PolishForums LIVE  /  Archives [3]    
   
Posts by Mr Grunwald  

Joined: 16 Dec 2008 / Male ♂
Last Post: 18 Nov 2024
Threads: Total: 33 / In This Archive: 10
Posts: Total: 2133 / In This Archive: 804
From: Poland
Speaks Polish?: Yes (Tak)
Interests: history - politics - food - heraldry - pro publico bono

Displayed posts: 814 / page 8 of 28
sort: Latest first   Oldest first   |
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

Mr. Tannenberg?

No need to be funny

Do you know what it means to be an informant

yes I do know

I don't need to provide any more links as none of you guys has provided any links to go against mine. All I'm getting from you is your opinion, that's it.
If I have to choose what to believe, a written word by some people who spend a lot of time to investigate our present subject or to believe your words, the answer is clear.

Oh.. So your sharing your sandbox we don't have any sandboxes to share? No more sandboxes for anyone?! Ohhh.....
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

at least you admit that the Germans are intelligent :-)

intelligence services! Duhhh.....

are you a newb or you just mocking me? Should I consider not speak to you?

The Spanish civil war and the invasion of Czechoslovakia alone wouldn't make them so successful.

did I say it was all alone? It was all combined!!!

maybe not counting me and some other people I know.

some are fanatical about pro-soviets or somebody who even resemble any. I am glad that the Union is gone and I can take any stand I want. Playing the devils advocate is sometimes funny :)

But no I am not even remotely Nazi or Communist/Stalinist

I'm not an informant though (lol)

Yes you are, bring more links or you-know-who will get beaten up again

screamers as Germans got raped by their neighbours for centuries just because they had NOT been big, NOT been powerfull, NOT been agressive!

and then they got raped while being powerful , aggressive and big. So now their peaceful big economical and smiling towards her neighbors ;D
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

So far, I was pretty much the only one in this thread who was presenting links to show that what I'm saying here is based on historical facts.

Thank you. You are an great informant I am merely an historian enthusiast and I read most from books. From which what page and all has all slipped my mind :/

(and I don't want to go to my room searching through all my books -.-)
yes I am lazy so sorry
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

tell me where the Germans gathered so much experience before the WW2

world war 1, Spanish civil war... Invasion of Czechoslovakia + intelligence?

another pro Soviet here?

I am the most anti-Soviet person among "normal people"

Of course...*pats Gruni*

Who needs numbers and facts....;)

When somebody got millions of soldiers charging hundred thousand enemy Germans that always shoot while Germans got mousers jamming from snow, sand or dirt... statistics or not they were advancing later on! There was no miracle just raw power. Although i would been drawn the war out more if I were the Soviets... Having not wasted much of their men, they would build up their industry faster. Or have more target blinks in the future... Think of what would happen if Soviet Soldiers actually went into Vietnam or Korea? Or China!
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

I'm not sure what you are meaning actually!

What do you know about kill ratios and losses?

Kill ratios don't have anything to say, you know the kill ratio in Crete right? The Germans still won! Also the German artillery was experienced/trained = very good same with the mortar teams. They were the "killers" at the front.

The Germans were better armed,

I quite like German equipment but, 1 shell works just like another shell. It's the efficiency of loading and knowing about ones weapon that gives somebody a victory!
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Lwów, Wilno ... kresy - Poland have lost enormoust part of our heritage... [389]

Hitler for sure thought so...

That was too late, Poland was "free" already

He would had changed the tone with Poland also very quickly would they had been more compromising.

I was talking about pre-ww1 during partitions, an option of cooperation with Hitler was unacceptable especially being drugged by Britts&Frenchies
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

Yeah...Norway would had shown the Wehrmacht otherwise....

lol I was talking about the war IN Norway... don't be ridiculous

Just before the British&French&Polish forces left Norway the main German forces were just to surrender in Northern Norway. But suddenly Norwegian forces surrendered to them as they saw their position as "hopeless".

It's really ironic

There are some heroic individual Norwegians during the invasion. Like the officer at the Oslofjord ordering to attack "Blücher" or the commander for an battleship outside Narvik. Otherwise troops were not supplied good enough, airports taken over in a few hours. No airforce so to say, warships from pre-WW1 the rifles were Swedish huntign rifles if I am not mistaken... The politicians general negative attitude towards war or anything military... If it wasn't for the terrain... The terrain+ allied soldiers were the main factor of why it took the Germans two months to gain control over Norway

But remember that, invasion of Yugoslavia, Denmark, Poland, Greece, lower countries, (Austria & Czechoslovakia too but... not much fighting but still an invasion nonetheless)
was Germans the larger force! Only during fights against France, British, Soviet Union and U.S.A forces you were outnumbered! Did Nazi Germany win in Africa? In "operation Barbarossa"? Or later in West France in 1944? It's an score of 1-3 when we think of when Nazi Germany invaded France in 1940! Tell me losing a football game with an score of 1-3 is that good? :/

The Germans were winning because of their brilliant military tactics and because of their (mostly) better military equipment. As far as the numbers, the Soviets had way more airplanes and tanks from the beginning on and were still losing (very fast) until the very cold winter came and the negative results on the other fronts started affecting the German military power in the war against the SU too.

buahahahhaha the trainign and experience was the most vital factor, during 1939-1940 the allies had more and better equipment. It was the drill and tried out strategies that made them win. Also the national accept of the ruling power (which is maybe why many tend to say germans and not Nazi Germans when thinking of Germans durign world war 2)
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Watch Poland grow and shrink (interactive map) [52]

but not many of the 80 millions in other countries come back...:(

Tsk tsk, you should refresh your propaganda and create a propaganda minister. I know many will take it rather "bad" to themselves. But you need manpower

especially with the growth rate
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Lwów, Wilno ... kresy - Poland have lost enormoust part of our heritage... [389]

Come...let it rest...it's history now...

Think of it, what possibilites would Germany have if it created an free independent Poland with close ties/alliance to Germany? I think a lot of troops would rebelled during ww1 and help the central powers? A lot of Americans would not be on Entente also!

1-2 more million happy volunteering soldiers fighting by your side. With over natural zeal to crush your enemy: Tsarist Russia. Do you think there was an option to do this BB?

Secured eastern front + millions of non-hostile Poles and lots of food! Hmmm? :)

90% of teachers and students were polish

Polish? ;) Not Ruthenian, Jewish or Austrian? Gosh the Austrians were weird
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Watch Poland grow and shrink (interactive map) [52]

Why would you need such a big country? You are a people of...what...35 millions?

You know how many Poles there are abroad? What if Poland started to be successful and was starting an "campaign" to get their former "Poles" back?
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

Who told you that??? ;)

Are you telling me that when the Germans invaded Netherlands they were fighting all forces at once? (the divisions in Netherlands)

The only times I can come to think of when the Germans were outnumbered was in Soviet Union/Africa/Italy/France 1944

And also in Norway after a time (lost almost there but the defeats in lower countries + France lead to a withdrawal for the allies in Norway)
Mr Grunwald   
2 Jan 2011
History / Polish flag over the Reichstag first? [399]

PS: Only comparing direct Kill ratios and losses should show you who sh'it on whom the whole time, even outnumbered and fighting at several fronts at once at the same time!

BB what stand would you have over an world champion in boxing losing after meeting several "novices" which later on earned from experience how to defeat him? Doesn't that say anything to you? Germans were best, yeah. But they got beaten by Russians... Doesn't it ring ANY bell to you? :p

there was absolutely no army in the entire world which could face the Germans 1:1 and win during the WW2.

In flat landscape you mean
otherwise Germans by most of the time were outnumbering their enemies (not on a global level but on a local one)
Mr Grunwald   
1 Jan 2011
Genealogy / Any Polish Tatars here? [95]

In this respect they are true nobility, I would say, the noblest of the noble.

I as having noble heritage can agree upon it.
Mr Grunwald   
1 Jan 2011
News / 10,000 ISRAELIS READY TO CLAIM FOR POLISH CITIZENSHIP AND POLISH LAND! [628]

Many Europeans

because I know that you appreciate arabs and hate Jews.. So, why should I speak to you in Hebrew?

hahahhaa good one! Ehrm sorry no your mistaken, I don't give a toss for either of the side, their likewise stupid! ;)
Take a look at Scandinavia! When did we fight each other? How much bloodshed was it? The Germans ruined it! :)

Aleichem shalom..

Shalom

I am a full blooded Belarussian, Russian, UKrainian and Polish Jew.

Eyyyy! An person having heritage from the great Rzeczpospolita! How wonderfull! :)

I don't know why she had such a fear of the Poles versus the Russians. Maybe, it's her old age and she had you mixed up with someone else. LOL

I honestly would have problems differenciate between the balkan nations in former Yugoslavia if they were standing on a line (sorry Crow but you are indeed very much alike in speach and body)

Its hard to be a patriot in a country where you are always hated and called a Christ-killer. Where they burn down your villages and murder your people.

Ohh you mean Tsarist Russia? I fully agree
Poles were more on the economical thing, remember that Jews were dominating the middle class in Poland until after WW2! Do you think that would been "accaptable" by any other country?

called a Christ-killer.

It's more of a chance that it happands today as most Poles don't have much contact with Jews only through media or priests (if they say stuff like that, there are soem radicals I presume in Poland) But I got an hard time swallowing that it was the "thing" behind anti-semitism in Poland before WW2.

Yeah, of course, you will deny any of this ever happened in Poland.

I won't deny it happaned IN Poland. Just not under Polish rule or done by Polish officials!
It MAY have happaned at the hand of a few Nationalists (which were very few) even a few antisemites started an organization to SAVE Jews! Does that say anything to you?

Many Europeans

MANY maybe, MOST? Definatly not

Just look at that Catholic bishop from UK who was talking about how gassings never occured in the camps.

He is a Britt... I don't care of a word he says

Lets takle a look at the leaders of Poland's communist party. How many were Jews? Was Władysław Gomułka or Boleslaw Bierut a Jew? No, they were Jew-hating gentiles who oppressed the Jewish people with their Polish goyim communism. Communism was ruled by non-Jews!!

For me any commie is a commie, period! So your right at that! But remember that many had Jewish heritage and spoke Polish like a typical Jew did. So there were many thinking he indeed was A Jew. But in reality he clearly wasn't as he was waving a red flag...

The only reason any Jew should visit Poland is to visit the death camps, which should be a very good reminder why Jews should never live in Poland!!

So any reason to check up how the Jews came to Europe... How they lived? How they survived the centuries? How the culture was going or what great achievements they contributed to the Polish sociaty is of NON-importance? That means Poles value Jews/Jewish colture more then you do! How does that sound?
Mr Grunwald   
30 Dec 2010
News / Ruski a slur like Pollack? [53]

It won,t be long before Brit is seen as an offensive word..!

It is...

Or maybe Britt.. hmm

"Ma ruska dziewczyne" means that his girlfriend is Russian.

No it means he got a Russian girlfriend, "his girlfriend is Russian" would be more like "jego dziewczyna jest Ruska/Rosjanka"
Mr Grunwald   
21 Dec 2010
USA, Canada / Which countries are Americans usually traveling to? [114]

Actually it's a wrong approach as military itself doesn't make any decisions. They go wherever they're ordered to go

I am just saying what the facts are! I am not saying I see it that way or that it's correct....

No such thing as a "British" accent!

people mostly see as the English as British! While Welsh are Welsh, Scotts are Scotts.
Mr Grunwald   
21 Dec 2010
USA, Canada / Which countries are Americans usually traveling to? [114]

Americans vs G. Bush
Many more people have positive opinion of U.S.A, but not maybe that much about their military forces ;)
Nothing is in 1 basket (well Soviet Union was but but)
Mr Grunwald   
21 Dec 2010
History / Lwów, Wilno ... kresy - Poland have lost enormoust part of our heritage... [389]

Sorry to hurt your feelings, Gruni.

It's ok now

Gruni, you are too intelligent to join these two tight cr*p-holes :)

*Becomes flattered from all the beautyfull words*

You don't, because of the above-mentioned reason.

Very good reason indeed :D

Are you of some noble origin?

Yes (My Polish side, there are only 3 noble family's in Norway (two of them with Danish roots the last with Swedish roots)

You see, I treat people equally whether they are royal family or don't know who their parents were. It doesn't matter.

I belive child's upbringing and their social background is quite important. I clearly see the difference in behavior between people with farmer background and those of middle class background for example. Quite often it even have political "traditions".

Btw, do nobles in Norway kiss other men's hands as Jola does? He seems to like it the most. Ironside too.

Most Norwegians do it only in comedian shows to laugh off nobility (actors). Just to paint you a picture the Germans were shocked by the picture of seeing children sitting and elder persons standign on the buss when they invaded Norway in 1940. and many other stuff. Norway has since the black plague allmost exclusavelly been peasents or middle class (workers with peasents roots)

Although what I like about nobility is the respect to one's roots and cherishing old traditions and symbols of the past.

Yes it is very important as we are so few!

It's actually depressing to be of noble heritage in todays Poland. The nobles lost everything in Poland/Ukraine/Belarus/Lithuania and most of them got murdered or had to flee their homes.

Your telling me.... -.-

Gruni join the dark side!

I am an individual and I have no need of any factions! "When alone I am strongest!"

Let's not forget that a lot of the friction between Poles and Ukrainians in the past was because of nearby large nations playing Poland and Ukraine against each other for their own benefit.

Sad but true :/

bunch of unwashed monkeys that they are.

people like you were given oney from partitioneers and were allowed to live so that your "type" could enflame further conflict! Disgusting! Even today! Pff

Did you ask your Ukrainian brothers opinion?

Have they ever done that?

What for? There is no such nation as Ukrainian.

See? SEE? I knew it!

I don't see sharing a border meaning necessary another world war...

Ey ey ey... Germans got brains, Poles got brains! Don't think everybody got brains... *tries not to activate Zombie mode*

I am sure we shall win.

Without any support either... hard to win then!
Mr Grunwald   
15 Dec 2010
News / 'Bored' Poles build 31ft tall Frosty [16]

"najwiekszego balwana na swiecie"

Why's that?

Cause some Poles call peopel that are retarded or stupid "Ale z ciebie bałwan"
Mr Grunwald   
15 Dec 2010
Travel / Has anyone seen Mazowsze (established in 1948) [9]

Poland's commie regime bankrolled Mazowsze and ŚLąsk and created Cepelia which not only gave employment to the poor countryside but helped preserve many ancient crafts that would have been lost otherwise.

Well they had to do something to avoid uprisings... They sure knew something about earlier Polish uprisings :)
Mr Grunwald   
15 Dec 2010
News / John Godson, born in Nigeria, might become Poland Sejm's first black deputy! [313]

Poland does not have that history.

History is something one can go back to, it's an guide. But you need to open the book and read it and not only see the front page and think you have read it allready.

This is why I am not sure that such a situation would arise as quickly if things are handled correctly.

Indeed! Tradition has also an large impact on an persons logical thinking. Parents learn their kids what they learned from their own parents. The line may be broken one day, but it is up to everyone of us to decide that.

I also doubt that Poland will be as attractive a destination for many immigrants when they have UK, France, Spain and Germany.

Poland is growing, it need's people. Oportunities are opening. At those you mentioned their closing. Doesn't matter if it's an giant toy store or an handmaking toymaker. You look for what is aveliable.

The other history we have in Europe is the one in which you took part... WW2.

Yeah, the losses of so many people lead to "You want to do THAT again?"

Perhaps another thing is that whereas US had a large population of Black Americans.

America is founded on colonialism... Settlers ARE her PRIDE and ORIGIN. Fighting newer settlers just make me laugh really
Mr Grunwald   
15 Dec 2010
USA, Canada / American...Polish Resident...Returning to the land of milk and honey [103]

I hate people, especially you folks.. still feel it necessary to tell you what I'm doing.....g'damnit

Your mixing people with what an family is? :o

I'll be heading over to the US for about a month.

Good lfight! Although it's a bit late to say it :/
Mr Grunwald   
15 Dec 2010
Life / The most dissapointed with Poland are those who have Polish origins. [35]

It's Poland's neighbor so i figured someone from Poland would show more respect but nope, it's not Poland so it's ok.

You keep forgetting the "Potop" and Polish ulta-patriots

There is a saying or more an poet (Can't remember his name sorry) that went like this: "There were two birds in a cage, the one had experienced freedom and wanted to fly in the heaven and never live in the cage again. The other couldn't understand that bird as the cage had been all his life and was safe for him and no hawks would ever eat him" I would add an bird that got away and had been in an earlier cage which maybe was a bit "worse" or not that beautyfull but it had it's owner which took care of the bird inside very well. Until he died and his child took over.

That's my thoughts
Mr Grunwald   
11 Dec 2010
History / Lwów, Wilno ... kresy - Poland have lost enormoust part of our heritage... [389]

I am not that much into nobility cr*p

You better watch your tongue or ill join Sok&I-S camp

As for economy dont make me laugh, Ukraine has no market atm, Polands exports to Ukraine are pathetically small, you're an economic black hole and the only country that cares about you (Poland) cares about you because you're such a nice buffer zone.

Sucks to be Ukraine :)

Now Nathan... Do I speak to you like that? Do I?! :((
No need to bash on nobility!
(You can bash arrogant aristrocratic arses, I feel the same way)
Mr Grunwald   
10 Dec 2010
Life / POLISH TEENAGERS TURN TO PROSTITUTION... [77]

It's like dog **** flavored ice cream. The product might exist, but the market doesn't

Doesn't look like you have heared about the term "Gigolo"?

maximum wage, minimal effort... sounds alright if you were in a jam.

Yeah and the reputation and respect! mMmmhmhmhm! Best job in the world ehh? (sarcasm)