PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by DominicB  

Joined: 28 Sep 2012 / Male ♂
Warnings: 1 - O
Last Post: 23 Sep 2020
Threads: -
Posts: Total: 2706 / In This Archive: 2159
From: Chicago
Speaks Polish?: Yes

Displayed posts: 2159 / page 9 of 72
sort: Latest first   Oldest first
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Work / Salary & cost of living in Warsaw, Poland [29]

@DominicB

Also, forget about any ideas that the other two adults will ever find work in Poland. That is not going to happen. And life for them will be like being in jail. They are not going to be able to do anything but sit at home and stare at the wall.

Your plan is completely unrealistic. Like I said, you would need twice or more than what you would be earning to make it even worth considering.
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Work / Salary & cost of living in Warsaw, Poland [29]

@Jaz

You can count on zero percent. They have little incentive to give you a raise at all. At those wages, you would be basically stuck working for them even without a raise, and they know that. You would be trapped with no way to get out.
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Life / Moving to Krakow next year, 5000 zloty net. [48]

travel to my home country 2/3 times a year.

Depends where your home country is? If it is India or Pakistan, forget about it. Even once a year is going to be difficult, if at all possible. If it is the Ukraine or somewhere else very close, you might be able to do it.

Where are you from?

I was also told that the cost of living in Krakow it's not high.

The cost of living is very high in Poland compared to wages. A greater percentage of your wages will go to covering your cost of living than in richer countries, where the cost of living may be higher, but wages are even higher. This makes Poland and the other countries of Eastern Europe poor choices for those who want to save money. Kraków is one of the most expensive cities in Poland. Also, it costs a lot more for a foreigner to live in Poland than a Pole. And don't forget that you have to deduct your total cost for travel, relocation, visa and residence permit from your earnings.

In all, 5000 PLN net will give you a decent lifestyle of the type you describe, except for perhaps the trips back home. Better if you are from the Ukraine, less if you are from outside of Europe. Where are you from?
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Work / Salary & cost of living in Warsaw, Poland [29]

500 zloty left at month end.

No matter how much they struggle, even 500 PLN a month is way beyond their reach. Again, they have to pay off their total travel and relocation costs, and that is going to be somewhere around 1500 PLN a month alone if amortized over twelve months.
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Work / Salary & cost of living in Warsaw, Poland [29]

Do you believe that if a third world (so called) person (in labor category) gets 2500 PNL. Then he/she will save atleast 1000 PLN per month.

No. They would not be able to save anything at all, no matter how frugally they lived. You are forgetting about the costs associated with relocation that have to be deducted from the wages.
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Work / Salary & cost of living in Warsaw, Poland [29]

@NabaP

The OP is an Indian. Indians know how to save money.... in India. They have no clue how to save money in Poland. They do not speak the language, and they have no network of friends and family. Life will be much more expensive for them than for a Polish family, especially in Warsaw. There will be zero savings.

Also, unlike a Polish family, they have to pay for their relocation to Poland and residence permits, and that has to come out of their wages.

So no, supporting three foreign adults and a child on 8000 PLN a month is not possible.
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Work / Salary & cost of living in Warsaw, Poland [29]

That doesn't mean that you couldn't save some.

On that little money, you couldn't save a penny, not even for a tiny rainy day fund, no matter how much you struggled. Just putting food on the table will be a struggle.
DominicB   
24 Nov 2017
Work / Salary & cost of living in Warsaw, Poland [29]

@Jaz

That's barely enough for a couple, and even then it wouldn't be easy, For three adults and a child, it would be impossible, even if all you ate was rice. You would need more than double what you are making.
DominicB   
23 Nov 2017
Travel / Do I need an invitation to enter Poland as a tourist? [53]

@Ray20607

Since you are sending money, then would it not be worth trying to improve your relations with your wife to the point where she will allow you to visit the child? That would save a great deal of time, effort and money over the convoluted plans you have presented so far. She's probably the only person who can sponsor and invite you for a visitors visa, and the consul responsible for issuing the visa will be more sympathetic.

That would greatly simplify matters, and have a realistic chance of success.
DominicB   
23 Nov 2017
Travel / Do I need an invitation to enter Poland as a tourist? [53]

@Ray20607

Really, your options are severely limited, and they are all going to take way more than a month. You can try to get a tourist visa, but that is going to be hard from someone from SA unless you are an ideal candidate, and from what you have written, you do not seem to be anywhere close. That would give you the right to be in Poland for a maximum of three months, and you would not be able to work or seek work, nor can a tourist visa be "upgraded" to a work visa. There's really no point in going that route.

Your best chance is to find a job in Poland while you are still in South Africa with a company that is willing to apply for a work permit to hire you. Chances are slim to none, but you have nothing to lose except time and energy. Your chances are best with schools in small towns off the beaten track, especially in the Far East of Poland, where native English speakers are rare as hen's teeth and schools just might be desperate enough to hire a greenie without any special qualifications or skills. Places like Augustów, Łomża, Chełm or Sanok. In popular large cities in western Poland, like Poznań, the odds are stacked against you.

In either case, it is unlikely that you would be able to get a visa to enter the UK. Your chances of doing that are just as poor if you applied in Poland than were you to apply in South Africa.

From what I gather, the situation is this:

Your wife has sole legal custody of your child and has no intention of letting you be part of their life in any form. You have no visitation rights, are not paying any child support, and do not have the wherewithal to obtain any rights from a court in Poland or the UK. Your wife and child have moved on and are apparently living just fine without you. You would be a most unwelcome intruder. Were you to show up and invade their space, it would not end well for you. If you approach this child without the explicit and written permission of the mother, the police and social services may well consider as an attempted abduction or other threat to the child's safety and welfare. There is little chance that they will be sympathetic to what you have to say for yourself. You could end up being arrested, deported and banned from the entire Schengen zone for the rest of your life.

If you had abundant financial resources, you could consult a good family lawyer in South Africa with experience with custody cases in the EU and apply to the court for visitation privileges. But it is going to be hard to find such a lawyer, and lawyers like that don't come cheap. And since the process is long and drawn out, even more so since you are in South Africa, the costs will be extravagant. Hate to say it, but it looks as if you have little option but to accept the situation and carry on with your own life.
DominicB   
22 Nov 2017
Travel / Do I need an invitation to enter Poland as a tourist? [53]

@Ray20607

No offence, Ray, but no one is going to ever go through the trouble of getting an official invitation for you. It's not just a letter that they write and send to you. They have to apply to the local authorities, and guarantee that they will support you during your stay and that you will leave the country when your visa expires. That means serious financial and legal consequences. They have to show that they have enough income and savings to support you. Nobody would every do that for a stranger, especially one who is planning on working a low-paying job as a English teacher. Even close friends would be wary of vouching for you under such circumstances. Besides, you would not be allowed to work on a visitor visa anyway.

You're not going to get a visa that enables you to work in Poland unless you land a job in Poland BEFORE you leave South Africa with an employer that is willing to go through the hassle of applying for a work permit for you. Very few language schools are going to be willing to go through that for a greenie teacher with no special skills. Forget about any plans of showing up in Poland on a tourist visa and hoping to find work once you are here. That is definitely not going to happen.It is illegal for Polish employers to hire individuals on tourist visas. Tourist visas are issued, well, only for tourism, just like the name says. It is illegal to seek work, apply for jobs, or work in any capacity on a tourist visa.
DominicB   
21 Nov 2017
History / Association of Lovers of Lwów and Southeastern Kresy [27]

@TAK1730

Not only. I still have family members in Belarus who are part of the officially recognized Polish population there. That enables them to have certain rights and privileges, both within Belarus and within Poland, such as being free to cross the border and work in Poland, if they wish, and to return back to Belarus if they do. And to maintain their Polish language, customs and culture. This was all stipulated in the post-war treaties that fixed the current borders, which are still in force. Likewise, there is an analogous officially recognized Belarusan minority in Poland, with similar rights and privileges. Not every Pole in Belarus or every Belarusan in Poland is part of that officially recognized minority. They have to meet the strict criteria set out in the treaties.
DominicB   
21 Nov 2017
Law / As a foreigner non EU citizen working in Poland, can I get visa for my spouse? [34]

@Farhana

As a temporary resident with a permit of less than two years, you cannot invite him or have him join you as a dependent.

Your company cannot invite him, and wouldn't if they could. They may offer him a job and apply for a work permit to hire him, and he could get a visa on the basis of that offer. He would have to apply for the visa on his own. Being married to you won't make any difference.

Otherwise, he could find a job with another employer in Poland while he is in Bangladesh, and apply for his own work visa.
DominicB   
21 Nov 2017
History / Association of Lovers of Lwów and Southeastern Kresy [27]

@TAK1730

It would depend on what the Tsarist, then later Polish, authorities recognized as your ethnicity for their purposes, and what the individual claimed as their ethnicity for their purposes. There was not necessarily agreement between them.

When you talk about ethnicity in modern Europe, it is generally in terms of membership in a recognized and long-established minority in a particular country according to national and international law. The main areas where it is or was applied are: right to stay in the country as a citizen, or being subject to being expelled (as was the case after WWII); repatriation; and special legal status in the particular country.

The individual in your post above may well consider themselves Polish and apply for repatriation to Poland. If he is able to prove to the Polish authorities that he fulfills the legal requirements to settle in Poland, or be issued what is called a Karta Polaka, which gives him special rights and privileges from the Polish government that other citizens of Belarus do not have.

I know that you are looking for a quick and simple way to determine someone's ethnicity in this part of the world. There are no such quick and simple ways except for seeing official documentation. Also, there is no single concept of ethnicity. There are several concepts, all of which are ad hoc, and all of which depend very much on the time period in question. The criteria for each purpose and each time period can vary enormously and conflict with each other.
DominicB   
21 Nov 2017
History / Association of Lovers of Lwów and Southeastern Kresy [27]

@TAK1730

Not necessarily. And it would depend for what purpose, and the time period in question. The concept of ethnicity is a complicated one indeed in this part of the world, even today.
DominicB   
21 Nov 2017
Law / How can I get Polish citizenship after been married to a Polish spouse [75]

So you have no way to prove that your marriage is genuine, it has nor been registered in either the UK or Poland, and you clearly intend to stay in the EU if admitted. You're hoping that your Polish father in law is going to take legal and financial responsibility for you and apply for an official invitation for you with the local authorities. (It's not just a matter of him sending you a letter; it has to be an official letter of sponsorship approved by the local authorities).

Sorry, but the Polish consul is going to start from the assumption that your marriage is not genuine and that you have no intention to abide by the terms of your visa and leave the EU when your visa expires. Invitation or not, you are going to have a very difficult time convincing him otherwise. The birthday story is unlikely to tug on anyone's heartstrings.

The consul does not have to have a good reason to refuse your visa application. He has to have a good reason to accept it. And the burden is on you to provide unambiguous reasons that he will accept. Nothing in what you wrote comes close.

Based on what you have written, it seems like a waste of time and money to apply for a visa that will almost certainly be refused, and not worth the risk of adding yet another visa refusal to your database record.
DominicB   
21 Nov 2017
History / Association of Lovers of Lwów and Southeastern Kresy [27]

@TAK1730

From all over, but disproportionately more from Mazovia than anywhere else. Also, a very large percentage of the Poles from those countries were actually Polonified locals.
DominicB   
20 Nov 2017
Work / Information about jobs for Indian students in Poland [286]

@Ans my.Q

Well, you don't have any experience, and there is little demand for inexperienced IT people in Poland. Whatever you do, don't come to Poland thinking you are going to find a job here. Get a job BEFORE you come.
DominicB   
19 Nov 2017
Law / My permanent residence card is being cancelled due to divorcing within 2 years of receiving it [19]

@Tosic

I just noticed that your other post was from more than two years ago. So you ended up not going to South Africa, and have been residing in Poland on PR since then?

As for the divorce, it can turn out that it is taken care of rather quickly, especially if the objecting party's objections are dismissed by the court. Or it can take a lot longer. How much longer? No one here can tell you. It all depends on the particularities of your case. Every one is different and only a good lawyer would be able to give you a real answer.

One word of warning, a Polish woman's word generally counts a lot more than that of a foreign man in Polish divorce court. You'll need a good lawyer, and good lawyers are never cheap. They usually cost an arm and a leg. This really isn't something you should be trying to skimp on.

I am assuming that it is her that wants the divorce, and you who are contesting it. Is that right?
DominicB   
19 Nov 2017
Law / My permanent residence card is being cancelled due to divorcing within 2 years of receiving it [19]

@Tosic

Well, considering that you are soon moving to South Africa, you will not be able to fulfill the terms of the permanent residency requirement anyway. You would have to reside in Poland for at least two years on permanent residency status to get citizenship. Any divorce will be finalized before then, almost certainly in favor of your wife.

If your wife wants a divorce, any plans you had of gaining citizenship through marriage are over. Cut your losses, move on to South Africa, and start over again. There's little point in spending money on a lawyer, cheap or expensive.
DominicB   
18 Nov 2017
Genealogy / My mothers family? Sobkevitz (?) Moved from Poland in the early 1900's [8]

@Daniellei30

The name is spelled either Sobkowicz or Sobkiewicz in Poland. The "b" is pronounced like a "p", hence the confusion about the spelling. Both are fairly common names found all over Poland. There is a third possibility, "Sopkowicz", which is a very rare variant. Not much you could do with a common, widely distributed name like that, I'm afraid, without solid documentation. "Stella" is not a Polish name, but one that was often used as an "English name" by Polish Americans. Looking for her with the information you have is like looking for a needle in a very large haystack.
DominicB   
18 Nov 2017
Study / How is the reactions of Polish students to foreigners students? [2]

@mahmor

Generally it's not a problem at good private schools. If your children are shy, they could have problems making friends, because they will have to do all the work of making friends. If they are shy, the other students will leave them alone and ignore them. They should be intensively learning English now. Otherwise, they will fall behind in their schoolwork, and probably receive little help with catching up.

The most common type of discrimination you and your family is "benign neglect". Very few people will bother you, but, on the other hand, you shouldn't expect a "warm welcome". You won't be exactly excluded, but you won't be included, either, unless you make the first move and break the ice. Again, being shy is a handicap.

Any really hostile discrimination you and your family will encounter will come from two sources: drunks and football hooligans, especially when they are in groups. Avoid both and you will be OK.

Also, make sure to get rid of behaviors that Westerners find weird and confusing, like head bobbing, eyelash batting and calling people "My friend".