sunnah (Way) of Mohammed, and must be followed by any Muslim. There are 91 verses in the Quran that instruct Muslims to follow the example of Mohammed, who is the ideal pattern of conduct, the perfect Muslim.
What Mohammed said and did is found in the Hadith and Sira, and these books cannot be dismissed. A Muslim that only follows the Quran (a Quraniyoon or Quranist) is considered a hypocrite, even an apostate, by mainstream Sunni and Shia Islam. The penalty for doing so is death.
I noticed the typical "out of context" claim about quotes from the Quran. The necessary context is found in the Hadith, the Sira and the Tafsir. Sahih Bukhari and Muslim are considered the most authentic Hadith collections. A further major resource is the Sharia, as detailed in the Umdat al Salik (The Reliance of the Traveler).
These are the sources that provide context. However, the Quran does have this to say: Q33.36 "It is not for any believer, man or woman, when God and His Messenger have decreed a matter, to have the choice in the affair. Whosoever disobeys God and His Messenger has gone astray into manifest error."
forums.carm.org/vb5/forum/world-religions/general-world-religion-topics/islam/4756236-is-it-possible-for-islam-to-reform-part-two/page5
I hesitate to accept the opinion of an unknown Muslim over the word of Allah and the most renowned Islamic scholars. I regard them as having more authority.
The Hadith and the Sira are the Sunnah (Way) of Mohammed, and must be followed by any Muslim. There are 91 verses in the Quran that instruct Muslims to follow the example of Mohammed, who is the ideal pattern of conduct, the perfect Muslim.
What Mohammed said and did is found in the Hadith and Sira, and these books cannot be dismissed. A Muslim that only follows the Quran (a Quraniyoon or Quranist) is considered a hypocrite, even an apostate, by mainstream Sunni and Shia Islam. The penalty for doing so is death.