PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by Tacitus  

Joined: 6 Jul 2017 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - Q
Last Post: 18 Oct 2024
Threads: Total: 2 / In This Archive: 1
Posts: Total: 1247 / In This Archive: 457

Displayed posts: 458 / page 9 of 16
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Tacitus   
23 Aug 2018
Life / How's the life of an LGBT person in Poland? [90]

Well, we must show some patience with Poland (and Eastern Europeans in general). They are not mature democracies yet, and sadly, and thus sadly, there acceptance of LBGT is still underdeveloped. It is just a matter of time until this changes though, each generation will be more accepting to this then the last.
Tacitus   
23 Aug 2018
Life / How's the life of an LGBT person in Poland? [90]

don't insist on needlessly flaunting their sexuality there usually is no problem.

Nobody should be afraid to show his sexuality in any modern society. Though sadly Poland seems to be somewhat lacking behind Western Europe, so I would advocate some caution.
Tacitus   
18 Aug 2018
UK, Ireland / No Poles Allowed! - Latest Polonophobic Outrage Out of Britain [660]

Indeed. And the Chinese government likes to remind their people of the time of humiliation inflicted by the Europeans. Europe is at the crossroad and the EU is the only chance we have to stay relevant and prosperous. Or the small European countries will become pawns in the game of the large giants from Asia. United we stand. Or divided we fall.
Tacitus   
18 Aug 2018
UK, Ireland / No Poles Allowed! - Latest Polonophobic Outrage Out of Britain [660]

Actually it's been nonstop for over 2000 years. Even under the ancient Romans and Greeks Europeans were far ahead of anyone else in the world

This is utterly ridiculous and completely ahistorical.

The Persian Empire for example was head and shoulders above anything during its' time in terms of power and sophistication. The Greeks were just a bunch of pitiful citiystates compared to it, and not more of an annoyance for most of its' time. The Greeks had sone great philosophers, but the Persians were the ones making great inventions et al (e.g. the calendar).

The Romans had a more than worthy opponent with tge Sassanids, and their successor were the one opponent they could never beat. The Middle Ages were a truly backwarda time, when Europeans were living in the ruins of the Romans. Meanwhile the Arabs experiwnced an golden age. We know from travel locks that Europeans who visited the ME felt embarassed about their inferiority. The Ottoman Empire was ahead of all Europeans for centuries. The Mongols were basically unstoppable, and only the timely death of the Khan saved central Europe from them. Indeed, many scholars contribute the rise of the West partly to the weakening of the East by the Mongols, who destroyed cities like Bagdad that dwarved anything in Europe.

And all of that leaves out China, that was more prosperous for most of its' hostory. It leaves out the people in Southern America that build large cities in the oth century when you could only find ruins in Europe. I could go on, but your point is simply ludicrous. This is not up for debate, but accepted by historians. In any book written about the rise of the West, it is acknowledged that the West was until perhaps the late 18th century not very special. Their are studies showing that until the Industriam revolution, Europe's trade output was awfully small compared to the rest if the world.
Tacitus   
17 Aug 2018
UK, Ireland / No Poles Allowed! - Latest Polonophobic Outrage Out of Britain [660]

@Bratwurst Boy

14 out of 16 supreme court justices are loyal to Merkel

Proof?

I can only assume that he was counting the number of judges which were appointed by the SPD and CDU. Which not only betrays his ignorance about the nature of their coalition (believing that e.g. SPD judges will be loyal to a CDU chancellor) along for his ignorance for their selection process. Every candidate is a consensus candidate because no government can appoint them with their votes alone since 2/3 majority is needes (especially in the Bundesrat where the CDU/SPD government does not even have a normal majority). Coicidently abolishing the 2/3 requirement and thus the need for consensus is one of the things PiS is guilty of doing, which will no doubt cause great damage to the political culture in Poland, but that is another topic.

Yeah...building EU camps on the greek islands or northern Africa to handle these people BEFORE they gain entry into the EU will probably be easier to achieve.

Well, we shall see whether or not we can make those camps work. So far no country has been willing to act as an host country. No doubt it will require a lot of money as incentive for them to change their minds.
Tacitus   
24 Jul 2018
History / Frederick the Great governments from Poland's perspective [24]

Frederick the Great remains very controversial among historians, because he is ultimately a man of many contradictions. Listing them all here would take too long, but I believe that he is of interest to Poles because he offers a glimpse into possible paths Poland could have taken if circumstances might have been different. Imagine for example, if someone as capable as him had been elected as Polish king in the early 1700 when there were still chances for the Commonwealth to reform itself. Or indeed, if a military genius like him had been available to Poland when it struggled against the partitions. Or for that matter, if he had been king of Saxony instead of August the Strong. No doubt Poland would have come out of the Nordish War in far better shape than it actually did.
Tacitus   
23 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

As always, the comments are better than the article.

The comments simply illustrate the problems one has to deal with when arguing with facts. People are simply more likely to prioritize individual experience over statistics and facts. This is due to how out brain works, it simply prioritizes information that underline our arguments more than others. People are not rational, which is why e.g. gambling is so succesful. However it is still important to show those in the hope that others might reconsider.
Tacitus   
23 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

They are not 'immigrants'. They are refugees, or so they say. As 'refugees', they are supposed to go back home when the war is over.

Dirk is obsessed with immigration in any kind, not simply refugees.

Do you have the balls to send them packing one day or are they - like AIDS - forever?

That depends on how long the war continues, how well they are integrated and how their refugee status was in the first place. And again, this is just a friendly reminder, if you come to see entire groups of people as diseases, you should take a step back and look at your moral compass. What you say is not very different from how the Nazis talked about Jews and other people they wanted exterminated, because they were "cancer to the people."
Tacitus   
23 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

We have pointed out many times that his believes about refugees are factual wrong, but he does not care about statistics. Using examples that are more easily to understand and more difficult to refute seems to be a better way. Eastern Europeans are leaving for Western Europe in droves, that counteracts everything Dirk writes here. And few if any have any wish to return. Perhaps they say so at first, but like any immigrants, once they live there for decades, they are mpre likely to stay.
Tacitus   
23 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

@Dirk diggler
All of these are issues that serve no long-term danger to Europe, or are purely imaginative. Employment rate are for example improving in most countries, and the Euro is stable again. Brexit has served as an effective warning for other countries, which is why EU approval ratings have gone up. The rest of your post is baseless rambling which I have disproven again and again with statistics which is why I won't bother it here again. Your problem is that you are obsessed with your hatred towards immigrants and thus blind towards the real challenges in the future. Thankfully this is an attitute not shared by most Western Europeans. We can be relaxed in the knowledge of our strength.

Meanwhile things are looking very dire for Eastern Europe's future, even disregarding its' political blacksliding that might put its' democracy in danger. Those countries are facing a demographic collapse, and its' youngest and brightest are leaving for "filthy" Western Europe. Indeed the brain drain has if nothing else increased in Poland especially Hungary.

theguardian/commentisfree/2018/apr/10/orban-election-hungary-europe-future-past

giving zero *****

They are talking tough now, but the fassade is crumbling. Let's give it one more year, once the UK stumbles out of the EU and Trump has done more damage to the Western alliance, no doubt Warsaw will then be willing to give in on most issues.

@Rich: You are in dire need of help, if you seriously believe that comparing people to flesh-eating bacteria is a valid analogy.
Tacitus   
23 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

There is no need to worry about Western Europe's future, things are looking very well. Though I am afraid that this can not be said about Eastern Europe, where the structural problems are much greater.

The politicians in EA are simply using the refugee issue to cover up how royally they screwed up on the more important issues. Warsaw has been sidelined on any mayor issue since 2015, and Hungary is a basket case. But hey, at least they did not have to take in a few refugees!
Tacitus   
23 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

Ironic, isn't it?

Well, nationalists seem to initially cheer for each other, but as it turns out, their vastly different interests makes it impossible for them to cooperate for long. Just hating muslims is not enough basis for long-term cooperation.

The PiS government has suffered one foreign political defeat after another since 2015 because of this mistaken belief.

I say Farage is a lying dumb piece of ****...I wouldn't quote him regarding Sweden either...

Indeed. I'll never understand how anyone could take this pathological liar seriously. Any illusion I had over this man were gone after reading his disastrous Zeit interview.

zeit.de/politik/ausland/2017-05/nigel-farage-brexit-ukip-russia-contacts
Tacitus   
23 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

It takes two sides to build bridges. Merkel has made great efforts throughout her career to have a good relationship with Poland, even though PiS when in power has done their best to sabotage her efforts. Which is a shame, because it is far from given that her successor will be as open-minded towards Poland than she is.
Tacitus   
19 Jul 2018
Life / Tips on tipping in Poland [45]

I really do not understand why they do not fix the broken american system. I am usually very generous with tipping (not only in restaurants but also other services), but tipping is in my mind supposed to reward someone for good service. I would not like being pressured into giving purely because my waitress could not live from their wages.
Tacitus   
19 Jul 2018
News / Officials in Poland are hailing an upcoming visit by Donald Trump [720]

Because our societies are stronger than them. We know our strengths, which is why are not compromising on what we are out of unbased fear. As the USA has proven, it is one moment of fear that can make a country do incredibly harm to itself by electing the wrong people.
Tacitus   
16 Jul 2018
History / Silesia to Czechia [54]

@Ziemowit

For example Charles IV, Rudolf II.

@Dirk

Maybe that's the game Merkel and her fellow autocrats

Funny how an ardent Trump fanboy accuses Merkel of being an autocrate. It is not Merkel who is getting along so well with Kim, Putin and Co.
Tacitus   
16 Jul 2018
History / Silesia to Czechia [54]

So because Serbia was part of the Roman Empire , the Byzantine Empire and the Ottoman Empire (far longer than its' existence as an independent country), it should today be part of either Italy, Greece or Turkey?
Tacitus   
16 Jul 2018
History / Silesia to Czechia [54]

Most probably will the future Lusatians want to live and work in Germany anyhow...

This is certainly true for Polish people in general. 85k Polish people immigrated to Germany in 2017 alone.

thelocal.de/20180412/growth-in-germanys-foreign-population-driven-by-immigration-from-eastern-europe
Tacitus   
16 Jul 2018
History / Silesia to Czechia [54]

Several Emperors even lived in Prague.
Tacitus   
3 Jul 2018
Genealogy / Angela Merkel is partially Polish. Her family name could be Kaźmierczak [208]

drew heavily upon the US-Constitution for her inspiration

True, but unfortunately they drew all the wrong conclusions from this. A very big problem was in hindsight that the constitution was written to ensure that the central government (which was in the hand of Democrats) could exert its' power over the regions, which were suspected to hatbour antidemocratuc elements. This is also the same reason why the Reichspresident received so much power. As long as a devoted democrat as Ebert hold the position, he could protect the Republic against its' enemies, but they evidently put not enough safeguards into it once someone like Hindenburg got elected. The heavily centralized constitution also lead to a rather ironic situation, when the Nazis used it to dissolve the SPD lead government of Prussia in the so-called Preußenschlag, which at this time was the last democratic stronghold in Germany.

I am certainly not arguing that the Allies had no designs for a highly decentralised Germany.However unlike with Japan, they did not have to exert much pressure. Leading Germany politicians were firmly convinced that a future constitution should return to Germany's federal tradition. Adenauer expressed this conviction mere days after the German surrender in a letter.

And again, the German founding fathers looked on the British and American constitution for inspiration. They implemented several aspects, but also chose to alter others. For example, the Bundesrat would have almost become a Senate, but this was dismissed because that would undermine the strong position of the regional government.
Tacitus   
3 Jul 2018
Genealogy / Angela Merkel is partially Polish. Her family name could be Kaźmierczak [208]

Just more nonsense from you. Russia is facibg a severe demographic crisis, particulary in its border provinces to China. Poland's demographic outlook is also rather depressing. Few children, and those continue to leave for Western Europe. And as for the much praised Russian "resistance" and willpower. They watched as Putin made himself dictator. What makes you think that they showed more than apathy towards other things?

The rest of your post is as usual primitive rambling. If you are confortabke painting Slavs as closer to apes than humans, so be it. At the very least, they have according to you more in conmon with muslim "invaders" than with other Europeans.
Tacitus   
3 Jul 2018
Genealogy / Angela Merkel is partially Polish. Her family name could be Kaźmierczak [208]

And how is this in any way relevant for Russia's long-term future?

Rich Russians are investing the money they stole from their countrymen in London to keep it safe from Putin of they ever were to fall out of favour with him. The oil is still not as high as Russia needs it. The money Putin wastes on foreign adventures will be sorely missed within the next decade when Russia needs to invest into its' infrastructure. What happens when a leader wastes money so inefficiently can best be seen with Venezuela. Putin is simply living from the substance of the short boom at the beginning of his term. Like many other Russian leaders before him, he has no long-term strategy, which will cost him his short-term gains in the long run. Putin is weak. He'll not have to deal with the fallout of his actions, but successor will be in a horrible position. A failing economy, demographic collapse, no reliable allies in the West, an emerging China in the East that will attempt to regain lost territory in the 19th century. A disaster in the making.
Tacitus   
2 Jul 2018
Genealogy / Angela Merkel is partially Polish. Her family name could be Kaźmierczak [208]

Federalism was not really imposed on Germany. Naturally the Allies had an interest in promoting a decentralised government as democratic safeguard, but many leading German politicians like Adenauer and Schumacher believed that the new Germanx should have a federal structural. Incidently this was a return back to German roots so to speak. The constitution of Imperial Germany (and before that the HRE) were incredibly federalized. The Weimar Republic was the odd reception really.

A big fat NOTHING.

On the contrary. The West ensured that this - like all other foreign endeavours of Putin - was yet another Pyrrhic victory in the long run. Putin has now annexed Crimea and controls a small part of the Ukraine. The rest of the country is now mentally lost to Russia, likely permanently. He delivered the USA and Europe a geostrategic victory few would have thought possible before 2014.

Russia controlled 30 years ago half of Europe. 4 years ago it still had its' puppet in Kiev. Now it has only control were its' soldiers stand, and they are losing groubd in the long run.